Virender Singh & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS


  

         

"#$%$&'(')*


 +',$)%$,-')./")%")#/$, $#'#')$, (!

+$,(0( -#"#$",1")"")%#/$,(  $(2)%$)# (!

 *  34  - 5 4-  ,$($)#*6 ,"7$$)508",".9"):%7&"#$:,#/$2$#'#')$, ,5$(/"7 02#":(('(#")#%7&"#$ $)$,"9:",1")": ,,$(2)%$)#(#")% ,- /"/"9:%7&"#$:,$(2)%$)#   /$#/$,#/$ $2,#$,(9&"9)$;(2"2$,8"1<$"99;$%# ($$#/$=0%.8$)#>
 <$,$$,,$%##/$ $2,#$,,)#  /$#/$,#/$=0%.8$)#(/09%<$,$2,#$%')#/$%'.$(#> 66 66 4- 

4!

5"89$(/$7' );%$&$"($%!;'$2$#'#')$,")% 8#/$,2$#'#')$,
;"(;,?')."("-#"0,($')#/$$"9#/ $2",#8$)#:",1")":"# "09#/":'(#,'&#")'2"#-/$$@2',$%') /",)$(()

A:9$"7').<$/')%#/,$$&/'9%,$):)"8$91:%'#1" ()!:

0&/'")%)(/0 %"0./#$,(!#&8$(0##/"#B0" 0&/' %"0./#$,!:;,'# 2$#'#')<$",'). 6 C6
:#'#9$%"(+',$)%$,-')./")%#/$,( +$,(0(  -#"#$    ",1")"  ")%  #/$,(:  ;"(  '9$%  <$,$  #/'(  0,#  , ,$'8<0,($8$)#/$,#0'#')$$ (: :

6")%#/$("8$;"("99;$% )


C<1"&,%')"#$<$)&/#/'( 0,#/$2,$($)#;,'#2$#'#') ;"('9$%<1()#/$2$#'#')$,:)"8$91:%'#1":;/;"("##/"##'8$ (#0%1').')C#/ &9"((')#/$1$",

D')+'%1"'?$#")- -$&)%",1 -&/9:(,")":")'2"#:,,$'8<0,($8$)##0'#')$$ (

:

6:"(


2$,#/$29'&1#/$ 7$,)8$)#%"#$%


D
 ))$@0,$66
!/$ 2$#'#')$,("9(($$?#/$B0"(/').,%$,%"#$%
A 
 ))$@0,$66 !:7'%$;/'&/(0&/,$'8<0,($8$)#;"(,$0($%

$(2)%$)#(      ")% 
 ')  #/$  ,$291 /"7$  "%8'##$%  #/"# ,$(2)%$)#'((0$%#/$'%$)#'#1&",%:;/'&/;"(7"9'%02#

:

')&829'")&$#/$%',$&#')('((0$%<1#/'( 0,#') 6 
C6

# ;"(0,#/$,(#"#$%#/"##/$')(#,0&#')(,$.",%').$@6.,"#'".,")#")%#/$, "&'9'#'$(##/$"8'9'$(%$&$"($%",1")" 7$,)8$)#$8291$$(:;/ %'$(;/'9$')($,7'&$:;$,$'((0$%")%,$'8<0,($8$)##0'#')$$(') (&/9")%&99$.$/"7$<$$),$7'($%;'#/)$;')(#,0&#')(%"#$%



))$@0,$6 6!

$(2)%$)#(#")%')#/$;,'##$)(#"#$8$)#/"7$ #"?$)  #/$  (#")%  #/"#  2$#'#')$,      /"%  "229'$%  ,  #/$  <$)$'#   ,$'8<0,($8$)##0'#')$$2$#'#')$,
")%'),$(2)($##/$("'% "229'&"#'):#/$<$)$'#/"(<$$)(#",#$%#,$9$"($##/$2$#'#')$,#'( 0,#/$,  (#"#$%  #/"#  2$#'#')$,      '(  "9,$"%1  .$##').  #/$  <$)$'#   ,$'8<0,($8$)##0'#')$$2$#'#')$,
,8#/$%$2",#8$)#0)%$, #/$')")&$$2",#8$)#:",1")":-&/$8$%"#$%AC

D $&"))# "7"'9#/$("8$<$)$'#0)%$,#;%'$,$)#(&/$8$( /"7$/$",%#/$9$",)$%&0)($9(,#/$2",#'$(")%/"7$"9( &",$0991.)$#/,0./#/$'9$ ,$29'&"#');"('9$%##/$;,'##$)(#"#$8$)#'9$%<1 ,$(2)%$)#(  ;: #/$ ')(#,0&#')( %"#$%


D
 ))$@0,$66
!

