High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/959/2008disposed of

Savitri Devi And ORS. v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2021-08-09Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill5 pages

#$ %&'( &) * '

+,-,*%. /0 %1 &0

'%2&1* 3333344&55 6&1*,* /%%&'(, 78

'%2&1* 33333 &*4'

+ 9: /3 / :/ :: 1&*& %+ 13*2 *2/ -2. 0')%&('1%2&44&55 %*3 1382;5/ -2 55. ., 783 <<< :/ ::.3 2 *=%%&1 *8& -%>& ,4('12&1 -%21',-20 &')'

(&1& )

,&%'',%81&>'(%2&4

&= ).

1;&1 %2&445 )% '

*('145) -'

1&)'1 =&

)5),5% '

*2&&% '( =', % '( )'=4& 3 /=& * %>& '

1&)'1 *,87&)% %' 7,*% &?)&4% '

*3 445 )% '

* '(3

1;&1 %2 *445 )% '

*('1

*4'*5'(%2&44&5 %2&5 -2%'( 7, %* '( %2& '

@85& /,41&=& )',1%

# $ !

'% )& %2 *445 )% '

A* **,& 333 2&=%%&1A* 7',1 %'& 85&5&1 *&5('1%2&/%%&%'-'%21',-2%2& *51; *5 4'(%2& 3 % * %'8& '%& %2% %2 *44&5 A* 1&)%& %'8& 5 *%& ('1( 52&1 -'

33!0 &'1 &1 !33!4**& ! !3:&1 *&5('1%2&/%%& *, 85&%' ;%2%%2&4'* % '

'( 5A*445 )85& %2 *)*& *)1;*%55 *& %2&5 -2%'(01 ',*7, %*'(%2& @85&/,14&=& ',1%*=& % '

8'0&3

))'1

-5;.%1&B,&*%'(5&1 *&5('1%2&44&55 %

A %2 )'

*& %'(5&1 *&5('1%2&/%%&.44&5 *%>& '1 ('12&1 -%'

; %*&5(3 445 )% '

* '(3 &!'( ()

1&*& % 44&5 2* 8&& ( 5& 8; %2& )5 = %* ('1 & )&=& % '( A1 8; %2& 5&1 '%'1 )) 5 =* 1 8, 5.

-12"2&1& (%&11&(&11& %'*%2&91 8, 59$'

%'( &%2'(,1

0 &A1 333 1 &( ()%* &)&**1; ('1 7, )% '

'( %2& )*& 1& %2% %2& 44&55 %*C)5 = %* 3&3 A 'A. )2 5 1&

='%2&1 '( %2& ( 5& 4&% % '

&1 /&)% '

'( %2& '%'1 6&2 )5&* )% *&&> - )'=4& '

% '( &%2 '( ,1

!33. ='%'1 0&2 )5& )) %. ),*& ,&%'1*2

&-5 -& 1 0 -'(%2&'((&

-0&2 )5&. 3&3D,5 *)1 8&1 -1&- *%1% '

'3 !E8;1&*4'

%'3E3 :&1 5 '

* &1 - %2& &0 )& '

1&)'1 . ()%*

) 1),=*% )&* )'

)5, %2% ,1

. = %%& 5; &=45';&& '(

-12

,*%1 5

',1 *= &0&5'4=& '14'1% '

: = %& "

$ A'1> -%/2 05 >6 &A. %2&)) %A2 )2%''>45)&'

!33

,&%'1*2

&-5 -& 1 0 -'(%2&'((&

-D,5 *)18&1 -1&- *%1% '

'3 !E8;1&*4'

%'3E3:&1 5A2 5&))&4% -%2% -1'** *51; '( A* *3EC. 2&5 %' 8&

*3.EEC4&1='

%2.(%&1*,8%1)% -01 ',* *

A1 *,='(

*3..CA %2 %&1&*%%%2&1%&'(3 F4&1

,=(1'=%2& %&'(( 5 -'( %2&)5 =4&% % '

