Balwinder Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others
!"#
%#&' ()%&* !+ $!
%, -. /*% -*'
'
'0'
.%# 1%2% -*'
'3 - '
' ()
% 405%%/+-&%+#*3 '
6
7 %8 * 3 ' % ,9 / %' . 6:3'';0 .&% . /%3*' */&00%3%5 + 5 # 1%2 *:
*%&*% /-* ##&% -%-$< =
$<,*2:*
1%2.&'7 %% -55 '#.&8 0'+ $>>?7#'*+@*$>>? 0'@8*%2 %5 --% - 0'$?6% $<6*%2 %--- * 0',*55-%##& :0# 0 $?6+*%'2 3'&2-*%*3''#. '0 -*
1%2 5 '*%2#- :2:35 #5%5 /'* 9'*% /,9 /A3 &#%%'#:%'% -3'''' /'0&* B0%#&% '%'%3'&2- 06$?6 .5%:+ 0$<6*%'2
'-3-*%*3''#. /%3*''*%2 #- :2:35 #5%5 /'0 /%3*'*% / ,9 /A3 &#%%' :%% -3'''' /*B0%#&% '%'
3'&2- *'%- 0
*/% &#*3 ' * '% ,3 '
%/% ' 0 $?6%' 3 *+ 0 - 0 < #* 1%2 .&'7 5 #. /%3*'% -. 6:3''8 0'+$> $7# '*+@*$> $ 0'@8+0 /%3*'% -. 6:3'', /2% /,*9'#35 *3''#'''% '%' '021&*B0%#: /*'''% %-A%5 %
C=D *3 '*%,6#-/% &'%/% '*%5 --
':+*:& -*%*0 /%3*'% -. 6 :3'' *% 2 - - 35 % % 0 * 3'' # . '''% ' % -'/%- % - % # * ' &* 0-/5 #*'0-%-$$
--
?"<#
7 %%. /*'0'.%# 1%2% -% *8% -*&
&- ,63 '
.& -:+*' : 3'#. /%3* *3%5 * &*35 %330 '%5 5%% -; *%2 -;*%2 &53:13%-E-
C?D % / *%- % - &0 ' # * 3 ' % % & '-%2 /*+,- # -% :5 2**& '
'%: ' # * %' ' *% %% . /*@' &%' 7'03%8+ * .% 5 - #&% -%- !
$*%- #-* 1%2. - % '% % - %' F% - 35 %- ##& 70368) '%.& 0'+ $7#'*+@* $ 0'@8 ,*0 -*3''#. ',-&--2#-2:
35 #5 %5 /' 9' :
*% 5+ $> $ 0' , %-5-: #&% -0 - 0'< #$> $ 0'+0 .&% . /%3*'% -. 6:3'',B0%:/2% /,*9'# 35 * 3'' # '''% ' 7 , 6-'/ %- %' .
'''% '8 *,%' %5 -5 5%- $> $ 0'%9%,%:* /* # & '-% # 35 #5 0 .&% . /%3*';
. 6:3''
0*+*'0#0 -+%'%5%##%&+*%*,6 3 ' *%&%'*%-B0%#-*'''% %-A%5 %
$>> -,*0'/2#35 ' &*
* ,'# -0&- *:% $+*#+&0- *%%9 %,%:* /2:/*#& '-% #35 0 -*$> $
*' 0 *0' %&&3- *&%5#0 /%3*'% . 6:3''#35 %'. ' 5'# 06<#$> $
C<D .%# 1%2 A&'#'3,'0 -3' &= >#* '0 *%'#50%-* 1%2.&'
7 %% -55 '#.&8 0'+$>>?
