Bhupender Singh v. State Of Haryana & Anrs












 




  


 !"#$"%&#'

"(&(&#"% )"%* * (+(" ,+%-+#++#$+#("% ."*!#$"#(* 


 
 
 

    


!

"
!#
$!%&$
'

(" & 
)&*
+
&$$!( ,
!

-.,/) '

1 !
+
#

,
!
!

"
!
'!

2 



-.,/) '

"

!.$,
+
!

,
3'

3/ %"*"#( / 0%1+$+23$24+("

%("!"(&(&#"% 0%,+%&*.+(""3%53,+%-+#+ 0%6+#7+85-+83$24+("

%%"*!#$"#(  
  4
 "!%+-"%&#("!%"*"#(!"(&(&#&* %&** +#4" +7%&(&#("

#+( %" 4"%(&%+%& %: +*&#' &;! '#"$8"(("%$+("$ 32&$"

7&43("!"(&(&#"%7+*#(&#("%2&"7"$#("'% #$(+("$&$#( !**"**("%": &*&(""<!"%&"#4"+*!"%+$2"%(&*";"#($+("$    %("%  !%+-"%  +*  +8*  =""#  ;+$"  %  &** &#'  $&%"4(&#*  (  ("

%"*!#$"#(*(4#*&$"%("4+*" ("!"(&(&#"% %("+ %"*+&$!*(

%&"

8-3(" +4(* ("4+*"+%"(+(&#("-"+% 3+# +$2"%(&*";"#(7+*&** "$ %&#2&(&#'+!!8&4+(&#* %("!*( &*(%&4( "8 +%"

&4"%5% !> >&#(""8 +%" 4"$ 8"
+*("+#$ +4?7+%$

 
8+**"!+%(;"#(3,+%-+#+"%"7"%"((+8!*(*3 ( 7&43(%""

!*(*7"%";"+#( %5"#"%+8
+("'%-+#$#"7+* %</*"%2&4";"# "%": &*&(": +8& &4+(&# %("*+&$!*(7+*0+*("%>*"'%"" %;+ %"4'#&@"$A#&2"%*&(-&#4&+8%?%4&8'-%4#;&4*+#$ &2"

-"+%*  &"8$  "<!"%&"#4"  &#  ("  "2"8!;"#(  %  "8 +%"  "!+%(;"#(  

"#(%+8  %  +#-  (+("  52"%#;"#(  7+*  %": &%"$   #  +$$&(&#  (  (+( ?#78"$'" ,&#$&B+#*?%&( !(;+(%&48"2"87+*+8*%": &%"$  " "4%"(+%-3,+%-+#+ =8&4"%2&4"
;;&**&#2&$"8"(("%$+("$  * '(48+%& &4+(&#7&(%"'+%$(+;=&' &(-&#(""<!"%&"#4"48+ *"#  +'+&#+#+$2"%(&*";"#(7+*&** "$+#$((+8*&<!*(*7"%" +$2"%(&*"$ ( *&<!*(*3  %!*(*7"%";"+#( %5"#"%+8
+("'%-3 #"!*( %</*"%2&4";"#+#$#"!*(7+* % +4?7+%$
8+** # * =*": "#(+$2"%(&*";"#($+("$  3+48+%& &4+(&#7+*;+$"&#
8+ *" (+((""<!"%&"#4"7&88#8-="4 #("$+ ("%+4: &%&#'("=+*&4 ;&#&; ;: +8& &4+(&#"!"(&(&#"%="&#'4+#$&$+(" +4?7+%$
8+** +#$+2&#'%": &*&(": +8& &4+(&#+!!8&"$ %("+ %"*+&$!*(= ("7+* #( 4+88"$  %  &#("%2&"7 )&$" &;!

