← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/26213/2016allowed

Maya Devi v. State Bank Of Patiala & ORS

2017-11-07Mr Justice Jaswant Singh23 pages

 

      

 

!

  ""# 



    

 



$ %&'()*+,-.)''$*$-%.

    

 

!   "  

 !

    # $

 !  % ! !

&'()

*%     '() % *    '() %++,++,#-    * 

*

 !

 !

'() !

  + % ! !  !

 ** %

*& 

     !

"!

  # $%&' ()%(* (+ ,(&& -.

/ 0*

/

  !

!  / 

  "!

  # $%*%&'0&1 ,* (* ,(&'

-.

/  0'

2   !    

    



"  

2 

  

/ 

  "!

   ,) (1 ,(&1  -.

/  0+ 2  3

!    3    ! " " 

 !

 !  

 ! 2 ! 

 



            " "2   

!  



2

 

  !2 



 2 

!  



"    

  ""/ 5

67  .   / *'

*' %!!

  01  ,-,.#223    #4,.#223 '() * (  5*   /  ,.,4+,#4%** !  % 

  %   

#6#+  6        !!*    

!  !!

  #-,4+,#4 !!*  %   +.,4+,#4



!     ***  

!  !!

 '(  

! 

7 ! *  

* "

080,6+6,6+,#9:

7

03;   *      <+:; 

* "

80#9   ,.0,6,3+,##=            *  

!  !!

    

      +.,4+,#4  :

7

  03;   !

!  9 > 

*

!      !*   !

&()  +4  01    66 **#4    

 )

 !   

   /7 !

 *    ?       %   %            !*  *   % *   !  @ !   

 !

*      % 

   * *@ !

  *   

! 

7 ! *   

* ,.0,6,3+,##:

7

06;

7 ! *   - "  !  " !   2   

2  "2 2

4 - "    !           



      !    !    )(  2

 2 !

  % "

   @ !

A())   

 7 ! *            !         ***     

B *   B   

!   !!

     

 

*      * *  

 *7     *  !*  %   !!

 



     ., %  * '

  %

*  

   

 

 

#3 ., 

'

0'@0C(  7

  %

*

.3 6, ?     

 

7

 

 

*!

*'

!!

  !*   !

&()    .,         

     

* *    !*   *  *

!  !!

   @

      *        %  



   !

 

! !!

 



   *%  !* @ !*     *     !*  **     !*     %              !!

  

 

          .,     "

 

          

! !!

   % !

&()  *   

! !!

 

   *     

*  *

*

   

! !!

   $  !* %

* 7! @

7 ! *                        7 

!  !!

    ' 

D  *  

! !!

      !

*  0  *) !

   4    **   "

+:;  

*  ,.0,6,3+,##:

7

06; 7   ** *

 *  *  

*  

   !  *       ** %   &  !"! !#!$ %#&'& "(2  &) *+",+#-!./ 9 

  . &* !







  

 "

 ! !  "

"       ! 3



 " !

     !

2      

  

  : 

"" :    !

"  

.

+ 

2 2



  "

2   !  

 

  

 2  2 

! 

!

 !  "

"

!  





 !      "         

 

 

            !

 ;



" 

 

 9 "  ! !  

 !

3

 





  

2

2

!

!   

.  6; 

"

  " 

2 

2 "



 "  



  

   

! 

! 

  

       

   "     



3

!

9



  2



" 2

"2-& 

"  

!

  ! 

  !  

!    " 

    -,



" 



3

!

  .

;

   

 3

.



!  

"  /

 " 9  2  .   !

  " !

"    "

  

 ! !  "  ! 



 



    !  "   

  

  "       

  !   !

 

     

" 2

  

    

         !

2        

  

   93 /  8  -0-01%#"!    &)

*++" * #-!./ 9 

  . &*

      !

2      

 

 

     !

 9   2

2

  "  



  "   2 "2-     

"   

    

!  

    !  

    !      ! 

!  "

 ! 4 2-



" 



 3

! 

     

;



 "      

 

 4

"  ! ! 2    

 ! 

3

 



     <  

"  /

  

3

.

