High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1125/2012allowed

Anita Devi And ORS v. Surat Ram And ORS

2015-04-01Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan14 pages

!" #$% !& % !

%'(()**+

,-'*'%(.*'/(0 11(22' 3(04 ,/,40'!-'/(0 !(1('

/((5*40)(-167' 11(22'

3(04 ,-'*'%(.*'/(0 !(1(' ,-'80*/%(.*,* 11(22'

3(04 /((5*40)(-167''/(0 !(1(' !+

9$7 !# , 8 7%",

"0(('+ 0/5*00 .)'( 0'/(11(22' *

00(1(' ' *

00(1(' ' * 0! 41' .)'( 0'/(11(22'

00(1('*

00(1(' * 0:/6#*2 .)'( 0

004&.

.)'( 0'/(11(22' * 00(1(';*

00(1(' *

</('/(0'/(!(10'(02)2(511(0-6=(225('(( '/(>4?-('@&(

=(0((00(''/(!(10'(00'&( </('/(0'/(>4?-('/42=(0(10'(*'/(*?('@&( 8 7%",

#!7 $6'/*>4?-('

5*22*1(

'*'2(

0**?4''/(-(50'(

1(=6'/('0))*('2*-0*=42 04? */0'9'/(0*=429

/=((*2(=6'/( )2*-' 0 (/)(-(' )-1('* 5/(0(

/=((*2(=6'/((5*40)(-16 7*-*'( /=((*2(=6'/(5(0 80*/%(.*,* )/22(?*?'/(50'/(0*=42 .*(5/*)/ '/(0().(060*?/'/.(=((?0'(''/(*40)()-16 '/(2''(/(0*?

2'110'4*'65?0'( ''/(10'*('0('/(0?4-('*'50(0('/' >40-('/22=(('(0'*('/(0?4-('/22=(/(0 %(1*'('/* 004&.

2(0()4(20'/(5(0* /'14'*11(0)(0'/(0'/(10A6

)4(2/*0-('/*40''/'/(*4'''*'=(*?

*/*=()( '/(-''(0*0(0('=()*(0(-(0*' ()*( /()''/()(0('/' '=4'

B+ " 7)(*:$/41*(0,*?/5?*?0-(0' '*2,()40*'6 40-1 , 2?5*'/#.*(0,*?/ ,>*.,*?//(65(0(52:*?'/((A'0(-(2('*('/( 02*''2(/(0-$*/'(-12( '/(-(5/*2( '022!#B )-(0-=(/*''1((/*'

$/41*(0 ,*?/ 0(42'

$/41*(0 ,*?/ (22 5 0()(*.( (0*4 *>40*( ( 5 ':( ' ((02 1*'2

40? 5/(0(/(4))4-=('/**>40*(! ;

4(0,()'* ;B "50(?*'(0('"2*)( ,''*(0 %*'0*)'8404:/('0 '*''('/'$/41*(0 ,*?/5 6(0?( (5(-126(7)(*:

,4110'<(1,C40*, -- (05 (0*?! 1(0-'/ $(0('/(0*=42 0(1('

'/(0*.(0 '/( 5(0 -(26 ,40' !- 80*/ %(.* ,* 0(1()'*.(26 *'11(0'/(65(0(10)(((?*'(A 10'( .*( 0(0 '( ; 7'(0 D '/(6 11(0(5(0(225(')'(''/()2*-1('*'* 5(.(0

'/(6*'*2(50*''(''(-(' 12(*? '/( 10'*( 225*? *4( 5(0( 0-(+ </('/(0'/())*('/':(12)(4('0/ (?2*?(' 0*.*? .(/*)2( !#B =6 0(1(' 0(42'*?*'('/$/41*(0,*?/ 22(?(@""

*4( *10.( '5/'-4')-1('* '/(1('*'*(00(('*'2('0-5/-@"" </('/(0'/()2*-1('*'**2*=2('=(*-*( '/( ?04 ':( =6 0(1(' * *' 50*''( ''(-('@"!

!(2*( '/(=*'/(2'1605)(0'**)'( A"

'/(*)-('/(()((5('(0-*('=(!

1(0 -'/ 0 5 (4)'( 1(02 (A1(( '/( (1(()6 '/( )2*-' 5 ':( ' =( ! D 1(0 -'/ 8((1*?*.*(5'/(?('/(()(()2*-'

-42'*12*(0 ; 5 112*( !

))4' 2 )0'*4- !

'010''*)/0?(!

4(02(A1((5(0(225('/*56 ''2)-1('* !