'#"$  8"(("%  $+("$  3 &(  7+* &# %;"$ (+( "  $&$ #( !**"**  (" %": &%"$ "<!"%&"#4" +*  !"% (" +$2"%(&*";"#("!"(&(&#"%7+*+2&#'"<!"%&"#4" %;(",+%-+#+ (+(" 
 #4&8  % 
&8$  "8 +%"3  &*(%&4(  %+#4  ."7+%&3  7&4   7+* =(+&#"$!%&%(+4: &%&#'("%": &%"$: +8& &4+(&# "!"(&(&#"%7+* #(  4+88"$  %  &#("%2&"7  ="4+ *"    =(+&#&#'  ("  "<!"%&"#4"  !%&%  ( +4: &%&#'("%": &%"$: +8& &4+(&# ,";+$"+%"!

%"*!#$"#(*= (*(&88"7+*#(&#("%2&"7"$+&$&;! '#"$8"(("%$+("$

&** =C"4(;+(("% 4+88"#'"&#("!%"*"#(!"(&(&# D"+%#"$4 #*"8 %("!"(&(&#"%* =;&(*(+(("!"(&(&#"% 7+*!**"**&#'("%": &*&(": +8& &4+(&#+#$"<!"%&"#4"+*!"%"+%8&"% +$2"%(&*";"#(+#$* 44#$&(&# "<!"%&"#4"&*#(;"#(&#"$&#("

  . 8"= (*(&88(+(+*=""#*(&! 8+("$&#("* =*": "#(+$2"%(&*";"#( D"+%#"$4 #*"8 %("%* =;&(*(+(("4#(%2"%*-&#("!%"*"#(4+*"&* *: +%"8-42"%"$=-("$"4&*&# ,#>=8"("!"<
 %(&#
&2&8!!"+8   (&(8"$+*53'!,
6
 &($&
5"
&'3
&)
&',
!

$"4&$"$# 

 D"+%#"$  4 #*"8  %  %"*!#$"#(    * =;&(*  (+(  (" !"(&(&#"%7+*#(!**"**&#'("%": &*&(""<!"%&"#4"+*!"%,+%-+#+ "8 +%" 4"$ 8"
+*("*+#$ +4?7+%$
8+**"*"!+%(;"#(5% !

> >  "%2&4"  . 8"*3   3  7"%"&#3  &2"  -"+%*  &"8$  "<!"%&"#4"  &# "2"8!;"#(  %  "8 +%"  "!+%(;"#(    (" 
"#(%+8  %  +#-  (+("

52"%#;"#(&*%": &%"$ %("$&%"4(%"4% &(;"#((("!*( &*(%&4( "8 +%"

&4"%D"+%#"$4 #*"8 %("%* =;&(*(+(+*!"4& &4;"#(&# 7+*("%"&#("+$2"%(&*";"#(%"'+%$&#'"<!"%&"#4"+#$+44%$&#'8-(" !"(&(&#"%  7+*  #(  4+88"$  %  &#("%2&"7  "  C $';"#(  %"8&"$  !#  =- 8"+%#"$4 #*"8 %("!"(&(&#"%&*#(+!!8&4+=8"?""!&#'&#2&"7(" +4(* +#$4&%4 ;*(+#4"* ("!%"*"#(4+*"D"+%#"$4 #*"8+*+8*%"8&"$ !#("C $';"#( ,#>=8"("!"<
 %(&#("4+*" 

&!

&'/$.-3
&/,
5"
 &3**&
&',
!

"4
. !%";"
 %( 3&# * !!%( &*4#("#(&#* ,"+%$("+%' ;"#(*+$2+#4"$=-8"+%#"$4 #*"8 %("

!+%(&"*+#$+2"+8*'#"(% '("$4 ;"#(*+2+&8+=8"#(" &8" "  +$2"%(&*";"#(  %  ("  !*(    &*(%&4(  "8 +%"  

&4"% 5% !> >&** "$=-,+%-+#+ =8&4"%2&4"
;;&**&#+*#(=""# $&*! ("$   #  ("  +$2"%(&*";"#(  &** "$  &#  ("  -"+%    #(&#'  7+* ;"#(&#"$  %"'+%$&#'  "<!"%&"#4"  +*  (  7"("%  &(  * 8$  +2"  =""# +4: &%"$!%&%(+4: &%&#'("%": &*&(": +8& &4+(&#%+ ("%+4: &%&#'("

