High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20736/2018dismissed

Krishan Kumar v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2024-08-20Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger8 pages

" !

!#$% (%)*+*&,

- - ./*+0#, .12#/

------ %$*$*&,%/

3%/+1+ 4$#$% #/5#,# &$0%/+

------

%+6&,(%,$+ 7 8

4 4

/%+%,$ /- 4#$5# 3*/ 4*,90 "#(#:

(:&)#$%

/- $;#/+0 40#/2#< (:&)#$%

6%$*$*&,%/-

#=,%%+0 0#(>#?< #/5#,#-

/- 4-- *??#,*#< (:&)#$%

- - - 4 <

%$*$*&,%/

./*+0#, .12#/ )*:*?

1,(%/ /$*)?% &,+$*$1$*&, ,(*#< *,$%/ #?*#< +%%;*,9 ,#$1/% )%/$*&/#/* +%$$*,9 #+*(% &/(%/

&/(%/

< 6#++%( !*+$/*)$

%>#/*

+0&/$ 7&??%)$&/7 >0%/%B5

4*,90 :*??#9%

0&?#/5< %0+*?

.&+?*< !*+$/*)$

%>#/*-

6/#5%/ B%%, +%$$*,9 #+*(% &/(%/

< 6#++%( &22*++*&,%/< 1/9#&, !*:*+*&,< 1/9#&,

+0&/$ 7!*:*+*&,#?

&22*++*&,%/7 &/(%/

< 6#++%(

*,#,)*#?

&22*++*&,%/< #/5#,#

+0&/$

*,#,)*#?

&22*++*&,%/7< >0%/%B5 #66%#?

/%:*+*&, >%/% (*+2*++%(< /%+6%)$*:%?5-

- /*%'?5< (%2*+% 40/* 0#>#,* 4*,90< 6/%:*&1+ :*??#9%

0&?#/5< 6/&)%%(*,9+ >%/% *,*$*#$%( '*??*,9 :#)#,)5-

61/+1#,)% 6/&)?#2#$*&,

21+$/* 21,#(* )#??*,9 16&, #66?*)#$*&,+ '*??*,9 +#*( :#)#,)5< '&1/ #66?*)#$*&,+

*,)?1(*,9 &,% +1B2*$$%( 4*,90< >%/% /%)%*:%(-

#66%#/+ &,% )#,(*(#$%< ,#2%?5<

#2&$#/< >*$0(/%> )#,(*(#$1/% '#:&1/ #,&$0%/ )#,(*(#$%< ,#2%?5< ,(%/6#?< >*$0(/%> )#,(*(#$1/% '#:&1/ 6%$*$*&,%/C 1?$*2#$%?5< /%2#*,%( '/#5- -

0% ++*+$#,$ ,( /#(%< .&+?* ++*+$#,$

+$ /#(%< .&+?* /%)&22%,(%( )#,(*(#$1/% :#)#,)5-

- 0% &/(%/

:*??#9%

0&?#/5-

- $/#,+6*/%+ )0#??%,9%( &/(%/

'*?*,9 #66%#?

B%'&/% !*:*+*&,#?

&22*++*&,%/< #??&>%(< &/(%/

-- 2#$$%/ /%2#,(%( &??%)$&/-

- 6&, /%2#,(< *$+ &/(%/

< #9#*,

:*??#9%

0&?#/5-

%%?*,9 #99/*%:%( &/(%/

< 6#++%( 0%/%*, 6/%'%//%( #66%#?

B%'&/% !*:*+*&,#?

&22*++*&,%/< (*+2*++%(< &/(%/

- -

/%:*+*&,

@ B%'&/%

*,#,)*#?

&22*++*&,%/ (*+2*++%(< &/(%/

- - #'&/%2%,$*&,%( )*/)12+$#,)%+< )*:*?

/%?*%'

+< ,&$*)%( #B&:%-

- 8%#/,%( )&1,+%?

+1B2*$+ /%:%,1% #1$0&/*$*%+ B%?&> %//%( ?#> '#)$+ #66&*,$*,9 :*??#9%

0&?#/5< (%+6*$% '#)$ (&%+ )?%#/ #,$%)%(%,$+-

+1B2*$$%( 2%/*$&/*&1+ 5&1,9%/ #9% %:%, ?#,(0&?(*,9 ?%++ 6%$*$*&,%/- *+< $0%/%'&/%< +1B2*$$%( *2619,%( &/(%/+ 6#$%,$?5 *??%9#?

6%/:%/+%< #))&/(*,9?5< +#2% +%$ #+*(% :*??#9%

0&?#/5-

@- %/ )&,$/#< )&1,+%?

.1?(%%6 4*,90 &66&+%( +1B2*++*&,+ B%0#?'

+1B2*$$*,9 #'$%/ )&,+*(%/*,9 /%?#$*:% 2%/*$+ (%2%/*$+ &??%)$&/7+ &/(%/ B%%, 160%?( !*:*+*&,#?

