High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRERA-APPL/65/2020allowed

Unisys Infosolutions Pvt. Ltd. v. M/S Ultratech Township Developers Pvt. Ltd.

2023-07-17Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu32 pages

-1-

2023:PHHC:118760 ! !"!

$ #%& '

!'"!

) '*+

%, -.

0& 1 %#2 !& 2"!

2'!#

# $! %$ %

& ! % % '

$( $

% %

) $( %'%& !& 2"!

2'!#.

3 + "*45

* $

" - "(

%/012 %3

/0124 (

/+05/015 *

& " - "(

% 3

/505/0/0

&" -

* %7 ( %3

* 4

-2- 1

89&) :

; /0/% (% ; <% ; = " % ) % 7

: % > :? /005/011@1%

"++%28%A/, @ :%

!" # !

$%!

!" # !

$%! &'()

'()

&'()

*&'()

'()

'() + '() & $ ((& ,( - /1 *

(

B #@ !

/005/011 "+%00%000 @ 1<0//01/ "2%+A%8/8 @ 8108/01< "2%<5%2,0 @ 8108/01< "2%10%<<< @

-30105/01< "8%+,%525 @ 8005/01< "8%+,%525 @ /10</01+ "8%00%000 @ 180A/01+ "/%00%000 @ /010/01+ "8%00%000 @ /80//012 "8%00%000 @ 0A05/01A "5%+0%2+8 @

+1..

81 C/10</01A@/%

"/+%22%A<5 @ ",%A1%A/8 @ *( "12%5+%0/2 @

/<0</01A @8% B (

((

1 C0A02/01A@<%

(

( * 8002/01A *

* 0A0,/01A @+% "/+%2<%<+2 @

( ",%A1%A/8 @% "12%5/%A88 @ "12%5+%0/2 @

/10</01A 1

0A05/01A%

%7 B ; 002+/5 0A05/01A@2 "5%+0%2+8 @

% (

-4- "8%AA%250 @ B +F

"++%28%A/, @%

-1 C1,02/01,@A%

B % *D

G "/2%08%00+ @ H"A%2/%<<, @ I "1,%<0%++A @ J

0<0,/01,@,% (

(

0,0,/01,@5%

* * G"/1%+00 @

1<0,/01, @10%

0A05/01A% *

"5%+0%2+8 @%K

(+F

0A05/01, @11% ( (

"5%+0%2+8 @ * D

7 B L

% 0A05/01A 91

1105/01, @1/% 1010/01, @18% 0101/015 @1<% "/2%,A%+18 @% "/2%,<%/20 @ "/A%+5%A10 @%

B % *

-5- 1 : ( (( (

% 1A01/015 @1+ *

(

( #@ ./0 ,1 2)(*& ()3( 4&3 *& 33( ) 3 ) &3 * 5 6 % 78 & 3& ( 6 (

4 & 9 : 3&

* & ;)&*&6((&(<

/0 ,1 2)(*& ()3( &&3 (&3 3& 33( *3 &

3 ( & && &3 & * * (&3 ) 33( (

4 & & :3 & 3 (( ((&(<

/0 ,1 2)(*& ()3( =* 8 &*& 3 & ) ) 53 =* 33( &3&3& =*

/0 >& & )(3 33( "1 ?)(*&@* 3&3& &* 3& (& ) 1 ?)(*& /0 >& * & *&& &( && *& 33( 53 1 ?)( *& 4*( @* 3&3& &*

-63& ( 4*( ) 4&& =* - 1 %

% &("

(

* /<0A/01A%

' & ( (28+2 D

) H @/%@8%@<.@A-=$J ; <2 /011 * *

' % 7 (% & !7 1A0A/01, "@<E

>C( ( D

?" "

& " - "(

! "

%/01A %>

/01A?

/,0A/01A$

/012%

/012 & % 10% 6 (

(

/012 ( ; /<, /01A /205/01A% 810A/0// "@+

* 3 D 4

: :

7 2

: 6 *

10F % %

( 10% /+F

9 $ B *

(

9 9 (

% *

(

-7- 1 ( * *

* %

/+05/015 D

% *(

#@ .

