High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22773/2017dismissed

Surain Singh And ANR. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2017-11-07Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath6 pages

! !"#$#%&

! !"#$#%&'!()!*

'!()!*

'!()!* +

,*#%#%-.%/% .!* ! # #%!*$ 0$ ! *1%%/ .!*$ !$2%/!% $

3& 3& 3& 3&453663 453663 453663 453663

*!$!% & 3*7!$.,2 +/'" !+

* .!2! # #%!*$

663+859 663+859 663+859 663+859 .! 2! # #%!*$ .'! ".::!%-!/ .! */!* / !/ ;<

2$$!/ )1 *!$2%/!% + /!":#%#%- .! 22:#" #%

* *!'#!=>(/# #" #% .! */!* / !/ <

%/ :$ /!":#%#%- .! 22:#" #% *$ 1 .!*/!*/ !/

.!!? !% . .!:%/ (!$,*#%- < 7%:

(*: $# , !/ #% 0#::-! .*2,*+ !.$#: #+

#$ *#" !.)/ (1 )! !?!(2 !/ *( :: (!% %/ : !*% #'! :%/

*( =%!*$.#2 %/ 2$$!$$#% *!$2%/!% $ ; )! -#'!% *!$2%/!% $@ : .,-. .#$"$!.$:%-.#$ *1), #%)*#! +6%$.#(+ *".%/ %/ --, =!*! .! )#- :%/=%!*$ .!1 $:/ @; )#-. )#$= :%/ 3.#%-.%/ .!*$=2*!!(2 #%$,# $=!*! #:!/ %!)13%#(+/.,! "8 $ 2*!!(2 *9%/$!"%/)13,::( $> ,2+ %A# $> ( ! " 8%/ 2*!!(2 *9 . .! $,# $ =!*!

/!"*!!/)1 .!!%#*,),/-!+#$*%

B <C;)1-#'#%-"%/# #%: /!"*!!$ /#*!" #%- $ 2*!!(2 * /!2$# $,( + C+

> ,2

<C;#!=# .#%%!(% . =$$2!"# #"::1(!% #%!/#% . */!* . #%"$! /!

,: )1 .! $ 2*!!(2 *#%/!2$# #%- .!(,% ,2

<C;+ .!%/2*!!(2 *=#::-! .!*#-. .! $ 2*!!(2 *::!-!/:1 /#/% /!2$# .!(,% %/ #:!/ .!22!:)!

*! .#$,* )1=.#". .!1=!*!/#*!" !/ /!2$# .!(,% .!%/2*!!(2 */!2$# !/ .! (,% !* .!!?2#*1 .!2!*#/-#'!%)1 .! *#:,* %/) #%!/ .! 2$$!$$#% .! 22!: #:!/ )1 .! $ 2*!!(2 * =$ ::=!/ %

B <B %/ !?!", #% =$ #:!/ * 7#%- 2$$!$$#% *( .! %/ 2*!!(2 * .! !?!", #% .! $ 2*!!(2 * =$ /#$(#$$!/ %

< % .!)A!" #%*#$!/)1 .!%/2*!!(2 *)!#%-)**!/,%/!* !" #% <8)9 .!,%A)!",*# 1 5%/!%,*!$" + <C D *$.* E .!" 4F), .!22!: #:!/)1 .! $ 2*!!(2 *-#%$ .!/#$(#$$: .! !?!", #% =$ ""!2 !/ )1 .#$ ,* % ; <;< %/ .! "$! =$ *!(%/!/)"7 * .!!?!", #% .!/!"*!!#%""*/%"!=# .:=.! %/2*!!(2 *".::!%-!/ .!*/!*2$$!/)1 .#$,* )! *! .!,2*!(! ,* )1=1 2!"#:5!'!! # #%#%=.#". .!,2*!(!,* 2$$!/ .!*/!*%< /#*!" #%- .!::!" *"%"!*%!/ *! .!:%/#% /!"*!!$ .!2*2!* 1)!:%-#%- $ 2*!!(2 *%/ /! !*(#%!=.! .!* # !?"!!/$ .!#* 2!*(#$$#'! :#(# $ * % %/ #% "$! # #$ ,%/ . .! *!$2%/!% $ .!*!#% *! !% # :!/ //# #%: :%/ (7! -/ .!#* /!

#"#!%"1,2 .!"!#:#%-:#(# .!%.!=,:/(7!%*/!*""*/#%-:1 .!::!" *'#/!.#$*/!*/ !/ 2$$!/ .!*/!*/! !*(#%#%- .!2!*(#$$#'!:#(# .! $ 2*!!(2 *), . */!*=$$! $#/!)1 .! ,2*!(! ,* % << =# . /#*!" #% .! ::!" * *!/! !*(#%! .! "$! 7!!2#%- #% '#!= .! 2*'#$#%$ .! " .!

