Dharam Pal v. Deva Nand & ORS.
!"
#$%" !!
!
"#$%$ & '( ( !
( !
&
#$%$ !!
)*( $ +
!
"#$%$ & '( ( !
( !
,,, '
()'
* **
*
+
- ( )* .
/ (&0! ! !
- 1*& " / (&0! ( ! '
! 2
- 3 $ +/ (&0! ( ! '
,,, *
* - 4 3& 0 !
( !5 ! ( 5( (! (
( 36 ( -! 00 ( ! 7 4 3*/ ) 8 !/ 9! 4 3*:;
-74 7 ' ( <
= 36 & !* 5 0 0 ! !
( )*( $ + 5 5( ( 0 !
& + * ( ! 00 ( !
.! ! !( ( 36 ! 0 *(+ !
4 0! !!
! 3*! 2
/ 0 ! !
( )*( + 5 + + )**> ! ! ) 36 0 3 + + !!
' ? <"<=
@ ! 6 0 ( & + )(+/ !0!! 6 3 + + !!
' ? <)<= 8 ! ( ! 9! !0!! 6:; 3 + ( & 6/ + + !6 ( + ( 36 ( ! '
& '(/ 0 ! ( ( !*0> + ! ! 0 *! 00 ( !/ ! 0 ! ! *!
! A!
! '
(! (
*( $ 0!
=/ 22 ( 22 ! A( 7( 0! ! 00 ( ! 5 + ! ( + ! ( ! '
! 0 $!!
A(
!0 ! ( !5 ! 0 !
*( ! & $ 0!
( ! -! " 0 0!/ = 8 !/ 9! 0! =:; 0 + 0 !
36 ( + ( & / 5 ( * ! ( + !0!! 6 ( !
4 ( ! 0! ! ( ! !
3*! 0 ( & ( 0 ((*0 ( 36 ! !
/ ( 4 3* 5 ( 3! ! !
( 5( ( 0 !
! ! !*
/
B ! 0 ! )*( $ + ( /<2/ B ! 0 !
2
( + ! ( ! !6 ( & 6 3 ! 6 0 !
+5 ! ! ! ! ! ! <C * ! (! + ! !
!
+ ( !
( 5 ! ! E*!* 0 !
/ !0 ! ( !
4 *3 ( 36 ( 0* ! !
& 3 ( ( 0( * (
.#$%".
!!
( 0* ! ! +* ( !! ! ! *! ( *!
+ &* & * ! ! 3(6 6 8 ;
*!
0!* 3/ 8
; & *+ *6 5 ! !6 ( ! /
; 3 ! !F/ 8 &; + D ( *+ 0 6 / 8&; 0!* ( 3 / 8& ; 0 *! ( *3 !0 ! 0 0!* ! */ 8&
; 0!* ! ! / 8&
; 0!* !
! 8 !;/ 8 F; 0!* ! * 8 +!;/ 8F; 0 *! ( !
! 0!* 8 +!; ( 8F ; ! 3! 0!* +! 5 ( ( * ? ( D ( 5
!
! ? !/ ( !
!
! - / !> ( (* ( 5 ! ( * & !
? ! F ! 6
B ! ! !
?5 & / ( 4 3* 5( ( 6 * /2/
B ( / B !5( ! ! ! ( ( 0+ * ! ! *! ! 00 ( !/ 3 0 !6 3 ( ! ! F! ! C/ 3*! ( 4 3* 5( ( 6 /
B *( ! ( '! + 5 5( ( ! ! !
00*! 0 ( ! ( * + *( + 36 4 *!
B 5( ( *( ! ( / 0 !/ !! (! ( ! !!
! 5
A( (/ ! ! ( D ( ! !5 ( ! !6 ! ( ! ! !> ( (* ( 5 ! ( * & !
4 *!
B 5( ( 00*! / 0 ( !/ !! (! ( ! !!
( /2/
B 5 ( !5( ( 0 F ( / B + !
#F
/ #F
/ #F = ! #F 2 ( #F = ! #F
< ( ( 0!
?5 & / (( ! F ( !* 5 ! !!
/ ! ! *! & ! *! ! ! !!
( 3( +(+ + 6 3 5 5 !! ( + (* + ! ( *0/ *!