;& & * )" *& &@ 3( 2 3( 3 &3 & &

=* 5 A""+B78 &(&3 &

( (( &

, &*( )* 3( ( & 3 3 )( * &3 * )* (&3 (

4 & (& 3 * * ( (& 3

, 3 4 4 & ) (& A 6 6 4 *(( & :

+ 6:

,&3 &

3 (*( 3( 2 *

()( & @*

( 3 3)( & A 6 6 4& '" *&&&3 & & 3 3( (

4( (( 3)( &)( * ;& 3&3&

* * " &3 4(((*( && )( &3( ( &3)(3( & ( 3& 9 A 3&

* , * & 3)( ( 3 4(( ) (*( & & 3 A 6 6 & & 3

,3( & 3 3*& ( &3

* 4 B & & ) ) &3 1 4(( ) ()& ( & 3( && ((

3&3&

-8- (( ( * & ( " 4 &

4 ( (( & )( 14&"*& (

&3( 4(( (( 3( & &

& ()( & ( &)( 3)( * # * 4 * *33( 3( * * @* )()*&" *&4(( &* &3 4((

& & 4(4- /1 (

* %

(( B

0/11/015@1, 81 C

* * %*

/505/0/0: %

#@ .

&&& & (( ( & )& % *& , 33(( *( &( 3( &3 73&&4& =*

& )(4 =* # (

4 4 4

( 4& 4 *& ) &3 73 ( * 4 &4) * (3 ( ,3&(( " )*& 4 *3 33(( )* &)( (& )*&

,% *& * ( 4 &3 * & * &33

-9- =* ()( 3 + 33& ) 4 & &4 :

, & *( ) (*3 * ( 3 5 A""+B78 ) ( 3& *&& *) & )(3& * 4"+B"

6:78"* 33(( 7(( 3 5 6"B"B:78 ,& &5 B"6:"B78 , )(3&4)3 &

, )(3& 5 B"

"+A78 , &

* 5 A""+B78 # & (( ( 3 ) &

( )(3&) & 3 +

, 3*3& & )4 3&"&3 73&& 4 ( & & ( 3 *& * 3& ) & ()(3

,&3 73&&4( (&3* & ( 63&

* * (3 )* ( *&&&3 73&& & & (3 (9A 3&

* & & & # *&& 3& % *& ()&3( ( & 3( ((

*& (( ( * & ( " 4 &

4 ( (( & )( ,&3 73&&* 6 6A/

*&8!((3 33& ) 3& * 4

" 5 "6A"A78 ) & # 33(( ( * ) 4&

( & "

-10- 33(( & 4(( ( & 3& ) ( *& 3*

&& ( &3( ((

(*( )& "4 & 3& 33( &) - 1 & %

&!$

1 $

B (

/205/01A "@+

% *(>C( ( D

( $

(

/012"

( "#$%

& '

( &)*

+ & ,-.!/ /-/* 1 :

7 2

:% (10F

* %

9 9 ( * K

"++%28%A/, @%

"+1%,2%08, @

0A05/01A% *

( *K

( $

/012 1/ $

((

:% /005/011E %

* *

1A0A/01,

% 0AB

-11- 18

6 % *

(

( *

% * *

( 1 $

(

* (

(

"/0%00%000 @ +/

(

1,F :* %/01<%

B ( +F

1,%15.8<

/012%

( (

* 1 :

(

( /+05/015%

K %

(

(%3

4 7 B ; 002+/5 0A05/01A% "5%+0%2+8 @$ $

/012%

7 7 E

% (

((

(

* K 1-

/10</01A @/ . 0A0,/01A@+%

-12- *

"12%5+%0/2 @ "12%5/%A88 @E

* -1

&!$

$ 2 '

-1

( C

7 /<0A/01A% (

/01A%

/,0A/01AE

% "

3C( (

(

/012 -1 :

: /005/011 -1/

* %

% %

D (C $

/012 -18 (

( "/2%08%00+ @ (

(

"5%+0%2+8 @E

( -1

(

B B 3

-13- * *

1 &

(

% D

B * >C( ( D

/012N

( /+05/015 /505/0/0% *

* %

(

* N

1 9 (

#@ ' * *

! 7 /80+/011

(% & ; <2 /011

( ' & ( (28+2

( 9 ) .

( % $

8/% )

//0+/01+ ' & ( 7 ; = 5 :

)

" % $

8/% D ( ; < =*

& ; % ) % &%

* *

-14-

* 6

/005/011 &

4 >

("+%00%000 @

@ : #

/0/%@<O "P' 89&) ,5 <

6 @/ "++%28%A/, @

"+1%,2%08, @ 5 <:

-1 -

/< 7

/005/011 , *+ + <

<<*

) 5

(

9 (

( *

* *

(

(G"+ @B

9 (

G"+ @ B

(

-15-

(

9 9 ( ++++

* *1<0//01< /<0A/01A"@8 <<*

) >

)

**<

*)*

" *!7 /A0A/01A @

) * *

/80+/015 18

)

(

/,0A/01A <<*

)

/012 >+

/205/01A >+

>:1 1 8 -

) 1 - "@+ ( " -

28+2 ' & ( 7

( ) .

