Tulsi Dass v. State Of Haryana And Others
!
!
! " "#
$ %
&%
'
( ) * )+ , !-#!," ".& &%
)+ ,"/ /"," ". )+ ,"- "," "#
'* $ 01 &% % 1 & $ 2
( 3&%1&& $ %
4 &%1& 3
3
& )+ , !-#!,
" ". 5 & )+ ,"/ /"," ". 5
)+ , "- "," "# 5
'*
3 "
3
5 , 3
63
(
( 7
8
3 7
(
3
8
(& 3
(
&
&
3
(
(
&
9
5
(
3
(
8
3
( 3
8
(
(
5
3
(
(
3
8
(
8
(
3
8
(& &
0
( :
(
&
0(
;5
) 6
! "# $%!
&' (# &)&
*+++,-.+ .
<
(
3
3
# )
,5
3
3
=
(
5 &
)
(
(
> 3
& 5 3
)+ ,! ," "# $ 7
0(
# " "# 0(
?5
) 3 )
>
3
(
0(
3
@ 0(
# " "#
) @ 0(
5 ,
!
!
! "#
! " # $ " $ %
& (
/!0 &' &$# # $ " $
'
& ( )
!
!
*
!
!
*
"#
( &$'" '&" " 1 2 $# # $ " $
& # '
# $#& 3# #(4!$ %( ($ ( $ & #$' (4 $'" 5!$4( & ! ($# $(!$(& # 67*+. .+.
89.786769 " $ +
& , )
*!
*!
!
- "#
./ # 0 1 :(!0$ / & ! ($#3#;(# ) $(!$(& # 6766 ' ( ,9<
89.786769 " $
+
& 2 )
!
!
!
!
!
!
! !
*
3#
=$ >' &($ ;$ $;?# # $ " $ 2
& &
! " # $ "
$
%
& % 4
* *
0
!
!
!
"#
! "
# $5 &' 3($#(# / ' & $ # $ " $ 6
&@ ( /!0 &' &$# # $ "
$
'
& 6
*
!
3#
! " # $8 9
*
:
1;
# , 0$0
3;
$;A' $?# # $8 " $ 6
& )
*
!
*
! 3#
! " # $ " %
& ( / !0 &' & $# # $8 " $ '
&
' < !
*
"#
( &$'" '&" " 1 2 $# # $ "
$
& = 1
!
!
!
"#
! "?# 4#( " & "
$
%
&- 0(
3 3 5 ) 3
( 0(
# " "#&
( !
0(
( !
0(
5 , % <
.> #
0
< 0
1
.>
# 0
! "?# 4#( # $
.>
# 0
!
!
0
!
* $ ((
! "?#4#(# $
"
(( )
0
"&
!
!
!
"& 1
*
!
*
"& 7
*
!
"& )
"&
"&
!
"& 1
!
!
!
!
!
!
- 4
.> # 0
1
!
!
* !
*
)
*
*
!
! 1 "&
:
*
1 !
"&
"&
"&
?
!
#
"& !
!
6 # !
.> # 0 1 &' 3($#(# / ' & $ 3#
% (# &! ($#) $(!$(& # 677B* -<7
!
. 0
*
* )
7
<
0
2 1
!
1
!
!
:
!
*!
% 1
! *
! ???
???
???
' @
4
! )
?
!
:
& # ! > ( ($ "
4!; '4(&C (#'! !0 >'#' 3!
3(&' (;($ ???
???
???
(( )
!
)
# " &
0
!A <B
" & 0 C $ 4 ! " &
+
!
! !
*!
:
)
!
-
(, )
. 0
!
0
!
)
. 0
!
!A !
1
7
!
.
0 !
?
*
:
*
*
!
!
.
0
!
!
* D ( ;($ #! ' 3!
3(# 4!; '4(&C (#'! !0 >) 1
.> <
. 0
!
!
!
$
< :
! *!
)
.>
#
0
:
)
.> # 0 1 ( &$'" '&" " 1 2 $# # $' '3#) $(!$(& # 6779. 996
0
!
