Ranjit Singh v. M/S Babu Ram Janak Raj Through Its Prop. And Another
!"!
#$%%
#&!
'!#() **%
, +"-" ./" 0- 1 #2 & -() !
+3% #4 #
*%%
$ .+%#4 +&!
')+1546
+% .+%2")!
((+78546
++ %% .+%)+-6985'+%5 -#&0%
)88 #( !# 3+
#!"
&-4(1 4
:%% 3""
4 09 4 44!
#8 '
""!
#" -4( )!#45 7) 09 7)!8 4!"1!""!#( 8 !8
+5 &-4(1 #6!
# #4 "
4
4;%%3""
8 4-4! !8.(!"
+
5"
8""587#4!'0 57"-3) 84% ) ") !# 57)! ))"0
#+!"
#"!4 + #!#
3+ 3
#"
#4"#
4!#4
!809 )!" !#!
+4
4%%57)! )7 -84+ 4"-#4 +$ <= 3
+ "-01!
+)"0
#4 "0- !# )!" 0"
% 8 8 7" !8
85 ) +5 8 )4 ) # #
+ !1 +(-1 "%8 -()!
!"+
>? !# &-4(1 33
# # 0!808 7++# " 7 !""- 4 (!#"
3
+@
#"-+ )!" 3+ 0
!1 85 ) +5 # "- ) 7++# " 7
+ "
+6 -
4 -3 3
+% )
+)"0
#7+ #(894 "!#0"
+"7 88")!" 8% # "-33 )!" "-01!""!
#"5 8
+ )" + 8!
4 -3 &-4(1 #B08 '-3+ # %:% !# +!1!#8 8 % C ')#2+ ,"% '
.)+") +%
1
#% "2!#( 5')+!D%'%-82)55
-#&057) !"3+ !# 5 "#
#0 )8
'
% = 3
+ !" 4!+
)#4 + 39
"!
4-+!#( -+"
49% '!# +# 4 3 8!
! !8 )4 !8
-
# #0!808 7++# " (!#"
+57) 7""
4 7#7!
-#4!
6# !1 5!
!" -+ '
")88 !8 # !46!
4!" 8 "!#("
7) 7" #"!08 +"
+ # # - 0 "!4 # #0!808 7++# "!""- (!#"
+% 4& -+#
%%%E 4958 833
+57)!8
+ !#( "!4
# #4 )!" + 8!# -3 "!4&-4(1 #B08 3 A 5)"+(-
!13-(# 4 &-4(1 )" 0
# 3""
7!
- ) 3
+ )!" 85
"1 !"8!08
"!4 #4
+!"+ F-!+
4# -#!
9 ) +!#(0
4 !4!#(
"%
>? = 8 33 " 4 #
4!"3-
"!4 -8#48 (83 "!
#% ) #B08 3 A !# ')#2+ ,"% '
.)+") +5 >? >+!1!#8? G5 7)!8 "
!#( "!4
&-4(1 3""
!() 5)") 84 7) ## 8(!#"
#6!
#!"3+
++ -"
45 # #890 4!"3 "
+) 88# )!" 8#4 !# # +!"6!808 !" + F-!+
!# # 1! -" -+! + 8 (8 !4
+#4 #0 )8 -"
4% 7") 84"-#4 +$ <H) -"
4)"3+
++ 8(!#"
#6!
#5 8 #0 4!"3 #89
+ ) 88# + )!" 8% H) 7"# 3+ 88# 5!# -+ #"!4 6!
75 !() -() #
)6 4!"3 "
"% 7") 84!#
7) 46
88# !" 0"
4
+!#(5 ")88 +33 !# #1! -" -+! #4 #4 8% # 8(!#"
#6!
# !" 41!
45 !
!" 49 33
!# #46
"1! -" -+!
# 1!#
-() = (8 '
+6!
" - 9 #4 ) + 1
# 1 " #4 # 4!"3 8% H) 88# 7" #
3+
46
5!# -+6!
75 !() -() #
)6 1
"#4 !13-(# +!" 8!08
"!4 #4 1
+!"+ 1!
40 2
!() %) !() ")88+
+!1!#8 8 % G#4 +4"- ! !
-#!
9
88# #4 3+
4 7!
1
+ !# +4# 7!
)87%# "
5! 88# !""
!88#
3+
45 7 F- !()
# 1!#
88# = (8 '
+6!
>G? - 9 #4 3+
4 7!
1
+% '!# 88# !" "!4
)6 -#4 +( 1 )# +" !13+!"
#1 #4 "!# +!1!#8 33 %/G !" + 1!
4 0 2
!()
!13+!"
#1 !13 4-3 88# !"
"-"3 4#4 88# !"
"
#4!
) ") -84 -
0!8 #4 +"-1 =5/7!
"-+
+8!2 "-1 )
" !" 11!
8 %) !() ")88 3+
4 7!
+!1!#8 33 8 !# +4# 7!
)87%E # 6!
7 0 3+ 6!"!
# !" 88 4% ) !13-(# 4 &-4(1 !" "
"!4 #4 1
+ !" + 1#4 0 2
4 44!
#8 '
""!
#" -4( 5 )!#45 !"!
# + ")
+)
+ +)!" 8% "
+!"!# -"
495
!13 4-3 )!1!""-"3 4% ")880 "
#0!8 #)!" -+#!")!#( 4 F-
0!8/"-+
9 0 #4"
" !"
%
+ "5 !+ 85 + 4!+
+
8 433
#:%%57) -3 #5
4 33
")88 3+
4 7!
1
+ !# +4# 7!
)87%
! %% 4" H)
+'3 2!#(/
"
4$ "/ H)
08 $ "/