(/;(#/"##/$($')(#,0&#')(2$,#"')#$@6.,"#'".,")#")%#/$,"&'9'#'$(# #/$"8'9'$(#/$$&$"($%",1")" 7$,)8$)#$8291$$(:  ;/%'$ ;/'9$')($,7'&$/$($')(#,0&#')(",$,$.",%').,$'8<0,($8$)##0'#')

66 $$(&/9")%&99$.$  /$ 7$,)8$)#0)%$,#?#,$'8<0,($#/$ #0'#')$$290(9"<,"#,1$$")%9"'%%;)#/$99;').2,&$%0,$*6 '!

$&.)'($%  2,'7"#$  (&/9(&99$.$(  ')  ",1")"  -#"#$ ;'99)#&/",.$")1$$,8#/$&/'9%,$)%$&$"($% ",1")" 7$,)8$)#$8291$$()#/$<"('('%$)#'#1 &",%(  '((0$%  #  #/$  <1  #/$  #/$  /'$  -$&,$#",1  # 7$,)8$)#:",1")" $9",$ $99!/$/$"%(#/$ ')(#'#0#')( ;'99 #/$) 8"?$"&9"'8') ,$(2$&##/$ "80)#    #/$  $$  # #/$  '(#,'&#  %0&"#')  '&$,( &)&$,)$%;/;'99",,").$,$'8<0,($8$)#"#/'(;) 9$7$9

''!

(,$.",%(:#/$&/'9%,$)(#0%1').'),$&.)'($%2,'7"#$ (&/9(:&99$.$(')0)="<")%') /")%'.",/ )') $,,'#,1:#/$1;'992"1#/$$$')#/$',(#')(#")&$")% #/$)  2,$$,  &9"'8(  "#  #/$  $)%    $7$,1 B0",#$,:  %091 7$,''$%<1#/$$"%()(#'#0#')(&)&$,)$%:##/$ ',$&#,:  0<9'&  )(#,0&#')(:  ",1")":  , ,$'8<0,($8$)#F $#'#')$,
'((#0%1').')",$&.)'G$%2,'7"#$(&/9")% &9"'8(#/$<$)$'##/$($')(#,0&#')(:;/$,$')#/$,$'()8$)#')"<0# 8"@'808&"2,,$'8<0,($8$)##0'#')$$")%#/$)08<$,&/'9%,$) ,;/'&/,$'8<0,($8$)#'(#<$8"%$/$(#")%,$(2)%$)#('(#/"#/$ ;"(.'7$)#/$<$)$'#0)%$,#/$

D-&/$8$/$2$,0("9-&/$8$%"#$% AC

D(/;(#/"#'#2$,#"')(#.,")#$%0&"#')"99;")&$##/$ $8291$$(#/$ 7$,)8$)#",1")"/$("'%(&/$8$%$()##"9? "<0##/$$@6.,"#'",$'8<0,($8$)##0'#')$$##/$"8'9'$(%$&$"($% ",1")" 7$,)8$)#$8291$$(:8$")').#/$,$<1#/"#'#"229'$(#"99#/$ ",1")" 7$,)8$)#$8291$$(#&8$(0##/"#2$#'#')$,:"#/$, 2$#'#')$,
'("9(" 7$,)8$)#($,7').$8291$$#/"#'(;/1/$'( &9"'8').<$)$'#

D-&/$8$/'((&/$8$&"8$')#,&$,8



D/$2$,0("9#/$("'%(&/$8$(/;(#/"##/$$@2$)%'#0,$) $%0&"#')#/$(&/9.').&/'9%,$),8#/$&9"(()0,($,102#H
9$7$9 '(#<$,$'8<0,($%")%#/"#'#;"(2$,8'(('<9$02##;9'7').&/'9%,$) ;:#/$'%$)#'#1&",%2$#'#')$,
 ))$@0,$66 !(/;(#/"#'#;"( '((0$%')#/$1$",
")%;"(7"9'%02#

 /$"229'&"#') '9$%<12$#'#')$,(/;(#/"#/$"229'$%,#/$,$'8<0,($8$)##/$ #0'#')$$/'(()%'#1"<$,$#/$,')&'2"9+'%1"'?$#")- -$&)%",1-&/9:(,")":")'2"#:;/'&/'(",$&.)'G$%2,'7"#$(&/9:) AD
 ))$@0,$66!    -')&$  #/$  (#")%    ,$(2)%$)#(  '(  )# &)#,7$,#$%  #/"#  2$#'#')$,      '(  .$##').  ,$'8<0,($8$)#  0)%$,  #/$ -&/$8$

D:#/$,$,$:"##/$("8$#'8$:/$&"))#.$##/$<$)$'# #;%'$,$)#(&/$8$(:)$,#/$%$&$"($% 7$,)8$)#$8291$$(")%#/$ #/$,,#/$($,7'). 7$,)8$)#$8291$$(#<$').(:#/$2,$($)#;,'# 2$#'#')'(0)%#<$;'#/0#")18$,'#")%'(%'(8'(($%

4- !

  


 (=?( /$#/$,(2$"?').,$"()$% * $( /$#/$, $2,#"<9$ * $(