Shobha Garg v. Haryana Power Generation Corporation Ltd And ORS
!
"##
$!!
# % !#
"##!!
&
' &# ! ! &
!!!!! ! &
#
# # $$% # & ' #( # )#
# *+$ $+ ,-.#/ $ 0( '1 #' 3# 4
/ 4
4.# 4
54 ( )# ' 11 . (
# 6 %( $ # . $7 +% 8%%
#'- 0 * (
#' 4 1 (
( -1-
' # 91 4 1 8%, 9(
"(*
"
(9#: '(
(( 1 8%;
< 6%( ( ( * "
(9#: '( ## *# # #
# * ( # :
* (
= # >&&(
*( "
( 9# : ' (
3# 4
? "
2 #' (
"
( 9# : ' 3# 4
?"
( 6%(# = # @# # #' ( ( 1 *( '
#'
1 (
6%( # ' 2 #' 4'
1 ( 6 % '1 (
91 4 1 * 7+
8,; -.# /70 * $ 8; -.# / 0 2 #' # '1 # = +% 88, ## #' -2-
#'1(1 A/ $786/ 88,
"
( ( '1
#$ + $+ ( #' (
## # # C #' * +$ $+ , -.# /$ 0 # ' #/ 1 # 1 .)# #' 1 ( ' (
## 3(
6 % & '1 # #' ( * ( -(
91 4 1 0 $7 +% 8%% 6%( ( * +% 8%,+6 +, 8%% 1 #'( 6% & # # # "
( 9# : ' 8%; 6%( *(# :
/
= # 2 #' ( ( "
( 9# : ' /
3# 4
?"
( #'( 1 -3-
-(
91 4 1 0 1 # "
(9#: '
1
=# (
# *7+
8,;D$ 8; -.#/7D/ 10#' ( (
1( * "
( 9# : ' '# (
3# 4
?"
# ?=
# ( ' 1
(1 "
# ( * 7+
8,; $ 8; 1 1 3# 4
"
# = #
/ #
1( ' ' :
# # 1 1 & #' '1# 6%( 34E>&( ;
+8 8;+ +, + 8;$ 1 *7+
8,;$ 8; -.#/ 7/ 0 ( 3# 4
E>&( ;
+8 8;+ ( 6 / 1 '1 #' 3# 4
E > & "
34E>&( 6 -4-
( ;
+8 8;+ '1 #'( 6 / 1 '1 (
2 #' (
1 3# 4
E>& ( 6 % :# # 2 #' ( # 4
* +6 8;; -.# /%0 ## (
# 1= 4
7+ +8 88+ 9 (
# 1= .#/, # (# ( #'( #' ;8 6 % ( ( #' +;6 +; 1 # #'(# #1 6% , & # (
#' ( 6 %
(## )#( (
1'1 *"
)# = # E > & =
# E>&& 1 * = # E>&()# < +/7++ * )# =
# E > && ( ( 1 # -5-
1 & ' # 1 6 # (
(
+;
886 (
( # 6 ( 6 '
1
1= 3# 4
E>&(
* & # (
@ '1 1 1 & # ## @ (
1 1 )# 6'1
= # E>&(
* "
( 9# : ' )#1
1(/
%+? 76 = # E > & ' ( 6 "
6 ( #
1 4
4.# 4
4.# 4
( + + 8, + +% 8;+ , +;
886 1 ' ( * $, +% 8%; -.#/80*+6 88%-.#/ +0* $ +, 88% +7 + 88, -.# / D / $0 #' ' ;
= # # #' #'(# 4.# 4
*$
88%(
( -6-
#' ## 7 + $++7 =# # # 1 ( 6 %
#'1 A ' A 77 ; 88%
( ( (
# (
%
* & # ## %( ' ' 6 '( *.#/ / 6 / %/ , # ' + =# # #
# # 1 #' ( ' ' (
# .
1(
#
6 % # ( # ( '1 #' & 1 # #' ((1 6%# (
* 7+
8,; $ 8; -.#/7D/ 0 #')# '1 (
# ' -7-
# 1 2 #' # ' ' '
# 1##
1( "
( 9#: ' & 1#' # ' #' (## # '#'
( #1 1 # 1 1=
## A $786 88, # * #' +$ $+ , $+ 1 & ( # #'##1(1 9(# 1 ( ##1(1 ( $
(#' # *7+
8,;$ 8; 1 *7+
8,;#/
!" #! $ # " % #&$ & '!&& #""##"" -8-
"$ % #! (# #! ! (# #! %#%""" '!"(#) * *$ 8; #/
+&&" ' !",!#,&%# & & & #! - () "" .
/ ).0)12/3 /
, !-(4 (# !(01+
# % !! " 5 6& *
# 1 . ( # / ( * * $$+?9E?E4/%$7$ +7 $+ 6 (
1 4( #( 1
? ( 1 ' # 1 & # #'1 1= ' #' 1 =
1 #' /
=# # 6 % ( # :
-9-
#' )# 1 / ( 9(# 1 # # 1 (
1 / 1 # 1 * 7+
8,; $ 8; -.#/7D/ 0 9#
1 * +7 8; * $ 8; -.# / 0 ( 1
#
# F' ( # (
1'1 '1 * +7 8; -.#/60 *$ 8; -.#/ 0 # ' ' #
( ##1 # 2 #' # #'
1 1 #$ +7 $+ 6 1 * ? 8; (# # . ' # 1 '
/
# #' #
(1 ' -10-
8, 8, 8;+ 886 ( # (
? 9 # #' # '1 # #'
#(1' 1 88,
1 %( (# (
' 9# 1 # # * '')#
# 1' /#' 1 # $+ 6( ( '1 #'( $ + $+ ( '1 ( #' = # # # # # (
# 1 # '1 #' #
1 1 / ' ' ' ?
# (
'
'# ##1#
%
#( , 9 #
;
& 1 ( #' #'
'1 ' * 6 % #( -11-
( '1 1 )# / # 1 # '1 # # &( #' # / 1
(
' "
( 9#: '1 (
1 # #'' 1 * +7 8; -.#/601 ( 2 #' ( ( ;
+8 8;+( 6 ' 1 #' '1 '
#' 1# # '1 ( / # #' 1
#(1' 88, # ( ( # '1 2
#' * #
*(
# # 1 (###1# #'
( (1 '1
( ( 1 / '1 -12-
#' '
# # '1 #' # 1 (# 1 ' '1 #'
? (
# ' $+ 4 ( '1 '#' 6( * +% 8%, %( * "
+6 +, 8%% "
2 #' ( * $7 +% 8%% :# 1 #'(
$ ( # # ( #'(#)# 1 6% #''### ( 1 '#' $ 6 ( # #1 # # (
( 6 (
1= = # E>& = # E>&& (
* "
#' 1 6 6 # ' -13-
( 1 #'' ' (
( . 1 # 1 "
( 1 ' . 6 < 1 ( %
# ( #
* %. ' %( "
& ' # ( 1 ' ? ' #' 1 (#1# (
# 1=( $$ & ( # ( ( # * +$ $+ , -.# /$ 0 '1 )# '1 #' (
# 6 D % ## # )# ' #' # ' ( 8G#(
1
* $7 ' $ 1 (! & )
*+,
5!') 7 8). 59!& 7 8). -14-