Subrata Ghosh And ORS. v. Union Of India And ORS.
CWP No. 15972 of 2023 -1-
" #
$ " " % & '
()
*
$ # $% &&'
(&& $% & && &
+ ) ,-, $ '. / 0 + # (,-, $ '. / + ) 1(,- + " 1 ,-,$ # '. / 0 + - ),- + 23&,-,$ # '. / + - ('
4(, (' ( $ 5" # '. / 0 $ 6" # '. / + +(),-,$ 7
# '. / + & ,-, $ # '. / 0 '. / 0 $ 8 - 9 4) 1! 1:(8 * -&)
CWP No. 15972 of 2023 -2- / (# ! (18,;( ,4 ( '. / 8 - $& / ( # ! (18,3)
& ( ( 1 14 96 & / ( # ! (18 $&(1 / ( # ! (18-,
!
:(( / (# ! (184
8 + 8< = + 8< : / (# ! (18 >-& & ? , 0 1@
0 4( &(,4 $ 1@
0, && 9(A 91( 4 $$8 + 8< (
0,
0,0 0,
0, 0,
B 7
- &(A (6<4&(
0 0 0 C (,& / 9 B 4
B $ 1 && &8 - &(8 '&& 8 (
0 !
, - ((4 1$ (6<4$(
"# #"
CWP No. 15972 of 2023 -3- !
" # $ % &"
' ( #$
"# #"
) &"'
* $ $$( $- ( 14 4$( &( && $$ & 0 B8 ( '&& # & 4 (, 4 $ (( 1 (9
04 1 (1(8 $$1 1 $& '. / B5 $ % & ' (
,'. / BB B5 $ ! !
) & ' (
( 1(;121& 0
B((4 4$ 1 ($ (( , $$( & 9 B4 (1(8 (((8 4 & ( 8+%&&& ( 1 $ 1(;142&= -/ B B6$ % & ' (
!
* D (
0 $8 1(;10
B # $ 6 $$ & (4 $$(8 1 (A
CWP No. 15972 of 2023 -4D( & +%
0 ( 1 (
0(A 1 D( & (, ( &4 4 @ , &(8, # -$(, & & ( (8) 1 $ - $$( ) & , (
04 ( 2 4$$( 4(8 " # ,4 4 (&(8&8 '
- 1$ (8&& (( 1 * $& ' = 4(& 0
, : / (# ! (18 >-& & ? 4
4 41 & $( (1@
4$$(( / (# ! (18,3) !
/ (# ! (18,3) 041 (A ( 1 (
0 4 $ ) 1$$( /#!
3) 4 ( A 1 $4 6 >? 7 / (# ! (18, < -,
&((8 : / ( # ! (18 >-& & ? 4
* -&) / (# ! (18,;( 41 $( (1@
CWP No. 15972 of 2023 -5-
( $ 4 A&$ & $4 $ ( 4 E( $- , 4( $ (
0 0 0 4 ) 1$$(& ( (6< $(4 : $$ $ ,4($$D ,4 4 $ $( (6<1 ( &>?,( & >? ( &7>?
!
& 6 +,"
#$ -( +, #+!,( " $
#$
# (.
/
0 1! 2 3 4 4
'"' ''' $ 4 4#( $/5 +, #+-,( " $
#$
# (.
/
'
6 0 ! 2 3 4 4
'"' ''' $ 4 4#( $( 7# 6
# '# 8' $ #
5 &"
' ( $
'
60 ! 2 4 4
CWP No. 15972 of 2023 -6- '"' ''' $ 4 4#( $( 7# 6
# '# 8' $ #
/5 +,"
#$ 9( +, #+!,( " $
#$
# (.
/
0 - 2 3 4 4
'"
' ' '' $ 4 4#( $/5 +, #+-,( " $
#$
# (.
/:
&"
' (# $
'
0 1! 2
3 4 4
#
0 1 $ 0 1 0 1! 7# 6
# '# ' $ #
/5 + ,"
#$ ;( +, #+!,( " $
#$
# (.
/
+<"
,0 9 2 3 4 4
'" ' ' '' $ 4 4#( $/5 +, #+-,( " $
#$
# (.
CWP No. 15972 of 2023 -7- /
0 - 7# 0 - 7# $ 0 -0 -6
# ) 6' .
#'
# - = #$
' (
"
"#
$ " <"
# " "$ #
# 4
* : ((4 1 & + ,:7#
''
' # # >?@ $ A# "#
# '' 4# 1 '
$ (!