&22*++*&,%/

*,#,)*#?

&22*++*&,%/< (& )#??

*,$%/'%/%,)% &1/$-

+1B2*$$%( 2%/*$&/*&1+ *,#+21)0 ,#2% /%)&22%,(%( ++*+$#,$ ,( /#(% ++*+$#,$ +$ /#(%< .&+?*< :%/5 /%?%:#,$ '#)$&/ )&,)1//%( >*$0 /%)&22%,(#$*&,+

+1B2*$$%( 5&1,9 %,%/9%$*)< >0%/%#+ ,&:*)%-

+$*??

+1B2*$$%( +1''*)*%,$?5 +1''*)*%,$ 0&?(*,9

,#2% *,:&?:%( +&)*#?

>&/;

+ :*??#9%- )&,$%,(%( 6%/ +%$$?%( ?#>< 2#$$%/ 8#2B#/(#/< )0&*)% /%+6%)$%( ?*90$?5 *,$%/'%/%( >*$0< %:%, *'

$>& :*%>+ 6&++*B?%-

+ /%9#/(+ 6?%# (&%+ )?%#, #,$%)%(%,$+< +1B2*$$%( )/*2*,#?

)&26?#*,$ &,% ,(%/6#?< >0& )#,(*(#$% 6&+$ >*$0(/#>, )#,(*(#$1/% '#:&1/ 6%$*$*&,%/< $#/,*+0 *2#9% -

+1B2*$$%( B#+*+ )&26?#*,$ ,(%/6#?< &,%

?&(9%( 0&>%:%/< =1(92%,$ -

< 6#++%( 41B !*:*+*&,#?

1(*)*#?

#9*+$/#$%< .&+?*< #?/%#(5 +$#,(+ #)D1*$$%( %:%, #66%#?

=1(92%,$ -

(*+2*++%( 4%++*&,+

1(9%<

%>#/*< *$+ =1(92%,$ -

*+< $0%/%'&/%< )&,$%,(%( $0%/% ,& (*+D1#?*'*)#$*&,(%2%/*$ #$$#)0%( -

)&,$%,(%( (%'#1?$%/ /*%,$#?

#,;

&22%/)%< *,*$*#$%( /%)&:%/5 6/&)%%(*,9+ /%)&:%/5 #2&1,$

+- <

<@@ '*?*,9 1,(%/ 4%)$*&,

#/5#,# )$

#))&/(*,9?5 )&,$%,(%( '/%% '/&2 *,(%B$,%++< &,% /%?%:#,$ )&,+*(%/#$*&,+ 2#$$%/ *$0 +1B2*++*&,+< )&1,+%?

6/#5%( (*+2*++#?

)*:*?

6%$*$*&,-

0%#/( )&1,+%?

/%+6%)$*:% 6#/$*%+ 6%/1+%( 6#6%/B&&;

>*$0 $0%*/ #B?% #++*+$#,)%-

- %/%< >&1?( #66&+*$% +$#$% /%?#$*:% 2%/*$+

,&$*)%( &??%)$&/< )#, +122%( 1,(%/ #/$*)1?#/+ %$*$*&,%/

./*+0#, .12#/

%+6&,(%,$ &-

4*,90 9% (1)#$*&,#?

D1#?*'*)#$*&, -- 6#++

$0 )?#++ 6#++ 8#,( 0&?(*,9+

)/%+ )/%+

%)&22%,(%(

++*+$#,$ +$ /#(%< .&+?* ++*+$#,$ ,( /#(%< .&+?*- 4&)*#?

&/;

+ ?&&( (&,#$*&,+ '#2*?5 6?#,,*,9 )#+%+- -

/&2 B#/% 6%/1+#?

#B&:% %A$/#)$%( )&26#/*+&,

16&, )&,+*(%/#$*&, 6?%#(*,9+2#$%/*#?

#:#*?#B?% /%)&/(< ,&$*)%(

#$ /%?%:#,$ $*2%< #B&1$ 5%#/+ #9%< >0& 9#*,%( %A6%/*%,)% 8#2B#/(#/* >&/;

'#$0%/ /%2#*,%( 4#/B/#0 8#2B#/(#/< >0%/%#+ &$0%/ 0#,(< B#/%?5 5%#/+ #9% ,&:*)% )&26#/#$*:%?5 *,%A6%/*%,)%(-

1/$0%/< ,#2%

/%)&22%,(%( ?&>%/ /%:%,1% &''*)*#?+ )&,$/*B1$%( $&>#/(+ +&)*#?

