High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20848/2018dismissed

Jasdev Singh v. Director State Transport Punjab And ANR

2019-07-30Mr. Justice B.S. Walia11 pages

CWP No.20848 of 2018 1

! "#$#%&'( ) $! *+#%,- ##% . * .$/$ #. ".0+ .

%$1.0 /%2 30- %!#, .- %!- .$ $1%! %$ ! "#$#%&'( ) # %+#%,- ##% . * .$/$ #. ".0+ .

%$1.0 /%2 30- %!#, .- %!- .$4 $1%! %$

-#$ .! . $- 55 ! "#! $ $ 6 55 $ $"77%8/ $#%$ 5 6 %!

" . #%*5* ! #%- "- 55 %, .!9$%% :/. ;)!

! ) <;

(' ( %!

) <;

' (1 $$ !3=- %!/$.# 5.#3/% 5>"/7>?

3/./.0

- %!#, .-0- . #%

.. ! $- .#3/% 5. 2 "#%,.

. %" $ !

! (@ . , .!#%, ! 7 %! - /%2 3 !6 =$ .A$-1 .A .$ %#% /%! . + "#% A - " . 8/ $-#%, .! . !

! <

));

)))0 1 $$ ! 3= - #. ". + .

%$1. /%2 3; % .

5 B % , .0 /%2 3 !6 =$0 1% , . . $1 "#* 5= %! "5 #7#%,

11#%7 % - 1 ##% .$ $ 5 "A$7#-; 5! . 6 )@ )) ;

CWP No.20848 of 2018 2

< )) . $1 "#* 5= % - 3 $#$ .! %% :/. ;

! @ ))@ .#

"$ - "

$ $15 ! !#%- #%$ %6.#1 ##%$ . - $! * +#%,- 1 ##% . #% ; 6 $ 11#% ! $ 5 "A$7#- % !

#5= 6 , $ #% * 73 .0 ) %! -#$ $ .*#" $ 6 . .7#% !#%B ."-0 )6- .

$# %+#%,-1 ##% .#% 6 $ 11#% ! $ 5! . % !

#5= 6 , $ #% /5=0 ) %! -#$ $ .*#" $6 . .7#% !#% " 73 .0 )-- 1 ##% .$"- 55 %, ! - #. .7#% #%

. ! 5 = )= .$- .#3/% 5*#! $ 1 .

.!$ %% :/. ;

!@ ))@0.! . !. #%$ 7 % - 1 ##% .$6#- "%#%/#= $ .*#" %!'C3 "A6 , $6 - !

! 7 %!%#" $ # )@ )) ;

< )) . $1 "#* 5= /.$/ % - . 0 - 1 ##% .$ 6 . . #%$ ! #% $ .*#" % ))@ - .

.0 - 1 ##% .$ #5 !

115#"

#%$ /%! . + "#% '' " - %!/$.# 5 #$1/ $ "0 )( - . #%

. .

.. ! $ D- "9 . 1 =7 % 3 "A 6 , $ 3 $#! $ . ,/5 .1 =$"

5 #%$ ! !

#5=6 , $ %!*#! .! .%% :/. ;!

! <) )))0- 1 ##% .$6 . - 5! %#5 ! ..

.$ 3 "A6 , $E'C 3= .

#%, - 7 3 #% . ,/5 . 1 = $"

5 >< "".!#%,5=0 =7 % ..

.$ 6 $ 7 ! - 1 ##% .9$ - 1 ##% .$ , #%

11. "- !- .#3/% 56#- ,.# * %" - - =6 . %#5 !. *#$#% ,.

! .7><)@> 6 %/ .=0 )< %! /.- .-#,- . =$"

5 .7 ))<6 * .0-

. 7 %#% ! 115#"

#%$6 . !#$7#$$ !*#! .! .!

! ('06- . /1%- 1 ##% .$ 11. "- ! -#$/.3=6 = << %! <( F#! .! .!

@@0.! .!

! ('1 $$ !3=- ?

3/./. 6 . $ $#! %!- 7 .. 7 %! !! "#! - "%.* .$=

. $-

CWP No.20848 of 2018 3 '

/.$/ %. 7 %!0- .#3/% 5*#! .! .%% :/. ;'!

! <)0 - 5! - - 1 ##% .$ 6 . %#5 ! . " #* - . 7 #%#%,

7/%

. !2/$#%,- 1 =7 % 5.

!= . " #* ! 5%,6#- #% . $E

C1 . %%/7%- 7/%!/ 6 <) )))#55- !

1 =7 % $#%" - $ 7 - !%3 %1 #!6#-#%-. 7%-$ .7<) ))) - .

.0! 7 %!%#" 0%% :/. ;!

! )

6 $ $ .* !3=- /%2 3 !6 =$.A$-1.A .$ %#%/%! .+ "#% A - " 1.

=#%, . 8/ $-#%, .! . !

! <

));

)))0 $$ ! 3= - #. ". + .

%$1. /%2 3; % .

5 B % , .0 /%2 3

!6 =$0 1% , . . $1 "#* 5= 11#%#%, - 1 ##% .$ $ $-#%, =$ %! "5 #7#%, 11#%7 % - 1 ##% .$ $ 5 "A$7#-; 5! . . $1 "#* 5= 6 )@ )) % - 3 $#$ .! %% :/. ;

! @ ))@1 $$ !3=- .#3/% 5 5 =#%.

