High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22503/2017dismissed

Manjit Kaur v. M/S Punjab State Power Corporation Limited And Others

2017-10-03Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh9 pages

Pooja Sharma 2017.10.10 11:14

$#"%!% !

&#'#""(" )*+"% ,#%( *#

"#%# - "./

*#"01"23*45#

"1#(#

#" 1#("#%# (#

1%&##

0#*!

*#""

50#%78

1# " %%! 5# '"

1# !"# 5#"

9!%1

/ "*#" *#*

#:!"# -3 '1#"#&;3 1# "#("#%#

#"1%&## "# #5#* *1#"%#

;1% &##

:#*5""#50; <"

0;31# 5% 1#5%#%2*#!

1#("#%# (#

"#11#(#

#" %("#%# 0;'"=

/%.!

"0 # *

5# "#%( *# >#"%#

;'%

:#*"7

1#0 !

%= 00#* '"=#"% # 0 2(0#"8#" 2(0#"8 10% #5 "5!0#* 4 *# 2#2 *#* ? @@A " 1# (#"

* "2 @@?

@@7 %%! 5# % *%#

;0 %3& #5 %'#"#

#* "#/"*

: %#

;1#(#

#"0%

0#*& #5 %1"!/1

("(#"51

#0&!1#%2#'#"#"# #5#*4 *#"*#"*#*

3 '1 51 %%!& #52#" 5100# /#

1#("#%# (#

)#"

#*5!

%#0 "1#(#

#"5 *%1& #5

0#* &;1#(#

#"'#"# 5 *#"#*("(#"0; *1#"50 21%'" /0;

&## "# #5#*1#(#

#"'%#

0#*%#

;?A- #&4# %#

;?AA ##4

/18,

/13'1 51'%&# 00#*1#(#

#"%(#"1#"*#

/ # ? @@? "#/!0"

&% %)#"

#*5!

%#0 !"1#"5 *%11#(#

#"'%'"=

/% %= 00#*'"=#"3'1 51 1 /1#"5#/";1 1#!

%= 00#*'"=#" *% %!511#%#

; !2&#"

#"5

&#00#*0'#"

5#/"; !

%= 00#*'"=#"% #02(0#"8#"2(0#"8 10% #5 )#"

#* 5!

%#0 0% 5 *% 1 "#5# 0; 1#" %#

; 0 %

%= 00#*'"=#"%1%&## %%!#*&;"#%( *#

'1 51001# %= 00#* '"=#"% # 0 2(0#"8#" 2(0#"8 10% 14# &##

00#*%#

; !2&#"%&;5 *#"

/1# "*#

/ %0%1# "/!2# 0#"

#*5!

%#0 "1#(#

#"1'1# 1#%#

;0 %

%= 00#*'"=#"%'%5 "5!0#*31#(#

#"0%2*#"#("#%# &!

1!2#

/ ;"#% 31#"50 21%&## "# #5#*1## *3 0#"

#*5!

%#0 "1#(#

#"5 *%11# 2(!/ #*"*#"

"# #5 50 2 0; 00#/03!

"&!!

"#% &0#0%*!# '1 511#(#

#"1%%!

#"#*/"#0%%%%1#1%&## 2*#

B--4 B1#"(#"% % >#"* 1# "/!2# % *4 5#* &; 0#"

#* 5!

%#0 " 1# (#

#" *14#0%/ #1"!/11# 2(!/ #*"*#"*#*

#:!"#- *1#"*5!2# %4 0&0# 1#

0# 1# 5%"#0

/((

#" *

& #5 % 1# %#

; 0 % "# * %(!#* 1# (#

#" '% ((

#* 1#(%

%= 00#*'"=#"4 *#0##"*#*

@@?1#'%(! ("& "(#"

* ';#"%'%0% 2#

1#((

2# 0##"1 52(0# ("& (#"

* %!55#%% !00;31#((

2# '%&#5 *#"#*%("4 0 00%1# '%5

"2#* 1#% *(% # 4#%#

;0 % !

%= 00#* '"=#"% #02(0#"8#"2(0#"8 10% "1#(#"

@@?

@@7'% %%!#*3'1 513& #5 %'#"#

#* "2 001##2(0;##%1#(#

#"0%2*#"#("#%# &;';

/ & #5 ?