( % $ @8/% ) % & *

! "-"

%/012&"-""

% /01A

1A0A/01,

**<

@/% 8% <% A )* ++:

-=$. " "@< ; '

; :

9 ( * '

) B*

)

; $

&,>5

@* 6

* *

% !7 ; <2 /011 /80+/011%

(@ ' & ( 7

-16-

(9 ) .

( %$

8/%)

//0+/01+

89&) :

; /0/% (% ; <% ; = " % ) %

( 7

: /005/011

"++%28%A/, @ 7 %

"+1%,2%08, @ *

9 9 ( *K

((

1 $

120+/0/8 *

7 %

( ( D

? *

!7 /<0A/01A

#@ 0 "1 )1! % &2! 13 '& 4 & ' &

% '13 '& 4 ' .2 4 ((' % + ( %%3(5 ;& C7D(&,4 3 (3&$E, %, F#G#G>G5C1%1,%'!8B6H5G% /G5% 5I%5'# G!I0 , &&> &( ,4 !* &$(

! &"1& '&" &) * >&*31*

!( & *&

+ B+ &" 6% ', % 7, $,7,89:;! % &$ "

-17- ::# 1!-.#//=-&&->*-=*-.! %

('& -/*-2*-.: ''(%&

3( &**&(

& *

) &&* &3 *(

J >&*31*

(3* &/% G + 66B 60

( *(

G J ,4&,6",B",K, /'0 !7,4 J C7 D(&,4 3 (3&$ % !&&3 & 4 & J F#G#G>G5C1%1,% '!8B6H5G%G 1 G +6'!8B H5G% L L L L 68 86 '

*& 33( - /1 "

0< % /,0A/01A%

( D

B *

/012 : %

#@ .D%,5,!1,G'1#$ E%$5'$E, %, 5 JD, 71557 7:

6 ;5CM5$8#? N'&*(B/0O $$%#!,#G;55>#',5,#G;$5F!, , 1& 5(5 *(&*&" $ *( '&" &)33( & & & & *&+ B+&( * &*3 *

( ) *3 E(( * H& K $ &" '&8B6" H& (8B6" /1& 0 , 3&@ *( ( ) 3& ,4 !* & $(

" 1& % %

*8= +-..&&7*-2*-..*

-18- ,&=*3&*(&&* &J8 /0 '* 33( N *(73 73&3&&3 &773& &3 &73 *& OJ8 /0 # !3 J8 '

G # ( /0 G D(&,4 3 (3&$ % !3 &3& * & !3 " A+

* & !3 "6+ /)0 & '&8B6" @

1( G& C(" H& (8B6"1& /0 !3 5 & !& !& # &3& P 3&

*&8 C& * K &( 8 3&

*&86 /0 C )@ 3&

*&86 /0 ! ( L

/ 0 !& ( L

/0/0 L L L L L L L L /0

& ( 3&@(* )$&& ( &"4&(&3(&)

(3" )" (*

*&& * 3&@" ( 3( " ( 3

" ( 3 ( 3 3

?3@= /0/0 L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L ( ((4

( * & & &

3&@" &=*& * & 3' 8, * & & 3& & &*( & *( &* &" ( /0 ! /0 ,( 53 K 3 *& ( $&@ B 6

! 3 +;

A /0 (($ ( L L L L L L L L L &B>*-:*-.: '%B ' 3+ +3''5, '% $ ( '

( *&* >*-:*-.:

-19-

?3= ' +( 6%'3 %&5

'+ 5 * + 6% % 5( + % % 6% 4 ' ( & 3 &

A *

( 5 6% * ( & & + 4D & %'

(' ! ''

+ %

(' + ;

A D(& G4 '&8B6" 5 + '386 3& $8 A + B+ $&@ ,4 3 &( @

(;( 6

*&G ,& & (& (3& 5

1(G& >&*3 ,4& 33& (3 $ % C(" 1*

6B 6 ) G#% H& (P 3( B6 ) 6

3'8

7 ! D%,5,!1,G'1#$ E%$5'$E,%, 3 + 6% $8 '

