High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3404/2014allowed

Ravinder Singh & ORS v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2019-01-18Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari14 pages

!"# $%&%!'()**+

( ,-

* .*.*.-

$% & ' $ $( ) *.*.- /* 0

* ## +)+%%,+& - . /+&0 1

# 2

# .

%,/3-40 # 1 +5)5 - 6+5)5 60 $% 7 # # 1 #

## # # #

! .# #

# *# 1 #

# 8 *# * ## # #

8 #

1:; 8 *## # +7+%%,++ - . /(0 . +,< /#

## # # 9 ;

* > 2 " # # * ? ## 1 # *# $( ) &7 *# +554 # ,4,+%,+4 - . /+40 9 *# #

# @ $%% A # ##1 # 1 # ? # #

#2 " ## #1 1 1 ## 1 1 # 1 &7 !

1 # *# * ! # " $()% ++,(%,+4 - . /+(0 *# * # # # 1 *## # 9 8 1 1 *## ## *

; - #0 +54+ - 6+54+ 60

> *## #

*# #1

#1 #

1 ,'+++55( - . /+0 1 # ++ +54+ 1 *## A @ 9 # #

# ,)+%%,,7 *## ,'+++55( - . /+0 #

? # 1

,4,'+55) - . /%0 # 1 9 1 # # * # # $( ) * ? # 1 1 +%+,+55) - . /&0 # 1 . * ;/+57&'/+55) +(+%+55) - . /70 9 #

6 //

# 8 +5)5 %,,7%,+, - . /'0 %,/ %7+%%,+,

- . /40 %,/B ##1 +7+%%,++ - . /(0 1 1 ? 1 #

# # *# ( C( 1 ## #

# # " D # # # ? 1 ##

1 * * # ? # 1 > # ## 1 # 1 1 ##

# > ## : 1 1 > ## : : # # ? 1 #:

: 1 @ $ 8 # ##

## # # : :/ A>:

1 ## >

1 #1 ## ## 1

1 # ## # 1 # ##

E ? # A #

1 %5 )( (& %%+:/ # 1 # 1 &, ,% 4( ,)(:/ &+,)%,+% 1

# 2

# 1 +4,4%,+, - . /)0 1 # 1 +) ##

9 # # 1 3

* # 1 2 8 # *=/++(+/%,+& # # +7+%%,++ # # #

*##

# ## . * ##1 1

9 2 A

# 1 # #1 # 8 # #1 1 *## +54+ 9 +4,(%,+& - . /++0 C9 > / #

+7+%%,++ 1 2

1/ /2 ! # 8 # 1 ? # 1 # # 1 E > B 2 3

* # $ + % 7 #1 F ? ? # 1 # #1: #

#1 1 2!/ /2 1/ $ & 9 1 # #

# 2 # $ & # 1 # 1 : # *# 1 ? #

# 2 # # 8 #

# #1 ? # # # G 9 8 #1 1 1 *## ## *

; H #I +54+ *

# 2 #

# 1 1 # *#

# # 1/ =

#1 *

# 2 # $ & # ? # 1 *

# 2 #

.#1 # # 2 E ? # #

# # # / #

# # +)+%%,+& - . /+&0 C+ = @ $%% A # #1 1 22!

# '++5( G % ? #1 ##

## & = 22! #

7 9

# # % -0 ' = # # ....

....

? + % & 7 # # 1 # # # #

# .# #

# * 1 # #

# 8 ? # 8 # # ##

+7/+%/%,++ 1 ; 8 *##/* /2! # +% ,,,:/ 8 1 J &,< # J +,< $ # J +%< ## A . +,< # ## # # 9 ;

*/ * /2!

# 2 " # # # = # 1 E

*# #1 8 #

6 // +& +54+ #1 %,/3-40 6 #1 #

8 # D #1 #

*## +%+,%,+4 - . /+)0 # #1 ##1 * #

,7++%,+4 - . /+50 1 # *## %4 5) () 7'&:/

#1 #

# ? . ?

#1 ##

$()%

++,(%,+4 # 1 # *## # 3 # 1# # #

# *#

2 " %,D +5)5 C%,/D 2 1 / -+0 9 %,/3 ## 1 *#

1 1 *

1 > # -%0 1 / -+0 * 1 ## # *# 1 # -&0 = # # / -+0 * ## # 1# -70 ? 1 1 1 1 1# 1 ## # # # # # -'0 = %,/3 1 . 1 * 1 . > %,/? ## #

-40 = 1 . 1 . 1 / -'0 ## 1 *#

1 1

* 1 / -%0 -70 ## #1

/ -%0 # 1 1 # / -&0

# # * 1 ## # F

/ -70 1

1 1 1 1# 1 ## # # # #

# 9 # *# * ! # " %7 * +5+) 9 C%7 2 * # *# * # K9 * 2 " ## 2 * # *# * # E / $# D

1 +5'4 # 1 1

&/D-70 *# * ! # " &/D-70

C&D-70 ? 1 1 1 1 1# 1 ## # # # # # E 2 A %02 1.%'345&* '%!'!"'#%

%6%1 # 9 # C) ? #

# *# 8 1 # #

8 #

1 A 1 > ; 8 +)57 - 1 6 +)57 60 # &

&* &2 # 1 # 7 '

4 +)57 #1 B &D-&0 -70 # +) &, #1 +)57 ;>

#> &D & 8# +4 ++ +)57 9 ## * 1 1 $ + % # # # 1 # 8 F / -&0 &D 1 # # 1#

# > # / -+0 &D 9 #> 1

# #

##1 # / -70 &D

/ -70 &D 6? 1 1 1 1 1#6 1 #> $ 7 # # *# * # # # 9 1 # #

1 # #

* ! # # # # 8 # 2 " E * *=/+&(,,/%,+) #

%),'%,+)

## # # *# * ! # "

* #1 +54+

# > # # ##1 1# 8 #

8 ? # 1

*# * ! # " +54+ 1 # # 1 // #> # 1 9 *# * ! # " > # # #

9 * ++,(%,+4 - . /+(0 1

# . 1 # $()% 1 1 ##1

. # # # +5)5

+& +54+ # *# * # #1 # #1 8 8 1# # # # // # +54+ 9 ## # 1 #1 #1 *# * . # # #

$# 1 . 1

* 8 # ? # = * ## > 9

> *# * ! # "

> ##

# 1

# # 9 * 1

# # *

# 1 1

> #

#1 #1 ## 1 8 +)+%%,+& - . /+&0 . # 9 ++,(%,+4 #2 " # - . /+(0 ## #1 # . 1 # ## # * ## # 3. 2 1 #

# +),+%,+5 *.*.-