#$#%,"5 #7 . 11#%7 % - 1 ##% .$%- 1$ 5 "A$7#-; 5! .6 $ .#3/ !#7 A % #%! "#$#% !#$1/ 8/ 1 =7 % $ .=- 1 ##% .$ .- 1$ 5 "A$7#-; 5! . -

. $ #! .

. %" $ 6 . %$6 . ! , #%$ -

/%2 3 !6 =$ .A$-1 .A .$ %#% 3= - .#3/% 5 *#! .!9$ %% :/. ;) !

! ) <;

(' ( %! ) <;

' ( . $ #! .!$- * 3 %#71/,% !#%- 6.#1 ##%$ @ ?

.% !"/%$ 5 .- 1 ##% .- $. # .

!- $/37#$$#%$ ! 3 . - .#3/% 5 < - * "%$#! . !- $/37#$$#%$ 5 .% !"/%$ 5 %!- * ,% * .- 15 !#%,$ $6 55 $- .! ( !7# !5=0 .

. %" $ !

! (@ - 3 - $ -

/%2 3 !6 =$.A$-1.A .$ %#%/%! .+ "#%A - " 8/ - 1 ##% .$6 . ! "5#% !3=- .#3/% 56- .

$- 6.#1 ##%$

CWP No.20848 of 2018 4 - * 3 % #5 !3=- 1 ##% .$#%- #.#%!#*#!/ 5"

"## $

"#$% " $!

&' !

( )

*$+

, &

" #$ #$ % " $!

%" - ! 7 %!6 $ $1/$ !3=- /%2 3 !6 =$.A$-1 .A .$ %#% /%! . + "#% A - "0 #% . $1 " "5 #7 - 1 ##% .$ %!.

. %" $6 . 7 ! 3=- 11.1.# ,* .%7 %#%- % 7 - /%2 3 !6 =$.A$-1.A .$ %#% %!- $ 7 6 .

%$6 . ! , #%$- /%2 3 !6 =$.A$-1.A .$ %#%0"- 55 %, - $ 7 6/5! 5$ - * 3 3= - /%2 3 !6 =$ .A$-1 .A .$ %#%0 $- "5 #7 - 1 ##% .$;6.A7 %#$%/%! .+ "#% > - "6-#"-1.*#! $ . ,# #%, "5 #7#% %#%!#*#!/ 5"

"#= ) !/3 115#"

#%$ #5 !3=- 1 ##% .$/%! .+ "#%''" - " 6 . 556 ! %! *#! .! . %% :/. ; !

! <) )))0 - 1 ##% .$6 . - 5! %#5 ! ..

.$ 3 "A6 , $E'C3=.

#%, - 7 3 #% . ,/5 . 1 = $"

5 >< +/3$ 8/ % ,.# * %" - 1 ##% .$ 3 #%, %#5 ! . *#$#% ,.

! .7 $ >< )@>

6 %/ .=0 )< %! /.- .-#,- .1 =$"

5 .7 ))<6 $ *#! ! "#! !*#! .! .%% :/. ;'!

!<) %!- 1 ##% .$ 6 . - 5! %#5 ! . " #* - . 7 #%#%, 7/%

. !2/$#%, - =7 % 5.

!= . " #* ! 5%, 6#- #% . $ E C 1 . %%/7 % -

CWP No.20848 of 2018 5

7/%!/ 6 <) )))#55- !

1 =7 %$#%" - $ 7 - !% 3 %1 #!6#-#%-. 7%-$ .7<) ))) -.

/ !

" !"

0- .1 .- -221

# /"

! # /"3! 4 5..6127-*8+ .7 -- -22(9'

#5:!! " ; ) , : !! < # /" , &

" / ; ! 4 -16(-(109: .

-- -22( 9'

#1 = , &

" & ! 4 5...61270*8+ .7 -- -22( ; ) , : < "

, &

" & ! , = , &

" ! # /" ) = , &

# /"3 -7 .5 -222

-- -222 -- % " ! $

# /"

! # "

-- -22( ) ! 3-

..60.( .2

..6 ! :

! !

5 2 -5 " # /" ! )

! # /" - "

CWP No.20848 of 2018 6 -

) ! " !

, # /"

" ": / -.

.-(

!, # /"-22(22

! # /"

> !

! !

, " # /"!

# /" -

..6 ! # /" ) !

0 $! " # /" " " , # /" /

! # /" < $ ! # /"

" ! # /"

! >

# /" " -22( ! " # /"

-- -22( !

05 -

.-- , &

"#$ #$%

! # /" !

CWP No.20848 of 2018 7 "-8" ! / $!0# # /"

) ! " " " ?

-8 )

! " !

"0!

! ! $!

" ?

! ) $!

$ !

) "

;

) !

" !

& ' !

!: !"# $%& %& %$%'% "%(( ( & ' !

CWP No.20848 of 2018 8

! #

! # $%

& ' ''

(

) & * )+

! &

.'%

& + / 01203 &

( 4

( + %

(

( / 01203

CWP No.20848 of 2018 9

+ +

(

-5 !

$ " 3

!: )%' $%#% %% ( & ' ! 0

" &

& / % 6

01*0,**

7 8 )

59"& 01*0,**

: #%

&) 8

59"& 01*0,** +

CWP No.20848 of 2018 10 %

# /

;

/ & 0. 6

)

& /

% & 26 <3

)

/ )

% )

& '' -1 ) 3 " -22(

! # /"!

! !

..-

.7 -- -22( /

! # /"

CWP No.20848 of 2018 11 -7 !"

") ) ! "!! *+(

,% , $ $ # $0 @04 # @04