D5225(5*'/*'(0('EF1(04-

/(0*=4240'/(0=(0.('/'1(0'/(.(0**)'* 0(10' 0*.*? 2*)()( !#%7DDB *4( DB D '/(*2*)()(*4'=(:( ()( '/(0().(06 0*?/'5(0(?*.(''/(*40)()-16 /(/0('/( )2*-'5(0(20(0('=((1*'(**A((1*'*'/( *"'*)(0'*2*G($:01(0**.(6(00 '*22'/('('/(*0''**?->0*'6 5/*)/(.(0*2'(0 /.( /(0 2(0( )4(2 0 '/( )2*-'11(22' 2(0()4(20'/(*40)()-16

2(0()4(20'/(5(0'/((*?'022/.(2 )0(4226?('/04?/'/(*2( *0' 22 5*22 ':( 41 '/( )( '/( 11(22')2*-'*(

7(0( )4(2 0 '/( )2*-'11(22' / .(/(-('260?4('/'*'/*)('/4?/ '/(0*=42':'( '/()'('*'/(2(0()4(20'/()2*-''/'*'* ))4'4'40(101()'/42=(-( =4'5/*2(0()0*?

'/( **? -('* 5 -( 0(?0*? '/( -( /( ()((5--*'*2,()40*'6 40 (5 20*( 1(0 /(0(0( 1(0 '/( 4'/0*'6 '/( 9=2( ,410(-(40'*

B!!*.*2;;

F*'**'=(-(*/**)-(

/(0(0( '/(*)-(5*22)-('!;B 6!;

1(0-'/4''/(-( 0*(4)'(1(02(A1(( *(!

; /((1(()6'/()2*-')-('!

/(C4('*'5/('/(0'/(?('/(()(( /42=(':(*'))4'0'/(1401(('(0-**?'/( -42'*12*(00'/(?('/()2*-'10('/42=((( 5 )*(0(=6'/*40'* B '*'2(!

'*'2( !

()*( B '(0)*(0*?'/(251*'

*'5/(24(0+ 0'/*1401( 0(2*)(/=((12)( '/(4'/0*'6'/(1(A40'* " # ;!!*.*2 B/( C4('*'5/('/(0'/(-42'*12*(0'/(=* ?('/(()((0'/(?('/(10(' '/(()((/42=(112*(5)*(0(=6 5#4?($()/'/( 9=2(,410(-(40'

* $ )(410 /(-''(05 )*(0(* =670?(0$()/ )*'*?

/0((#4?( * % % B ,410(-(40'( /0((#4?($()/

; '/( 1(A 40' 110.( '/( 10*)*12( 2* 5* $)(410/( 9=2( ,410(-(40')*(0('/()-1('*'=( ('(0-*( 4(0 ,()'* ,)/(42('/('03(/*)2()'

BDD'/( =* 10.( (?2*?()( '( )(0'* *)0(1)*( /( 1(A 40' =(0.( 4(0+ H ,()'* D'/( BDD)'10.*( '/( ?4*(2*( '/' '/( -4' )-1('* /22 =( 50( =6 '/( 2*-0*=425/*)/11(0'*''=(>4' /((A10(* H>4'I-('/''/(-4'

('(0-*( * *0 0(=2( (C4*'=2( =6 ))(1'( 2(?2 '0 ' 0(*) 2''(06 =.*426 H>4' )-1('*I ( ' -( H1(0()'I 0 H=24'(I )-1('* /( >4'

)-1('*10*)*12(0(C4*0((A-*'* '/(10'*)420*'4'*='**?4*C4(26 ***.*42)(I /(1(A40'5(''=(0.(40'/(0 4(0+ H <( /.( 20(6 '*)( '/( =2( 10(10(* 0'/((2()'* -42'*12*(0/(=2( /=((10(10( * /.*? 0(?0 ' '/( '/0(( ()** '/* 40'

-(26 # 0'/( )2*--(4(0,()'* '/( BDD )'/(40'*'/'-42'*12*(0/5* 24- '/(=2(-4'=(4(/.*?

0(?0''/(?('/(()(("(0/1 '/( =*??(' .'?( =6 (-126*? '/( =2( 10(10( * * '/' '/( 4*0-*'6)*'()6*(2()'*'/( -42'*12*(0)=()/*(.(/((-('

(A'(' (1(()6 (1(

D (A-*'* '/( 4*C4( *'4'* '/( **.*42)(324*?'/((1(()60 '/( -42'*12*) * ' -( (A'(' 0*'/-('*)2 (A(0)*( /( -42'*12*) * 0-226=('/(('42.24('/( (1(()6'/('('/(()((J ('/ )( '/( (' 42 2 -42'*12*) * (( ':*? *' ))4' '/( ?( '/( ()(( 4)/ -4'*'=(-42'*12*(=6H-42'*12*(0I' 00*.(''/(2(1(()6 '/* 40' / ((.40( ' *-12*6 '/( '/(05*( )-12(A(A(0)*((-('2 (1(()6 ('(0-*'* )-1('**)2*--(4(0,()'* '/=((0*?/'26''(* '/')2*-'*)(('/)2*-0'/( 1401()-1('*-4'('=2*/ ?( '/( ()((K = *)-( '/( ()((K ) '/( 4-=(0 (1((' 00*.( ' '/( 2 (1(()6 '/(0*=42-4' )*(0 &'

*'*(4)'*'=(-(000*.*?

