← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2120/2018dismissed

Shiri Pal v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2022-08-31The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli10 pages



          

  

     !"   

  $% !

 & '

 "  (

               

   

!

(!"

) *+

*



+,%

#*+#+

- #*& '

* .

" !

% /"

0*+ 

+

- #*& '

*

1%"

#(1

"

 *+

*

"(  2222

   3" 

 (

 / # /' # ) 0

 ( 0   %    " 

 % % !  5  6  " 7  +4%   + *  5 

     ( #'8 ##./' .



9* "/'

4%  0  (%/# (%(* )#'* "#() # :

#  

)) #! 5;*<   / 84%

  " (

 )(   1"

  = 5>>>

 $ ## 0

.

*

?(%*3" #   <   / *"

# (  . (     !  5   "  0"

 <  )(

3 ( '  7  +4%   "

/ #

 

#)  +  

. 0 " '%( 0  "  (

"(   ! 5 *# ,) ' ". (

* " ( 0  " 

 (

 . ,(   /'



.

0 "   !%()% 3" '.

##'(%

 /' "

@" "!%()%    

            

 ! (%# )

 ( 0 (" ." " (%" /#.

"#  $    % &  '

('(  &  )    %&

&  % &  %  *+      % &,



   -      % & % *  & )- )  ))

 % %   .& ,   &  -    % & +  &,

& 

  & '

('-(% & % *  & % / %  -   * 0)12 & '(- )   &

    -   12   12 0     %  &3  &,  &  '(% & % * 4

&) & %   %%    &

&  %

 & +  %    - 4  &

   -     )+  &

 - 4+ &

    - 

         + % &

   -

+  - 4      0.

5 5    % & '( % & % * &   %&

   &  0 &3& % 6      

   & '(&  -  )   &  7  %   ,  

 -%& '

)(      %  %&  %  &3  & % & % / 

-  

&

 &&&)    % & % *& - ,  & * %  &3 & % /  -% %

+  

&  * %   &  & - ,  86   % &

 '& ( 

   %  &3  &,&%6  )  & 

 7 % ,%%  +&

   & % * -   9 )9   % %& % &3  &  % & % /  : & -  &

 

  & * '

(% & % / +   

   &    &3      &  '( 6   6  %&

  &  0 - ,     &

  - ,     & * '

())%  &&

 &

   ) ,  %& % , &

 +& &   &3  &,    & '(% & % * ! 0    & '(% & % * -

   % & '(  % & '

('-(

; 0 % 4,  & % /    & 

   &  '(  - ), % 3   <   =&)- 

4,   &  ! %  &  % / + 

   

       ,   

& '(% & % *+& -

4    & '( / 0  % & '(  ,% 

  % &,  

&-   &      %     &   4    &

  %%   -%  &  %  * &  %&+ &,% &3  , )  &&        0  % - & %      - &    - .&  &

  %%  

&  '( %  &  %  *    ,   ) & % &   3   ,   % && 

&, %  &3  &   

  

&, ,  %%&  % & %  *+ +                6- &    &&  &,

)

)  3   ,   %  % 4,

    &,   %    % &

       % &      &3 2  3"%) %/

 "  (

! 5

" +   /' " !%() %  

 , # ( 0* / "  0 (   /% "("' #(  "( ') )(

 / %# ##*)  0 "/'*  " "   

 * ".%#/# ( 0+

 "/# 0

) ,

"( ')  # % 4%  * "

/#

%"/# 0

( ' )(# /'  0 ")(

." " .%#) 

")(

)% )   /# . ""

 ( " )* . ## /  /#  .  # )

" )(

   / (  ! ) # #'* .A( B"

/  ( ) ( 0.

" "7+

 %' " %  . 0 ( " ) "

/ 

/  # (

, 0("' #(   

    "!

* "   0( %! 5 +   3" !%() %  "

% " #

" (  ." " '   ).

 (

*. ##/C#%." #)(% 0

"0 ((  ' ! ) # #'* "

/#

! 5

 0   . %

4%

#0 ' #%( 0 # ((#  #'

"  ."  " ( 0 . ( 0  " 

   ) "+  5 + (  (%  " /' " (

* "  .  1"

  = 5>>> 

  $ ## 0 .

*

?(%* 3" #    <   / * ."%( "' "

  %  )   ("' #(   4% 3" # .

4% /'

"-) & '

/' % 0 



    %! 5 6 "+4%  + * 5 ##./'

.

 

 9 " (%/#  (%(*  )#'*  #()

% # :

#  

)) #! 5;*<   /    



( "

 0 % .