351
)$ (!
35- $ (!
B# (!
5!
' (!
5 ;
' (!
% +%, : #
" "$ # ) 6
#
:"( C# #& $ '
# '' 4##
;
D $ (!
3 3 )$ (!
3.
& #
# ;
D $ ( !
3 3 )$ (!
3
#
# #
#
# #$ 7# # #
# ) 6
# :"(C# #& *
CWP No. 15972 of 2023 -8- &( $ , & , 4 * -&)/#!,;( 4 (( 1 ' $ 4$
, %1 ' 8 $
&($ 48 # 4 , $ $ 4
1 $ &)*+,--,.-/0121/,/,.13- = ( $ ' 1 1(A (4, 4 4 (8 21& '$ (8 $&' !
$ &) 1 & & , , (( 1 1 1 $ ' # & 4 ( (8 (8 = ( $ & (4 4& , 1 $ # 4, 4 ( (
0 & 9 B,()$ '. / 0 ,4(1 (,4 4 4 (
CWP No. 15972 of 2023 -9- # & (&) 1 8 &$4&(4 4(( 1 (44 8 %1 ' (8 $ & () (4 (8(A 1 ( &)*+,--,.-/0131-2.41./- 7 = ($ 2 #
$ 1 84 (1( & (
0 & & & (8$$(( $$ & $- # &(A (8
(8&&/#!((# 0 = ($ & 1 (4((8 1 , &(8, # 1 $ $$(
& /#!
-
0 $$$( & 7 -, $ 1 ((41 !
/#!;( 3) $$ 4
&(8$$ ( (8 &) 1 $& 4 & (( 0 B = ( $ ($ * "
' & " * & $
CWP No. 15972 of 2023 -10-
> ?'-=<4 (84 (8 4( $$ %(( +!!
(!) , -!# "& +! & .
>
0?7#! 7>'?, /0.
& +!!
(!) , $
0>? ''0, - & !
!
> 0?''77 1 &
"
>
?B''
= ( $ 6 &
/#!
3) ;( $(8 1 8 $ 4( $$( $$(8 C $$( , ( & $ ((1 & & &((1( !
8(8 $ 7 -
0 $$ & & & $8& 1 & <( (
0 4 ) 1$$( .
( 4$$(& # )
= ( $ 6 & '( & (( 8 1 $$( 48 #& ( ' D ( & 4 (8 $(&) %4, 4 1 , 4( 8(4 )
CWP No. 15972 of 2023 -11- # & 4
(( $ 4 (1( $$(8 %, , $8 $ 6 (((4$4 ( $ & &$ 8 ' )35.567-,-5.48.86)-,.
.
( ( (1 , ' $&(8 (A D( 1 (
0 1 $$$( ) & &(7 . 4$$( (8 ) 1(8 & $ 1 (A ( (, >$?
& 1 (( & & ,4 &(8& (& && 0, B >$?44 1 6 $$( C & &, (A 9&& 4( 4 (4 7>?
>? / (# ! (18, < -
0 234 %!
5+ , +!, +1, ? # # ' # 7# ' #
'' E "
F
CWP No. 15972 of 2023 -12- +-, # # " '"
" # #
$
$ E * :& $ ,$$
1 , 4 (($$((& $( (1@ $# 4(&)( 1(8 # 4( (&) 1 &( &8 $ # * "
' & " * >$?, -$A' 1 (4 (( ((4 1$ $( 9!G # ( "' '
#$## .
, 6
# # ' # ( ' ' $ '
, 6 #$ 7# ' $ ' # ( ' #" $ "# $"## 6 #$'
$ $ ' ' #
( $ ' #
'' ' , ' '
' "' , 2 $# ' $ ' ( 4# $#$
#
($# #
'
CWP No. 15972 of 2023 -13- # # ' #$
" # ''' ' * 7 -$$(8 1 (4(4 $ ,4 & & 1 & 4 1@$ >?
!
, D( $& A$ 4
& 1@ 4 4($$(8 $$(8 !
, '(>?>? >?&) 1& & (6<4( $$(8 0 C ( 1$1$ B >? >?
$ >$?, $$ & $) $ 1 1( , ( (A ( $ (
0,
0, 0 0,
0, 0,
B 7
, $$ &) 1(
!
