The Chief Administaor Haryana Shehri Vikas Pradhikaran And Another v. The National Cnsumer Dispute Redressal Commission And Another



    

    

  



 !

"# !$%&%"'( ) 


* + 

, 

 +  -.+

 . 

  


 



 /

+

++

 ++/

++    


   

(  0/   +
 -  +  
 

 
  
 
  



  

-  +  , 

/

11




"

 #
 

$ 
!%

&'('

)

 

*
  #

 






  




%'

$&!

+ 


  






,''(''
- $ 
!./



0#

1 
+


2  


+


-     




31+2+4/





1(''

'(''
" 0#



(.('(''



0#


+


2 



+


-     



 3+2+4/

5
1,.,

'('
 



'.('('



0#

2  
+


2 



+


-     




32+2+4/
 
0

 




0
 



'
 #

 




  




  

$  

  
 

#
 
 !
7*
  !! # 
 
)
 ) 
 #
) "

- # 
8 0
2  

 #
 
"
 /
-     




3 4/

 


 

 
 
9
  

 

! !  


  !

 
 
"



 
  

1
:.


'+
999
5 0


 


 

;<%&(
=


"





  



 

1
<,&

('(,%%<


  
₹.

'( .'(>!
*
# 






 "

 

0
 
0#

  



)


 


= 


  
0
 
?
 




  
  




1:.

"
"



 
0#


"




 
"
"
 

 
 
 


 







0#

 40
 
+ 

9 

# 







 

0
 
 
*
 
  
 

'('
"

 
"  #

0  

2+2+
5 0
*
  
1'!  
"


=  
  
  

  

 


"





 
(&(&'((;
 


 



#
  
0#

 
   
 



 



) "


 0



1
,<


'!

 

1 
,,;
 
,&&


 
'&(
=
@ 



,
" 
# 
 
 


0

 #

  
 



$ 




1:.


'
+
999
5 0


1 
,,;
 
,,&



,
5 0

$



"  


#
 #
   
$

 

0



  

 


1 
,,;
 
,,&


 
'&(
=
@ 



,
5 0

= 
" 

0#


  
1'!  


 


# 








$ 


 




 

  
 
?
(&(.'('
 
 

0


= 


 


 

  


 

,''

'('
0  
2+2+
 # 


" 
 !

  



                       !    "

 #  "$ % &     # '   #   ( 



'      #    ''   '      #    #& ) &      '  #   * ( *#  ' 

 #     '(  '   #    & + "$$$$$,   #  

 '

   #  

&  #   &  -./ 

# &

  &  #   

   ' #   '  #     ' &#  

&

'  0

12 ##

# '  

  '(  '  #     

   
,
8




 
 
 




"


 
 
  

   
*
  


1

  
"
 


)




;(%'('
*

"
  
 

 
 

  

  

0#

  
1'!  >

 

= 
"
"
 

 
"
 


  

 # 





1,<


'


1'..

'.:


,





1:.


'!+!999
# 
 
 
" 
 #




$ 
#


  
0


''(%'(&
*
  
"
 
 




 #
 
 #
  


0 

 

 

 & &((>!
" 
 
 #
 
 & (((>!
" 

$
" 
 
" 
*
  
 


" 

'.('('



0#
2+2+
5 0



!

3 '      (   &   #   

  ' 

   & 2 ##

 ' 

   #         

  ( 

&



 #  '     '  4+    55  5. '   '    .5 '  2666'& ( 

    

   * 

& ' 078 (9#  3"53,:4 

$3 $"  #     '

      (      '   &          % &   ' ;  # 2         '

 ( (   

' 1'

 1< 

   &  

 

  &      (

      #   

2

     '+""$$, #   

  

& +"$$$,  

*   #  

   &   &  - / 

  (  '

   = 

2 #  

'  # $&' #   ' ' 

& '  2

& '        

 ' '  >
;

  
 

  
  




0  

+2+
 #    


0
   

0
"



 
0 

0


 
 

 "

 


 
)
 ) 


$ 








=  

5



1,.,

'('
"  
0#

+2+
 



(.('(''




"  
 


*
  


 


!

