Laxman Dass v. State Of Haryana And ORS.
!"# $%$&'$()* + &)*),*-$()* +
!"
" ./" 0 00 1 ./" 0 1/ # "$%& '()#() *"+,) -(.)!!',)/! 0')'1**)%)) 1)0#(*"+,) -()!!',)/ !"2 00 1 2
3-4,353-67&),*(
4 )#()"( ",) 45-6777 $-( '',,," ( )",) *$,)00!')""8 !" *) ,() *)1 (0))
)")0),()%) )) ( )"
*)",'))%'-* ,')0"$%(!')-- * ()(%) ()('" -')"+'')# -)) ) ) )" ()$) - '')# )) (
* ( " !
" ')"
0)
#6721))'
490)') *) ,0! ":(8);59/;<2* :())4=2=)"4=2>*:'') 66</42/;.7*4</;.45*4;/;.42* 45/9.7* 64/2.<* 66/;.7* 6>/;.7* 69/;.7* 66;/4/;.7* 6/;.7* 665/5/;.7* 44/<.>*46/;.7*45/;.7*67/<.>*66;/44/6/6.5*67/;.7*64/>.7*66</49/9.
44* 665/64/<.>* 6/;.7* 6=7/4/2.42* 6/4/9.4=* 6=;/9/<.>* 2/4/2.7* 665/4/<.>*6/;.7*=/;.7*47/<.>*$",')"-)''(8 (!
)"!
3-4%&$5$'3*48)&49$($-:%:)*)849$:*%43*4;&:4<$4:4:)* 6 ( )" ",'))%
8) -'" ) ! )+ ,)!),%*)"*(!! / -(
,')0"() )1 (0))
*))%") ) !"(*()"+)'"#( ' )" + (
')"* ) ( ""
,,"* ) )
/$-,)%(" !
"')"
= (
')"
$,)0)
#") ) ?8))
*$ ()')
#
!) *()")'0"$-,)'
(
')"
* )"* ()" #(* ' 0 )!!!)
!(')"
*) $,)0)
#"(0'%) )
)"* )() 8(-( #(*( )")+0 8) 0)"(!0 *()()
#0-(" !
"')"
* ?8))
*) ) 8) $ )'0")
#0*$ ('"# '#+% '% '' ( ')" $,)0
" - ,())$' !
! 8+*8) ,""()( #(*()
#0-( " !
"')"
?8))
*) ) ( #(, '" * )""" ($--( +)'"'%)!!",(')) ( )
* )"* ()- :)(%) )
('
* 8)
,"*())1 (0))
, '""0 -:)(%) )
* (, $ , "* $
,,"# ) ) - ( " !
" ')"
* ) :)(%) )
* "" 0) )!! )1 (0))
) ( " ,!'(
*8) )+"()(')"8)
--0(, 0$),- -0, 0$),-( '+),())$'!
! *-8(,(8) )
#"(!
!"
!",
*-)1 (0))
*)(('0"#)* ,) "@ $ ,
)'%(!0 *()(') ('"-( --,-( :)(%)) *"")!!)1 (0) )
*) ( ,(') > (')" '',,,"*)- 1#
* ( )" !')"# )" )- ,+# +", ( * 0)" ) ,,'
*())1 (0))
* !"4(*8) )$' !"
,)%", 0)%+",*!)%#()(()"$ )!!") )+)'"
,,
*$%:)(%))
*(') ('"- (--,- )"*8(0()
#0-(" !
"
')"
8) 0)"*$ -,())$'!
! +*8) )'
,,'
""*()($) -",-( +' !)
"* 6>7945;6*!
),8(-*)1 (0))
*()"') " 4>7<4556*541))'
90)') -(" !
"')"*())
(#(*)( , A )'* ) "(#( -( )0),()%)+(
')"
')'%()0),()%)* 8) ",')"$8-(" !
"')"
*$ 8()",() ()''0)))"'1)-(')"" !
