Managing Director Pepsu Road Transport Corp Patiala And Arn v. Presiding Officer Industrial Tribunal Bathinda And ANR
!"!
#$ %% &
' ' ( '
)*'
'
' ( (+
' '
&$ ,( &% ' -(
-( + % ./01 ! " #
" $% % $ & '! # ( ) " !
*+
$ , ! - ! * !
! ." "
%* //* " " %%/ %
- " " ! #" !
)
) # ) 0" ) )
"!
) ) ' ,1! "
' " !
# -! ! /2$
" ! # " ! " "
) ! !
"
) ! ) "
! + 3 4 ! ! ! 0 !) ) ! ! ) ) ' ! ! ! - * " ' ! 2 4 ! #" !) #
" ! 5 ) ) 6 '
! ! !
7 ,! !) )
! ! !
" * "
+ "
* #" 8" ! " " %& (&( -!
! /2$ "
)
) ) 9 " -! #!#4)! ,! )! ! "
!
! !
$ " 1!
! % -! ! /2$ " ' :# & (;< 6
! '
) " # &( ! = 9 &)( ) "
! ,! 1!
9 &(; ! ) "
! !
4)! ,! >! 9 &( ! ) "
! " !
!
>! :
" ! !
! " 6 4)! ,! ! ! &(:?
; ! " ! !)
!
!
)
6
! ) ! ' !
"!
)
' ! !)# "
! ! ; " ! " , 6 6
) 6 ! 4)! ,! -! ) ! ) 6 ;& # ( < , 6 ! '
!
1!
! ! )
!
) ) ! ! ! !
) >! ) 8 , 6 " 6 ! ) " ! ) "
! " !
!
8 >!
( < ! ) " > ! = ,! ;4)! ,! 8
6
>
;& # ( ! 4)! ,! 8 !
"
" ! 4)! ,! 8
!) " ! ! 6:
" ! ! "
! " !
' :
! " ! ) " > 4)! ,! 8 ' ! ! 4)! ,! 8 ' ' ! ) " ' ! ) ! ! :
! !)# " ) 4)! ,! 8 ) ) >! ,
,!
) ' !:
) 4)! ,!
8
! ! !)# ' "
! ! ) ?
&3( < ! ) = ;4)! ,! 8 ? ! 6 ) ) ! #! "
! ! " ) '
&2( < ! 0 4)! ,! 8 ? ! !)1! 6 ! >! 4)! ,!
8 )?
>! &7( < ! )
)
) ) ;4)! ,! 8 ? ! 6 "
) "
! ! ! )
! )
!
) ) ! ! 6 )! ) !) " ! ! )
! )
"
! ! ! '
)
! )
?
;&*( < ) ! !)# & # ( 8 "
4)! ,!
>! >! ! " ! >! ) 8
# &( ! >! ) 8
) 4)! ,! ) 4)! ,! ) !
) ) 1! ! 8 9 &)(
) "!
6 ! >! ) 8 4)! ,! >! !
! ) 8
;@' - !)# A4)! ,!A A
! ,! ! ! ! "
! ?
&$( < ! " ,
6 6 8 "
7 $ / 33#
33#= 3*# 6 ! !
) ! , 6 )! "
' 6 !
6?
;&B( 8 ) 4)! ,! 8
!
) ! ) " ! 4)! ,! 8
! !) " 6?
B
) ) ' " " )
) ) ! C'
2#34 #5
/"
7"% 2/8!#5 / '!#96 #5 #
/:+ ;
.<1 ' ; " " ) # ) ,! ) ) ! >!
' :# C7 ! "
! ) ! " " B/ /B* $ % //7 8 ' " " ) ) >! ) ! "
) ) 6 ! ) 0D)
! ,! 8! = 4 , &!( , @
E> D &!( "!
) !
) / 6 )
) ! !
'
! " ' ) ) ! ! ) '
/ ! ! >! ) 1! " )
" ! - " ) "
" !
" B3 %%B & '! #B( ) 4)! ,! = ) F / 0D) ! ,! ! 1! >! C
52#95!
#= ( 5% 7"% -%%&567#=2
>:
.1 ' ?? " "
! 6 " ! '
! ! ) !
- " %$ " " ) !>! ' :# C* 4" )
6 ' " ! % - " ) ' " ) " ) ' )
! ) ) " , 6 ' "
)! "
! '
!
) ) ! " !
) !)># ! % " ! ) ) "!
! < )
! ) !! ) ! % !
- !
) " ! " 1! " ! ) " " " " " G ! " !)1! " )
! " ' ) $ -
" !
" "
"
!
0
! !
- !
) ! ! " )!
< " ! ) ! 6
! ! ,
6 " )
! " ! %
) ! '
!
)
! )> ! = " >! ! 0
,! 1! 1! B - " !) ) ) ! % 4)! ,! 0
,! " >!
4)! ,! " ! 1!
! !)> >! "
!
) 0
,! ' " !
* , ! 1! >! 4)! ,! - !
#0 #9!#
/!#9
#52"
/!
