High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22611/2017dismissed

Naresh Kumar And ORS v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2017-11-16Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan3 pages

!""#$%$&'

("%)*+, (!)"(% -- "!$!$&"(% ."(%+% /! !" +&0 1 &2!)"(% -- "%3&2"&!%

("%"&!'-

(// &2)+425# !"(!)"3"!$!$&"(%

"!$!$&"(%47) ("!)(""$&&+,1"(4 ("%"(5$&8 %/"&$( %%$%! &!%+&2"(!)" "5"&+""3 (!,"&!4/! !" +&0 1 ) 99"&8"$&!)"$&%! &!3"!$!$&$%!!)"(2"(2 !"2:

&&";+(" -< $%%+"2 1= !)" ,,$%%$&"(4 "(>"3+( $5$%$&4

"(>"3+($&!"(,%7)$#)!)"#9 $,!)"3"!$!$&"(%!1" %%$8&"2 %"&$($!=3%$!$&5"( &2 15"3($5 !"("%3&2"&!&?$&!)"# 2(" 9"(@%4) %1""&("0"#!"2 +&%"97+92%+1,$!!) !!)"$,3+8&"2(2"(2 !"2:

&&";+(" -<7 %&"5"(%+339$"2!!)"3"!$!$&"(% &2( !)"(!)"% ," ) %1""&3(#+("2&9=("#"&!9=+&2"(!)"3(5$%$&% #! 5$&8)" (2#+&%"9(!)"3"!$!$&"(% !9"&8!) &2) 5$&8 3"(+%"2!)"39" 2$&8%&("#(24!)$%+(!$%!)"#&%$2"("25$"7!) ! !)"("7+921"&1 %$%!) !7+927 (( &!$&!"("("&#"$&!)", !!"( !$%!)"39" 2"2# %"!)"3"!$!$&"(%!) ! !"&! !$5"%"&$($!= 9$%!9"(@%7 %#$(#+9 !"2&ABBB $&7)$#)!)"3"!$!$&"(%7"("

%)7&%"&$(!3($5 !"("%3&2"&!&?)"(" !"(4 $& 9%"&$($!=9$%! 9 %%-",39=""%7 %#$(#+9 !"2&BB &&";+(" -? &2$&

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

$%!($#!4$%$99"8 9 !$% , !!"(47)"("!)$%+(!7+92&!8$&!!)","($!% !)"%+1,$%%$&% 25 &#"2 )"$& 9%"&$($!=9$%!7 %#$(#+9 !"2&BB +&%"9 2+($&8!)"#+(%" (8+,"&!%#&#"2"%!) !!)"$(%!("3("%"&! !$&$9"2 8 $&%!!)"$& 9%"&$($!=9$%!7 %$&!)"=" (A$" !"( 3"($2 9,%!:=" (%5"&!)+8)4 & !!",3!) %1""&, 2"!5"(#,"2"9 = 1=#&!"&2$&8!) !!)"$,3+8&"2(2"(2 !"2: &&";+(" -< 7 %&"5"(%+339$"2 &27 %3(#+("2+&2"(!)" #!1+!$&!)"% ,"

1(" !)$!) % 9%1""&%! !"2!) !!)" 339$# !$&+&2"( #!7 %$9"2 &9=$&!)"=" ( )"$& 9%"&$($!=9$%!2 !"2BB !)"# 2("9"(@% %! &2% #!"2+3&$& %,+#) %!)"3"!$!$&"(%)"("$& % 9%!)"3($5 !" ("%3&2"&!) 5"" (&"2+(!)"(3(,!$&%!!)"3%!+&$(%%$%! &! % 9%/"&$(%%$%! &!

-<- )"&D19"/+3(","+(!$&# %"

) %2" 9!7$!)!)" %3"#! 2"9 =$&) 5$&8 33( #)"2!)"($!+(!$&, !!"(%%"&$($!= &2 3(,!$& &2) 5"1%"(5"2 %+&2"('-

" # $

& ' (

# ) =997$&8!)"2$#!+,9 $227&1=&D19"3";+(!$&

# %" %+3( !)"(" 7+92 1" & %#3" ( $&!"("("&#"$&!)"3("%"&!# %"##"3! &#"!)"3( ="(( $%"2$&!)" $&%! &!3"!$!$&7+925$(!+ 99= ,+&!!+&%"!!9$&8%"!!9"2, !!"(% )"7($!3"!$!$&%+"(%(,$&(2$& !"2"9 = &29 #)"%

"!$!$&$%2$%,$%%"2

9+#@= )"!)"(%3" @$&8E(" %&"2'

"%E )"!)"( "3(! 19"'

"%E