*'%''
,() )# 8() ')8- ''%)!!" (0*)(", 8) )'
0)"*()(,0"+"-0(
!!%*$ ! (81 -) ()' 8 (!!'), *)"*()(),, !, -( )0 ()'')'
$0))"$%()0),()%),," 9 )@0))
$,)0)##+"-0(+",*) 0)" $% ( ')" '', ,,"* )" ) $,0 ,' " @ .<*)"8) '" ()#) )@, +)!!)'
$)#>;*$-( 0!!!'') (%,," (!!'') (%,,"*7=7=6772*0)")+",-
+
" 0
)'* !()$+ ) %)!!)'*)"*$+
'% !('"( )--0)++",*) $,)0")8(!')--B
*)"*)
$,0,)" .<8+*)@0))
% ") + ! $)# >45 - 6779.72* $- ( ')" ),)' 00
*)%))8+*( )"+ ! 8) )'
" 0
"*747;6772(, ')"# (! ()#) ( )8!$-( 2 # !",% - ( ) 8 !* ( ' !@!")"8)
$ "$%( ()0))()
()')* ))*$%)"0)"$%( *4>756764 0,=>:%%:)*%)849$5$3&*$(-),*%$58)&49$<$4:4:)*$&
< ( ')" , ' )!!)# - ( !* ()
)''
"")C "#0)"",0)"$%(')" $?
"#*
"
')
*!)*6>7945;6* !*
>2;")"=47=45;6 ( )"C "#0)"",* ,' "@ .=
$0
() ,)@.!)",8) ! ,"( )",+'
*$% (')" +'?
"#,,"*)"8(,(0)1 ,') !)1#
()(!')--(),((0))
*(!(*8)
",')") (8)"!
-(
')"(-*( )# () ( C "#0 )" ", - ( ')" +' ?
"# ,,"* )") $,0 0$"" @ .=*() $ )
#"+)'"%*$ " ),%*)"*)
,(*('"
!!"), + ( 0!
#" +", * ) $,)0 ,, '% ! ,"
)#) (!(*$%( ) %) ( $'8 $3%)*%8)&&$?$-4:*749$3=)'$%,=>:%%:)*%
; () -C,#()$+0)"
$0
* $ +% 0!'*) ,() * ,( )$)@, -C ",
$%( +' ,,"*)(( #(#)-0-,4= ()%)) '')# 00)"
# ') ,*4524 -
(B(,B *!+ 8(-*$,)0@),"()-
!
"
""
!
"
#
$
""
!%& 5 ,))"#-()$+@),"!+ *0)1 ,') !)1# *() !,-)% ')"*( +' $)"@, C ",+*8((,, '% 0)"+", $%( ) %) ( $'8*",')()(
')"
) ')"
*)"*$ $+
'%( ( )(() )+)'"#(*')" )() ),0!'8 (- (*8()"!)", +!
)'-(C)0)$)"* ) )!!)#(%)45>9)"45>2*+)' ()) ()
* (,
,,""(!')"
*$ ) ,(')-?8))
* #+( !",
*$,0#)
#"(
')"
) )
$ 8(() )- (-',-( $#)
(,8(), 0$),-( !)%#,()1)D 477/.
!%) - *(! -')8*) 8) )!!',)$'( )#- )-(.
(, #'#) * (*) ,)"
,>-B(,B*!+ 8(-)@),"()- '(% !" # #$ $%
&&"
) " "
"
"
"
!
"
"
"
"
%
* !
!%
+ "
) * "" "" ,
-
"
.
.
.#
/
0
#$ &" '$ '""
( ) # &" $*(
"$
$"
"
$"
**"
"*"
$"
+, !((#"
** -
."#( /
1
$"
"& !((#"
** -
."#( /
120
'""
$
( ) # &" *"
$
'"()"
%" $
**"
"*"
' $
&%*"
"
,% &%*"
$#"
"3 ""
#
$"
(
")" "
"" &%,("
$"" 4
"
" *1 2
)345%6
*8$&$*-$(&3;*8&)>49$3=)'$$@4&3-4$(%434,4)&A<&)':%:)*%
47 )"#--53,%$!::#)80,=0$-4:)*!#)849$3=)'$ $@4&3-4$( %434,4)&A <&)':%:)*%2 ,)@ ( ")8* ) -, () ( #(* ( 8( ) ('"# , '+)# !