  



 9      

  7 

. &*

"

 "



 

     

 8  2"(%#3 0  &) *4 "

#-!.  #  &'  &1 =0 &' ;  "



 . &*     !

   "   





           !



"  

  

 !    

   

!  

   !  

    !     ! 

!  "   !  



" 

 /

3

!

     

, &1 .   

  

        

2 /  

2

"  

"   





 

 

 

3

 !

 >;  . &*

? 



       

  9   !



  !

"     



 

/  ! 

             

  

"     



    

   

"    

 "! ;

  !

 

! 

? 

    " 

 

     3

     "   

 9 





 !

 

 



      . &* ;

   !

    

    

"          !  ! 

  

" "





 9

7

2  



;

 

  !

 

!



 



   " !"

 

   

  @!      /   

 "

 !    

  

  

      

  



 

3

 !

  ;  2  2



"   

    9

     

 

 

 

  

      

 

3

 !

  ;

    

    "   "  

  

. .  9 2-&ABA )7 &(&*    !  &()*2    7       "



C 



  

2  

 C 

  

 2 

"

   



2 

  "

 8 % '

!





* : !

;

   ! +:;  

* ,.0,6,3+,##:

7

06;**   -   * 

*

 !

%*  !  / *

%  

) 

!  !!

              

      *   !*   

! !!

   !

&() 

!

  %  7 ! *      %  

!  !!

 

*   * !  +:;+:;  

* ,.0,6,3+,##@      +:; 

* ,.0,6,3+,##@     +:;         !* /   *        *  

!   !!

   @

                  

                  @  

!

  *  !  / * !  / %

* **    +:;  

* ,.0,6,3+,## > 

*

 !

 *  ** %   &  "!  (    0  0  !#  %#  "-1   5    

  )"    4    #  =0

* A . 2    ! " ;



2"  

&'   !

  

            "     

   

       "  !"



 7    ; @ - ;  

  

 7 



  

 

  

 9

 "

2    

 ; 3!"

    !D!  



  ; 

#

'(*'    &AAA        



     " 8    (  0  !  %#    !#  6-7   +  "  4    #  *  =0 *  @  

       

0 

 



    

! 



. &*  &1 7

9  

 

 



  2   2      

     !   "

%



9

"

 E ! 5  "F

0

   "           "    



   

  !        "

%



    

 ! " " 9  "





3 

  !

 

    ""   

 

 0"     

   !

 

! "    2

 " 

 !

 2  2

  5!  7   

 3     

!  

0  

 

    "   





 



9 



2 

  

  

"    3!"

=  G"  H" #!  5 

2-&AA* *77 &)+4 .  9 @     IJ 2-,((+ &'77'1(4G

9 I.

   H 2-,(&& *7.@$,A+4 5  #H"2-&AA* *77**+4   IJ  DH2-,((B A77'B&     9 I.

  3H"2-,(&( && 7711& 8  37!#6-7$5 %#"! 810!#   **  )"



,  # , =0 , ; 

 



    !    ! !  

   

  

  !   9   

 !

 

 .2

     "



  



 " #

"

 

 





"#  



    

  

   

  

    /  

    

            

2

!  

 



  2  "/ 

 

    

     3     

 " 

!

 J  / 

    

      "    !          !"    "  

 9   2 " 



 !





 "  

 2 "





"

 " 2 

" 

 ! " "

 

   " !        " "

 ;    3

!

!

" "

 



"

    ; 3



!""  " "        <  2 "   "    

   " 

          

  ; 

   



/" 





"  2  

  2     

" "

2 " 



"  3 

 

! "" " ;  7999 9     

     

0"      " 

!

 



 

! 2 3

 !

 "2 





 !

 "!

 ; 

" "

 

  " ! / 

 3  

 

 "

 ;   

!

  

 "    

 /

    3

  !

    2  ? 2   !  

#

   /

   

!        9 " "" 

!  "    "



"  2

"

     ;  / 

    "     "  " 



  "

! " /

2 7 !   2 " !  

 " "

    8 %    

  !    

     %!

*  3  * 

*

!  2

   !  / * !       !

     

*  "

80#9    ,.0,6,3+,##

%    &    



."



