High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4419/2013disposed of

Praveen Singla v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2018-04-17Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath4 pages

!"#

$%& &'()(*+

$%& &'()(*+ , , , ,

- .$/&&*(*01$ &%(%(*&. 2) %$%& $.3$*$$*4%5&.) &)6*4&*%) "+7 8" "+7 8" "+7 8" "+7 8"99" 99" 99" 99" .&)&*%+ ".5$5$1:4/'$%&: . ".5(/9;<$.;6%$:4/'$%&:

.%5&6&%(%(*&. ".$;.$=5"5;*%$: :$.3$*$ 99": 99": 99": 99": 5&6&%(%(*&.6;.'5$)&4$61%<&$);.(*0- )>;$.&3$.4)(* 95$).$ ? , )(%;$%&4 $% 2(11$0& 5$%$;1(: &5)(1 $0$45.(: ()%.('%

$<;*$$0$.:@5('5() A &&%$@$3 .<%5&$0$45.(<=$1$$%(*$1 (05@$3$4''.4(*0%%5&.&)6*4&*%):%5&6&%(%(*&.5$)0%%5&)$1& 4&&4.&0()%&.&4 %5&61%(*>;&)%(* ..&)(4&*%($16;.6)&) .$*$<;*% :,-:A

?$*45$)6$(4%5&)%$<64;%3 - ?%5;05%5&$.&$(* @5('5%5&61%(*>;&)%(*())(%;$%&4()$'<<&.'($1$.&$$*4%5&'11&'%. .$%& .%5&'<<&.'($16.6&.%3 .%5&3&$.

@$)AA

?6&.)> 3$.4)5;):%5&%%$1/$1;& %5&61%'<&)%:A:A

? .@5('5%5& )%$<64;%3.&>;(.&4%=&6$(4@$)

,A?:%5&.& .&:%5&6&%(%(*&.@$) 5&141($=1&%6$3%5&$44(%(*$1)%$<64;%3 :A?5&'$)& %5& .&)6*4&*%)()%5$%%5&11&'%.:$0$45$.(5(<)&1 5$4/()(%&4%5&)6%@(%5 $%@$.( $1>$*

$*4 ;*4 %5$% %5&$.&$() );(%$=1& .< %5&

'<<&.'($1 $*01& $) %5& 6&61& @&.& ;*4 ;)(*0 %5& )$<& . %5& '<<&.'($1 6;.6)&) $ %&. '*)%.;'%(*0 %5& )56) 5& 11&'%. $1) 6.&);<&4 .< %5& )(B& %5& 61% %5$% (% 5$) =&&* C&6% . '<<&.'($1 6;.6)&):%5&.& .&:/(4&5().4&.4$%&4

:%5& 11&'%. 4(.&'%&4 %5&6&%(%(*&.%6$3%5&$44(%(*$1)%$<64;%35&$66&$1 (1&4$0$(*)%%5& )$(4 .4&. @$) $1) 4()<())&4 =3 %5& <<())(*&.: <=$1$ (/()(*: <=$1$* A

00.(&/&4$0$(*)%=%5%5&.4&.):%5&6.&)&*%6&%(%(*5$)=&&* 6.& &..&4 *13 * %5& =$)() %5& (* .<$%(* .&'&(/&4 =3 %5& 6&%(%(*&. ;*4&.%5&(05%%* .<$%(*'%:

AD .)5.%E%5&'%7F$*4* %5& 61&$ 4()'.(<(*$%(* * @5('5 *%('& <%(* @$) ());&4 =3 %5() ;.%* -

8&$.*&4 ';*)&1 . %5& 6&%(%(*&. 5$) );=<(%%&4 %5$% %5& .&)6*4&*%) 5$/& *% %$C&* (*% '*)(4&.$%(* %5& (<6.%$*% $*4 .&1&/$*%

$'%)@5(1&$)C(*0%5&6&%(%(*&.%6$3%5&4& ('(&*%)%$<64;%3@5('55$) =&&* 4*& *13 * %5& =$)() )6% (*)6&'%(* $*4 @(%5;% 514(*0 $*3 &*>;(.3*%5().&0$.4:5&5$).& &..&4%$4&'()(* %5();.%.&*4&.&4 (*%5&'$)& G"$4$* G"$4$* G"$4$* G"$4$*8$1 8$1 8$1 8$12)%$%& ;*H$=$*4%5&.)I

- # %$%& ;*H$=$*4%5&.)I

- # (/(1#J (/(1#J (/(1#J (/(1#J ;.%5&.:1&$.*&4';*)&1 .%5&6&%(%(*&.5$));=<(%%&4%5$%%5& 6&%(%(*&.5$4);05%%5&(* .<$%(*;*4&.%5&'%%%5&&

&'%%5$%$) % @5&%5&. $*3 6.6&.%3 (* %5& )$<& $.&$ 5$) &/&. =&&* .&0()%&.&4 $) '<<&.'($1* ,

.*%$*4$)%@5&%5&.$*3$;4(%=H&'%(*@$) .$()&4(*.&0$.4%%5&)%$<64;%3=3%5&$;4(%.K%());=<(%%&4%5$%%5& (* .<$%(*);661(&4%%5&6&%(%(*&.%=%5%5&)&>;&)%(*)()(**&0$%(/&: %5&.& .&: <&.&13 =3 )6% (*)6&'%(* $*4 6.&);<6%(* 4.$@* =3 %5&

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

''.4(*013:%5&@.(%6&%(%(*()5&.&=3$11@&4:%5&(<6;0*&4 .4&.) $.& )&% $)(4& $*4 %5& <$%%&. () .&<$*4&4 =$'C % %5& 11&'%. % 4&'(4&%5&1()$0$(*$ %&.514(*0$6.6&.&*>;(.3:(*$''.4$*'&@(%51$@ 5& 6$.%(&) $.& 4(.&'%&4 % $66&$. =& .& %5& 11&'%. * A

- 99"# 99"# 99"# 99"# , , , ,

- 5&%5&.)6&$C(*0?.&$)*&4 +

&)? 5&%5&.&6.%$=1& +

&)?