0( 

 #

#&     '

  

     

    ' 

 '      ##

 ' #    8   2 ##

     

       &   '

   

    (  

 & (  #&  

'

 

 ' #

 







#  <  ##

 ' 



 ( '

 #  %   '   .5   2666     = '  &



(  

 

 

 '      <   #     

   #      ' # #  # &  

 '' '  :   4''

6  # '

  '' ' 

 

    (  & '      ?  

 & 

1

* 2   '        (  #    

 ( 

&



'    .5   2666     (  & 



   &

 ( ''



 #  ''    (  6   

      # '  

  @          '' '  :   4''

  ?    # '  #  

 6 %   &    

 

' ( &       '   0

1 

 ##

  

     



   

 

&



     



(  (  &    (

         6  
 

    # #

& '33     #  %   & ' $$        ' #

 

'

   '.&

      '  '  6   '  &   ' ' & #   

   ' 

  "6 

  '  #@'     

 #  #    #         

#  #      8

   A 0& 

3

  A@ B @  #   '  (   

# ' 

  

   #     &    8   2 ##

   (      

#  #  

   (

       #    '      ' ( ''

   & 

     '   

 @

   &   (

     # 

'6 

  #    8  2 ##

   @ '' '  '   

       & '

( < 

   

(    #  (

       '      # '   #   <    B 4'' '8   ##

' 

 

' ' #    #  

     

 

'    (    

  ( 

 

  (

      #      &



   (           &    8   2 ##

 :(  '

    2 =  (&      '        (&'

  ' # '   =  '   &< (  # ( '

# '

  '    #   '   

 '

  #  .&  '

'

     '  ''   '' ' 

   

%   '   ( ( 

 



  ##

 







#

#&   '

 

  

( '

  

  &'

 #   

  C 

  #  (  &      '

  

   #  

    #   &  ##

 (    $     (       

    

 (  '#    # 5<    &# '+"

"$,

    # '



'  

   

  ' 

    '  * & '

  '

,(

' &> &

 
  

  
  



 

1(''

'(''


'
-0/


+

 

%:<
   

0 

0  

1+2+





,''(''




"
 
 


0#

1+2+

*
  
 






0#

1+2+
 !

$<    '  '    B  .5   2D666  

? +# ,  A ?&+#(9#  "  $33 





'  B    ( #

5$ $$  <        ' # # &  #   & $$   #%  0AB '

  ' '  B    #      





 

    B    % 

     

# '  2 #   ( 9#   .3   $"$" $$ < 0

E #2   B6;    &       '

      B   % 

 (& 

   



'  B   

   (  2 #   &  0AB% &2 #  #

  B            B        "

#  "$%&   & (   & %  B  

0AB      (    ' '

       '

 &       & 

&  &   %    & ( & 

   # ' # 2 #  

  B  

  (   #'

 # '    (   

& 

       (  '  #  C   # & ? 

'  B  

 0AB    2 #      %

 

  '

    (    &

 

 

 '       0

E  #2    '
; FB( ; (  ?   > $ 224 ; 2 53     %   

 @ (   

'  4    &  #  

 *' # 

'2

# (     '  ( & ' 

    '& '  B ? ,(2

#0  



       

'  0AB    #  &#  

    '

 ?#   0

E  # 2      



##

     



'     ,'  

  ( 2 # 

&  ' 

6 # '

0AB      (  #&    ,   

 

    '              & 0AB 

     (  2 #    %  &     '          2666    %  

 ; 6 #&



  #   0AB & 

#@  # '

 # '    (   #         '#@  2 # 

 ' # 

 '

  5&6'& ( @ & 

    2 #     '

      (      '    &   6 ( ' 

 '   ' '   & 

    ' & (

   ' 0AB6

'  &#  &

 ? 

     #     &    2 ##

  ' , G '    9  ( +(

H 

' 2 ##

 * #& #      &  0

E  #   I )#9 &(  F @ '6 !

E J2(

     , $

 

$ $

K &

(  L 
36   &   (

? 

'  

2 ##

  

G '    * #&# 6 

*

&





#    #  '   (

 #&     

   

 2 ##

      2 ##

 *? 

(   &   ' *? 

 (    

* ' ? 

&  #   &

   

  

 ##

 '

 *   (

 ? 