::!" *% C >B C 2$$!/ .!*/!**!-*/#%-"!#:#%-:#(# .! *!$2%/!% $ .! .!* */!* =$ $! $#/! )1 .! ::!" * % <<C .!*!

!*+ .! */!*$ =!*! 2$$!/ )1 .! ::!" * %/ ((#$$#%!* % B<

=.#". =!*! $! $#/! )1 .! #%%"#:((#$$#%!*%B

%/ .!"$!=$*!(%/!/)"7 .!::!" * *!/! !*(#%! .!.:/#%-$ .!*!$2%/!% $ .!*!#%$# !?#$ !/ % <B .! :!-: .!#*$ .! $ 2*!!(2 * #:!/ =*# <B@

# :!/$G3%7,*#%/ .!*$0$ ! *1% %/ .!*$H -#%$ .! */!* .! #%%"#: ((#$$#%!* / !/ B

.!$#/=*# 2! # #%=$/#$2$!/ =# ./#*!" #% .! ::!" *8$,*2:,$*!9 /!"#/! .!( !*2!%/#%-)! *!# $!*:1$ 2$$#):!2*!

!*):1=# .#%2!*#/ ,*(% .$%$,)(#$$#% *( 4)1 .!2! # #%!*$#% !*( .!*/!*/ !/B

%/ "(2:1 =# . .! .!*/#*!" #%$#%"!# =$% /!"#/!/#% #(!+ .!*! *!+ B<@

B=$ #:!/)1*!$2%/!% $@ +=.#".=$/#$2$!/ )1 .#$,* +=# . ,* .!*/#*!" #% /!"#/! .!( !*=# .#% =(% .$+ '#/!*/!*/ !/C

.!*!

!*+ .! ",(::!" *+ !.)/ /#*!" !/*!$2%/!% $; /!:#'!* .!2$$!$$#%#%":,/#%- .!:%/ .!2! # #%!*$(!$,*#%- <7%:

(*: *!$2%/!% $@ 8 $ 2*!!(2 *9.!2! # #%!*$=.!%"(! 7%=), .!$#/*/!*+ #:!/ 22:#" #%$!!7#%-(/# #" #% .!$#/*/!*), # =$/#$(#$$!/% <

.!2! # #%!*$ .!% #:!/22!:-#%$ .!*/!*/ !/ <

#% =.#". .! ((#$$#%!* 2$$!/ .! */!* % <

)$!*'#%- . = 22!:$ .'! )!!% 2*!$!% !/ %/ = .!* 22!:$ *!: #%- $(! */!* .! ::!" * 8,*2:,$ *!9",(,) #'#$#%:

#"!* 8#'#:9+ # *! :$ 2!%/#%-+ .!*!

*!+ .$! 22!:$ =!*! ":,))!/ %/ :$ )$!*'!/ . % .!* #$$,! =$ 2*!$$!/ .! 2! # #%!*$ #:!/

@ @C<

"% !%/#%- . .!1 ./ #:!/ % 22:#" #% * $ 1 :%-=# . .!22!:), .!((#$$#%!*+#$* #'#$#%/#/% 7!%1 /!"#$#%* .!*)$!*'!/ . % .!*#$$,!.$)!!%2*!$$!/,2%=.!*!$ 22:#" #% =$ 2*!$$!/ .! $#/ =*# 2! # #% =$ /#$2$!/ % <

-#'#%-:#)!* 1 .!2! # #%!*$ #:!*!'#!=22:#" #%)!

*! .! ((#$$#%!* 2*!$$ .! 22:#" #% * $ 1 .! 2! # #%!*$+ .!*!

!*+ #:!/*!'#!=22:#" #%%/2*!$$!/ .!22:#" #% *-*% $ 1=.#"..$)!!%/#$(#$$!/'#/!#(2,-%!/*/!*/ !/;<

5!*%!/",%$!: * .!2! # #%!*$.$$,)(# !/ . 3(% ($% 3,::(=$%! .!2* #!$ .!%/2*!!(2 *! )!"(! .!=%!* .!$#/2*2!* 1%/!?!", !/#::%/)!I,! .!/ .#$!$ ! .#$$%..)#:=.#".=$*!"*/!/#%.#$%(!'#/!(, #% < / !/C <;

..)#: *%$ !**!/2* .#$:%/'#/!/!"*!! / !/ <;

#% ',* *##%-.$>!!*,! "=.#".=$(, !/%

C< <;

'#/! (, #%

B #(#:*:1 2* .! :%/ 3(% (=$ *%$ !**!/ .*,-.% ,*:$,""!$$#%#% ',* .#$$%$%/ =#/=+ %(!:1+ *!( 6,(*+ 2# (+ )#* #%-.+ $)#* #%-. %/ 0#/.1 !'#+ *!$2!" #'!:1 '#/! (, #% @ C / !/ @B <; .!*!