0$7=8# $>>? 0'3-'*%*'%5'*%%33:%*3'' 036+ 036% -036'&' &
& ,**%##%'#.%#
1%2 0 7/8#*' 0'-# '@.&@5% :036 '&+036'&036'&& '0- &
& ,* *%##%'#*.%# 1%2%'3'&%'/ *33 -A $7=8% -=7/8#$>>? 0'+%-%'#,'(6
!" # $% &"''% &%'%
( ))$#& #"
* AA AA AA AA 7=8*:'*%%33:%*3'' 036@@+036@@ -036@@'&' &
& ,**%##%'# .%# 1%2 %+# # #"
,*-./ *'0'+0 ''*& A *,'B0'(6 AA AA AA AA 7/8 @.&@ 5% ' % : 036@@ '&+ 036@@ '&036@@'&+& '0- &
& ,*
*%##%'#*.%# 1%2%'3'&%'/ * 33 -A
C D *33 -A$>>? 0'&%''#'*3'' 036+ 036% -036 *2%''# % : *3%:6'&%'
C!D ' 0 - %2 *% $>>? 0' % %33&%2 % 5 3%5 ' *.%# 1%2,**% '3%%'&0'#50%-2:*3%5 .5%:+,** -3%5 % '& 0' % ' % ''0+ '0&* 0' '% '0335 -2:*3' '#$>>? C"D * 3%5 # /&00 ,*&* * 3 '
2 /+*% '3%%'&0'/0%*& '# '& *'&& '#*3 '% -*53:'# /&003%5 %*#/ -0 -*$>>? 0' :
C>D *&%5#*3 '#35 %'. '
- 0'< #$> $ 0'*%'2 *,+%9 %,%:2:0#
0 $?6 '- - * 530/ - #&% -%- $< =
$< ,*0 -*3'' #. ' % ,2#-032:
35 #5%5 /'9' :*% /%%'#:%'@,9 / A3 & *%2' &#% :*& %:0*% /#&#%,+ *3' '#$>>?0'*%&&03-*#-% -% #&%2 /0%*& '#'&'#%*53:'#3%5 # /&00
C$ D *'10 &0+'0'#0# 0 #$>>?0'
,*&*'%--,*% 62'% &%0',*2:3' '#$>>?
0'*%/% 6- /##& :*0'#*52 /
#&
0 %-'%'#,'(6
0%*#(# 1%++%& **3' '#*'0'
'*% *% ##& ,*'% - / % :* / & %:
& % - : 0' # * 52 / #&# /0% /*&05 % -& '#'&# %33 5 302&'&% -3'' &
& ,* *%##%'#*.%
C$$D 5%:*0'2' *% #*%*'%0:0'
-,*&* *53:' #/&00%3%5 &% '9'5 '&2 #'+'0&* 0'&%
2 #&-#*'%& %:* 3' '#$>>? *&%5#3 '#35 * 3''#. ' ,*%'2-5 -0 - 0$?6# $>>? 0'% -*'%-0*%'% 6- /##&*3' '# *0'& %:*+ ,# 62'% &%0' '- 0
72-8
C$ * '0% ##& ' *% * % & 3%&- 2: * 3 ' 0'<% - #$> $ 0'*%'''' /*% -*'%- 3' *%'2&5%:-#0 &2:0# 0$?6%-,* 0
#$>>? C$=D *'& -3%%9 2:*3 ''%'5'& &- -5'-&- :0# 0$<6#$>>? 0'+ ,3'#. .&%. /%3*'A&0':5% #35 #5%5 /'* 0 /%3*'
*3'#. /%3* *% -% -*%#. **+&%:*'%53%:6'&%% '%53%:62% *3 '*%*0'/% % %35 % % 0#B0%'%0'0 -*$>>? &- %#%&*%*% 53''#. '% -''#. /%3*'+&%
2'
5 #%2% '' *0'%'*%&% &:3' %&%-'
&- &#'& ','-*%&*% # ' % & #'& C$?D */*#*%2-'&0'' +,- # -% :5
*',3 -*'%5'%&&- /:-'5''- 2 3 4 )%&* !+ $!
2 3 4
)
$<# $!
!"# 666 %, -. /*% -*''0'.%# 1%2% -*'
' ( )
% 405%%/+-&%+ #*%33&% 63 '
III
* %' ' 5 - * %33&% + * '%5 '
%,-'021&%10'A&3 '% -*-&05 '7 6$$ 6$ 8% %9 &-
)'% -'-'3'-# - / 4 &!56 75.6 - / 4