High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2660/2016dismissed

Sunil Kumar And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2022-02-03The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli17 pages

CWP No. 2660 of 2016 (O&M) 1

" #$% & '()*

+,-,.&&/0( ( 2(,( +& &3&&&/0( (4/(

()5 $ +&/4+0&.&6/'&6 04( $ 7,$&6// /'&&6&3&&80 $ +&,&90$&:6(((&/'&&&3&&6 80$( -,(0&/4-&,6/'&6 0(4/( "0 & (&/ 4(' ( 9: '// 0,:0 / ' ': (' 0 4'/:(&9:'/,'/,&,% ;;;; 0&:'0(&((&04'(( &'<,(0,:0 '.4/8&39&'7/0&8&/&,'/,/('!! 0=&/ '<,( ' !>?@ /&/ !

* !??*6 0 4( 0& 7/ 0 8 A,(/' 0( ,B & '.: ' :0 & .4(&&/&(4&'30=&/'<,(6 0&9&&/

(.' !*"0& /&( !*'%8

!@6 93 : 0 4( 4 0 3& !

B 093 '&.: 0& 0 &'<,( &/ <,& 0 (0& &: -0&(& CD E! "5 5 %(,&/ & 2&: (&.4,6 (' ,:& 0&( &4(/ 8 (' % !*')934(3'/:0&00&(9,&0,( 80'0(',/904((((&/0'.4(& 0

CWP No. 2660 of 2016 (O&M) 2 &'<,/&/8&(04&//4(/0 ',&/&( (,'06900':'(4//,/+' % ' !* &(&( /

04,(& 04&/:(&0&0& ./&/ 8&( &'<,// '&(((,/,/(' @ &/ !>?@ ' /&/

* !??&/!?

* !??!(4'3B 8/930&8&/,/ ('!! !>?@'/&/!

* !??*6 04,9'4,4(&.3 /4.&/,F& &/ (/&6'..'&6(,& &/.&&' 4(4&',:&&(404&44&/,/ 0&3&& 9&4.,03'6!?DD 0&(9'// 0& 0 &/ <,(6 & 0,( 8&( 9, 80'0 ( ( 0 4(((( 0&( ,0 9 '// 0& (4 0 &' 0& 0 &'<,( 4'/:( 8 '.4/ 8&3 9&'7 0 3& !??* 9, 0 0 4(((( 0 &/ 80'0 0 0,( 0&( &( 9 '(,'/6(&7(0'.4(&4&/0. &.40&( &(9.&/4A'0'&( /('.&93'/:0&0 (,,/:&/0&(&&/39&(/ .

&'<,(680&(0( '&(0&(09&(/00&(9'.4(&/ 0&/&( 8&(0(,', 7:04(( (' % !*'6 0&(9'//0&0:(&,0&(&'/0(&/4((93 4/:/.: '80'04/( /./&4(:6'&(60 0':'3&(4//,/(' % !*'((&( / 80&( 0( '&( 90 0 ':'( & , / &/ (&( / &/ 0,(6&'&((.

CWP No. 2660 of 2016 (O&M) 3 4'/:(60'(0&&(9.&/&(:&/(&( &/ 0&/8(&/ :&:'((80'0&:/3.&7(, &'&( /('.& * (,44 0 '&.6 0 &' 0&( 9 4&'/ 0 A,/:. 4&((/ 93 0 G9 +,4. ', /& '&( H

!" #!'/0&0(.&(,&&/80 0/:0&04&3..&/&(,3'&90/9<,& '.4(& 4&/ &/8(E 4(( (/6 0 G9 , /'/0&'<,(4'/:(0&&4(/ (/(60&'0&( 94&'/&,(A,/'&4,'.(80'0'&.94&((/ &&4'.: ' ' !* $%%&'

) * +

' @ 0 8 4 '&. ,4 0&: 9 0( , !