%": &*&(": +8& &4+(&# =*": "#(8-+#("%+$2"%(&*";"#(7+*&** "$#  37"%"&#3+*!"4& &448+ *"7+*;"#(&#"$*(+(&#'("%"&#(+(

 ("E"<!"%&"#4"7&88#8-="4 #("$+ ("%+4: &%&#'("=+*&*;&#&; ;

: +8& &4+(&#F   (  &*  +8*  #(  $&*! ("$  (+(  ("  !"(&(&#"%  7+*  +2&#' "<!"%&"#4"7"  

( +*&*48"+% %;##"< %"/ "  !"(&(&#"%  7+*  #(  &#("%2&"7"$  =-  %"*!#$"#(    +#$  &(  7+* 4#2"-"$(&;2&$"8"(("%$+("$ (+("$&$#(!**"**("

%": &%"$"<!"%&"#4"+*!"%+$2"%(&*";"#( %;+88-7"#7"(+8?+= ("<!"%&"#4"3&(&*4#*&$"%"$+*+# "<!"%&"#4"+ ("%+4: &%&#'(";&#&; ;: +8& &4+(&# #8"**("%7&*"&(&* !%2&$"$   #  ("  !%"*"#(  4+*"3  +  *!"4& &4  ;"#(&#  7+*  ("%"  &#  ("

+$2"%(&*";"#((+(("%": &*&(""<!"%&"#4"&*%": &%"$+ ("%+4: &%&#'("

;&#&; ;%": &*&(": +8& &4+(&##(""+%8&"%+$2"%(&*";"#(("%"7+*# *!"4& &4%": &%";"#(+#$+ ("%+2&#'48+%& &4+(&# %;(""!+%(;"#( 4#4"%#"$3+#("%+$2"%(&*";"#(7+*&** "$7"%"+48+ *"48+%& -&#'

"<!"%&"#4"  7+*  ;"#(&#"$  *  !"%  ("  ("%;*  +#$  4#$&(&#*    ("

+$2"%(&*";"#(3  ("  !"(&(&#"%  7+*  #(  !**"**&#'  ("  "<!"%&"#4"  + ("% +4: &%&#'(";&#&; ;: +8& &4+(&#+#$+44%$&#'8-"7+*#(4+88"$ % &#("%2&"7"C $';"#(%"8&"$ !#=-8"+%#"$4 #*"8 %("!"(&(&#"%&* #(+!!8&4+=8"?""!&#'&#2&"7(" +4(* ("4+*"+*&#(+(4+*"("%"

7+*#*!"4& &4;"#(&#7&(%"'+%$("<!"%&"#4" #


&!
&'/$.-3
&/, "
%&"

7". &84 ,#>=8"  ("

!"<
 %(+*"8$(+((""<!"%&"#4"&*(="4#*&$"%"$+ ("%+4: &%&#'

(";&#&; ;: +8& &4+(&#%": &%"$ #8"**("4#("<(("%7&*"$";+#$* 0%"2"%3  ("  !"(&(&#"%  +*  #(  4+88"#'"$  ("  +$2"%(&*";"#(  &#  (" !%"*"#(4+*"+#$#8-+!%+-"%+*=""#;+$" %+887&#'&;(="

&#("%2&"7"$ %("*+&$!*(#4+*"("!"(&(&#"%&*+''%&"2"$7&((" 4#$&(&#  "<!"%&"#4"37&4&*%": &%"$+ ("%+4: &%&#'("%": &*&("

;&#&; ;: +8& &4+(&#3"* 8$+2"4+88"#'"$("+$2"%(&*";"#( #2&"7 (" +4(*+*;"#(&#"$+=2"3("%"&*#;"%&(&#

  ("* =;&**&#*;+$"=-8"+%#"$4 #*"8 %("!"(&(&#"%+#$("!"(&(&# ="&#'$"2&$ +#-;"%&(&*"%"=-$&*;&**"$ G #"

3

7
  8 !C+