High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/27181/2015dismissed

Maghar Singh v. Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal Patiala And ANR.

2016-01-28Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain4 pages

! "#$#%&

! "#$#%& %'

() * + %'

() * + , -.

(/#%-.

##% ( 0 ($'$ . ( $#!#%-

#" (*%!'$(# 1(#2'% 1* #

%! %. ( $3%! %$ ,& ,& ,& ,& 45,/// 45,/// 45,/// 45,/// ( $ %& ( $ %& ( $ %& ( $ %& ,( 67 '$.#8*!9"

(. 3 ##% ( :::::

:::::

/* /* /* /* ##% (.

$ #1 !.#$3 ##%'%! ((#"1 + . %$#'#% %!# $ 8#%- ;(##%. % '(

" (#( (# ( <'

$.#%- . ;

(! !

= >%% ?'( @

A ##% (( #$ ! %%!'$(# 1!#$3' 2)$ (9#%-

! B %! %#" ".

11 %-#%- .#$ (B#% #% . !#$3'

#$ ! 2) . 3 ##% ( ;

$ ( (( ! 2) . 33(3(#

9 (%B %%!'$(# 1(#2'% 1* # ( !6'!#"

#% . "

$ . 3 ##% (*#%2(# *;

!;(8 ! $ (#9 (;#.. ( $3%! %@, - B %

(B C

/ (9#" $ . 3 ##% ( ; ( #11 - 11) (B#% ! $3%! %@, - B %#%#$;(# %$ B %

9 (( !.

. 3 ##% (;

2#'

1 8#%- 1".1

;.#1 % !') ##% ( ;

$ 33#% ! $ (#9 ( ##% ( ;

$ 3#"8 '3 %! !(3 /".1 ".#1!( % ##% (.

!2 %;

(% !%$B %)""

$#%$.

$.'1! % 8 1".1 ;.#1 !(#9#%-. 9 .#"1 2' .

'$ !B %!.#$;

)$%B %)""

$#%$*3 % 1);

#B3$ !%. 3 ##% ( %!.#$#%"( B %$; ( $33 ! / (9#" $ . 3 ##% (; ( (B#% !

(.1!#%-!'

#%<'#() %. 31 !#%-$ . 3 (# $* 11;#%-#$$' $ ; ( B !2). %!'$(# 1(#2'% 1&@ . . ( ! 3 (B % %<'#() "%!'" ! - #%$ . ;(8B % 2) .

( $3%! %#$

#( %!3(3 (E #$$' #$ % 3(9 !* ;. . ( .

;(8B %#$-'#1) . 11 - !B#$"%!'"E = . . ( (B#% #% $ (9#" $ .

3 ##% (#$3(3 ( %!6'$# # !E C . . (. ;(8B %#$ %#1 !- %) ( 1# (B. ( $3%! %$E 1# EF (# $ 1 ! . #( 9#! %" #% $'33( . #( ( $3 "#9 31 $ . %!'$(# 1 (#2'% 1 9#! ;

(! !

= !#$B#$$ ! . ( ( %" $'-. 2) .

3 ##% ( %" *. 3( $ %3 ##%2). 3 ##% ( .

9 .

(!1 (% !"'%$ 1 (. 3 ##% (

%! .

9 -% .('-. . ( "(! #1 21 % . #1 "

'11)

= % . 3( $ % "

$ * !B# !1)* 3 ##% ( ;

;(8#%- $ (#9 (;#.. ( $3%! %@, - B % %!

.#$$ (9#" $ ; ( (B#% ! ##% ( !B# !#%.#$ "($$@ ?

B#% #% .

"B31 #% ?.#2# ,= ;

$ #1 !

- #%$ .#B 2) 11 . !(#9 ($ %! "%!'"($ .

(#%"#3 1 . ( $3%! %@, - B % $ 3 ( ?.#2# , !

*3 ##% (.

!$ !.

#%"

$ *#%

''( * . ;

$ '%! '%! ( . #% 1' %" 1#<'(* , - B %;'1!2 1#2 () (B#% .#$$ (9#" $

%! .

! 3( ) ! ( ( #%$ B % 0#! ?.#2# ,* 3 ##% (.

! - #%$'-. (-#9 % $$ (. B#$ 8 $ "BB# ! 2) .#B ##% ( #% .#$ "($$@ ? B#% #%

'(. ( !B# !.

. .

!2 %;

(% ! (.#$( $. %!

% -1#- % !(#9#%- 2) . , - B % % @= ""

$#%$ ##% ( 1$ !B# ! .

. .

! 2 % ;

(% ! %

% ""'% .#$( $. %!% -1#- %!(#9#%-

1$ !B# !.

. .

!2 %3'%#$. ! (.#$( $. %!

% -1#- %!(#9#%- %!3 % 1) G*

H@;

$#B3$ !% .#B ##% ( '(. ( !B# !.

. .

!-#9 %( 31) $.;@"

'$ %#" $.#$9 .#"1 .

!B ;#. % ""#! %

%! #%<'#() ;

$ "%!'" ! - #%$ .#B %! . .

"% $$ !.#$-'#12 ( . %<'#()

#" ( .'$*#%. 3( $ %"

$ *3 ##% (;

$!(#9#%-

/".12'$ ##% (;

$ '%!!(#9#%-. /".12'$ '%! (. #% 1' %" 1#<'( ##% (.

! !B# !.#$

B#$ 8 2 ( . %<'#()

#" ( % .

"$ %!

"#("'B$ %" $ . 3( $ %"

$ *. , - B %(#-.1) 8. ! "#$#% (B#% . $ (9#" $ . 3 ##% (

$2) 11;#%-.#B"%#%' #%$ (9#" *. 1#9 $ /".1 ".#1!( %;'1!.

9 2 %3'#%!

%- ( ##% (;.;

% !') 3#"8 '3 %! !(3 . /".1 ".#1!( % ;.#1 !(#9#%-. 2'$;

$( <'#( ! "#% ( $3%$#21 B %% ( % .

"$ %! "#("'B$ %" $ . 3( $ % "

$ * .

(% ! %!'$(# 1 (#2'% 1 .

! (#-.1) !#$B#$$ ! .

( %" $'-.2). 3 ##% ( -('%! ( #% ( ( %" 2) .#$ '( ;.#1 ? ("#$#%-6'(#$!#"#%'%! ((#"1 + . %$#'#% %!# *#$B ! '

#$B#$$ ! >/A >/A >/A >/A %'

() * + %'

() * + 9#(