80930' .8&(((,/ ,:04/'3 0 4 & /: 0& 0 G9 +,4. , /& ( (F/ 0 '(3 ,4/ &( :&/( 0 4& ('

% !*'600&:04(.&8&(/ /&8& 0 /'( 0 (, '0 0 G9 +,4. , /& 80'0 '&. 9 /'// * +

0 4,.& 4&&:&40 .0'(,9'0A,/:.&3:/80:,/:4'4(( 4/,'/098)5 /0 1

" "

2 2

2 &

2 2

CWP No. 2660 of 2016 (O&M) 4

% &

%%22' 3

&' 2

" &"2

2 #- 2 & ! % /(

" & %

& /( /( 4 2 5

! %

2 2 '

2 & &*

& &

' 2 &

" 2

! 2 4 5 2 7

" & %

8 ' 2

&2 % "

2 2 2 5 2

2 #-

& %

& !

$5 2 #- &22

& 97 2 "

2 5 * 27 %

8 '2 22'

! &

:% :

2 2 25 2

2 #- ; * &

" 7'

7 2 4 & ' &'

"$% %

2 %

2 2

" 2

! .

& 2

" 2

" &"

CWP No. 2660 of 2016 (O&M) 5 < 2

" &'% 25

= >% &

2 #-

" # 2

" 2 2 &

' 22 ' &2

! 2 25 %

4 2

&' & 3

22' -

% 2 5

'2 2 5

22 2

% % 5

' 2 2

2 2

2 5 ( (('60(,'0 0G94I, 0&( '&/ 0 ',/( /,9 <,& 0 8/( J4&/K (' %6 J/4(/K'',:04((' %&/&/08/JK ,(/980900':'( (' % 0'

!*&(JK&(J&/K +.&360I4((J403('&4((((K '',:0.&('0&(&(9'& /.&J/&8: 4&'0&.&KEJ &4& F&.'0&K 0&(9'3(&F/0& (7: &4(:6900':'(80&9(&( / &/4'4(&( &//8930G9+,4.',&'3(&F/&(,/)5 "&% & 0( '&(( 80 0 &'<,( 4'(( 0&/ 9 &/9,0&8&/0&(9&,'/,/('!! 0' !>?@60/& '..'. 0'

!* !

!@6 0 ( &4( 4'/:( &/ 0

CWP No. 2660 of 2016 (O&M) 6 (&. 8 ',6 086 80 0 / 0& 0 '.4(&0&(9/./,/04(( ' !* 0('&((800&8&/,/('!! 0' !>?@0&(9&,'/4'..'. 0' !*604(( 0' !*8,/0& 9&: &44'& &/ 0 4'/:( 8 ', (4' 0( '&((6 &( 6 0 ' !>?@ 0&( 9 4&/ "9% 0 8/ HG ,(/ 98 0 90 0 ':'( (' % 0' !*(9&/&(/(&(/( 80'0.&(0&(7&4(: 0&'<,(4'/:( 900':'(.,(9 , / $&:09360& 0 4(((( 0&/ 9 &7 9, 0 '.4(& 8&( '/608,/9&4( +.&36 '.4(&0&( 9&''4/9,04((((0&(9&7608,/ 9 &4(:

2 -- !.!

" 2

8 " "'% ( & &( 0 &(4' '.4(& 0 &/ &'<,/ ( ''/60G9+,4., /&0&('&:'&3 9(/ 0& 0 I4(( 4&/ 0 .& 4& ('

% 0 ' !* /( ',/ & /4( '.4(&', 0&(<,/94/(0&0 '.4(&&.,8&(//80'00&(9I4&/

!0&0/: 0&.,8,/.&0&0 &.,(.&/&&&90&/8&/0&8,/9& /('0&: 09:&.&704&3.&/0& (,'0&4('&94&F/ 0/ &,.&7:0

CWP No. 2660 of 2016 (O&M) 7 4&3. 0 :('*!"!%6*!"

