Gurmukh Singh And ORS. v. Chandigarh Administrative Tribunal,Chandigarh And ORS.




  
    

 !

%!&' ()%&* #+ ,-,.*/ 0*% 1*' 

 ','

*% 10%*1- '%2, %+*% 10%* &*% 1*' 

'3 '




  


   

' () -*% 4+1&%+!*3 5 



  6 %7 '%%00128*11%1"$ "

"#9 3%''128* %1- '%2, %+*% 10%* &*+:*28 * 0 %33&% '. 0%1& !*3- *3' !,  0 '*%'2 1'-''1 *0, 1!'54,1&%%%': %' -'%'*3%!1'&- % &,1 2',2'% %1 ;

< *!%&'-%82 &12!8

;=< '% 1*3%5'3 '%>::. %'&* &% ' %,'1'&3 '. , '* 0+-- 0+ %  0+ )% ,!%&, 0% 1/*% %%&* %&8+?%3,*%% =93''!

,  0 ' )&*% &%3%- :1&112!1,328 :%8  !  &-3  '&  3&''  !  :*&*  &  :%'  '',1  

="

"#

""

*3 '%':%'3%5'3 '&-31% '& ',:%'1&%1 ="

"@

""

*:-,3&*% 0'

*'& 3&''2!* %1- '%2, %:*&* 1'',% &!:''!1& ' 1!! &&%' '+ %-8+67 !*, 1+*2, %1&1*%*'& '*%2-%1 '&8 *2%''!- *&-3'A67 *'& 1, 1+ *2, %1& 1*3%8!5%,% ',0*28'-!*

 &% 11%' *0, 1*%',&*%1& &%

2'',1%! 8%'!'&

;@< 'C&%''*%*3%5'3 '%4, '

*- 1!! 1'&3 '% 10%1''!*!%&*%*8%: -%'+*%,*'*%3-1*3%5'3 '%'

,  0 '% 1%2*3 ;D<
'*& &113' *%',&*%&%-:%'!'- %'128*3 '28:%8!  "9">""9 >#@!"#$%& '%

()%*+,*++ &) )- (&

()%*+.:* %'*811  %8% 8&*% 0*'& !*4, '2,',0*%1& ! *:

3-

*'%1 :%'1'-''128*2, % * !: 0-'(5

# !%0, 0!'--+% 1&, '!* %33&% ''%'*%*%33&% '-%823-1 :*1%:*  +:*28%33%&*'3 '! 1''%!*0% &

;9<
-%82' *%*3 '11 '.% 83-''

!-*2, %!% * 0 %33&% *'%-&%,'!

%&

 !  :*1%: 0  *  %  +  *8  '1  *  %:%8'

%,*':*%0% &% 1*%!!1'& 1 %0% :*, &*% 0 0*'& !*4, '2,% 0*%*8% 1 23-1 :!*!%&*%*4, ''13-1 * 8% ""

;$< *2, %*%'1'-''1*'& 1 1*-3,0 1 1 *0, 1*%'& 13 :%'2%128*3 &3!'5 4,1&%%% 1*%*3 '&%

%01'&- % !*%'

*%3- 0% 13%5'3 '*%2 %%183&1

 28*2, % '3,'1'

;<   *%  *%1  % 1  &, '  !  *  3 '  %  % & '1%2 0*% 10 *,0**&1 ; <
', %2*%*3 '!1*!'  *8%

"#@ 8 :*&*'3&!&&%-!*:

3- :%'%'1 * 0, 1*%*4, '*%12 3-1 
'%1!  0% 1

-'+  *  3 '  :*1:  *%    :*  28    %33%&*  * %,*'  !  1''%  !  *  0% &  )  ' 0  *  %:%8'

%,*':*%0% &*%!+ ,& '11:+1'  %-, %&&,%!%!'*&%,'!%& '%'3-*-! % * 2!*2, % ;#"< 'C3%*%*&% 11%': -*% 2  3-1  0  0  *-  '  !%&,%8  12%%2    :  !  * %- '-%1 *: '%- %1:**-5'%%&*1 * 
'%'% %1-1!%&*%&% 11%''%12: - *% *3 '+:3-1 *8% ""% 1*3 ,0*    *%  &*% 01  *  3- '  :*  %  %' %2  % 3'&21--  -% 0!,%& *% 02 %. 28*- :* -+:1&  !:**1, 1&*% 0 '-''1   / 0 















"

)%&* #+ / 0
































"



    
   

 ) @#9 ! "#$

 

 ! 555 ,-,.*/ 0*% 1*'','*% 10%*1- '%2, %+ *% 10%*% 1*'

' ( ) -*% 4+1&%+ !*%33&% 53 GGG

  *  %' '  -  1    *  %33&% +  *  '%-  '

%:1',24&%4,'H&3 '% 1*1&,- 6 5D7'%.

&1 )'% 1'1'3'1!

  ! .


























"

 1%23 2435 ! .

      "