 9* "( "



#

, "(    4%  <% "* "' "

  

## 

  " )(

  4%  #  .

 (  " (

  .

( .

" " %    .

"# .3" *

 ( 0 4%   4%  

 # (   .  ! 5 D 

 *

   

?

 " (

 "

# ' / #  )  ( 0 3 , 0 ## " (# * (

  #  (( " " % /' # 0=559 5." ".

 (      

 5; "/'   0 " (

"    "(

)/'

  0

## "0%   

3"(

)/' (

.

  "# ).

? /'(  0( , 0 

 " #? 0 "# )

* 

 (   4%  #  .

,  "

  /

' ( )  /'  0  (

 : )"

 + 0  " 

%  )(

* 

")(

0    4% .

 +E*% (   7+

55* ( ')    )   "#.

 .

 (   ( ') )(

  " ) @ #"

*

" %( 3"(

  " 

 (

 "

##0 / "  ( 0 .## "( , 0 "

* "%*%0"

( 0 ( 0 "0%

 " "(  "

/

, ")(

"

/( 



; 3"%0"  " (#  0  " (

* " (

 "

 "(#   ) 

/'  0

## ?

 # 

"

/#  

% "  #%

#(*".*

) " %    ) "#'   /'

.

 "()  ! 5  #

* "%* "# ) 0  "  ) 



  ##'0 %(

 ". "

) "(# / 0  " 0"#' 0%

  

"

/'# ' # "*  ( 0  #%.

'/ ,  "'  (  ) "(#  0

# *

  (  ) " (

 "

 "

##0 ( 0* " *  0 "( " 

. (

*. .%#/  0#' "(# ((# / # ' ! 5 +  ( 0  4%  6  * +,%

#*# %# ((  0 ( !

%/)

" 

(

 / )   . .# ./' "!%()%    D #() +% " ' %(   " 0 ( /  !  5   " +    %# ## 3"  ) 4% ) # )# ( 0 ( 0  (

.  (   4% *." "

"

# ( "(   4% .

,/' !

/' 0 (

: )"

=9;

 ;*." ""

/ "#   #  ) 

, 0 (   %" (  

,*   /#% #'  " !

  ." 

  )   "(  *"  ( &%/)

(

 . ;/ % ".



' " ( 

)  4%    #/' "

*

" * %" (    / C#% ." # #%#

0 ; '  (  % !  5   " +   <% "* ) (



""

 % ) "  

#   4%  .

 

)   

 F> 5   5*

" * '  %  /   ( ( 0 . 

*  )  ##0  % " : & % " %/)

"/# 0

"!

 ( ' ")(



%#'  "

0 "   )(

)%  .

 )(

)% % .

  4% .

 "%  +E* <   /   5  % !    " +   5

(  " 

)   "!( , 0 # *



)   %        )  .0#' 

)(

)%  "( (   " %   .

"# .* " *# %#"

( '  )  " 

.

" + 4%#

) 

*( ' /)   )  " 

(

 " 0  (   !  5   " +    %# ##* ." "  

# ) 0# ( 0 ( 0 9 &  0 "  " (  0%) * 0 0 "%0" (  (#  0 / ## " C(    D #() +% " ' %( *.  " (  

" 

(

# /# / )  )   D 

 !"#$%& %'%() &#"'* '+,&) %')"'*)"-&'  3"(

  " 

 (

# ) /  ("' # (     4%       %( /' (

 

 "%0" .

.

( 9 "'   ) ,"

##0 ( 0/% ' "("' (  "

   /

, ) ") D "  0 * " (  # " .

 

)  %/)

0

 (  .

, /'  . 0 ( " )   )    (

 : )"

 = 9; 

 ;*." ""

/"#  # )

, 0(  ! 6  5( 



, 0 "(  *    "!

  ) ##%)/ 3"%*. 

" (  

"("' #(   4% 

%#'

, #     "!

3" * "(# / 0  /' " (

   / 0  ("' # (     4%  ."##')    # /# /?    %.$&'") %'".%,')(%/) &#"'* '+,&) %'0")&'*&/&*  3" (  "



0 ##' (#   " .

 

)

)% )(

"  4% # .

)   /# ## . 0  ")(

 4% * ).

(   " % 5  %!   5* " * "/# 0

"!

 ( ' " )(

)%  

 %#'  "

0 D "  0 * 



#"



  . "C(  D#() +% " ' %(  " /# 0

  " !

  ( ' " )(

 

 "

0 )%  )(

   ." " "

 / ( ) 

)% )   /# .

/  ." " (%" /#.  

        



   

 

   

     !



  

 

 "

     



 !