%6*@ 0' !>?@&/'.4&:0.8004&&.&&4(( ('D!&/> 0' !*60G94I, 0&( '& / 0& 0 3 '(<,' 54&3. '.4(&(.&704&3. (&(4(' *@ 0' !>?@ 0G9+0&( ,0'& / 0& ' 0 4&3. '.4(& 0&( 9 /E// ,/ (' *!"!%6 0 &'<,: &,03 '&94&F/ 54&3.&(0&.,0&(.& ,4&//, ,(&&''4930&/8 '& 3 ,06 0 +,4. , 0&( ,0 9(/ 0& & &/8 0&( / 0 ' 0:0 '.4(& 0 '&'&.0&08&(4&/0&., "/% 0 &/: 0 4( (' @ 9 4& ('

% 0' !*60+,4.,0&('& /0& '&(6 0 4&3. 0&( 9 .&/ 9, /4(/6 &93 4&3 &., &: 80 ( (,9(( &/ /4(/ .&A3 0/:( 3&( .6 '.4(& ,/ 0 ' !* 0&( 9 4&/ 0 &/8( &( 0 /& '& &/ &'<,( ,/('@ 0' !>?@ :&/:0/4(60&( 9 '& /

0 A,/:. 0& 0 0:0 '.4(& 86 0 .3 (0,/ 0& 9 /4(/800=&/'<,('0&(,3 0 , 80 (4' .&A3 &/ 0/:(6 .&:093 8&(/4(/&3 00./( 80 (4' .&A3 0/:(6 0 0:0 '.4(&

CWP No. 2660 of 2016 (O&M) 8 8 869,(,/('*@ 0' !>?@ 8,/90'(<,' "% ( :&/( 0 ./ &7: 4((((6 0 +,4. , 0&/'& /0&/&8: <,(4E..&/,.8,/ .& 0& 403('& 4(((( 0&( 9 &7 0 &8 80 :&/(: &/0&('&:&9&/0/0& '04((((0&(9&7,/('! 0' !>?@60&/(0+&&/0'&9&3/(: &4(:

" % 0'.4,:0:&44/ 3&(980/& &8&/&/'..'. 0' !*6&3./ (,9((:(9I',//80'0.&(0&& I',/:0 ./6045<,(:&44/ C3&((06 04(( (' %'&97/ ":% 0G9,0&( ,0'& /0& 0&'<,( &/0&/&9'0&:/&/0&'<,(8&(,40/6 80'0 .&( 0 4'/: (/ '',//6 0 ,.9& 4' (' % 0' !*'&97 &(/((&&/.9&/'&.( "0% 4&& **D6 0 G9 , 0&( .&/ '& 0& 0 4( (' % 0 ' !* ( .& 9 7/9309 '&( &/8(808'// (&0. ((,&' '&,/('@ 0 ' !>?@ 3 (,9(<, 4,'0&(6 0/ 08(6'&704(( (' % 0 ' !*

CWP No. 2660 of 2016 (O&M) 9

0&: : 0 A,/:. 4&((/ 93 0 G9 (,'06 80(/'(60&:04('&(8&(74 4/:684'/(0 &',&.&I 0(&'&(0 & (&/4'4(&//8930G94I, 8/ (6<,'((&3.0&0'&(&0&/60(0438&( /90& &0(4/( @ *

!093 ,:&0 '&.(4, 09304(&/,64&3/ /(.((& 0 8 4 93 (4' '&3 '/: 0& 0 &/ <,( ( 3 .,'0((&&'004,9'4,4( 80'08&(&'<,/( .,'0(6& '(0( !4( .&&6 (&/( !.8/6 &(40(&'/&3,4& 0'/&(0&(4 0&: '/043604(0&'0( &34'&&/ 0,(0 &'((&/08(&.0&:,59,/ ?

@7 $ 7, $&6 &/ //& /'& & &44&: 0(4/(4/0(&:,.(93'//0&0 4(0&&44&'0/0(',80'&0&/((.,'0(03 &:,3 ''&. &',. 0'(,'/4.&(,: 5!5 &: -0&(& CD E! (&/( &&/3 &(/ . 0 &'<,(&/(0&'&4' &/80'08&(&'<,/ ,0 &:,/0&0(&/''&.04& 04(.&70 .&& / '3(& '& 0&( ,0 &:,/ 0& 0,:0 0 4 0&( 9 / (7: &4(: &'<,( 4'/:( ,/ (' % ' !*9,3&&.40&(9.&/(,40 4& /('.&&(8&&9(,3&:,.& 0&80( :&/(8(/0&04& 4&3E/('.&'&9&(/ & /&3 &/ ,0 0& '&. 4&3E/('.&6 90 &

CWP No. 2660 of 2016 (O&M) 10 <,/ 9 3 (.&3 4&'/ 9, /'&3 4&'/ +' 0 4(//:&3/('4 0&/&/0&/8&/ &(0/&800(&/&(8&(.&/6(,'0&:,4&( 80&:930(', > 0 : 0 436 0&( 9 &:,/ 0& 0 4(((( 0&/<,(8&(&7/&4&5F&.'0& * * /&/!