5J 2;2 K&*B((& $"= " L

;

=,,&*BB1$/ ,+*0 ,A( 7 # % $%&'

 =()%(* (+ ,(&& 

75$$ MJ .

J9#;$#;

J# 7J .9J#.;$  CJG#  9#  $N7$ ;9J#.@ 7.$

   

 7   #

%))    ,* && ,(('

 !

0 " "

/0! """

 

!  & ;  "

      /"        $/ 7 ""

   " !

,A D2,(&&  " 

!  / 

  ;

 " .

7

C  $/ 

78

 "(1 &( ,(('2



  " "

/0!  "  "  "

         " 



 " , <

 2   "

 

  "     

!     / 

    ;   "        

! =  1!!01$' !5! 7$#

.

0-1  #    !#-     % !.!  !#7 ::!10.1  1!!01$' %!1!# # # 557!:!

!!.$!$!

1!#  '.!%!  #  !  !%$   0!57! #5-#!0;7. 0! ) ;    

  

(1 &( ,(('   

  

   



   " * ;    

 /0 !   "  "  "

 

  

  



   "  '

.

 " "

   " 

    !        

     (1 &( ,((' 

,A (B ,(&&

 



%J 2   " 

 ;



%  "" 

"  "   

" 



"   "      !  .

  /   %    

"" !  "

"   "      ;  "  "            "



  

%" 



)&  "2,(&& ; ""  "



  

  %  "    

        ,A (B ,(&& /"

 "  

. 

 ! 

5 5J %!

J 

 !

 7 



 



 ! %0 C  !2 -J

'  

! !!

  

! 



!

&() *%    7 ! *   *

!*  %*!

   *    *  * 



   1



 !*  %

 !!

 



     ., %  *

* ! *!

0



 *   / * 

! !!

  *%   

* !

 7 ! * !  / /  

  7      +4    66  #, '!

*  7 ! * %  !* %    !!

 



     .,

%  *

%

*   ** *

 *

   !

  ## @    

! !!

  !

  *     *   !*  0* !

 



  @

!  !!

       

         *  

  *   

  *       !!

  

! 

 



+   !!

   *  !       

 B  *  !

  !   !* 

%* B  7 % 7! * *

    !* !

 7  * 

 %   !*  



     0   #+ > 

*

 !

  !  %7**

 % 

.*  



 



#, ,,,0&!

@

   

! !!

 C   !

* 

  !* *  

*  !

&() % *

 %  %        !*     * @  !   !



!  / *

%  %    ! +:;   @



   !

    #. 87 ! *  *   +:;  %     

*  

 !  / !!

 %    **  B  7 %

  

 *#6 

                   %*  !

!       

! !!

 8



 *#6 

 !

  *    

!**  !

  *  * *   @ *           *

        

  *   *    * *    

   @ *  



 ** *  %   ! 

  

!  

 *

 

!'

 

  * *   

  @ 

 * 7 %   *    

  %** *!

%   * %

*7 

%    *      

  !

   *  ** *      %        7          

        '

!

 

         3    0  %#  2!# 9$!!$5 !

 

4" *  *% !   * % !  !

*   % *

 & E;

 7   "



   

  !

  "

2 7  

 



  "

  

/ 

! 





 

"

 

 



    

  

"

 

 !

   

    

 "  ! " 





    

 

  "

 

 2  ! " " 



 8 #6 "



 

! !!

   *

   

           7 !        * 

* 

    *      %

     !*  

     **  *    

 

     )   %    * !   0 * 0    

     !

*   %

%  **      

,    7   %   * *     

  #9 '

!



   !"! !#!$ %# &'  &   "( : !

;   7    

 *  #6  !

  * * *          *  *    1

   !

!

  7     * *  %  %  B   ***  *  *  



 ** *  %    

!  

  *

   

  * * %  

  * *  #4 '

!



  "-#7<#0!#%# 3 00!# !

  *4* " 4  ! 2  & * <

 "    



 " 

! 2  

  

;         !  

! 

" ! 

               "   

 2  2 "" 

" "   9 " 

     !  9 

 



 "    



""

 

'

!



*   

! !!

 %

* %    E   !       F %         '

!



   <<7(%#('"$ !





"+4 *!  4  & =  $

  " " 

 !