% 55 %&'()%,51&5 *% '

'(%2&A1 3& '(CE1 A* &((&)%& .>&&4 0 &A%2& ,=8&1'(

%*3,5% 45 &1'(A*445 & *%2& A*;&1*'5 %%2%% =&3

% '

55;.*,='( *3 C'

% '( 5'** '( )'

*'1% ,= A* A1

*,= '( *3 C ('1 %1 *4'1%% '

)21-&*3 --1 &0& '( %2& B, %,= '( )'=4& . )5 = 20&( 5& %2 *44&53 :&1 )', *&5 ('1 %2& 44&55 %* *,8= %* %2%

2* 8&& A1'

-5; **&**& * *3.EEC 4&1 ='

%2 8; %2& 5&1 1 8, 53& *'

01 ',*)', %***2'A %2&*51;*5 4'(%2& 20& %' 8& )5, 2 * )'=&3 ,1%2&1='1&. %&1=* '( 7, % '( %2& *$

-- (. )1&=& % '

))', % '( (,%,1& 41'*4&)%*%%2&1%&'( F*2',5 8&(('1 3 '=4& %'(5'** '( )'

*'1% ,= &%)3 * 5*' *',-2% %' 8& & )& 3 % *. %2,*. 41;& %2% A1 %'%2&)5 = %*8&1&A'1>& ))'1

-5;3 :&1 )', *&5 ('1 %2& 1&*4'

% *,1 )& )'=4 ; A2 5& 1&(,% - %2& 1-,=& %* 1 *& 8; 5&1 *&5 ('1%2& 44&55 %**,8= %*%2% &B,%&)'=4& 2*8&& A1 8;%2&5&1 5A2 )2)55*('1

' (,1%2&1 & )&=& %3 % * *,8= %%& %2% )'=4& 2* 8&& 1 -2%5; **&**& .%2,*. =4,- A1 338&,42&5 20&2&1 5&1 *&5('1%2&44&55 %*

20&-'

&%21',-2 %2&0 585&( 5&3 2&1& * ' *4,%& %2% ,1

5'*% 2 * 5 (& ,& %' 7,1 &* 1&)& 0& 8;2 = ='%'10&2 )5&)) %.A2 )2%''>45)&'

!33 ,& %'%2&1*2

&-5 -& 1 0 -'(D,5 *)18&1 -1&- *%1% '

'3 !E. 8; 1&*4'

% '3E3

- '( %2& 5&1 5 '

%2 * **,& 2* %% ( 5 %;3% *5*' '% *4,%& %2%%2& A*E;&1*'5 %%2& % =&'(%2&)) %.2 * %&'(8 1%28& -333 )'=&'(%2& 2*.2'A&0&1.8&& )'11&)%5;**&**& 8;%2& 5&1 5* *3.EEC4&1='

%23% *1&5&0 %%' '%&%2%1&)'1 '(%2 *

)*&A* = %%& 5;8,1 %2&( 1&A2 )2%''>45)&'

%2& -2)',1%41&= *&*

%2& ;&1 3 '4 &* '( %2& &?8 2 %* 8&('1& %2& 5&1 5 1& '% 0 585&A %2& %2&1'(%2&)', *&53'A&0&1.5&1 *&5('1%2&/%%&2* ) 1),5%& )'4;'(*51;*5 4'(%2& *'

!3331 %',%'(%2& *=& *%>& 1&)'1 *,87&)%%'7,*%&?)&4% '

*3*4&1%2&* *51;*5 4.%'%5 *51;'(%2& A* *3!.!C3& *= & %2&*51;'

%'( . &%)320&%'8&)', %& %'A1 * )'=&'(%2& 3%2*8&& 2&5 8;%2&'