- ')"
-0()46%) 00")'% !,"#(,0#-,-(, !) *$,)00!8"
)+-0+ 0(
( ')"
$ " #)"
) ')"
*$ %8() ) %!.,"*()
,( )
#0-')"
) )($#8( ( ,,"*0)1#!)%0-( 44
- * ,()$+!.,"*)#) + 0- ( )(
!) +)'"$ ),,0!' ("* $% ( ,," (-* , ( !
!"!",
-(!*:)(%))
8) ) !)%0-(
(
*(
,,
*,),')0($--)
(, 8((!
+8-,')
-
$ , = -,>-B( ,B% (
*8((%, '"$,08''0!8",')0( $--()$+-" ) %!+ ")8)%'+)# -0*%'%-('+)!",
*$ ! 4597('"#(" !
"')"
) %8( !)%0- )'%* 8( ( ,,"* 8) ! 4597 ( #(('"#(" !
"')"
) ) $ ( !)%# )-") 477/.!%)(
*8($+
'%( )")!! !",
*'%()")'0")
#0+(" !
"
')"
*)
,(*(
,,
*,),')0($--( )$+@)," ) %!+ *,)(%,')0()(
')" )+"-0+ 0(
46
, A ,* ,,4=-B(,B8) "
( #()'# ')+)0"0$#0)"( #(,=>- 45<>*(-*)%" !
*) ') ')"
*8(()
$@!','%@!
"( )" " ) %!+ *$ $)"$() "$",""$%( +' ,,"
')'%(C "#0)" ",0)"$%( +' * 6>7945;6* '' )" +"* )"* $ )!'% ",')" $ ,0!''%, A )' $4:4:)*$&93%*)4=$$*3=5$4)<&)'$49349$;3%53;8,5%,--$%%)& :*:*4$&$%4)8)*$13*9:A3 3%%
4= , ( () )
#" )% ),% ( "#0 )" ", - ( +' * ) $,)0 0)"* 6>7945;6*)") $,00$""@ .=(
*$+
'% )%",'))(*()( (')8- '8-(" !
"
')"
,0!''%+"*)"(!(*(
*" ('"
)%+ #-)%#(*' +( )0+* ( #((!(,),')0)'0" *) )
*(!')"
*$ +( )",')0, '"$8''
"*'%8(*(8) )$'$#-(
--,+",*$ " !')%# () ( 8) +)'"'% )!!" ) )
,,
$% (
!",
*:)(%))
4> 8+*) )!'%" ,
"$%$(() ( $'8
,(+",@ ,"(-*(! ! ,)+,')0)'0" ,"
,,
(
')"
* $ -0( !
!"!",
*:)(%))
)!!) *()(#)$-(C ",)'%+"C "#0)"", -(')" +' ,,"*) $,0 ,' "@
.=*(!() )1!'"#(
!! *)"*() )'
")8)') !,(-*$ ( )"), ),0!''% )(,)'(!
!"'0"#)*8(,((, '"
,,"* ) ,() *$#,0!''%)#) (,())$'!
! *-( #)*) $,)00)"-)+ -( !
!"!",
:*35&($& 49
)-0)(*( " -")%0(8 !*)"*8(()$+$ +) *( )0 " 0
"( 0!
#"" ))--0")"0))" 42 (+0-)%))),"()%))) .
+))%#,*6747 - (*()--) B(,- 6747B *-"7>476747E%+ -!+ -( ,*( +0() !))%#8(,( ,0! "-)') @ )"
-(+0- + )" ) ))#0 !)0*$),)'E" !)0*#, ' )'!)0* ), !)0* 0)'
$)"% )" )%# !)0* +'!0 )" ),()%) !)0 +* ( , )' - ',* ( , )' 0)'
$)"% )"
! )+ -00)'F'-)E)"- ")*$ " (.
--,)'0$ *$,00)"( $%(+0*-0 )0# 0$ ! ## ")%)))C%)) ()') )#(*)"*-0( +0#)G)
*8( )#)#"81#8)"
'-!,)"! +)- ,8 (,4>-(,-6747')% "8(- , - ()%#*'+)!8(-* )"
@),"()-&.