1
!
!
*
!
!
*
!
1
*!
*!
1
)
! )
)
.> # 0
)
. 0
! !
!
)
2
)
*!
)
4
) .!
<
.!
)
((++,
4
$ 0 4
4
(
1
!
!
???
???
???
1
. 0 >( &! !0' & (>!0!$ ;#D( !> 3(4! #'&($(& (#(4' 04#!0 '#4#(> '4 ($# &(& (;!
#" ( &($;( $!4((&' 1# D
!
.
0
*!
!
.
0
:
!
) 0
#
;
" &
!
!
*
!
*
( 4!
$ ' ( D!3( 4#( 0 $ ($ !(& ( # &$& !0 $!!0 (;!&( !0( C '$" & ( $
(# 1!3($ ' 1 ( ( C '$" &$' ' D! ( 4#(# $( &'#' 4 &&'00($( D
#
;
!
!
???
???
???
2
.
0
:
!
!
!
FF- ' )
.> # 0 ( / !0 &' &$# 3# (( ; 1 & $ $(!$(& # 67*-+ 9+*
, 7
)
! *
1
!
! . :
0
:
)
0
2 ) 0 B
:
#;)0 CGH ;
"(+(& #00 22(
"& )
!
"& )
!
!
!
!
(3( # 4 1$!
&# >!
& D( 3'
D ( !
" ' 4#(# ' 3!
3' 14!; (EC (#'! #!004#!$ >
"& #
!
)
*
!
!
!
"&
!
?
"
&-
1
!
!
.> # 0 $ / 3# % '
!
:
! ? *
!
)
!
0
!
:
?
*
= <! !
0
F 8+.<86769 &(4'&(& ! *-7*6769 3' ;$#(!0$" &! ($#)
F **67,86767 AD'$ ' 1 & ! ($# # ( !0 $" &! ($#) F 8*.<,<86767 '# &($ # ( !0 $" & ! ($#) 3'&( A &1;( &(& 79*6676, $ !
!
!
?
?
+ 4
6+(+(2
3' ;$# $ 0
!9.786769 ! ;
B
< 0
%+,(+(2 )
0
6+(+(2
#
I 07$ =% (+(2 ;
B #
.
!
)
# I
(+'(+(, "4 ? $ ,&
!
!
!
"4 ? $ 2&
1;
E (+
(++'(+(, #
$ 0 4 =''
$ # 40< 4
4 0 <
( )
:
???
???
???
???
2 1
8<-<86767 ( !0 $" & ! ($# 3# '# ;$ ! < 0 ,++%(+(( ! G# #
I
#
! :
#@$
(4' (3(!( !*<69,!06766
+(+(( # :
867+-867*. ( !0 $" & ! ($# 3# $(#
' +=+=(+(( ! <
0 G# #
I C
'3'
D($' 1 ='$" !66 !0 676,
"
6+(+(, % 1 ( !0 $ / & ! ($# 3# ;(# 6766 ' ( ,9<
!
$ 0 4 =''
*
(#
" ( (E !
$ & 1! ( !
& ( $' 4' (# > '4 1!3($ &'#4' ' $" ' C '$" $( &'#' 4 0$!; !#( > '4 "
! 4$';' $' & ' ( 0!$;($ ( 4 $1( # !
D( (#D '# (& D("! & $(#! D ( &!
D > ($(# ' (
($ ( 4 $1( !0 ;'#4! & 4 # ! D( (#D '# (& !
( $' 4' ( !0 $(! &($ 4( !0 $!DD'
''(# '# #! ( & ( $
(# !0 (3'&( 4( > '4 " ! D! ($!4(& $(#$(&'#' 4 6 4
I <
4 ? 0 # '
#
$#& 3# #(4!$ %( ($ ( $
& #$' (4 $'" 5!$4( & ! ($# 67*+ . .+.
)
*!
!
!
!
#
; 1 !
#
I 4!
4
!- # !
0 AD'$ ' 1 & ! ($# 4#( # $
!
