High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/900/2021dismissed

Partap Singh (Deceased) Through Lrs And Others v. Suresh Kumar

2026-02-13Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal17 pages

!"#$%&&'

"#"(#) !"#$%&&'

$ *+ & ,- .+

! " # $

& ' $ ( (

& )* ! '

! "

/// ,- .+0& + , - %.

/0 1/1% 3"

45 3 & 4

" - 1.

/1 1/%6 3"

3!5 4!

3 & 4 ! '

" 7 "" " 2) ') " " " 8 " "

- '

9 &" ! ) 2"

"" " 2)') """ " :/ /0 1//; # 2)

"!" "" " 2 $ %6% $' & 3 & 4 4 * '

" " 123 !4 5(2 ! 3"5* # "! 3 8 " " - " 2) ')"7 7 "7'

<'! %

" " $' & 3 & 4 ! /0 /0 1//;

4'"' 1;

/0 1//;2) =) & *

+ ' 6 1> ///7( " 1 .1 >//7('2 ' 2 ) % "" '

:/ /0 1//;'#

*)')" %

""" " %? >/ ///7(

" 1 1> ///7(' ) % '

' """ &3 3 & 4 ! $ :;71?6 1;

/0 1//;

<'!

:/ /0 1//;'# "' &

9 " . 1> ///7('! 2)

+ ' 2) 5

! $) 2 3 & 4

< ' " ) " 1 1> ///7( . 1> ///7( 2 " . // ///7(' 2 2)

"" " " "

' 22 " "!" ""

<'!

" 6 >/ ///7( "'

' ! '

"1//;(1/%1 <'! " ' " ""

> <'" ! ') "

' /:

/6 1/%1 "'

%' 8 " "!" ""

='! %" # :/ /6 1/%1' ""

% #

' %0 /;

1/%1' %

# ' ) 4" '& """2 3 & 4 /% %/ 1/%1 "# "

<'! /% %/ 1/%1;

// ""

"""2 3 & 4 '

' # " " 2

3 8 ) "" "" ! " @#! 72 3 & 4 " " & < ' ! "" ! ')2 )

' " " 2 " " "

+ ' 3 ) 2- "" ! 3'

(- " ) 2 2 ?%

" "" %;.: " A23 '%)2, " (" ! 2 ""# 2 2 2) %:" < 3 '

B ' % " $' & 3 & 4 ! /0 /0 1//;

<' 2 " 1 1;

/0 1//;" " 6 1> ///7(

< ' ! ' /:

%1 1/%/ " %/ >/ ///7( "'

1 1 .1 >//7( ) 2 1>C "

! # " ) " )" 1 .1 >//7( " "

. 1> ///7( ) " '

<'! ""'& ' ''& ! ) ' " ) %'"" " & ' "" ) " &3 " !) " " <'! ""

%# '"

)" " =' " '

' D " " " <'! ' ' '

'" )'#

<'! ' " % " "" ' 2 " )' !' # )"

> "", ' " " '2 ' 2' "" ' 8 "

2 ) ' " )" >

9 " "' ' " 3 (

! "##

! "## % & '

(

) ! "## *

, *$-

. ! "##

+, *

'! "##

! "## /

! "#0

- )

! "#0

1 %23

1 + 4! "#0 + 5 .

+ 3 " "" " - ' "3 " "

< ! "

;

<'2 2) " $ '

2 <'2 ' )# :/ /0 1//; '

" ' /:

%1 1/%/ <'2 2 /:

%1 1/%/ 1;

/0 1//0 ) & ' " 7 !#

;

<'2 2) "" " 1 .1 >//7( 2 ) "' 2)) "

. 1> ///7( " . // ///7( '" ) ! "'

!' !

& " ) <'" 2 ' 2!2 ' &) 2 ) <'2 ! ' 2) "" ' "'

" '

$ ! 2 & ' ''

'" " 2 ) ' 2) ""

;

< ' 2 %: " %;.: ' ) !& 3 ' " ""

" - " 3 - " "3 2 2 3 )' )

;

<'2 ) - '

2) "" %# !) !) " 2 # $ % 2' " "" " !2

;

<'2 &3 '

' ) ) ' # "" &3 <' " 2 '2 " (- " ) ) <'" 2

$ ;'" 2)" " ' <' ' "!" "

"!" " " ' @# 4E:7 @# 4E:7*

;

> <'2 2 3 " ' " ! <' ' /:

%1 1/%/ '

" ' :/ /6 1/%1 %0 /;

1/%1 ' 1/%:

<'2 2)" ' "" 2 ) ' " "

;

<'" 2 $ %>" @# % "" ' 2" #)""!) <' '

2) % " " '

2 #

;

<'" ) ' ! " ! " 1/" < 3 %601 " A 3 ,

;

" " 6 1> ///7( 2 ' ) %/ >/ ///7( <'2 " ' "" ' ! '" 2 " "!'"

;

<' ' '

7 3 2

' " " <'2 2)'

' "' " " ) ' ' "

;

%/ <'2 2 3 ) "" 2 2) '

!2 ! )2) 2 &2) &3 <'

2 ! ' ' !2

2 ' ) " 2)2

3 <'2 2- " ! 2 " 2 & ' < '" 2 2- 2 & ' ' ' "' " %/ <'2 '"& 1;

/0 1//;

'# :/ /0 1//;

<' ! # "

' 2 $)2'

! #'# '

& 2) ') 2 2 2)" ""& ' %

D " "" )2 " % 2 &

" ' 2 ! ' ! !