# "
"
"
7
- "
#
"
# " " "
/
# "
" " "
"
"
"
"8
# " "
"
"
"
" "
" "
"
- 8 "
"
! "
9 " "
8
"
"
9
"
"
! " "
"
"
# "
"
" " -
#
" "
" # " "
-
"
# " "
"" "
" "
"" # "
"
- "
"
""
- " "
-
-
--- --- --- --- -#
" 8 "
" 8 "
"
- -
--- ---- --- -- 4< !
)' - ( )$+ (8 * () ( ,* 0!
$'#)()%#*81-(8'-)-(,8 *$ "
!+ (81-()!! +*(%#
$'#" ")1 !
-( ,-,
-"
#)" - ,8*(
- (),#( '%*( !(-)#, ' ,'
"# '-'%*$.#%*$.#) *$.-'G*$.! ," )"(- , *) * 0)"( 4; (+0-)%))() )'
),")%)) ) +) ( ))1 () )" )
)0+)"() ,* 6749 - ( ()--) B(,-6749B ,6 , -(,
!) *!+" ("--,8*!+ 8(- @),"
()- 6 ( ,* '
(,@(8 A *.
) @@@@@@ $ @@@@@@ '6 *"
( " ,((0 ,(( 30
$""
(
,("
""
,"
'4 45 ) ) (() )'
$"-",6 # -(,
!) *) ,8- !#% (0*,47-(,
!) * !+" () +0 ,)' ( 8( ","* ()'' )$' () ),,!*1!*0)))",) ("+"
)'*C "* )%)" .,0,,8 )'
(
) %$'#)-(+0!+")"A )-),)'
)",(,)'
!!
,(
-)) -), -( ,) ),,"*(,
%- ()"#+(!
-(9 /@ #)!)-( ! ')"
* ( ! /)#,% ,,"* )$' (# )"
0))#( *) $,)
( 8) ! (')"*( #($'##()0),()%)8+* ,( )0),()%),,"*0)%$$ 8(-),)', ) * 0))#)"0))(9 /('
*+8-()$+ ,*)" ,)#()$+ )"%#*8(,( 0)-
# (),8 ))"(
")$'%0))#" *$ " -
#()(8( 'G"-($--(,00 % +* 8( ( )%)) ) 8) %#* !
" 8( !
' -),)' , * ($% -
# () ( ) % $'#) ,) !( )"%# "$,0 )0'"$,0 - ''%#)'+)G"*(
-),(+#(!
! -8(,(( )"
%# )$' ("(-*( ( "B(,-6747B )" B( , - 6749B ) "," " ,()# ( ) % $'#) 8)"
(,8 * )
() )"" )% ,)'@ 8(()-)%))*)(
,( )"")" )% ,)' ) ('" 9 * )" )'
--, -),)'
, ) !
+%" ( % ! ,,"* (
)$' (#(9*(
-!
+%#()$' ,)#+#
(,8 (
"(9 64
')'%)",
"( %# )$' ("
" , = - B( , - 6747B " ,()# ) % $'#) )")'
!1!)"0))(! 9*)
@ #)!)-(!')"
*$ " ( @ #8( ()-)%))
66
(0* ( %# )'
","0))(
) , )$ ( )%)" )"",)'@ #8((% -()-)%))*)"*()- )$' (9-( ,8 $#(
"('
*)''((@! -( !1!
)"0)),-(9*)")'
-(,8 (
"(* )","$
"$!
+%"$%(%#*(! #+0)'#)G) *8()#)#"( (' , 81 - )$' (# 9
(
0) - (
# ( )"")" )%)"" ) "$+ 6= ! "-8()- )"", 6> ") , ,(0),) '-() $ ",""* (
* )'' ( !"# )!!',)
* - )%* )'
)"
" ! "- !00 1# !1/ # + 1)+ #(
9$49$&%<$36:*7B&$3%)*$(
$%B)
9$49$&&$<)&43=5$
$%B)