@85&/,41&=& #

/ %2% ; * *2'A %2& *51;)&1% ( )%&* *%'A1 * .5 (& *,1 )&41&= ,=.1&4;=& '(5' *&%)3.*2',5 '%8&&?)5, (1'=%2& )'=&32&1&('1&. )'=&'(%2&

* **&**& * *3!!C 4&1 ='

%2 3&3 *3.. C 4&1

,=3 % * '

5;%2&)'=4'

%'( )'=&%?A2 )22*%'8& ,)%& 3 = %%& 5;. )'=& %? 5 8 5 %; ('1 ( ) 5 ;&1 . **&**=& % ;&1 ('1 )'=& 8&%A&& *3..C %' *3 ..C * F3 2&1&('1&. %? 5 8 5 %; '( %2&

A',5 8& *3 433A2 )2 *'80 ',*5;*&%'(- *%%2&4&1= ** 85& *%

1 *. %2,*. )'=& * **&**& * *3!!C 4&1 ='

%2 3&3

*3.. C4&1

,=3 0 &A'(%2&-, &5 &*'(%2&'

%2&)*&'( "*,41$. )1&=& %'

%'((,%,1&41'*4&)%*% %2&1%&'( F"

EC$ *(('1 .*%2& A*E;&1*'5 %%2&% =& '()) %.A2 )2%>&* )'=&'(%2& %' *3.

.!C4&1

,=3 0 &A'(%2&-, &5 &*5 'A 8;%2&'

)*&'(

"E$

0 5$. '(C%2 *%'8&445 & * ,=8&1'(

%* * (',1 "$. %2&1&8; 1&

&1 %' 8& *3..C" ! E!$3445;

-=,5% 45 &1'( .

);'(%2&)5 = %* ***&**& *

*3..E C "? $3 2& )5 = %*1&5*' & % %5& %' *3 .C &)2

('1 (, &15 &?4& *&*

5'** '( &*%%&3 2& )5 = % A 'A * & % %5& %'

*3.C '

))', % '( 5'** '( )'

*'1% ,=3 %&1=* '( %2& 7, % '( %2& / 0 *$

- ! - ) -- %%%

&) * '

3E3 '( %2 * 1$ $

2 $ . #$ . +%, -- 44&55 %*'3

E 3&3)2 5 1& '(%2& 1&& % %5& %' *3.C&)2 '

%'(5'**'(41& %5)'

*'1% ,=

44&55 %'3%' *3.C'

% '( 5'** '( ( 5 5 )'

*'1% ,=3 5 = %* 1&. %2,*. & % %5& %' %'%5 '( *3.!.E C &% 5& *,

&1+ :'**'(

);"? $

*3..E C :'**'(*4',*5)'

*'1% ,=

*3.C :'**'(41& %5)'

*'1% ,=

*3!.C :'**'(( 5 5)'

*'1% ,=

*3.C :'**'(&*%%&

*3 .C , &15&?4& *&*

*3 .4 5

*3.!.E C 2&=', %'()'=4& 51& ;A1 %'%2&44&55 %*. && 5&** %' *;. *255 *%

,)%& (1'= %2& =', % )5),5%& * 8'0&3 44&55 %* 1& % %5& %' %&1&*%%%2&1%&'(F4&1

,='

%2&& )& =', %(1'=%2& %& '(( 5 -'(%2&4&% % '

% 551&5 G% '

3 44'1% '

=& %'(=', %'()'=4& ='

-*%)5 = %**2558&

%2&*=&1% '*( ?& 8;%2&5&1 53 1&)% '

*'(%2&1 8, 5 1&*4&)% %'=

&1'( *8,1*&=& %'()'=4& =', %%'%2&)5 = %**255& ,1&3 H %2%2&8'0&* ='

( )% '

%2&=', %'()'=4& .41&*& 44&5 * '(3 ": * 55$ ,-,*%. , -& rts H2&%2&1*4&> -C1&*'

+ &*C' H2&%2&11&4'1%85& + &*C'