← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18818/2022allowed

Vinay v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2025-08-22Mr. Justice Jagmohan Bansal9 pages

   

          

 "#$$%    

 

   

&#  '(& $ )  & )(

      

 !

     "# $%   &&&&  & )(*$+

(, ' ( 

#  

!" ))*+)),

  -  . 

#

 #  / "

% - // !  ) (    



 

 0 1+)2)2  32'))2)2" 

 

- 4" .  



 5 " 4     " /

 

 #  #   

/ 

/  #6 

   

" /

# (  "   7

!

"! 

/

! 4 "

5 















 











 



!"



"'



**+,""

)""

--,'"

# $%



("!)



!"

&  

 #.

$



!(!"/(%



!-



+00,""

)""

0),*"

!(!"/(



("!0

#   $

&  



.

2 

(( 

!*)0

(*""

'",0!

,1, #1$



("("

( 

 !"

 

 4 /    ! 8"! 4 "

5 &, ,

 

!,

1 

 

3 



4 



(,

 



+,

  5 !( !"/( #!( !"/($

#.

$

*,

  5  !" # $

#  !"$ #.

$

),

  5 . #,1,$

#1$

',

7  



3  

8





" !

 5

5  

# .  5  

# 

"/

5 "4 /

!  1 9   !

 "

  4/

 5     /

 #  4 !    5  

#

"

" # /  "#"! 

/ 5 !"" 

 !"/   "8"  !"/ 

( " " !

!  ! *3'1'/



- ! *2)2/

.

#    

" /

5 "4 /!/

" " !

! ( "

"

5   !"  '*2*)2))  /    

 " /

 2:21)2)'5

! ( 



/   $ " 

-

! ;

<$-=>   2:21)2)'  !

   

 "# "  "!  5 )?2))2)'



 $- 

  

 !

   !

 4  !

  ( !  8 "!

4#/   ''2,)2)?

  -

  < 

      

./.0  #/   2@2:)2)1 

 4 $   !  -

   (0- ?

   "# "    !

 " 4/

"

 "! 

/!"/## 4  

 "

 

"  #

 "  #

 $- #   4/

$- /   

.

 $- 2:21)2)'/

""  *



 5

$-5

 

!



  

  " 

 "

#  * .   "   !

 "

 



 !  ,

  "

    

5  

   32'))2)2  "  

 "# "!  5 )?2))2)'(   ! #  # '

$ 

 B

    

 )2)2    "  "! 

/5 "



!"

 # .

.

  "!  

   

 /

 ""   *

 5!

 5

#/

""  *

 "

!"  ""

4  ( 

    / "/

" #

 $-!

/ #/

""

 5  

  4 B

 

 !

    ( 

! $-!

/ #/

""

/    

 B

   

  !

! 2'2,)2)); 7 @>!

 /#



C 7/ 

"

(  !

!   

 !

     , 8  & &, 2 

44  ,1, '

3     %("("

 

  , !0""-!*(*     , !0% & %*0-     9  (!,!!,("("

9

+"0*""



  :%:9  ;

  4 

9 

3  , 44    % 44  3 ,1, * & 

3    

%("("

   4  

3  

!+,"!,("(!

  

 &, , "!<+!!

  

(<,"!,("(!, =   4 

3  

 

3   

 >  (<= ("(!

        ,1, '



 &, , )*0!<) 9 !*)0(*""



9



"-"*("(!,



 9   (<,"!,("(!

    

 9    "-,"*,("(!,

"

"#$% $"$&'$&

( : .  

 4 

  5 " 4    /

 

  #   #  (  "   7

!



 

% ?# $ $

@    A%

 #3 "0

$A   9 

 , , 9

.

      B

 

 #"*$ = 9

  9

 .

   

  B

 

 



#"+$ ,C

@ -" 3'  

4 

5! 8

 4  "

  5  "!  

/   3' 

   )* +!  ,-.

"- ! /

!,

& 4   1  5 

, , 

 9  

   

  ,

(,

&

4

&  1 D&&

&@@





9

7 



 

4 ,

+,

&

4





    %      

  9 7  





4 ,

*,

&

  

   ,

),

&      ,

',

& 4    9 

E =



, 9



   ,C

'2

 :

 -"  )1   

 8"!  

  !

  "#4"  5"" 4  

/  5  #

  "  7  

!  "  "!  "

   !"

#   0

 :  -"  )1 

  

0 0 1-  !      

  !    - , - .

--,

.

 -   2  !   -  - !   -  

  !-  ''

  !

  #

  !

 

        5 8

! "

 # 4)?2))2)' "

* 

 !" )'2')2)2   ?



 )@2')2)' ( 

"

" !

 !" '*2*)2))  !   " /

2:21)2)'   " 

 

!"

   %   "!  

/ (

   " !

/"  5  8



 (    5  "#4"  

  " /

 ( 

 5

#"  !

 !"/  #

  5 

#! "

 # 4)?2))2)' ')  .



/    # # 5 

8 +/// 8"!  5    5  

  " /

 (  4 !

  " /

 

 #   #  

 #  4

!

 

  

 - 4"  5  /// 8"!   '2D)  "

 B

 ;

C>

"

* 

 !" )''')2)2 1 

)@2')2)'.

"

! * 

# 

" ""

 / 0

"

 !" 

)@2')2)' !  )?2))2)'(  !

""!"  ""

 4 )@2')2)'     5!

"

 1 

 5  !" .



/  

 /

 ':23)2)' * 

2:21)2)'5

 '32')2)' 1 

  )@2')2)'.

1 5   1 

  ! /

1 



"

?



   "! 

/

/

""

 "

  # 



     /    

!   "  /

""





""

 5 #

/  "#"!  '3 (   !  

  ''2,)2)?   ""

5  5   '

($   !  -

 '

( 

/"

 !

!"#    " ?!*,

     =   4 4 



   9

=





=  4  



     ,

 4  F     = 

    44  %4   

 = 

 

9  

  , G      4    

44  %4  9  

  %  =

     4  4     

* &  =  "',"<,("!0,

!),

G      4     44  %       E 

 

%  ,

   4  4    

   !",!",("((,

!',  4 

3  =    9

     



    =

  =  

    

  =   

44 

     4  4 ,

!0, G            



 ; = 7   



=

       9   

 4 

3    =  

    





  ,





34      9 

44  %4 

4



,,

3 

  = ("!0 9      

  =    4  E



    

,,= 9    

      %  

  

   

44 ,

!-,



=        4



3  9

 

 

         

,C

'1 .  !  

  " /

""  *

"

   !"  ""

!   5

#/

""

 5!  /

 /

 

" /

   #   .   4 !   

# ""

   # /

   /

4"  

/



" /

 ""

  .

  !

!""  !  5      !

" 

 /"

" 

/   B



 



! 

#  # 5   5    (  B

 5 

 

   # +$- !"  ""

(

 !

4    

/   "4"  #

    !!

 !!"

!  ""  '? .  5 4  !

#

 -

  !

       

 4  ""

5  !!

#"""

5  '* ( 



 ! 

/ 

5 #

#  ',   "4   5  / 

.

/  !"    #    "" 4     

""



 + & )(,    $$% Prince Chawla F   #+

  +0 F  

4"  +0