* !??* 0&&8&/.3 0&/&'<,// 0&8&/<,(8&( (*@6@C6

@C DCE5&/, 6&&.,

( *!6?

6!C6??C @E5 (&/( /(9,(/ ( 0 &., 8&( &( /,3 // 9, 0 (&. 8&( &''4/ 93 0 &/8( ',/: 0 4( 0 : 0 &' 4&// 0 436 0&( 9 &:,/0&04604(0&(,4&'&( 0.0&: &0,(0&/&'<,/8003&(/:9,0(&/0,( 0&(9&(/ .0&'<,(80&( &' 0.&(0& , 0&/<,(60'(,'/&&.&(,:5!58&( &(/&/(30&'&&/680'00&(9&'<,/680'0 &'',( 04(<,/9/(.((/80I.4&3'( 0&: &44&'0/ 0( ', 9&(/ ,4 .((&. &/ .(4(& 0:&/0 &'0&0&/<,((3 .,'0((&&'004,9'4,4( 80'08&(&'<,/6 0&(9(&/0&&(404&:.&/6& '(( !4( .&&6 (&/( !.8/ ?

34&':&'04'4&//8930G9 +,4. ', /&6 $ $&0&(&:,/ 0& 0 4( 0&: 4&//8: &'(& /&0&(.&/&&.4.(&/0(', (&(&7,/,&/&&: 0/.: '4//,/('

CWP No. 2660 of 2016 (O&M) 11

% !*' 04(0&/9&3.&/&8:(&. 0&0&/&'<,/6030&&0,(80'00&(9&(/6 80&(0'(,'/&&.&(,:5!5I('&0. & 0&'<,(4'/:(0&/9&(/ 0&&( .&36 0 4(((( 0 &/ <,( 0&( &&/3 9 &7 93 /&8: &4& F&.'0& * * /&/ !

* !??* 0 &/ <,(&'<,/I',/:0'(,'/4 5!580'0 .( //4.,03"(,4&%((, ''(,0& 0403('&4(((( 0&/<,(0&9&7 + &&(0 <,( '.4(& 0 &/ <,( 9 4&/ 0 &/860G9+,4.,0&('& /0&I4((4&/ 0.&4& (' @"

% 0 !*'89/./9(&( / 0'.4(&&.,8&(//80'00&(9I4&/.& 0& 0 &., ( .&/ &&&9 0 &/8 &/ 0& 8,/ 9 /('0&: 09:&.&704&3. 0/60&:,/0& 0&'4&'/9304( ,$,'4&4&"(,4&% (&( 0404(&(0(&/A,/:.0&(9I4((3 ,/0(&. &&*

/4.,03"+,4&% !

&7: ,06$ $&0&(&:,/0&('08/JK '',:900':'(./0.&(' @"

% !*'0&(9&/&(JE&/K6900':'('',: 80&9.&/&3 , /&/0&8004<,(:&4 4/ C3&(.980/& &8&/&/'.: ' !* ' 80'0 .&( 0& 0 (&E&,03 ( <,/ /.(&0&&3.4 :&44/ C3&(604((((0&( 9&793/&8:04&'0&.&0'.4(&(//6 8:&0'&. 0&/8 &4(:,E( @"

% !*'

CWP No. 2660 of 2016 (O&M) 12 ,0&:,/0&0&/<,((3.,'0((&&'0 04,9'4,4((.,'0(0&/(&(& '/&/&3&(E /'&& &4(:8&/(3& '04&:.( &3, 4& +

0&:9(8/,0,:0 ,'(/&0& '&.( 4, 0 93 0 '.4: 4&(6 0&: : 0,:0 0 (4'4&/:(&/ 0 A,/:. 4&((/93 0 G9 '(, '0 0+,4., /&68& 0'(//40& 0(&4/((9/(.((/ .0&&( 0 (&'&(6(0'&:'4&//(&/ 0(&0&04(((( 0&/<,(0&(&&/39&78&39&'703&!??* 93 &4& F&.'0& * * /&/ !