7 >'#4#"3% *"#("#%#

'%"# #5#*4 *#"*#"*#*

/1#"#

14 *#0##"*#*

@@A3%1#1*0"#*;&##

"2#*"#/"*

/1#"%#

;'% 0%2#

#*11#%#

;0 %'%("#("#* 1#&% 2#"

55"*

/0;%#

; !2&#"'%00#*1#" >'#4#"31#*# 0% "#/"*

/*# & "135#/";39!0

5 3*#

/ * 0;

'/#%8'"=51"/#&% %30#:(#"

5# *0%*#

/ ("#%# (%'#"#2#

#* %(#"1#*# 0%31#(#

#"1%&##

%1'

14#&## ((

#* * 0;'/#%8'"=51"/# @ @AA 0(#"

*1%&## %1'

&#?;#"%3 2 1% *?*;%%

@@1#*# ("#%# (%

/1%&## %1'

&# @@?3 2#

/31#"#&;1#(#

#"'%'#00'"#&!1#"%#

; !2&#"

%1#%2#'%5 4#;#*1#"4 *#0##"*#*

@@ 2(!/ #* "*#"*#*

0;522!

5 1##"0 #""*#" 1# (#

#" 1% &## &0# !%

; 1# *#0;

5100# /

/1#"*#" 522!

5 *#* @@A("#%# (#

#" % '"=

/ % .!

" 0 # *

? !(#"

/ /

##" (#" * % 50

/ %#

; &;

5 *#"

/1#

0*# ((

2# * 0;'/#%8'"=51"/# &% %'1#%#

;0 %1%&## 5100# /#* 1#/"!

*11# (#

#"'%'"=

/%= 00#*'"=#"3'1 51 1 /1#"" =1 %= 00#*'"=#"3'

1!5100# /

/1#%#

;0 % %%!#*

1#;#"

@@A1#(#

#*%"#/!0"!

%= 00#*'"=#" ? @@? 0%1#"/!2# 0#"

#*5!

%#0 "1#(#

#"1%#

;0 %%

%= 00#*'"=#"% *%= 00#*'"=#"%14#&## %%!#* *1#(#

#" 50

/"#

: 1#"%#

; 0; 1#/"!

*1%1#'%%= 00#* '"=#"&! '% ((

#* % !

%= 00#* '"=#" 1#(#

#"1#"%#0

55#(#* 1#" ((

2# * #4#" 5100# /#* 1# %#

; 0 %

%= 00#*8%= 00#*'"=#"1# 2(!/ #*"*#" 0;1#522!

5 '1#"#%3 1%0"#*;&## *#5 *#* 1#!"1%*!;("#51#"

/1% 1#5

B# %&!

2!0 #!%0; %=##( %#0 0 4#1#("

2";("

(0#1'1#

//"

#4#*(#"% 3'

1!*#9!#"#% 3(("51#%1#!"1 %'

0# %!"#"(0#%!"#31#!"'!0*&#!

*#"0#/0&0 / %5"!

B# '1#1#" %&#0#*%/# * %&## #"

#*" 1# (#

#"1%(("51#*1 %!"&;24

/"#("#%# #"0 /#"

(#"

*3'1#"#%31#"50 21*0"#*;&## "# #5#*

1#;#" @@A&!

'% #4#"5100# /#* 1 0##:#"5

/('#"!

*#""

50#7 3 1# !" % %## 1 1# * %5"# 2!% &# #:#"5 %#* !* !%0; *"#% &0; !*/2# "# *#"#*

5%#

"#$%&'& ()'!*'

(&# !%

7 7 3 > C&0#1#(#:!"1%&%#"4#*11#(#

#"(("51#*1# 5!" #"0 /*#0; *0#/0 5#'%%#"4#*!( 1#"#%( *#

#"(#"

* %#4# ;#"%'%1#0*1((

2# 5!0* &# 50 2#*%2#" "

/1% 0;*#0;'%1#"#&!"#% (("51

/1#!" #"0 /*#0;'#"# #:(0

#* 1#" !*/2# 1 %!"

31#("5#%% %#0#5 '%

1#;#"

*1#(#

15%#(("51#*1#!"

;#"

'%1#0*1 "#%15!%# 5 "%#

4!" (#

#" *%

5#1#(#

#"#* "2*#0; *051#% *1#'"

'%* %2 %%#* 1#/"!

* *#0; 0; 0"0;3

"# 31#50 2

#"'%* %2 %%#* /"!