G ,4&G $& '* & ( 3&( (( & 3( 4&

$&3 !3( ,4&86 Q'&**&4& 3( 3&

*& G "B6 Q$(&

K (&

3( Q;

4& 3& & 6 ,4&8B Q'&**&4& 3( 3&

*& G "B6 Q$(&

K (&

3( Q;

4& 3& & 7 $8 E3%3$ A %

('& (

?3 *%& %,7.-.: E' 49+'

4 %

('& E0 4$ A ( 4 A L L L L /1 :

* K

% B

!7 (

M@@M 6( ( D

B *

? /<0A/01A%

-20-

3>&*31*

!( &*&

+ B+ &"$&@H& ("'&B6",4&,6",B", K , /'0 4 C G /R$8

67' / '08667AA+ :

+ 660) 3( A 6 ((&3

L- C

% *

( /,0A/01A *

(

/012%

3 "B 6 - 81

( %

/<0A/01A 6(

7 %

>C( (

/01A%

* >C( ( D

?E*

( #@

6( (

/012%

B >C( (

* * ! *81%/01A

* /<0A/01A

7 ? ( *

!7 1A0A/01,

>C( ( D

? *

/01A * (

/012% %

.3&@&

-21- & 4 3( & ) *"3&&(( 33( *& && & 3&@ 4 3& & & -

? $

8 15%<0%+5 A0A5 ,0

/012 010+/01A

*( >7 7 ?*

? 7 % (

/012 *

/,0A/01A

% (

B ( /205/01A

? *

& ?* $ 7 (

/012% 8A 7+ @*;

+< #@ .%

6+ ' B 3&*(& 4 ( * ) " (( .

3&@- 3&& &3 4 3( & ) * & & * & # ( ( 33()( ( 3&@44& & ) 3& ( )* ( )&

* & (

3&@ 3& & 3 && (&" (*

((7 )*&"3&& &( 4( 3

& * &3 )(

-22- & *(" & *3& * & *( &( &4 ( &( *& - 1

B >C( ( D

?E % (

/0127 B

% ;

( 1 9 (

7 2./<

* 7 3; = " 4 :

#@ .+ , !3 33( &) & & & 3*&3 33( *(& *& & (() ) * # 8 *( (( & & *(& *& & ( (*& ) 33(

&*& 3 *(& *& & 4 & /B0 & 3)!3 6 , !3 (( & D 33( &7&*3 * *)@ 33(

3( 4 (( & *(& *& & 7& (*& & 7&*3 * 3& ( 7& ((((4 &/B0 & 4&

) 3 " (()7&& 33( (()()(33

-23- (

& 9 5 78 3& = & 3& & & 3& * ( # 3 ( (( * 4 B & * *(& *& & *&< 3 ((333( 3 95 783&= &3& &3& *( ,@* (

& & 3 (( )

D &(& ,(

& (( ) & & " &( & & 3& 33( *(&

*& & - -1 :

( (

/012%*

/205/01A% *D

( #@ F C G C F

C, "H, =,F .78.-/ 0 "I

J K3'2.!L

G 0 M 4&* *8> +-.:&&=*-/*-.: , D(&,4 3 (3&$ % '&8B6"@

1(G&C(" H& (B6 CG 15586:A76 76 6+ A 6 '*)@J

4 + ' 6% =*72= % G 3( F 3 4 '

5 3& ) ''4 13&& 9

4, %7, ', F5 5 '% $ ( '

( * &* 3 & %, -.= & F 3', -.:

+B C 3((' % &&7.*-:*-.: &./*-/*-.: I*&&=* && & &+ B+&>&*3 1*

!( * E(( *H&K$ &"'8 B6" H& (" 1& 4 & & % + 6

-246B 6 * ) &&" ,4 !* & $(

3& "1& ") 8S83& 5(/5 *( (3 0"6+ 155 5*(" 6 &

( & & & &4 *4 ((4

& J8 /0 ,$&&((3(43& &*( & *( &* &T /0 L L L L L L L L L /0 ,& & (()( &3&

& 6+ A 6 B

666T /0/0 L L L L L L L L /0

%%(3

+% +( ,('

3 '& 4% 5, & %(5 ((' % +,+

( $ 3 + 4 $ 4 + '$ 3%( & 4 & 4 + ', 3 & 5 '$ + 4 + %N /0 L L L L L L L L L /0 , 3&& (( &*& * 4 & " ((44&4 &3&@* * 3&&? )* & 3&& ( 3 3& 73( & 4& & &( & *)8 /0 ' 8A ,3&&(( &*& & * 4 & 4(( 3 3)( ,& &3)()3&&(( &)((3&&")"(() '

