Union Of India And Others v. Ex Naik Sawaran Singh And Others

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT

CHANDIGARH CWP-16896-2024 (O&M) Decided on : 13.11.2025 UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS . .Petitioners

Versus

EX NAIK SAWARAN SINGH AND ANOTHER . . . Respondents CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIKAS SURI PRESENT: Mr. Harmanjot Singh Gill, Advocate and Mr. Neelesh Bhandari, Advocate for the petitioners.

**** HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI , J. (Oral) 1.

In the present petition, the challenge is to the impugned order dated 03.11.2023 (Annexure P-1) passed by respondent No. 2-Armed Forces Tribunal, Regional Bench, Chandigarh (hereinafter referred to as 'the Tribunal' by which, the
 



 

   
 

 






   


   


 !





    

"
# 

$%  


 &% # 




        

  

  !"# $

"
 
&% # 





# # 
%'


 &% 
%



 

#


  %'





 

 '


'

 #


 
 
'



 


( )


%#
%
  

*+

,,"-./'








#%  



0  

 


   

#

1 

 


2
 


 
%


 
 


 
% 






   0


%

 

 
 '


 

  




$%  


3 

 # 

#1

   






 

 



 

 %


'




 # 

"


#  



 
  


 

  
0
 


 

   


 #

 





1


 
%


 '


 # 
"






 
 

 


  /

# 






%
#
%

 



+ 
4 


5#
6
0

 %"

''


 

  




% 
# 


% 

  

'


&% # 

 
 
 
 

 

 3 

#
7%'

 # 

%
   
 "
0% '



 

#'

#
&%  %


 
%



% 




  %
( )

&*'  +

 ++  # $

"!",-.*/

'
 '
  


 

'

&%
 # 
   -5#
  
 





%#
%

 
  



( )


 
%


1)&*' 2234+5  # $

"!",6

*/

5!  

+'


 




# # 


'

#


  1



#% 
 !


$% 



 
 
 








&% 


 


 

  
'

&%
%






 

% 1  , 
  

# 





&% # 

 ( )


%#
%

 

# 7 

0 18

"

!"9

"  *  



'


  

'






 
#

%#
%

 8   

      

     

       

  

  

 

   



   

     

 

  

   

     

 !           

    

       

 

    



"



  
   

  

  #     

    

   

 

      "

  


  



 

 
       

  
   "



           

      

           

 "

  
  

 



    $   

 
 



  



   
   %& 

'  

"

 (   )

*
+,-./0.1* 12-3  





          

     4 9 5

%


 % 


#

% ( )


%#
%

 

 

 
#

 

&%


%#
%

 '





 
 





%


 
 
 

 
#



%
 

&%
  # :
6%'

 
%


 






 %




,-.*/

%" '




 
%'

 
 
 

 
 '

#

 



'




  




     



 


&"

'
 


  
 
( '



%


 

&%


%#
%

 
 
   



 
 


 

'



 

 








%

   
  .
0
 
%


 

 


 


%
 


  




 %

   






&% # 

''



# 
 

  
 
 
   
 


&%  
# # 
; 



%

    

 

 

% 


%#
% 
 '


  
%  %'
#




 
 
( )


%#
%

 

*+


,,"-./

 
%



%

  
 '



% 
 







# 7 

0 18%" ' ; '

%




 #


   


 

''


 %'

% 

#
%
 1

  


  

&% 


6%'

 
4 


%



2+-999!-."


/./."
 
# $

"!" ,68 

'




'
 


 #


%
''



'




#

 

''
% 


 % 
7






%#  



 
  



 '






 




0
 








 
  

'

  


 


%

   
% 

#
%

  


% /
0
  



 #

 (HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI) JUDGE ( VIKAS SURI ) JUDGE 13.11.2025 Riya Whether speaking/reasoned:

Yes/No Whether Reportable:

Yes/No