''/(*)-(K&''/((4)'*'=(-( '50'/(1(022*.*?(A1(('/( ()((K&''/(-42'*12*(0'=(112*( 5*'/0((0()(''/(?('/(()(( <( ' '/*: *' * ()(06 0 4 ' 0(.**''/(25'/(1*'5(0(*422 ?0((-('5*'/'/(.*(5* ; <())0*?260 '/((2()'*-42'*12*(0 24- '/( =2(* *225( '/(0(* 2*:(2*/'/()2*-'5//.()/( '11264(0,()'* =(*?50( 2((0-4'10(?2*?()('/( 10''/(0*.(0'/(-'0.(/*)2('/ '/(5/10((0'11264(0,()'* 0(?0'/()(5/(0('/(?('/( .*)'*-/11('=(41' 6(0 5(0( '/( )*(0( 1** '/' * 4)/ )( *00(1()'*.(,()'* 0,()'*

B 4(05/*)/'/()2*-0)-1('*/ =(( -( -42'*12*(0 '/( (-(' **)'( * '/( ,() ,)/(42(4=>()'')00()'*1*'(4' *24-'/(=2(* /42 =( 225( /* * ' (40( '/' )2*-' * 4)/ )( 0( ' 50( 2((0-4'5/('/(112*)'**-( 4(0,()'* '/( BDD)'22'/(0 )( ('/ 5/(0( '/( 112*)'* / =((-(4(0,()'* '/(-42'*12*(0 **)'( *24- '/(=2( * /42=(225(I /(0(0( '/( (2()'* -42'*12*(0 -('*(*)24- *'/()( $)(410*'=(225(/(-( 5 225( =6 5#4?( $()/ * % % !

!!*.*2;

B/( 1(A40'0(*'(0'(4(0+ H '/( ()** * ,02 3(0- )( 410 '/*40'/(2'/''/(-42'*12*(0' =(4(/42=(-('*(*)24- '/('=2('/(*>4?-('5/*)/ '0'5*'/1(0'*.(-42'*12*(0 D '/(?('/(()((''/('*-('/( ('/5

6(0 '/(-42'*12*(0 D4?/'

'/.(=((112*( /(0*=42':*?

*')*(0'*'/(?('/(()(( 50?26112*('/(-42'*12*(0 ;'/(

*?/40')--*''((0*4(000=6=0*?

*'5''/(-42'*12*(0 I )(?(=)/(20 '/(-42'*12*(0 1(0/*?(*'=(112*(1(0)24- '/('=2(?*.(* $ & '/( 0*=42 / 20(6 112*( '/( * 10*)*12(

5/*)/ 5 '/( )00()' 110)/ * '/* )(

/(0(0( '/( )'('* '/( *40)( )-16 '/' '/( -42'*12*(0 1(0 ?( '/( 10(' '/( ()(( /42 /.( =(( 112*( '(?'(I 6)( *'*'=((('/''/(?('/(5*5 '/(()((5 D6(0?(-*0)2*-'5 L

6(0''/('*-(*2*?'/()2*-1('*'*=(0('/(0*=42

.(*'/')( '/(-A*-4--42'*12*(0 D*'=(112*(

5(.(0 *'/(?('/(()((*)*(0( '/(-42'*12*(0 *'=(112*(/(0*=42?0.(26(00(*)*(0*?'/( ?('/(10(''/(()((=61126*?'/(-42'*12*(0; /(0(0( -'/(.*(5'/'*'/*)( '/(-42'*12*(0 *' =(112*(1(0?(()((/(-4')-1('* '/4)-('!

A A M!

/(0*=42 2?0.(26(00(*?0'*?!

02)0'*4- !

'010''* )/0?( !

4(02 (A1(( 5/*)/*)'006''/(4'/0*'6 $)( 410/(0(0( 4-! 02)0'*4-

! ''/(-*0)/*20(022.(()'* ?4*)('/('/(0 !

04(022'0*'(!

''/('/(0-'/(0'/(()((022.( ()'*'/(*00(225( /(-4'(/)( )-1('*'/4)-('!

/(-(*225(

12)(*'(0('EF1(04- *'(0('E; F1(04-* 225(0-'/('(*2*?'/()2*-1('*'*'*22*'0(2*G'* 4' '/( )-1('* !