!66*.8676,@
8,69 & ,6. !0 6769 < 0
%+,(+(2
@$4
0 AD'$
' 1 &! ($# 4#( # $
1
0
0 3' ;$?# 4#( "# & AD'$ ' 1 & ! ($# 4#( # $
@$4 < 4
< @$4 E2+ (+(2 3'
;$?# 4#( "# &
0 07$ E=% (+(2 3' ;$?# 4#( "# &
* ! A
!
( < 0
86<68676* &(4'&(& ! 6,7.676* G((;#(!0$" & ! ($#)
!
*!
1
*!
!
!
? !
!
!
!
<
?
!
)
7
#
!
( !
" 1$'(3 4( !0 ( 4!
#( 0!$ ( (
'# ( 4$';' 4#( & ( &($;( $!4((&' 1#
!
1' # ( (
4 ! $!4((& #';
(!
# " # D! ( #'& $!4((&' 1# $( D#(& ! #;( #( !0 04# & (3'&( 4( ( 0 $ ($ ( D!$(& '0 ( &($;(
$!4((&' 1# & 4$';' 4#( 1' # ( (
$(
!>(& ! $!4((& #';
(!
# " ( ( &(0( 4( !0 ( (
>'
D( $(A &'4(& # ( (
>'
3( !
&'#4 !#( ($ &(0( 4( '
&3 4( '
( &($;(
$!4((&' 1# > '4 $( 1!' 1 ! D( 4! & 4(& ;
4 0# 4( ( ($!4((&' 1#' (4$';' $' ???
???
???
)
*!
!
) *
.> 4 ?
0
! "?# " & ( / !0 &' 2 ($#? " &
)
.> 4 ? 0
"& )
! "& )
!
!
!
!
<
! ? * "& #
!
)
*
!
!
!
"&
!
?
-
#
!
?
4
0
*!
1 ( / !0 &' & ($# 3# $; 6779. 6.
)
!
!
:
#
! )
*!
! 1
?
!
? !
1
! ! ?
! !
* 9 *
:
- )
*! 1 !
*!
4
!
( ='3'#'! ! $!
($ 3# % '
!67*6*996 1 !
*:!
4 !
)
*!
! 1
?
? ! )
! *!
! )
# I F 8++++8677- $(; ' 1 3# ( !0 $" & ($# 6B*7677-
< 0
! "?# " &
!
:
:
!
)
#
I
(& $/# 3# ( !0 $" & ($# 677.9 96,
:
< 0
.
0
: .
!
$ )
.> # 0
( ='3'#'!
! $!
($ ?# " &
! "?# " &
9 ( / !0 &' & ($#? " &
.> # 0
!
!
!
???
???
???
???
F( $( #! !0 ( !' '! (3( ! &'$(4'! 4!
& D( 1'3( ! ( (00(4 4!;;! >' (##(# ' &($;(
$!4((&' 1# & ( 4$';' $' >!
& 0'$# D( (E;' (& '
( 4$';' $' & !
" ($(0($ ' ( &($;(
$!4((&' 1# # ' >!
& #! $(A &'4( ( ' ($(# !0 ( &($;( 1
! !
!
#
I 0 * !
!
- , 1
0
0
! !
*!
?
< 0
# <
1
#@$
(''! 0!$ (4'
(3( ! ( '3'
!*,<.,8676* G ((; # ( !0 $" & ! ($#)
.> # 0 3'&( !$&($ &(& 6+**676*
! 2 )
.>
<
0 =$ >' &($ ;$ $; 3# ! ?D (
AD & $" '1 !
$ $!
1 (1'#$$%( ($ F 8.<,+8 676*&(4'&(&! 6B7<676*
: ( $(#! 0!$ ' '''! & ($ " 4! 4
#'! !0 &($;( $!4((&' 1# ' # 4 4#(# #((;# ! D( $((80!
& ' ! >((& !
(; !"(( > !#( ' (1$'"G4 $4($ #D(( !&!
D $'; 04'( ! 44!