 

# $  %

"

>) +&

    %            

  -    )  ) -&,%

- ,   4        &

 &  -   %  %

  4, 

  & %  

  '  "  (  "

 % 

 

    ) % * % +,)           

     "  



- 

 " $  #  

'

$  % 

    '  (# 



    

" 

$  %

 $

# 

    .

$





 

'

(#

$  '  %

   '   

 ' %   #



    / 

    

  

    )'      

     + % * %   )  





 + %* %  

  

 % 

 

  %  0$  %   

      

 1

 2  

     " #  

% 





   $ '%  

 

  $    (    "

   

# 

 

$      ' 

 

  >) +&    )  , 

    +  -          &  *+ 

 &  0$  

 #  

  

  2     (  



"'    

 



     % 

   %  

  ) 3

$

' 4  

# 

   5 

-  3"



# #'

"/

)  "  /  #  '( %/

"!

"

 "

0

 /# 0

.

 ) , 0 " )(

4%  3" * " 



)(

)% "

/ /' ") ) # "%* "/'?  DDD  %'&%() &!%'* ) %'$/&!/ 1&* '&!) %'23425%() &!)   %(2678"/&(,#( ##&*  3" !%() %   D #()  +% " ' %(   # #' /

 ) # ( 0   ( 0 %! 5 */ " "  ( ') )(

, 0 ( )%  / %# ##   "

"   %# ##* ( 0  "

((3"!%()% "

/

.AB% 0 ! 5 )% /  A >B# ( ) "?%0) (%" /#. ,,&  2  -   

$

' #     

% 

  

     )' 

  #$     $





  ' $ %      % '

  

'   #"%

%

 * %+,)

   

$   %  ) % * %*"



  

  #

   '%  % 

    

    

  #$   4%  "

 

' 





  



       &67 1  *   * $ 8  % &9

::'2   ;

  %  2  

$   %

 

 #$    ' 

 

  

  <$    %

  

 

%% & 

$ =  &        % 

  %

  %%

$

  '     %  % 

"



%% &  

'

"

 

 & 

 9%

 !  "  % 

# % 



 #$   *  

#





 '  



  

 

$  & 

 

 '   

$ 

 " 

 

  

 "  %#   %



 # %

   '   

  $ 0&301   ' $    

' 

     

  

$  &%' 

' 

 

      %%

$  '  

 # 



$

' "  %   "

 

   

#  

&  

  

  "

#1 '

 

 )&%'

$

'

    #$  '  

 

 %%

 



   



        #$  %  $

  

% 

#   %# 

     &   

    %

  

 

%%  





   " 

 

  $

1 '- /   4

    " 

     = &  

 

  #$

%%

$  >&

   

   %%

$

   

 %

    



 

    "      

$     

     

    #$   

 

    

0+%  %&3  &,      )+ & '(%-     - 4+ +  &  4+&

 

+  &3  &,  #2  D 

"

 # ) "( , 0 .##

 (#' #*    

 .

 .

%  9* " ("' # (  .

, /'  0  (

: )"

 = 9; 

  ; " )(

)%  .

%#'  (   " % .##3" *   " ( / ! 5  

%# ##* " * (    /# %(/'

 )# ( 0 ( 0 D$  &') "# ) %() &#"'* '+,&) %' 

 +,%

#*  "  0 " 

 (#   .



) *"

") #' 

"!

 4% 

"(%/# (%( % # :

# #() % # :

 #   

 )) # !  5;* <   /  3" #   4%  ')%"

"  "(%/# (%(

 #()   )  .       ( ) ' "#  !  5; <   /  ( '% (# "

  " ( 0%) /' "( .  )(#  0) " " )

"    )(

/,(  ) ." # # 0.

" 

  0% # "  "(%/# (%(  

"!

> " '."   "/ (   /% % # :

4% *

 "

 0/  !

 5 +  4%#  /  %     .   # . %))  :  (  6   D #()  +% " ' %( * (

##'

 "

 0 

    "

* " ("' (     4%  0 /

,* " /# 0

( ')  )(

 

  "

0 #   0

 4%  ' )%"

"  "(%/# (%(*.   "

 "#

  " 

* " !

 "

%##'  "

0  /# 0

 4%  / " "  0  % 0   ! 5 + / 0* " 

(

  )  3" ( , 0 (  /' " ( "  "/' ? 0

"# )

   0#'*

) %("#

; &  0  )  " )  .  (

* ## ( 0

((#

* '* #) " )

 6 !

%4% '



 4  5                      4

 5              +)"!"

) " "( , 0>  G>= " "(

/# G>=