High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5082/2011disposed of

Joginder v. Bhoop Singh And Another

2018-11-27Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh3 pages

!" #"$%&% '()

*"&"'!( * +"&,- !,. /0#1 $ !"

*!," 22"// '!

& &2*""!3 4*0#1 $ !"

**"&2 '#"'!

," $/ %5 '! %& %' 22" / &""+%'6 "', '$"5"'!

$ 52"'& !% ' ' $$ 4'! %'74*%"& &4&! %'"# %' 5 ! * 1",%$4/ * $$%#"'!!, !! +2/ $" ' ) ,"*%84' /, & . *#"#$ 52"'& !% ' &000 #"! %/"#,"*"4'#"*(

%& 8%/%!9 '#/ && %'$ 5"

& 0)0 "#%$ /%//& &0 %' '#&4

"*%'6 &0 4!4*"2* &2"$!& &0 %&$"// '" 4& &0 4'&"/ *!," 22"// '!. 4/# *64"!, ! &!,"%'74*"#, & &4

"*"# 2"*5 '"'! #%& 8%/%!9 ! !," ":!"'! ; ' $$ 4'!

524! !% ' *%6,! *58"/ ."/8 .0,"%&"'!%!/"! $ 52"'& !% '<4 #%& 8%/%!9 89 22/9%'6 54/!%2/%"* 5"!, # %' !," /%6,! 74#65"'!

'=8/"!,">42*"5" 4*!

52"'& !% ' // ."# 89 !," *%84' / 4'#"* 1 *% 4&," #&%&%' #"<4 !" '#'""#&"', '$"5"'! 4'&"/*"2*"&"'!%'6!,"%'&4* '$"$ 52 '9, &&422 *!"# &&"&&5"'!5 #"89!,"*%84' /.%!,!,"&485%&&% '&!, !!,"*"%&' "1%#"'$" '*"$ *#.%!,*"6 *#! 4'$!% ' /#%& 8%/%!9$ 4&"##4"!

524! !% ' *%6,! *58"/ ."/8 .' *!,"*"%&"1%#"'$".%!,*"6 *#! 1 $ !% ' !,"%'74*"#2*% *! !," $$4**"'$"

, 1"," *#$ 4'&"/ *!,"2 *!%"&02"*4&"#!,"2 2"*8 + '#*"$ *#& ,"*"%&' $/" *"1%#"'$" '*"$ *#.%!,*"6 *#! 1 $ !% '

!,"%'74*"#2*% *! !," $$4**"'$","# $! *": 5%'"#! 2* 1" #%& 8%/%!9, &' !#"2 &"# &! , .#%& 8%/%!9! !,"":!"'! ;%&! 8"

!*" !"# *$ 524!%'6 4'$!% ' /#%& 8%/%!9&&45%'6!, !!,"%'74*"#. & # %/9. 6"*?,%&%'$ 5"%& &&"&&"# !&@02"*5 '!, '!,"8 &%&

5%'%545. 6" '# $$ *#%'6/9#%& 8%/%!9! !,"":!"'! ;<4 / &&

" *'%'6 '#89 22/9%'654/!%2/%"* ) '!,"8 &%& ,%& 6"0/ &&

%'$ 5" <4 #%& 8%/%!9 %& &&"&&"# ! &@00@ @ : :

):A ' 5 4'! & 0)0 // ."#89!,"*%84' /4'#"* !,"," ##%& 8%/%!9 '#/ && %'$ 5"&, //8" #74&!"# 4! / &&

%'$ 5"

," *%84' / , & . *#"# &0 ' !," 8 &%&

5"#%$ /8%//& '#&0 *2 %' '#&4

"*%'6& '#!,"& 5"%&

%*5"# ."1"*0!,"$/ %5 '!&, //8""'!%!/"! &)0! . *#& / && 5"'%!%"& /% " '#5 !*%5 '% /2* &2"$!&&45 &B0

* 4!4*"2* &2"$!& '#5%&$"// '" 4& // ."#89!,"*%84' /&, //8"

B #74&!"# 4! &)0,"$/ %5 '!%& // ."# ##%!% ' /&45

& 0 *":2"'&"& !* '&2 *! !% ' '#&"*1%$"& ' !!"'# '!

'!,%&1%". !,"5 !!"*0 ##%!% ' / 5 4'! &B0B0@&, //8"

2 9 8/"! $/ %5 '!.%!,%'!"*"&!C);2"* ''45 * 5!,"# !"

2"!%!% '!%//*" /%D !% '// !,"*!"*5& '#$ '#%!% '& !," . *#&, // *"5 %'%'! $!

"+, %!! / 4#6"

)

5 , '8%58*