High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2736/2015dismissed

Maman Chand v. The Financial Commissioner Haryana And ORS

2017-11-09Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath3 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

!"# #$%&%'()#*+#, )#*+#, )#*+#, )#*+#, -

-. . . . /!*!'0!'1 #"%"%'#, 2& 0#%'!'$%!3**%&&%'#,!'1#$,#"!,4.#)#'5# #6!,"*#'"!'1"0#,& #&6'1#'"& /( /( /( /(7 8/ 99/ 7 8/ 99/ 7 8/ 99/ 7 8/ 99/ ,#&#'"( /,2%:!49!:3!.1)$!"#.

,"0#6#"%"%'#, /,&0;/5"0,#:!. .!,4!'! /,0!;"%%'<0.1)$!"#.

,,#&6'1#'"= '# ,,#&6'1#'" 9 9 9 99/ . 9/ . 9/ . 9/ . 0# 6#"%"%'#,& 0!)# $0!33#'<#1 "0# ,1#, 1!"#1

6!&&#1 +4 "0# 33#$",. %'1. ,1#, 1!"#1

> 6!&&#1 +4 "0# **%&&%'#,.%&!, %)%&%'.%&!,!'1,1#,1!"#1 6!&&#1+4 "0#%'!'$%!3**%&&%'#,.%'"0%&6#"%"%' 0# 6&" 8!*+!,1!, 2%33!<# /5!'!. %&",%$" %'1. #33 )!$!'"!

"#,"0#1#!"0 9!+53%'<0'

663%$!"%'&?#,#1534 %')%"#1!'153"%*!"#34"0#6#"%"%'#,!'1,#&6'1#'"&=@,#*!%'#1%' "0#$'"#&"0#33#$",. %'11%1'" %'1"0#6#"%"%'#,!'1,#&6'1#'"& =@&5%"!+3# ,"0#&!%16&"#+&#,)#1"0!"!&6#,#6," - 1!"#1 >

. 3!'1 "0# 6#"%"%'#, ?!& !""!$0#1 +4 "0# ,1#, "0#

5," 05&. 0# ,#*!'1#1 "0# *!""#, +!$; " "0# 5+ %)%&%'!3

%$#, A%)%3B.!

%1'?%"0!1%,#$"%'"$'15$" ,#&06,$3!*!"%'"%')%"#"0# !663%$!"%'& " %33 56 "0# )!$!'" 6&" 8!*+!,1!, 0# ,1#, "0# 33#$",?!&$0!33#'<#1+4"0#6#"%"%'#,!'195&06!3C,#&6'1#'"+4 ?!4 &#6!,!"# !66#!3& +5" "0# &!*# ?#,# 1#$%1#1 '

> +4 "0# **%&&%'#,.%&!, %)%&%'.%&!,+&#,)%'<"0!""0#6#"%"%'#,0!1"!;#' 3!' ,*"0#+!';!'10%&3!'1?!&!""!$0#115#"''6!4*#'" +!'; 3!'?0%$06,)#&"0!"0#?!&1# !53"#, "0#+!';<!%'&""0#,1#, "0# **%&&%'#,. "0# 6#"%"%'#, %3#1 ,#)%&%' +# ,# "0# %'!'$%!3 **%&&%'#, ?0#,# "0# 6#"%"%'#, 0!1 ,!%&#1 ! 63#! "0!" "0# 3!' "0# +!';0!&+##'6!%1' +5""0#%'!'$%!3**%&&%'#, 5'1"0!" !3,#!14"0#33#$",. %'1!'1"0#**%&&%'#,.%&!, %)%&%'.%&!,0!1 6!&&#1"0#%,,1#,&'

!'1

>.,#&6#$"%)#34.!'1"0#3!' 0!&'?+##'6!%115,%'<"0#6#'1#'$4 "0#,#)%&%'+# ,#0%*%',1#, ")#,$*#"0#1%

%$53"4 +#%'<1#$3!,#1!&+!';1# !53"#,0#,# ,#.%" ?!& 0#31 "0!" "0#,# ?!& ' #,,, %' "0# %*65<'#1 ,1#,& +#$!5&# "0# 8!*+!,1!,&0531+#!*!' %*6#$$!+3#$0!,!$"#, 8#!,'#1 $5'&#3 , "0# 6#"%"%'#, 0!& "05<0 )#0#*#'"34 !,<5#1 "0!" "0# +!'; 3!' ?!& 6!%1. ?0%$0 ?!& !$"5!334 %' "0# '!*# 9,%&0!'95*!,+5" ,*"0#$#,"% %$!"#%&&5#1+4"0#"!"# !'; !"%!3! 1!"#1 . %" %& !66!,#'" "0!" "0# 3!' ?!& %' "0# '!*# 9,%&0!' 95*!,!'1/!*!'0!'1&C4!,#8!3.?0%$00!&!3&+##''"%$#1+4"0# %'!'$%!3**%&&%'#,%'0%&%*65<'#1,1#,

'&#D5#'"34. 1 '" %'1 !'4 ,#!&' " %'"#, #,# %' "0%& 6#"%"%'. +#%'< 1#'51#1 !'4 *#,%". !'1 !& &5$0 "0# &!*# %& 0#,#+4 1%&*%&&#1 A99/ B A99/ B A99/ B A99/ B 2/ 2/ 2/ 2/ -

-. . . . 0#"0#,&6#!;%'<C,#!&'#1 #&C 0#"0#,,#6,"!+3# #&C