!0 #!;( 4$';'
$!4((&' 1# 3' 1 D(( ' ''(& 1' # ';G ($ '' ( #;( ';( > ( (; !"(( '# # #( &(& (G# ( '# ( ' (& ! (# !0 ( " ' ># &$>' 1 D(0!$( D(' 1
# #( &(& & # "' !$&' (&( "'
4! 4
#'! !0 &($;( $!4((&' 1# > ($( 4 $1(# $( !0 3($" #($'!
# $( >!
& (4(##$'
" ( '
D $&( !
(E4 (C ($ & # >'
D( 1' # '4 ' ($(# ''' ( &($;( $!4((&' 1# '# !
;' ' &'#4' ' ( ' ( #($3'4( & (00'4'( 4" !0 '4 #($3'4( & # '# ' '''! &4! 4
#'! #(E(&''!
# "# !##'D ('#' '4' ($(# 1
(+=
,+(+(+ "$ &
4
?
!
C $ 4 !/
" & ???
???
???
# 2+= 2(+ (+ < (+ 1$0
!
#1)
.
:
:
)
*
!
4
$ 0 4
=''
?
J: J
: .
! !
-
1
!
!
!
!
1
!
!
!
!
! 1
!
!
!
: !
?
*
% 4
#@$ (''!
0!$ (4'
(3( ! ( '3'
!B6.+8676* =$ >' &($ ;$ $; 3# ! ?D (
AD & $" '1 !
$ & ! ($
!
+(+((
6 )
.> < 0
86,+8 6766 $;A' $ #
AD &' & / & ! ($#)&(4'&(&! 697,6766
( )
#
I
:
# 0
C $ 4 ! H <
G C === ",& #00 6=
0 C $ 4 !
" & ! !
:
;
*
*
:
5
* !
*
7
# I
1
:>
(++%
4 !
# I
!
???
???
???
< ! D(' 1 !' (& " #/(& '0 ( 4 $1(# 3( D(( 0$;(& ' ( 4$';' $' 1' # ( (
& '0 "(# > ( ($ ( 4 $1( # (( ># $!& 4(&G 4(& D(0!$( ( ($ (& ' 1 ( &1(H
($ (& 4!
#( 0'$ " 4! 4(&(# !
1 4 $1(# 3( $(&" D(( 0$;(& D ( 4 $1( # (( ># ! 4(& D(0!$( ( ($ (& ' 1 ( &1( # 4'$4 ;# 4(# ' '# (3'&( ( 4! ( '! !0 ( (
D#'# !0 ( &($;( $!4((&' 1# & 4$';' $' '# ( #;( '# (' ($ # D# '(& !$ (#D '# (& 3( ! ($>'#( # ' &'4(& D!3( (
4 $1(# 1' # ( (
$( D#(& ! $(4!$& & &! ! ' 3!
3( " 4!; '4(& C (#'! # !0 > & 04# (#4 $1( 4!
&D(($;($3() 4
#
I
1
*
- @ : (
5 0(
5 >
&
& )
3
-
3 (
) 5
3
B: .
. ! " ".
@
) %
& /-- '
.' *'5* 3
.'"*
) %
& /--
*
% ) = & B5
5
0 (
& >, ( 3 5 & 3
( B: ( 3 5
3
( " >,
(
- >, (( 3
( % % 8
," 3
( 3
3 ( 5 (
3
(
"
- >,
(3
/ <
5
@. ) ) 5
5
(
(& 5
( ( 5
( 3 3
:
5
( 3
(
(&
&
3 & # 3
8 " 3 & 5
8 B
5
&
3
55
& >, ( 5 & 3
0 3 ( 5 ( 3
( 55
- >,
0
)
7 3
&
7 3
5 (
) & 0(
5
5
(
7 3
B &
& 3 7
&
3 3 5 C5
) ( &$'"'&" " 1 2 $# # $ 3 (
(& ( (
( 7
5
8 :
3 5
&
@. ) )
5 &
5
(
5
( (
&
3 3 5 ;5 = )
$;A' $ # $
&
3 5
( ,
3
5
( 4( & &
& (
5
(
3
3
5
5 $
&
@. ) )
&
&
3 5
3
3
(
3
(
( 5
> (
( :
5
@. ) ) 5
5
3
A ) ) 5
(
>
(
5 (
3 3
5
A ) )
3
@. ) )
& 0
=
)
=$ >' &($ ;$ $;?# # $
3 5
#
& 5 , )
*
!
