Chamkaur Singh v. Vishal Dhawan And Others


   
 



 !"# $%&%!'()*)+ 

              (  ,- ).
/0 1-  





   !" #   

  

 !" #   $

222 /0 1-3)

-  %
&'()%**%+,+) -

    #   #
)
  # "

"    .-  

## # #

0 # %! " #      .-     1  

0 %
 %+

2

3     

      .4"   4 0" 5  



0 %
  %+   "

%(
6
%+,+7 5

 #    " ++6 #    # *      +'

,( +,+7 8

0 %'9 

+ .-   #   1  81 

9 :  !

  "  

! .-   /#     ; 6 

#   #   "
&,< 8#  =

>9 # 4" #  

   

+

5 #"   

#  !

    

## 8    9

  

0 %
9 #  .- - # "

" # " # 

   

+,
6 0"        

  '  8#- " .

 

9  

 !   #      ?  5      " :  8

# #    =&4%5 '#>9

+ 5     

    @  " #  "  #  #  .#      5 " #  ! - ## +,++

 ; 6 

 8

0 %(9  ! .-   /#   # 4" #  

    

"  " #     +,++     ." . .- 

5    .- - #  - 8

0 %)9 

  !      

   @  .        #

#     @  " #    

  . ! .

(

A- - #  

       4" 

  #

# 

)

* !    "  #   

:  "  #     .   



   

. 2 .          - 0"  +,
6     # 0 # 0" #     7, +,
<   #   +6 +,+
       #  #  .-      2 # .      # 4   ! ""  .  @  " #  ! - #   +,++   .-     ." . .- 

"    #      - # 7, +,
<

  # 0 # 0" #   

:  "  .   - ."       

##     " #   

 "   4 

  #   "    "   "  "   "

#     

.46789 0 49:).7 ;&7 9.%'<73+ =

%:%5>

+ :  "  # .     

(&   ! .-   /#    "    - !

  " 0

 " ! .

 

 "    "  #   89  .      -



  2 .      # #

#      - . ! 

  


 " #    

  . ! . 2 # .       -    

##

(  ## 0  " #  +,++   #      . . .- 

2  .   !    ""  # ;*%
&   ## "-  .

#"

.

" #       . 0  .-  2 >.   # 2 "    #  0

   "     " ! .    +& +,++   " #  ## +,++ 

.-      

:  "  #   89 .    4     .-   "  #      ".   #" #    " 

"

 "   

#    0     # -  # " #  .

!

<

* ! "   .   .-   "  #   

&

5        ! . 0" 

+,
6 5    # 0" #     7, +,
<

  #   +6 +,+
 ""

 .- 

0 %
9 

  



 " # 5 "   #        % ?) 7   7  85 %'%""&  %' '#  !  "%5  &4%  "!9 8!&& &&%!'  @A  B A  !"  &8 $%"%$  8 9"!9;

'$  !" 

<9 ; '  !  & 55  5!'<  B%7  5 9'

%:  9 5% "  !"

9 $!: 9A '#"!9<9 '!"8 9;

' '%'C4'$%!') ) 7 7 $!49" %&'! :

%5 @5 !# A '# 7 9 $ '@  89!@5 ;!"5%;% %!'"!9"%5%'<7 &4%

) %'  $ &  7  85 %'%""&D 885%$ '& B %  "!9 89!$49%'< $!49" 3B7%$7%&'! :

%5 @5 !# A)   %&3  7 9 "!9 3  89 A #  7   7

885%$ '&D85 %'%""&;

A85 & @  55!B #!"%5 &4% B%7!4  ""%E%'<  #:

5!9 ;  $!49  "  '#  %  %& 4'# 9 6 '@A7  885%$ '&7 7 AB!45#;

7 <!!#!"7 $!49" D ""%E #7 $!49"  & '# B7 ' :

%5 @5 "9!;7 & ;8: '#!9&!"7 
!49)F
,

 #  #       .

  #   # #

 

 " #    

! . #   ! 

 %

#  "

"

!

(&    ##"    #  " #

 %  

 " 

    - ""

  "-

 #   ". !

5

#   ##"    #  "  "      %   -

 "  # 

#  #  

5     "  

##/      # "

"-

" # !

  
,  -  

##/    "-       #  0 (/)     " #  ! - ## +,++ *   . .

          - 4   " #

# " #

+

 

 "   . .

      # ;*%
&   "

5 "  !  4 "

 +,+
      !  "

1 - +,++ B!

# 

 # 0 # 

 "   "     .

    #  .-     "

 .    . " -   5   

       ## "



   

##  ## 0  " # 5    

"

 

#     " 0"

 .-    

7

5 4





      "   " #    #

 "   

  " #       . !      .     # "

 " # *     "

" "   "

 A "   - ."        

 # -  # " #    4 #-         . . .- 

(

 #  #  #"   "

" " #  " *   #

  - 

   ""

-   

)



89 #  -      #

/%69 ;<< 9B 5  4#< . 8 ;@ 93+ 4

 C 

/   D/$ C . D/$