%/ <'2 " 2) # "

%/ :

<'2 2 "" ! &3' 2) "" 2" 3 "

! <'" 2 " ! ! 2)

% ! ' 2 !

%/ ?

<'! 8 " ' "" ' )2 %' #

' :/ /6 1/%1 %0 /;

1/%1 <'2 ' /:

/6 1/%1 " ' :/ /6 1/%1 ' 1/%:" & """ "

2 ' )! ""

)2 ) ' " "

%/ >

2 2 3 ! " "" "!" "" ! ?%" -23%;%6 " 2 ) " )

%/ .

! " %:" %;.: ' 2 " " '!2 )

%/ <' 1/" 3 ' 22 " '& 2 )"

%/ %>" '2 ' " " 2- " 2 )2) &3 <' " 2 ) '& ' " ' 2 " " "

%/ ;

< " '

2) = ,2 3 :

34 ;<4 #2 54

&=2&"!;>;4 ) ;

3&+ &#!"23

4 4< %7? &&-4 3#;=(23@4#) ) ;

3&+ & & &&-4 3#;=(23@0% 887? ;

4=#!( 24

+2!& #& &A;>;<2

<0 9%0 3 ;#!

5;A<;# & :

;<4B

2"< (= %86%0!

)4!

!"#%&9&7 = ,2

3 4C!(<;B

=-3;# & C!(<;##;#-3;!408 #!3; ;!

89 %%

< ! 2 2) " !

" )D " 3 " ) ) '

)" "

+ :/ /0 1//;' @# :

+! # " "" "

" E% # ' E> '

) 2 ! 2 # ! ' ' &

2 ! 2 ' ""

+ ""# 5

$)2 E:

= 2 !

2 ! "

'# E? '

2 ' %/7( ! 2 2) %

" 8'

)' $ 6?%% :/ /0 1//; + ' 2)

' + = ' 9 @#

&'# E; '

2 " %2 %:

+ # " % ""

"7 ' &3 '& '

'& #"& '"

) '2 2 & $ %'& ! "" ' "

B 2 &' !2

% # " ' ')

* ) "" ! ! # " 3 " " ' ! ' $! '

' ! " 2 ) "" <' " 2 ! 2) ! ! "" 2)! " '

) " ' " # " :/ /0 1//;

$' ' " ' + '# :/ /0 1//;

+ ' /:

/6 1/%1 " )" ""

+ " ' :/ /6 1/%1 ' /0 /;

1/%1 + "" 2" 2 /% %/ 1/%1 ' 2 "" ! '# '

' )

+ ' %.

/6 1/%: ' ) ) * 3 "

)" "" ! ')2 ) ' " " " ' '

' ' '

! " & " !

+ ) ' " ' 2 ' ""@# 1@# 6

6 %>

+ !)22- ' !'

" ""2 " 3 " ' 2" 3 ' )2 " ' 1;

/0 1//; '

) "

%1 1/%/ ' 6 1> ///7( ' 2' %/ >/ ///7( ! " + 2) !

E6 ! &3 3 & 4

2 " $ %

/0 1//;" " 6 1> ///7( @# E67* " "

'! %/ >/ ///7( @# %'

+ !) & 2) # ") "

<' ' ' " ) ' 28 ) /:

%1 1/%/ ) ! " 2 ) !

+ 2- " 3 2& 2) + 3

) %:

" %;.: ! ' # < "6 4 7 . 8

2 3 4! * "

3 ! " ' " """ 2) <'

" # ") "' """ 2) " ! ) ' )2" ! "! %0

+ ) - 2

2) "" %# !) !) 2 # "" " ! 2 ! " <"

!) # 2) ' 2& 2 "" "" ' " ""& ) - % # !) "" & " " " # '

+ 2- &3 '

' ) ) ! " +

&3 !)" ' "" "

&3 ' &3 2 # + " 3 ' 2"

( ' 2& 9 " """ " :/ /0 1//;

&3' )) %;

G ' $ %>"

@# % "" ' 2" #)""!) "

!2 # 2" #)"

+ ! " 2 <" 2 !& '2" &3 ) !

+ '! !'" ! " 1/" 3 ! "

2 '

" '2 &2 ' & )2) !& )! 2 ""

<" " 7 " 2)!"'

) !2 " ""!)

)2 '

* 3 )

)" ' " " + ' "

$ !D ' ! ' " @!)'

' '

* 3 "

) ' "

+ @# 1@# 6 ! 2 )2) 2 &2) &3 # ='! )' '

" )" ""

+ & )"" # ) ) ' +

) ! ) )

2 2 3 ! " "" ' & !' '

' " #

) . 20 3 9 :+ ; " < =

; " '

'78 "' - "8 2 3 :+ < + # .

; " %8? 1

" < 1 )

);< 6$ 1 > 1 ?

20 3 9 : 4

06 4 4< %7 2 " " "" + ' " 2 )'

2 " ! 33 ) ' " '

8 "'2

< !' " " 22"" )

" ) "

,- .+

C(;@%0'

- F %:

/1 1/1.

& 7

G 2