"
( 5% 7% '
3"
6#+ .1 ' .'1$ ;;;.;1 ' < ,! ) :# A- "
) ! 0
,! >! " "
! " !
) !)> >! -! ! % 0 1! >!
! " !
) ' )
,! " >! - '
" "!
6 "
" -! >! - ! '
6 " F %
C6!
#9!#
/+ #3!
'9/ @ #5 #
/ 7"% '6@ (0:
.<1 ' ? 0D) ! ,! !
-! !
/2$ ! "
)
! % " ) "
) ) -
2#7 " ) " ' :# C/ !
!
) " - "!
! 0" ) ) ,! ) -
52#95!
#= ( 5% 7% -%% &567#=2
> #5 /"%+ .1 ' ??$ ..1 ' AA1 " *
":
A* 4" ) #
6 ' " !
% - " ) ' " ) " ) ' ) ! ) ) " ,
6 ' "
)! " ! '
!
) ) ! " !
) !)># !
% " ! ) ) "!
! < ) ! ) !! ) ! %
!
- !
) " ! " 1! " ! ) " " " " " G " ! " !)1! " ) ! " '# )
A % - '%&%
!03=/ #5 /"% 7%
@ !"
/!
	 /+ -/# =+ <.1 ' <$ .<.
' 1 "
": & $( A $ - " !) ) ! ! )
0
,! " >!
< - ! +
< 4 < &!( & -E /7/ , $( )! -!
!
! ! ) "
!
) !
) ! !
) )
!
" ! " "
2 ! " " )
+
< 4 < & -E /7/ , $( &!( - 8!
= 4 H ! -E %%%
, B3/ &!( $ " )
"
- E , G - & //3 -E ,<
2 &!( " !
)! )
) " ) !
"
"!
)
!
>! )
) 0" " ) !
)
!
0
,! " $ / ! ) )! "
,! !
" /B7#B* /B*# B$ !! >!
E ,!
@ G I G - & -E /B$ , ( " !
!
)!
" >! " ! 5 *# # //% " ! ) 5 B# # //%
! -! !
" )
! " -! !# 4)! ,! <
) !
! A ) "
@ '25@5!6 00!
/>
&*"
6/
=!#9 0 ( 5% 7% 6 !/
/=@ # / B/ "
#
4> "6 /!> 00!
/> &C5
/ '#96+ ;;A.1 '%%% <;$ ..1 '2B/ @
?1%
) ) !
>!
,! )
" "
! - ) !! 4)! ,! 0
,! !
)
"F
C '
5 /#"B /
/B / !
# 7"% 42 @:
.<1 ' ? 0D) ! ,! ) !:# C7 !
!
) " - "!
! 0" ) ) ,! ) - 8 52#95!
#= ( 5% 7% -%% &567#=2
> #5 /"%+ .1 ' ??$ ..1 ' AA1 " *
":
A* 4" ) #
6 ' " !
% - " ) ' " ( " ) ' ) ! ) ) " , 6 ' " )! "
! '
!
) ) ! " !
) !)># ! %
" ! ) ) "!
! < ) ! ) !! ) !
% !
- !
) " ! " 1! " ! )
" " " " " G " ! " !)1! " ) ! " '# ) A - '%&%
!03=/ #5 /"% 7%
@ !"
/!
	 /+ -/# =+ <.1 ' <$ .<.
' 1 "
": & $( A $ - " !) ) ! ! )
0
,! " >!
< - ! +
< 4 < &!( & -E /7/ , $( )! -!
!
! ! ) "
!
) !
) ! !
) )
!
" ! " " 2 ! " " )
+
< 4 < & -E /7/ , $( &!( - 8!
= 4 H ! -E %%%
, B3/ &!( $ " )
"
E , G - & //3 -E ,<
2( " !
)! )
) " ) !
"
"!
)
!
>! )
) 0" " ) !
)
!
,! " $ / ! ) )! " 0
,! !
"
/B7#B* /B*#B$ !! >!
E ,! @ G I
G - & -E /B$ , ( " !
!
)!
" >! "
! 5 *# # //% " ! ) 5 B# # //%
! -! !
" )
! " -! !# 4)! ,! <
) #!
! A ) "
@ 	 @ #
'25@5!6 00!
/>
&*"
6/
=!#9 0 ( 5% 7% 6 !/ /=@ # / B/ "
#
4> "6 /!> 00!
/> &C5
/ '#96 .1 '%%% $ ..1 ! ( * - ) 0
,!
" " " ! "
) + " )
- " " ! " "
) " ) 0
,! ) ! !
) )! ) 6 )
=! 4)! ,! 0
,! ! ! " ) ! >! ) 0
,! !! ) < 0
,! 0
,! 1! "
"
8
"F
-
) ,! ! "
" 1!
@ !
)
! -! ! /2$ " "
) ) )> >! !
- #" !
* "
! ! ' " !
3 E!
) 00 5
!
" ) "
"!5 .-( #2/> +
< + :
J+8 < E) :
J+8