!*57.#(- !?".%-!/ .!:%/=# .:!-:*!2*!$!% #'!$ 3(%(%/(, #% !?".%-!=$$%" #%!/%@

<;<'#/! (, #% @@B 57.# ( $:/ . :%/ ,". #%-.+ ,*)".% #%-.! "'#/!$:!/!!/<B/ !/ <;<%/(, #%@@ / !/ ; <;< =$ $%" #%!/ ,*)".% #%-. ! " $:/ .! :%/ ' * #%-.! "'#/!$:!/!!/ <B/ !/

%/(, #%BBB=$ $%" #%!/%

' *#%-.! "$:/ .!:%/ %A!!'#%-.! " %/ (, #% =$ $%" #%!/ %A!!' #%-. ! " $:/ .! :%/ 6(:A!! 6,* =# ! ,*2*!! #%-. %/ (, #% C =$

C $%" #%!/#%.!* ',*% B

%/6(:A!! 6,* .!*!

!*$:/ .! :%/ ,*#%#%-.%/3.#%/!*6,* .*,-. =/#

!*!% $:!/!!/$ << %/

/ !/

@ %/ (, #%$ ;B J ; =!*! $%" #%!/ #% .!#* ',* #$ ::!-!/ . .,-. .! 2! # #%!*$ .'! 2,*".$!/ .!:%/(!$,*#%-@;7%:<(*:)1 =/#

!*!% $:!/!!/$ <<J

), =!*!/!:#'!*!/ .!2$$!$$#% $2!"# #"7.$*%,()!*$ %/ 2*!$!% .!1*!#%2$$!$$#% #$ ,* .!**-,!/ . .!2! # #%!*$ *! .,$:#):! )!!?!(2 !/ *(:: (!% :%/#% .!#*2$$!$$#% *!$2%/!% $; %/#%'#!= .!*! +: !*% !:%/#%2$$!$$#% *!$2%/!% (1 )! :: !/ #$ :$$,)(# !/ . =.!% .! */!*/ !/

=$2$$!/%22* ,%# 1 .!*#%-=$-#'!% .'!.!*/:!*%!/",%$!: * .!2! # #%!*$%/ !*2!*,$: .! *!"*/+ ( .! "%$#/!*!/ 2#%#% . .!*! #$ % (!*# #% .#$ 2! # #%5!*%!/((#$$#%!*.$2$$!//! #:!/*/!*=.#".*!A!" #%- .! 22:#" #% $ 1 %/ .$ )$!*'!/ #% 2* .! !

!" . G!'!%=.!%$,)$!I,!% 2,*".$!*$+=..'!2,*".$!/ .!2* .!$,# :%/!'!%)!

*! +2$$!/ */#% !*#(#%A,%" #%+ .!,),/-! $ :$$ :*!/1 "%":,/!/ . .!*! #$ % 2*#( "#! "$! * /#% !*#( #%A,%" #%%/$#//!"#$#%=$:$,2.!:/)1 ,* % %/$#//!"#$#%.$)!"(! #%:#K!/+$% ,* .!*22!:**!'#$#%=$

#:!/)1 .$!$,)$!I,!% 2,*".$!*$#% .!"$! 2! # #%!*$+=.*! *%$ !*!! 2!%/!% ! :# ! !*

+ !'!% .!#* 2*#( "#! "$! *!-*/#%- *#-. -! #%- % #"! * 22* ,%# 1 .!*#%- #$ % !$ ):#$.!/H .! 2! # #%!*$ *! /!

#%# !:1 .! $,)$!I,!% '!%/!!$ %/ =,:/ $ !2 #% .! $.!$ .!#*'!%/*$+=..'! #:!/ $!!7#%A,%" #%!# .!* *( .! #'#: ,* * .! 22!:: ! ,* + .!*! *!+ .! /!"#$#%$ .'! )!"(!

#%:

B .,$+#%'#!= .!)'!+ .!*!#$.*/:1%1*!$%=# . .#$ ,* #% !* !*!#% .#$2! # #%%/$$,". .!$(!#$.!*!)1/#$(#$$!/ 86639 86639 86639 86639 '!()!* '!()!* '!()!* '!()!*

.! .!*$2!7#%->*!$%!/

!$> .! .!**!2* ):!

!$>