4
$ 0 4
=''
?
J: J
: .
! !
-
< ( 0(
5
3 3 "
&
(
@ 0(
5 ) #C?# 4#( '*& 5
& (
(
3
8
& 3
8
( & 3
(
&
5
(& .
:
)
(
(
(
)
3
( 3
0
>
&
3 3 !
!
#
3 (
) 5
3 3
B: "#
/ " ".
@& .
) %
& /-- .-# :
)
% ) & = '*& &
5
(
( 55
@ >,
3
(
(
5 (
& 3 5
(
C 3
(
((
&
3
% % 8
," 3
3 ( 3
( @ >,
&5 ( <
5
@. ) ) 5
(
& 5
@. ) )
( ( 5
3 3
:
5
( 3
(
(
( % 8
,. :
- 3
(&"3 5
8 ""3 & 5
8 B
5
&
3
55
( 3 C
5
3
3 ( 3
( 55
@ >,
)
7 3
&
7 3
5
5 (
) & 0(
5
5
(
7 3
B &
& 3 7
& 3
3 5 C5
) ( &$'"'&" " 1 2 $# # $ 3 (
(&
( (
( 7
5
8 @ :
3 5
&
@. ) )
5 &
5
(
5
( (
&
3 3 5 ;5 = )
$;A' $ # $
&
3 5
( ,
3
5
( 4( & &
& (
5
(
3
3
5
5 $
&
@. ) )
&
&
3 5
3
3
(
3
(
( 5
> (
( :
5
@. ) ) 5
5
3
A ) ) 5
(
>
(
5 (
3 3
5
A ) )
3
@. ) )
& 0
=
)
=$ >' &($ ;$ $;?# # $
3 5
#
& 5 , )
*
!
4
$ 0 4
=''
?
J: J
: .
! !
-
< (
0(
5
3 3 &
(
@
0(
5 ) #C?# 4#( '*& 5
& (
(
3
8
& 3
8
( & 3
5 (
&
5
(& - :
)
(
(
(
)
3
( 3
0
>
&
3 3
/
3 (
) 5
3
B:
" " "# (
@
) %
& /--
% ) = & &
5
(
" 55
( 5
& (( 3
5
% % 8
,. 3
3 ( 55
" 3
1D
E
5
(
1 &
3
&
"
<
&
@. ) )
( 3
(
. " "#
( % 8
,# ,! 3
(&
& @ 3 &
3
&
8 :
5
3
&
(
(
% 8
,"
(
( 3 % 8
,# 5
"A " " "#&
3 3 3
(
( % 8 ," ,# 3 5
3
&
3
3
3
(
(
% 8 ,.
"
B
5
&
3
" 55
5
$ & (( 3
5 +
3
3 ( 55
"
3
)
7 3
&
7 3
5 (
) & 0(
5
5
(
7 3
B &
& 3 7
& 3 3 5 C5
) ( &$'" '&" " 1 2 $# # $ 3 (
(& ( (
( 7
8 ""
:
3 5
&
@. ) )
5 &
& 3 3 5 ;5 = )
$;A' $ # $ 3
5 3 & &
3 5
( ,
3
5
( 4( & &
& (
5
(
3
3
5
5 $
&
@. ) )
& &
3 5
3
3
(
3
(
( 5
> (
( &
(
( !
0(
5
& (
(
3
8
& 3
8
( & 3
5 (
&
(& ".
:
)
(
(
(
)
3
( 3
0
>
&
3 3 #$%& '(
)*+
,
B +
(> >2 +
5
>2