* !??* &/ 0,(6 0 &/ <,( (&/( (/ 0 +& & &/ 4,4(( 0 4:08/J403('&4((((K60G9+,4., /& 0/ 0& 0 '/: 4&'0&.& ( &/ ./ &7: 4((((&/I4&/0&'04(((( &/(&760&/ (0+&&/ 0& 04(((((&/930(80 &/8&304(689390'&4&'3 (4&(( &/89&&&9 0&/8'&.0&04(((( 0&(G9&7 .0.&/0&0((84(((( 0 (&' '&(6 0,:0 ''&/ 93 0 4( 9, &( (&/ 93 0 (4/(6 I',/: 0 '(,'/ 4 5!5 &/6 0 4(((( 0 (E.&: &/ 8&( &7 93 &4& F&.'0&6 0 680&0(&0/0&0403('&4(((( 0 &/<,((&/(&7&/0,(6(&&&904(

CWP No. 2660 of 2016 (O&M) 13 '/0&0((4(((( 0&/<,(&/&''/:36 0':'3'',:(' % !*':( !

0,:0 .( 0 4'4 &/ /8 / 4.,03"+,4&%6& 0&:9'//0&4(((( 0&/<,(0&(9&760((0/ 0&/ 0 4(( &0('&. &4(:9:(,:0,E( @"

%9,(('6 04(0&(4' '&3&704&0&0'.4(& 0 &/<,(0&(094&//4(/9 0 ' ,688,/7(0(' 04(0:0 0 4'4( &/ /8 / 4. ,03 "+,4&% ( .4&0:0:000&0G94I',804: 0 8/ H4&/G '',: +'5 % &/ 0 8/ H/4(/G ,(/ 4( +' @ "

% !* ' 0&( 3 '&:'&3 9(/ 0 .&:&/ ' 90930/:0&08/H4&/G/(',/ /4(&/'&(60&.,0&(9//609:&4&3( , / 0& 8,/ '(, .& J/ 0 &.,K 0&( 9 I4&/ && *.&0&0&.,(E8&(.&/&&&90 &/8 &/ 0& 8,/ 9 & /('0&: 0 9:& .&7 0 4&3. 8 0&9680&0(&0/0&0'&( 0&/60'.4(&8&(/,3//9,04('0( &''40(&.&/0,(60(&0&('&3/('0&:/(9:& .&704&3.&/0,(60('/':'3&44&:(' @ "

% !*'&(:(( &&(0(&''&((''/ !* (:&/(04& &( &/ &, 0&/ 8( ( ''/6 8 '/ 0& 0 (&/ 4& 0&( 9 &(/ & &9(,3 &:, .& 80 4&',&( 80& ( 0&( 9 : 0 &8 0( :&/ ( 8 (/ 0& (3 0 4&

CWP No. 2660 of 2016 (O&M) 14 /('.&E4&3 ( 9 &(/6 ( <,/ 9 &(/ 80 0 '( 4I.3 0 &7 4&'6 9&(/ ,4 80'0 0 /('.&E4&3(9:(,:09&:/ $6& 4&((: 0A,/:./4.,03"(,4&%(4'&30/: 0&0403('&4(((( 0&/<,(89'(,/9 &7 .0/& /&8:04&'0&.&E&4&5A&.'0&/(5( 0+&I'(048(0/,/+'@> 0!>?@' 0&8(&(8(/0&0&/<,(((0+&& &7:(4((((&/0(&.'&9/(/ +& ('',( 0(:&/'.

( ( 0& & &7: 4(((( 0 &/&'<,/60 +&'&&(0&/ .&'<,(&/0,(&34&9:&(/ &(0&/ .&'<,(93 :&&74&'4 '.: ' 08&'&/(4'&30A,/:.4&((/93 0 G9 +,4. , /& / 4. ,03 /&"(,4&%89'&3.(4&'/&/'&9&/ !