;

0( 225( ' '/( -'/(0)2*-'

5/(0(!

0(225(''/( '/(0)2*-' ))4'2.(()'*''/(*0 4''/(0(-**?10''/(-4'*(! F*( !

/22 ? ' '/( 5*5 '/( ()(( *' %(.*)2*-' 5/*'046'6*0'/(-*26 -((''/(-*260(1*=*2*'*('(0'/(('//(0/4= !(-**? F'/()-1('*-4'*(!

/22?''/(-*0)/*20('/(()((/(/0('/( -*0 )/*20( /22 =( *.('( * 2? '(0- %! 5*'/ '/( '*2*G(=:'/()/*)('/(*0-'/(0'(00()0*?'/(*0 '(=*0'/*'/(%!=()-*?->0 '/(-4'/22=( *=40(''/(-5*'/4'640'/(00(00-'/(40' /( -4')-1('*/22=(*0()'26*=40(=6(1*'*? '/(-(*'/(=:))4''/(5*510('-*0)/*20( '/(()(( '=(40*/(=(0('/(*40)()-160 '/(0*=42 '/()(-6=( /(2*=*2*'6'/(5(0'/((*?.(/*)2(5 /(2'/(?04'/'/(*2('(('/()('/''/( )16'/(2*)()(104)(=6/(054'=(:($(0(

'/*40'

'/(5(0/*2(112*)'*=(*? * 0 12)*? 0()0 (A40( ' *'*2 (.*()( 5/*)/ 0( '04( 1/')16'/(0*.*?2*)()( =(0*?2' *?*'BB *12)( DB *4( * '/( -( ,40' !- 0*.(0 /( '04( 1/')1*('/(04'(1(0-*''/(*'()(0'**)'(5(0(2 4?/''=(104)( /(2(0()4(20'/(*40)()-1611( '/(112*)'*'/(?04'/'*)(50*''(''(-('5 *2( (1*'( '/( )' '/' '/( 5(0 '/( 0*.(0 >*( '/( 10)((*?/(0(0( '/(*'*2(.*()()'=(225( -'/(.*(5'/''/(40'(A*'''/(>4'*)( *'*4'/''/(*40)()-16?'.(0**('/(50? 2*)()( '/(*'*2(.*()(-4'=(225(/*40' .*( 0(0'(

1(* * *0()'('/(*40)()-16'.(0*6'/( 2*)()( A 104)(=6'/(11(22'5(0 /( 2(0( )4(2 0 '/( *40)( )-16 / '6 ''( ' =0 '/' '/( 2*)()( !#%7DBB (A40( *4'=(?(4*(.2*2*)()(/(0(0(

*')-(4''/'*)('/(*40)()-16/'?'.(0**( '/(2*)()( -*0(*?50?4-=(02*)()('/(1/')16

'/((000/))400(,*)('/()400('0*.*?2*)()(*4' =(?(4*('/((*?.(/*)2(52/.*?.2*04'( 1(0-*'*'()(0'**)'( '/(0(0( '/(*40)()-16* '('*'2('0().(060*?/'*/(22*=2('0(*-=40('/( *40(0)-1('*50(=6'/*40' 5(.(0 *)( '/(5(011(22'(2*=(0'(26*'11(0510)((( ?*' (A10'( (.( * ' *2( '/( 50*''( ''(-('

'/(0(0( 0- ; 5/('/(65(0(10)(((?*'(A 10'('*22'/(*2*?'/*11(2 '/(*'(0(''/( 50( -4' /22 =( 1* =6 '/( 5(0 0*.(0 '/( (*?.(/*)2(>*'26 *2(=6'/(5(0* ))0*?26225(''/(=.('((A'(' </*2(10(*?/*11(2 '/(2(0()4(20'/( *40)( )-16 / 0?4( '/' '/(0( * 2*=*2*'6 '/( *40)( )-16 ' 16 '/( -4' 5(.(0 *)( '/( (?2*?()('/(0*.(0*10.('/(0*.(0'/((*? .(/*)2(5/.*?.2*2*)()('/()4-(''/((*? .(/*)2( 5(0( ?(4*( '/(0(0( '/( 2*=*2*'6 '/( *40)( )-16*'/(0( 5(.(0 0(0((02*(0 '/(5(0/22=( ('*'2('16*'(0(''/(50(-4'0- ; ' /(11(2'/(*40)()-16*( *225(''/'(A'('

.*(5'/(0(?*?*)4*

*2(=6'/()2*-'11(22'*225( *2(=6'/(5(011(22'*2225( 5/(0(

*2(=6'/(*40)()-16*10'26225(' '/(=.('((A'(' 8 7%",

# %