>&/;+ :*??#9%< ?*;%< B?&&( (&,#$*&,+ '#2*?5 6?#,,*,9 )#+%+- - ?$0&190< 0&?(+ B1$ *??*$%/#$%< /#$0%/ +$1(*%( 16$&

$0 )?#++ 0&?(+ +1''*)*%,$ ?#,(0&?(*,9 ,#2%- - + '#/ /%)&22%,(#$*&,+ ?&>%/

%:%,1% ''*)%/ )&,)%/,%(< #?$0&190< B&1,( /%)&22%,(#$*&,

%:%,1% 1$0&/*$*%+ '#:&1/ )#,(*(#$%C 0&>%:%/< (1% )&,+*(%/#$*&, #))&/(%( +1)0 /%)&22%,(#$*&,+ $0%5 6&+*$*&, #++%++ +1*$#B*?*$5 )#,(*(#$% +1)0 /%)&22%,(#$*&, >&1?( +&2% 6%/+1#+*:% :#?1%- /%9#/(< /%'%/%,)% )#, &B+%/:#$*&,+

*:*? @

1,=#B<

- ?$0&190< &>,+ C 0&>%:%/< &B+%/:%( '#/ 0&?(*,9 )&,)%/,%(< +#2% $#;%, *,$& )&,+*(%/#$*&, 61/6&+% +%)1/*$5 $&>#/(+ 9&:%/,2%,$ /%:%,1% )&??%)$%(

%+6&,(%,$ #B&1$ #)/%+ ?#,(< +1''*)*%,$ $#;%, *,$& )&,+*(%/#$*&, 61/6&+% +%)1/*$5 /%:%,1%< )&??%)$%( &/%&:%/< !

*:*? < &1/$ &B+%/:%( /%:%,1% +$&&( #B&?*+0%( B&$0 4$#$% 1,=#B

#/5#,#< ?&,9 B#);< $01+ &>,*,9 6&+$ >&1?( 21)0 +*9,*'*)#,)% #,5 '1/$0%/-

-@ + /%9#/(+ +1B2*++*&, (&%+ )?%#, #,$%)%(%,$+< &B+%/:%( #?/%#(5 +$#,(+ #)D1*$$%(

/%9*+$%/%( 1,(%/ 4%)$*&,

< #$ -4- .&+?*< =1(92%,$ -

+#*( =1(92%,$ 160%?( 4%++*&,+

1(9%<

%>#/*< *$+ =1(92%,$ -

6%/1+#?

=1(92%,$ -

>&1?( +0&> 6/&+%)1$*&, '#*?%( B/*,9 0&2% 91*?$

4*,90 B%5&,( +0#(&> /%#+&,#B?% (&1B$-

!*:*+*&, %,)0 &1/$

&B+%/:%( &,)% 6%/+&, #)D1*$$%( )0#/9%+ ,&,% 6/&+%)1$*&, >*$,%++%+ +166&/$%( 6/&+%)1$*&, )#+%< +0&1?( $#;%, #(:%/+% '#)$&/ +1)0 6%/+&, )#,,&$ (%%2%( *,%?*9*B?% B%*,9

+#*( )#+%< &,7B?% !*:*+*&, %,)0 &B+%/:%( #,&$0%/ =1(92%,$ &1/$ $ "

>#+ #66?*)#B?% '#)$+ $ "

+16/#< )#,(*(#$% 6&+$ #)D1*$$%( )/*2*,#?

9*:*,9 0*2 B%,%'*$ (&1B$ ?*90$ &B+%/:%( '#)$+ )*/)12+$#,)%+ +$*92# )#,(*(#$% )&26?%$%?5 >#+0%( &1$-

4*2*?#/?5< )#+%< 6/&+%)1$*&, '#*?%( B/*,9 0&2% )0#/9%

#)D1*$$%(-

0%/%'&/%< $0%/% ,& +$*92#< #$$#)0%( )#,(*(#$1/% 0%/%*,- -

1/$0%/2&/%< #&!

()) <

*:*? C 0%?( !*:*+*&, %,)0 &1/$ )0&*)% !*+$/*)$ )#,,&$ ?*90$?5 +%$ #+*(%< %:%, *'

$>& :*%>+ 6&++*B?%< 1,?%++ $0%/% #,5 6#$%,$ *??%9#?*$5 &/ 6%/:%/+*$5 $0%/%*,- %+$#B?*+0%( 2#*, #1$0&/*$5 >0& #66/%)*#$%+ #,$%)%(%,$+ #??

'/#5 B1$ 6%/+&,#??5 *,$%/#)$+ >*$0 $0%2-

:*%> #B&:% (*+)1++*&, #$$%,(*,9 )*/)12+$#,)%+< 2%/%?5 B%)#1+% &/ 0&?(+ +?*90$?5 )#,,&$ +#*( )0&*)% ;%%6*,9 :*%> #??

/%?%:#,$ )&,+*(%/#$*&,+< *??%9#?

&/ 6%/:%/+%-

- :*%> 2#$$%/<

(& '*,( #,5 2%/*$ +#2% #))&/(*,9?5 (*+2*++%(-

%,(*,9 #66?*)#$*&,

+< *'

#,5< +0#??

+$#,( )?&+%(-

- -

+=;+ 0%$0%/ +6%#;*,9/%#+&,%(

"%+

& 0%$0%/ /%6&/$#B?% "%+