M/S Ericsson India Pvt. Ltd. And ANR. v. State Of Punjab And Others




   
   






!"!#



$ %&$$ ! '( ( ()*%  ++*,,($ -."/"

"((* 012 ()*%$ .*$+*($    ! " #
"#"#$
  ! #" #
%#

" %*$*( %3..4 "% '&(*4 % "), 6)07*% % 6+, 6)*%4 '&(*$4 % ++*,,($ &&& "#"#$
'( )   ++,&( % &( 8 9$ *,9 ++*, % %*$$ :*(* ++,&(4 *,9 8 9$ ++*, &*
 $($ ,,5* *  ++,&( % +,&7 %*&% 21*&($

%2(%( 
&,( &(4 ,7 *;0%* <

21*&($

%2(%( 
&,( &(4 ,7 *;0%* < (=* %*&%
 $($ $+$*   ++,( -)
),,*7* +%*$*( *((*%$ (*( ++*, %*% 

+$$*
?  8

((,* $ %&$$ ! %'(* ( ()*% ' "((* 012 ()*%$4 5)*%*



+$$*

$(%&( &% ":,, (*%+%$*$

&,((
0&,4 " "

7%4 5)*%*29
,:

*(( 

$((0(* %*$+*(  7$( ++*,,( )*%* ) 2** *&*4 5$ $021*&( :((*% &),,*7*

 *%* $:$$* +%:%,9 +,&7 %*,&* 0+ 107:*( +*;

."  /%0 ./ 
1.20 3.430.1..22356  8/9 0 3./ 52/30.(+)#** ),7 +%*$&%2* $&)*:*4 ?%( &( '=* !( 5$ (&* 21*&($

%2(%(
&,( &(4 )*%*(*% %**%%* $ @()* A

) ,%*9 2** +%**%%* 2*%* &:+*(*( ,5 ()*%*%*4 %*&%7 7 (5 %*:**$ &( %*$%(* ( $:* (:* ?%( 50, *;*%&$* ($ 10%$&(  !( 5$ (&* +*%$ )$ +(* +0%$0* )$ %*:**$ $+*&& $((0(*4 &( +*%:((* $5(&) ( )$ &'**&* 2 $) '0%2,* %0:

()*%*%*4 ()$ 50, ,9 &)(& **&( 10&, $&+,* 20( ,=*,9 7'* +%*:0:

:$&)*'0$ ,(7(

 ?* +*%0$* 21*&($ 5)&) )$ 2**

( B7)

*,) *%0$, +%7%+)  $ 21*&($





50, 7 $)5 ( $+*&&,,9 :*(* ++*,,($ &(*:+,(7 7$( $ 5)&) )$ 2** +$$* 5()0( ,,57 +%&*$$ ,5

?%( *(( )*%* 2*%* ()07)  

5$ ,9 $&*

(*% ) 2** +%**%%*

*,) B7)
0%(

'&* &+9 5$ 7'* "((* 012 



$ +*%

%9 < 







)*%* :*( ?%( *(( ( +( (:* +*((*% ) 9 2*%* 9 ()*% 7$( C0*$( 5)&) $021*&( :((*% &),,*7* ! $0++%( ()*%*4 '(

% -$), D%74 0()%E* %*+%*$*(('*4 5) ++** )$ '(



)0$4 $ &(0, $+*&( ,9 &%:$ 7$ ++*,,($ =**+7 ()*% +($ +* $**= '0%2,* &$*%( ,, +$$2,* %0:$ =57 ()*%* )'7 +%**%%* ( ( +%% +( (:* 

'*%9 &(*7%&, %2(%, 5%$ 5)&) *, $+0(* &(*:+,(* % ,,7 5() (*%:$ $02:$$ %2(%(4 % ( &($ *&$$ :((*%$ 2*9 $&+* $02:$$ %2(%( & (*%*%* +%( %:

()*% 7%0$ &* ++*,,($ +%**%%* 21*&( *((

',* 2*%*

*,) B7)
0%(4 C0*$( *$ %$*

,5 %*7%7 $+*&(  ,(*%(* +%'* $((0(*4 ?%( &( '=* $($ $*((,*
  

           


5)*%*29 ,*7, +%&+,*$ 2** , 54 5)&) %* ()0$# 

   

    

 



     

     !

 "   # # $" "

  %     !  !              !

  #&

 "    #$  ! &

  "      # !! # $!

  

  ! "

&

 "  # ' 

    ! " &

 !

   !$

 &

!   ! ! "

"  

  # &   !  !

 

""

"

     $   (



 

$   $  !"

" !!#  "      #  !  

    

  !

   

  ! 

"

    "



# "

    # #(      

%     $"    (

)  !    "

  $$

  !

   



(

 !   !!#  ""  

 "    *


$"

    !!   !!#    

$   !

+ # $ " '$  $#  !

$   

! "  "

  $    

     , < !
', ++*, < 

 %$7 0( "



((,* . 

  9:859.   23   52/30  4"   805   #799 230;0 .3.  22  51 9'  3 8/99<=>  52/30.' *&*



' $:,% $$0* 5$ ','* 5)*%*29 &,((
0&, 5$ &),,*7* "*&($



<
$((0( !

'$ 3*&) ) $*( $* 107:*( )*, ++*,,( 07)( (=* %*&0%$*



:((*% 5$ (=* +*;

5$ $:$$* 7%0 ()*%* 5$

4 &0, '=* .*$0,((,94 5*   9 +,0$2,* 7%0 (*%*%* 5*,, %*$* %*% 

4+$$* >07* %*$*( &&%7,9 $:$$*  *7 ++,&($4 94 $),, $( $+$* ,7 ()$ 107:*(  ("#"#$
)   "," (%#

") 772   ?)*()*% $+*=7%*$* F*$ ?)*()*% %*+%(2,* F*$