* *#0;&;10*

/11#(#

15%#1*%0#(4#"1 "

/1% *'=#!( 0;'1# "*#"%'#"#(%%#*

1#5%#%

0#*&;%2# 1#"(#"% %'%1#0*11#(#

#"5!0* &#00'#*"

*# ( //;&5= 1#"#2(0;##%3'1'#"#4 / 0 &!1# ""

/1% (("51#* 1# !" '#00 '

2# " 1# 4

5 1# "

#4 5#% !*/2# <# 51 1 %!"

$ !

% &' 31#(#

(("51#*1#!"&;24

/"#("#%# #"*#0; 2"#1

'# ;;#"% *1 %50 2'%*#50

#* 1#/"!

* *#0;'%1#0* 11#(#

#"'% #

0#* " ;"#0 55!

(0#

*#0; *051#% > C&0#1#!("#2#!"

()

* ++, - ,31%1#0*%!

*#"- D

! " #

$ > C&0#1#(#:!"

1#5%#

.! /

..!#

1 2 2 2!1 "#("#*% 22 2+31%1#0*%!

*#"- 432 %

% . . 21!0

5 6() 7('%++ 3+8 # & ' 9 #

) 2 2 .

()

"6(): 0!!6*;

).7 - , 8

( ) " *

" !

2< )6++, '1 0#*#0

1#:#"5 %# ('#" 1#> /1!"!

*#""

50#7

1# 3> C&0#1#(#:!"&%#"4#*1('#" 1#> /1 !" &# #:#"5 %#* !

*#" "

50# 7 1# 3

%5"# ";3 %#:#"5 %#2!%&# !* !% *"#% &0#3*2 5 "4#"%; "1"#% 3(#"% E%#

0#2# ""#0 "2 > /1!"!

*#""

50#7 1# 3&# /

%1##"

;&*;#0%#3#4#

*#* 1#00#/

/#2# 1 0#/0"

/131% #5#%%"

0;*#(# *!( !

&02#'"1;5 *!5 (#"% %##=

/"#0 3 *1#5!""# !%#%/" 1#* %5"# ";"#0

%!51(#"%

#:#"5 %# %!51('#"3'1# 1#(("51#% '

50# 1 *%"&02#'"1;5 *!5

52 2=!!* 0!

526('%+ - ,6> C&0#1#(#:!"&%#"4#*1

%'#00%#0#*1('#" 1#> /1!" %%!# (("("

#'"

*#""

50#7 1# %* %5"# "; *1#> /1!"

#:#"5 %# %* %5"# *#% "*

0;%% %1#"*; *1#

*0#

"1#59!

#%5# *1#0#1"/ 51%&## !"1#"%#*1#"#

1#"#

#*#0; 1#("

/(#

%!51*#0; % 5"

0;#:(0

#*31#> /1!"2;*#50

#"4# # */" "#0

1##:#"5 %# %'"

%* 2(1% '%0 * 1#("

(0# *#0; *051#%%

/1"#%"1# #:""*

";"#2#*;!

*#"1#'"

%* &#0#*%/# %0 =#0;

5!%#5

!% *(!&0 5

5 4#

5# *&"

!% 5# 1#&4#4 #' 1#(#:!"'% 00'#*

"#5#

!*/2# "# *#"#* &; 1 % !"

! 2

"# "#("#*%, 33'1#"#

1%&## 1#0*%!

*#"- 4+2 + # ,

- $ 1#&#

*#5 "# *#"#*

1#5%# % 0"0;

(05#* (#"% % 5

%" /1'; &# / 4# (#"% 3 '1 1 2%#0

(("51#%1#!"&#0#*0;"/#

/"#0 "21#!"31# "#9!

"#*% 5"

0;#:(0

1#*#0; 1 %("

(("51

/1# !"

@ 1#("#%# 5%#0%1#50 2

#"'%0"#*;

"# #5#*';&5=

1#;#" @@A1#(#

#"1% '5100# /#* 0;

1#522!

5 3'1 51

(!"%! 5# #"0 #""*#"*#* @@A /"!

* %2*#!

#"#1 %%/# *%%!511#(#

/*#4 * ;2#"

%1#"#&;* %2 %%#* 5&#"

+ , ( 1#1#"%(#=

/8"#% #* F#% 1#1#""#("&0#