" 

 "

 . &* &1 7

.

/ 

   !" "

!        

 "

    







"2      !



"       

 

    " 

"

  " "

 ; 

"

  

/" 





"

 "   

  

  !" "

2 " 

 

" 2 3 

 

!  ""      "      2    

" !     

 "       !    ;



 

  7  

" "

 ""

 ! 2 

  ! ;7   

 

  







"" 

"   !      

  2

 2 "" 

" "   9 " 

    !

 8 '

!



  '#0"(%#3 0 0!# !



 " **!  #9  & / + #

2        

 

" "

!  

"  ! 

   3

 "" 

" 6"

   

 

 ""

 ! .

 



 " 





* "2          " "

 "  



  



" " 2

. &* &1 7

9  #

"

 

" # 2





 

!

? / 

! 2  



3 2  /!

2      " 2   

   ;  ! 2 

" "    2 "2  !

"  "   ! / 

 "







 



  

  8 '

!



  37!#6-7$5 %#"! 81 0!# !

 **  "

4!

0!  +  & , ; 

 



    !    ! !  

   

  

  !   9   

 !

 

 .2

     "



  



 " #

"

 

 





"#  



    

  

   

  

    /  

    

            

2

!  

 



  2  "/ 

 

    

     3     

 " 

!

 J  / 

    

      "    !          !"    " 



 9   2 " 



 !





 "  

 2 "





"

 " 2 

" 

 ! " "

 

   " !        " "

 ;    3

!

!

" "

 



"

    ; 3



!""  " "        <  2 "   "    

   " 

          

  ; 

   



/" 





"  2  

  2     

" "

2 " 



"  3 

 

! "" " ;  7999 9     

     

0"      " 

!

 



 

! 2 3

 !

 "2 





 !

 "!

 ; 

" "

 

  " ! / 

 3  

 

 "

 ;   

!

  

 "    

 /

    3

  !

    2  ? 2   !  

#

   /

   

!        9 " "" 

!  "    "



"  2

"

     ;  / 

    "     "  " 



  " ! " /

2 7 !   2 " !  

 " "

    8 '

!



   :6-0!%#"!!

&-1 0>00!# !



 " * *!  #.  & &)  "2 .

 !       

    M"   

 " 

 

,& # "2&AA, 

   " 



" ! 

 ! " " !"

2

  "  !

"" 

  !  "

"    " !"

 "  "

  "

  

    

!        

    

2  "

 

     

"     



    "     

  " 

 

M"    " "

   !  

"    "

2        "

     

  !    " !"

" 

 "2



 

 

        2    " !"

2 " "

 

" 





! "  !





 !





 

" 



      " 

     "  

! " "

  

 "      "   .

   



!      5!  7        

   



 



 M"      "      $"   G



         "    



 



   M"   "

                



 ; 3 "

   

  """"

 !"

";   

 ; !    

?

         !

  

 3

     "  "  "  "

   "  



2 !   "  "      "     

  "

 !

 " ! 

"

 

 9 

"

 

   "

       2  

   ! " 

 

F     

      '

!

 

    7     %

 

! !!

 

*    



! !!

   C **  



  * *  #- % 

    !

 

* ,.0,6,3+,##:

7

06;!  +:;7 ! * %

*   *     

! !!

  *)           

!   !!

      *  

   *  !* % *  * !

 



  @   

  *     %*      !        !*     

! !!

   !* 

!*

   !!

 



     .,  ? !

    !* % %  *G !*   66  #4     %** %% 

* $  7 ! * * 

!

!

 

!  !!

 ! * *! +:; 

* % 

*

* !    %   !

    %

*       

! !!

  !   *   !*    

'    *   *      

 !!

    

! 

"

   !

7 ! * * *)! +:;

7 !*  %   !!

 



     ., @

 *  *    

    @  * +:;  

* ,.0,6,3+,##:

7

06;

) %     * * !

 

 

  

 **  

 *#6 

 %    * :;

 +.,4+,#4:

7

03;

B * !

& ()                 !  /     

! !!

 %!   





  !    ! 

  #3 ?

! ** % # 

0''!1! 2"3 ) *45 < 

% !

= O <   = O