, 8& $ # (8 $ 1( , ( (A ( $$A& 1 D( & $$ & &,4 4( & 4 & (6<$'(>?>? >?>$?
B : ( $ & & & 21& ',4
$ (8$&' %4,4 1&
CWP No. 15972 of 2023 -14- 2 ((4 (4&) 1 &(& 1 & $ 8 '4
&)( ((1( -4 D $ $8 * (,4 ( ' ( (
0((8 1 ) 4, & 4 $$( & 7>?, & & & ((1(((8 1 ((((4 1 $ 7>? 7>?
!
(( 1 (, ,(
#
-
& ' (
,> ? '', $&'A& 4 (4 & $& 21& 4 (
-1:'
$ " #
#$ ' ' $ 4#
A#"
($ ## # . ? :
A#"
4# $# $ " " $ A#" b) #$ ' ' # $ $ $ #
$
# "
"# # 4
# +0 2 0 H 6D + % 9,!44 % 3, ? :
" ""
A#" ' "# # $ '
( ' #" $$ #" $
CWP No. 15972 of 2023 -15- "
#
$ 4#
"
A#" 6 ( ' #
#$# # $ A#"
' "# d) )# # $ # $ '
$" I.F" D 2 (+ %%9,;44 ;J?
$ $" I.4# K '# : $#( %%1#''+ ,44%;24# 6 C D (+!
%, 144 9J e) : "
# # A#' $ " # ' '
' ' ( # - 4
# 6*
# $ "
) *& ' (
> ? ''07, $&' ( 6 #( # ( $ 4#
A#"
4# # $" " $ A#" 6 # $
#$ ' 6 ( ($
' #$ $ $ #
$ # "
"# # 4
# 6 $ ' #
#$# # $ A#" ' "
# : 4# ( (
# # $ #$'
$ " : 4# # "
# # A#' $
" # ' ' ' ' (
# - 4
# 6*
CWP No. 15972 of 2023 -16- :((4 1 421& , $&' +.
&
" >?'-=< K A#' ( " # A# < ( ' " # ' #$
# # A#" &
( " ' "
# # " ' # " $ #
# $ A# ' $#
$ " " # 4
# 6: $(
'
" # ' (' # # $ '
$ 4# 6 ( ' A#" #$ ( $ # " # " #
#' # !:' " # "
( $ ' ' '
$ ( ' ( $ $4#
' 4
# 6 # $ '
$ " # " ( ' # $
# #
' $ A# :
$ $ ' ' ' $ " '
' # $ < ( " # &
CWP No. 15972 of 2023 -17-
# # ' # " $
#& ' $ 4# ($ #$ 7# " # # "
#" ( #$ 7# " # $ # #
##
'
>" #L4# L A#" $"
( # $ " # $ " * .
( ( 1 , $&' 21& +.
>$?, ( 9:4
# 6' # $
" #
A#
A# " :'
$ " $ " 4
# :" $ " #
$ "' ' #
.
: "' " " $$# $(' ( # $
A#" # ($# "
"
$ : " " $ ' 6 #
A#" ' "#
# $'
( '
#" $$ #" $ "
#
$ # "
A#" ' #$ $ $ #
$ 4
#
" #"
CWP No. 15972 of 2023 -18- # # " ' # '' # ' ' # 4
# 6$ " # # # $ A# 6
A# ' # ( E
%%3$ # * , 4 4 ( (1( ( &) 1 8 $4&( 1 ' (( $4( $ (4 , $4& 4 ((4 &84D 8 ' # & 4(4&8((4 1$, 4(4 D &(8$( ((4 & 1 - &&, (44( 8 & ) ((4 -$$(8 1 (4 $ , $$ ( 4 4 & 9 B 1 $$(8 4& & & < ( $ 6 & & 4($$, , 4 84( 4& 4 & & 1 1 (A ( $$( $ - # 4, 4(
A8 1$$( (((1( &
CWP No. 15972 of 2023 -19- 4& & &
$ - -(( $ 4 (1( $$(8 1,4( !
$ $ 4( , , ( 1(8$ 4) A$ (D( 7 -(( ) (4((( ( 4 4 $ 6# (()$,$ ( A4 $& &8 !
& 8 $ 6 4(, 1(8, &9 $$( !
8$8 '
0 (( $ 6 !
4$ 1(8$ & B -(($ 1$$( (( $
/
&'
(&& !
"
& & !
.
$) 19 F9/ .
$( F9/