5( ( *( ! ( (/ +( ! ( 3 !6 ! ! F! ! C * ( 36 ! !/ ( 4 3* +!6 5( ( /
B 5 0 *! ( ( E*!
4 ! ( !! ( (* + & ( 0 !! + !!
+
2/
B ' & ( 0 5 ( 36 ! ! ! & !!
(( ! ! ( ! *0 0 0 0!
* ( ! 0 & (* + ! ( / * ( 0 .*! 6 ! / *! *!
5 ( !
4 ! * ( *!
+ &* ( D (
!
(
!
< 7 ( + ! !* * ( 36 ( ! ( / *!
5( ( ! ! ! ! ( * + *( + 36
A ! 3& / ! !
( !
! ( ! 0 ( 0 !
.#$%$.
!!
( 0* ! ! +* ( !! ! ! *! ( *!
+ &* & * ! ! 3(6 0*( + 0!* ! & / ! * ( > 0 !0 ? ( D (
!
! ?6 '* + ? / ) ? !> ! ! ! & * ! (0! ( ! *+ *! ! ! !
?5 & / ( 4 3* 5( ( 6 *
//=/ ( = B !5( ! ! ! ( ( 0+ * ! !
*! ! 00 ( !/ 3 0 !6 ( 3 ( ! ! F! ! <C/ 3*! ( 4 3* 5( ( 6
B *( ! ( '! + 5 5( ( ! ! ! 00*! 0
4 *!
B 5( ( *( ! ( / 0 ( ! ( !! (!
! 5 ( ( ! + 5 5( ( ! ! 00*! ( * + *( + 36
A( (/ ! ! ( D ( 5
!
! ?6 '* + ? / ) ( (* ( 5 ! ( * ? * ( *!
+ &* 7 ( !* * ( 36 ( ! ( / *!
5( ( ! ! ( * +
*( + 36 A (( ! F ( !* 5 ! !!
/ ! ! *! & ! *! ! ! !! ( 3( + (+ + 6 3 5 5 !! ( + (* ( / ! / ! *!
B 5( ( 00*! / 0 ( ! ( !! (!
0 ( !
</
4 *!
//=/ ( = B 5 ( 36 ( 4 3* + ! 3 #F ! #F <=/ #F 2 ! #F =2 ( #F / !5( ! ! ! ( ( 0+ ( ( 0!
+( ( 3 !6 ! ! F! ! <C * ( 36 ! !/ ( 4 3* +!6 5( (
B 5 0 *! ( ( E*!
4 ! ( !
( .0 -+ 7 !
& .> ( ! & 0 ! !
! ! + 0*!* ( 5 ( 36 / (*0 ( 0>5 (+ ! #F 22/ #F 2 ( #F ! #F 0 !F ( ! ! ! * ! 0! !
!!
5 +
B !
( 4 3* ! ( !! ! ! G ! ! 5 + ( ( !
(( 5 ! 5 36 ! ! !
A 6 0 / ! (0* ! ! ( !! ! + 0*!* 0 ! ! ! !
6
! + ! !
5 /=
B 5 ! 6
=
! 5 2/<
B ( ! 6
! 5 2/
- + ! 36 !! ! 0 5 0 + & 6 6
4 ! 5 ! ( 5> 6 3 *!
6 + 0 & 6 6 3*! ! 0!
!! ( *( ! ! ! ( +! & ++ ( ! > ! ! + 0*!* ** + ! 6 !
( 36 !! +(
B ! ( * + !! 6 & ( 0 ( ! 3 ( ! ! & ! 0& 6/ *!
</
5( ( ! 00*! 0 6 ! / *! *!
5 ( !
A ! 3& / ! ! )*( + ( !
! ( ! 0 ( 0 !
/
4 !
! ! 5 ( 36 ( 4 3* !
00( +6/ 3! ! ( 36 ! !6 5 ( ( ! 5( (! (
( 36 ( 4 3* ( 4 0 ( *! 0 !
3 ( ! ! ! 5 ! < (6 ! (! 0 ! 0 !
( 0 6 ! *(+ ! + 5 0 ! ! 3 !
! ( ! ! ! ! 0 ( *! ! ! ! <C * ! (! !
/*
*
!"