 &   '

  

  ' #  

  @    & &  

   

 

 # 



    '

   

  @  %  





'   %>   

 

    (6

'  &

     '   

 6#   4   $5$ $

 &     2 ##

     

      

 

'  '    (   &  B  2

% &   +(

 B  

 '    & # )   ( '  #   '   

4   >
<
*
  
  
  




A 
-+ /
2 #
1''(<,

'(',
0  

 40
 
+ 
"
"
" "
"
0 #

 


+ 


  
 
 

  
 

)

.
A 





  
  

  




 
0 

0


 
 


#


 
$ 








=  

 




 
"
 0
 #
"


 




  



A


  

 "

 #
  



#

"
0
 
0#

  
 
"
 


=  
 

 

)

$ 




"

  


 

 


 

 

 
0



0#

2+2+

:
1

   

0
 




%
9
 
 
 



  


  
 
 
 
 
 

  
 0

 


(
9
 


0
 

0


  !

 
 

  




+


5 


  

+ 
0 
 #
#








 #

 #
0#

2+2+
0 
 


0#

+2+
 



0#

1+2+
*
 

"
 


    #


 


1:.


'
+!999
5 0


 
;<%&(
=


"



  

  


('(,%%<
 
 

 

 

':
#


# 






 

0
 
*
  
1'!

  
"


=  
 
0#





 
:(,'((;

 
0  


#
 


 
1?+



 

  
1"   




  
0
 
0#

 








= 


0
 
 

"

  
 


  


# 





1:.
 

0
  
 



0



 


 
 
*
  
"
 
#
 0 0


  



 
 




 




 
 
 
" 

 


 
 
0
  


 

 
 
0

9 

) 
 0#


 

0#


 


# 







 

  
 
 




 


 





 
 


*







 


 

 

':
#



0

)






  #


   
 
 
" 
) 
 #


 



"



 
 #





= 

0
0#

  
1'!  


  

"
 
0#

 #


 $


#
" 
) 
 
  


 > 
"   #
 0 0


  
  
  




 

+


+


 


  
 



1+2+
*
  

 

 

 40
 
+ 
 
  


" "


A
"
0 #

 

+ 
 


0
 

#
 
#
0
$ 
0#

  



 

1

) " 
#
"


 
"
  #


 




0

 


 







 
= 

 
0
 







  


"



= 


0
 

0


 #

  

 



1:.

" 


  
1'!  



    

 0 
 

 #
  



 #

0

 
 


   







1:.


0
  #





 !B!





"
0
 

0


  

'
1"
  


   
  


  
0

0 

0


8  0#

  
"


0

 

# 






 #
"

  

  
  


 
9
  


 



 


 

(&(.'('
 #
 "  
0#

  
 # 
 




  




   





  

 

 
"  
 #
  
= 

0#


  
1'!  
 
 

'('
*
 

= 
"

#
   

,
9
 #
 

 #

 #







 







C 
 "


  
 


$
= 

"
 

 

  
" = 



2

 

 #





 
0#

 
"


 



 #
0  

2  
+


2 



+


 
  
 

"

  


  
"
 
0#




+ 
1
 
" 




 ) 
 #
0 #



#
0  

2+2+
9
 


   



0 

0



 


 
*
 

= 

0

"

 






 


  


) 
$ 



0#

  

;

  


$
   


"

 


 
0
 

0

0#

2+2+
9



 

   #



   
#
 
 
"



 


  


  
 
" 
 


   





 



 
 





= 
   
9
 






 #

#

#





  !
 

 

  

&
9
 


  


  

  

  



"



 #
 
 

0



#

 


#


  
 
 
0
 
9
 


  

0  

+ 


 #







#
0 

 


 


  



  




"
 
0 
  
 

"

 
 



<
*
  
"




  #
 


 

 &( (((>!

 


  

 





 

 # 

 

 
# 




0#

#
 


 

':
#


A

 
0
 
"

9

  4
D  
5 
+  
*

0
 


 

"
 
 
 0
 




#


  
1'!  






0
 

 "

 #

.
9

  








 
0#



+





 
"

 

(,
 




  
#





  
1'!  


0
 

  
E
<F

 


 
 #
 
0#


 


  
#

 #



 
"

 
 

 
)
"

9
   4
D  
5 
+  

0
 


 
"
  

   

0 
 


+!4 !56!7 ), 

--  +  

78 7"7

 

 @ ,

 LM, 

  LM,