# & ( (

& 3(* 4 3& ,3&&((&3& ,5( /5 *( (3 0"6+ 5*(6 *) '>& /0/0L L L L L L L L ?%3 % F C G C F

-25- 1 &%

* 6 $

/012%

#@ ..7* &( & % A 5 (

$ 3+ 4 4 + '*U/03&&(( 3*& 3& 3& "3(" & )*(

)" 3 & 33( " & 3& 4* & &

4& & & ( 4 * 3& & & & &("* & (4 &)

& /60 , & & ( & && *)8 /0 (( ) * & ) 3&&) (( 3 3&*(& (3 3&@ (*

&* )*(

3& "(

4 3 & ((3 4& & ( (3 4& "

&)43 4& 3& "3(&)*(

")"& ))(( 4 3 3& "3(&)*(

) &"& &3)() 3&&(( (( 3&& *(" * & 3&*(&")3&&) -

: *( $

181/)0%

33&&(( 3*& 3& 3& "3("&)*(

)" 3 & 33( " & 3& 4* &

-26- &

4& & &(4*3& & & & &("* & (4 &)

&- $

% $

18/ 6 *

( % D

* (

* *

91 ;&&"

"++%28%A/, @%

50F

B % "+1%,2%08, @ & %

9 9 ( E

(

18/)0 / 1 * % *

(

"/0%00%000 @

(

G 1,F :* % /01<

B ( +F

(

G 1,F %

B B

? ( *

-27-

? (

( /1 $

/012%

#@ .% .> 3 +

( /0# 3&& (3(&* )( 3 3& "3(&)*(

"U /0 & 4 & & &(&")"*( 3()3 & T& /)0 * * )* (3& * *3 & & & & * & & & && " (()()( ((" (( 4 4&4 & 3&@" 4* 3&@* &&()(" &*& * & ) &3 3& " 3(")*(

")"4 &* & ) 3&&) )( (*

&3&* &J $&4& (( 4&4 &3&@"(()3") 3&&" & & & (" ((

& 3 "*&) 3&&) /60LL L

/B0 # 3&& ( & & )( 3 * &&&*( && *( &* && & 4 & & &("

-28- (()()(3*3 (("

&3&* & - *

* (

* *

* *%

( / 1 (%$

/012% &("

* (

( %

% (

* *

: % $

15< #@ ../* 4 &&3 +''

U/0,(( (( ) ( ( & * * 3 (

4 & * & ) 3&&) 3

&3&* & " &3&&" 3&& (3( &* )( 3 3& "3(& )*(

" )" & 4 & & &(&* * )* (3& * *3 & & & & * & 3& &&*(&& *( &* & -

-29- //1

% * * & ?* $ 7 C7+1 @*;

+<D.

(

: % ,2

D ( K

#@ .;& 4( & & )

34& @* ( 4 & *(& *& @*

&"4 ((*((* (* 3& ( M& * ?" M &?" M3 (? M3 ?" @ &

' : A(&( 4 & * * " & & * * " & &

3 & & ( (& 3 " & 3 ( & & " & *(& *& 4 34& & * 3( "4 =*

&( @*

3 & & * & ' 6" " : A" @*

& (*( 34& & " 3

4 (( &

' & 4 ' 6 # @* * & ' 6" " : A & 3 " @*

& 3& " *& 4" 3 ) 3 34& * @*

& * & ' 4*() 6+ -

-30- /81

( %

((

D ( C % $

/012% E *

* %

% D

/1 *

% $

/012

#@ .78* 03 % + 3 5*U , * *&(( (*8 /0 & & & *(&(3&@ &( & &* &T /)0/0L L L L / 0 *&3( )( *3 3&&" (( &( * & &*( & *( &* &T / 0 *&3( & *( &&& && & 34&* & T /0 3& & * & * ) &* *& ) 33&3& >& ) & && * 3& - /1 ( K

* % & (

/012%

. (

* B

-31- * %

( ( (

( ( D

"( % "(

9 @9 $

B %(

* ( ( D

E (

/012

(

>C( (

?E K

B @K

9 ( *

- * 6

(

/012%

/-1

( E

(

/91 7 B

E *

( % /+05/015 /505/0/0% *

* %

% *

* 6

-3281

( %%

%, -.

!& 2"!

2'!# *(

%#'"

6( # P ; =

" * # P ;