,0 ( 8 (/ 0& 0 9,/ 4 0 4& /('.& ( 0 4( &/ 03 0& 4/,' '' /'9 0,(080&0'&((/'&04(( 80(&/0&/9&(/ .0&'<,(4'/:( $393 (&:0&0(/('.&80, :&(8080.0 4(0&9/('.&/&/&(.&3(,&/0(&/ 8(680(&/0&(9&(/ 0 /: /('.&'& 9'//.309&(( &:,&/9/&(((&(0&(9 .&/ 93 0 4( 0 (& 8 4 0 ' 0( :&/6'&9.&/0A,/:. 0G9+,4., /& 0'&(

&A 12*

- ;"< ; 8004I,0/&(,/)5

CWP No. 2660 of 2016 (O&M) 15

" !# $ !

" !

" # % # &

(("

)

*#+#++*

! ,-.

% # /

# "

# ! " %"

(

2 3

# "

# !

" !

" 4 0

! 5 #6 0 6 8 0 & (&/ 0 &:, &/ 9&/ &(((.&/9304(04& && !C $ 7, $& 0 (:0 0 &'( 4&// 0 8(&.0&(0.3'//0&0+&&'<,/0&/

CWP No. 2660 of 2016 (O&M) 16 0 4,9' 4,4( ,F& &/ (/&6 '..'&6 (,& &/ 4 (4&'6 '&& && ,:& &( 4 0 4& 44&/,/0&3&& 9&4.,03'6!?DD 0 4,9'4,4((&'0/93/&8:E&44:0&3,4& (40 &3,4&44&/ 0&'<,(<,(60&/<,(( 3.,'0((&&'004,9'4,4(&/& '(04&: ( ! 4( .&&6 ( &/( ! . 8/ 0& '(// 0( 4& &:,. &(/ 93 0 (4/( &/ 8 & '.4&:.800(&.&(0((&.4& &'974 ./80/&:800'&(&(:, 0&'<,( &/ &'004,9'4,4(&/(0(&E(&,0380(09( 4(/'/&9,,F& 0&/&'<,/6& 0&:9 (/+& !

0(&'&(604,(& 04&/:(.&/8 0'&:''&(4&//930+&6(,&.9:,,(3'&0&0 4( 0&( 3 ''&/ 0 &',. 0 '(,'/ 4 0&: 9 &(/ 93 0 &,0( 9, 0&( 4(3 .&/ 8: (&.0&0(9,,40,(0&(9&(/ 8./3(& <,&9 4(7:08A,(/'(,/&,8 '&'3(&, &'(9,'.4 &'( .04,(& 04&/:(6('3(&'&0&040&(&44&'0/0( ,80'&0&/(&/3, &'(8''&/6&00 .((&. 8&( .&/ : .4(( 0& 0 9, ,4 0,( '(,'/0&(9&(/ '&3/4'&0(7/ 4&'' &(0( &'&((, ':&0<,&9 9:4&3/ 8693'/:,&:,(068 &,((&7:,40(

CWP No. 2660 of 2016 (O&M) 17 ((, ,0 &/ .4( I.4&3 '(( 0&: ''&/&/ .((&/0 &'( !D ( & (<, 0 &9 /(',(( &/ 8 &8 (,..&F/ 4&& * * / 4. ,03 "(,4&%6 (4' '&3 & 0&: '// 0& 0 '&( 0&/6 0 403('& 4(((( 0 &/ <,( I',/: 0 '(,'/ 4 5!580'08&(&(/"0,:0''&/9304(%0&: 9 &76 (&( 3: /('0&:: 0 &93 .&7 0 4&3. '.4(& 0 &/ &'<,/ &/ &( '(/: 0& 0 &/ <,((3.,'0((&&'004,9'4,4(680& 0(&0/0&0(&'&(60(&0&( ,3/('0&:/( 9:&<,& 900 ':'( '',:(' @"

% !* ' &/ 9: (6 0 4( 4 .( /(.((& &/ 0'6 0 (&4(/(.((/ !> &: /(.((/ 0 .& 8 46 & 4/: &44'&(6 &36&(.0(&. & 084(/(.((/ +&,(<,6 &36(&/(&'&/ "

2+- % + "

==% *

&/ 00(4&7:E&(/ (E 004&9 (E