High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1080/2009allowed

Parbhu & ANR. v. Anita Bansal

2017-09-15Mr. Justice Arun Palli11 pages

""#$ % $$ #$"

$!& # '( )*'

+' * +

!"! #$!$ %&'&

$""(( !()! &'&

$ " ' * +,- ".

'&&/0123 *%$""(&!!+, &$ "-"(

. "( /! -- &$ ,0%""% (

&,%1$$((0$$""((& ,$! +23!+ 1 0(%$1$++ " $ !0$!$ 2 3!+ " ( !( $""((& $'($!" " %+ ' 4$/! $!0$,"( %""% + $( #'(5!05! '& 3$(&

6 7&/!" 0&$10$1

"! '! $ "-"(

$( $'

,/! 4$""(1$((%+"(&'1 $ $ ((%!+1 !0$,"( $+"%0 ""(&!($',(%,%1% +'0"" " ""(! 6!(

$##+"(%,% (0 ""(! ##&' $!+ ,. &$ $$!+&1$$"

2!( /!" 0$' %(&$ !+& %&,(.,%$#! #8!(%&+"(%0$ ( !(

$""(- "-"(

$&&$! " " %$( %,(,%$""((- &$""( + 4$ 0 % & $1' & (( !+, $ ""(& &1$- (07

&$+"%0 ""(( $'0,"!!" ($ 0%

+&2141&/0115 4$""($,!,%$ ! (,%$ "-"(

&.0" $!" " %& 1$$,(+! 0 3- &, !((% , $"((,%1% ', $( #'(5!05! '& 3$(& 1$ $ !+, " $ ,0 .$1 7

& 6.((:9 :- & 96- &! 1$$ '!

4$( 3$(&" $ 0$ $%

- &1$$$"(

: (+,1 $" &0!$1 $", ( " 1+! &!+, 0:7 :

&,$ 6

#0 $ $ ""(( $ $ 1$$!" " %&,0+"( 0 $ &$%$ ; (% $<!""$"(

= 8!(' " !(" $" " %$ &$%$ ! #8!(%& #'( ! *4 :77

1 ((% ! 6 7& =$ $ = ! $1 , :

" $2!0+ $ (#! &$'0, ' !"$""(($ &$% ! '$+$'0 "" #! & " $'0 ,

& $% 1 " 0 ' 7 7 : 4$"(

$'0/+$ ( >$'0( !+ %'$ +

& ?/ & ?/6&+!?/ " @( #++ ?/7&$( #'(5!0'!((%$ $ 2!0+&$ ,0"(0&' 0!+,$( $ &$($$"(

$" '$ ($!" " % 1$ (." +$ 6 4$" ""((- $'0! ""( 1$$+!" $ 0, $( ( 5!0& 3$(&$#! 0$ $"(($ 0 $#'(5!0$$""((- $ !

6 " $ '!((%, " & ! $ !(% $ 0!++,$( $""((- $$% $' , '1$$!,%$ (#! $$ " $ - ' & 7&1!((% ( " ,((!1$$"(

0!+1( , $#! $$"(

$;"(1 0 <$$ ( 1-$ $!( (01$$""((- $ ! " 0-$ 1+,( A ! $ & $ 2!0+ $ ( ( 5!0&1,%$""((- $ ;+!?/$,"( B$+!, " ! &1!($'!'($ 0 0-$ < 4$!$ 0 !& $2!0+

$( ""((#! &$2!0+ $#'(5!0 1 $((0,%$""((-

4$ ( ( 5!0 ( $ 2!0+$(% % (0$""($, '

7 4$ &$(0$' ,( ,%1% ""(&$#! 1 ! $ $($" $ $%

&(" $+!;?/6 <&$1 $" $"(

- "$!" " % ( (%,($&1$$1(, !,%$ " $@( #++

4$ &, '0$$""((- $, ,(!%'&'$! $""(&1$$1!( -($"(

$ ( (+,%$ &$ ""( (,% $" ""((- 1+

(01$$" ""( (&$""(($' ( (""(! 6!(

###::-#

&0$ $$%$" !"$" $( $ '! , $""((#! ,!""( (0 ('$, (&$%!(,($$$%1 -$ $" " % C$ ! $ ,$""($$( 1 0 $ !(,( +" 1$& ,!$%$," 0 , $ (#! & $'0, ' $!$+&$'!( ," !

C,$ $$'0$ 0!+ ( !(&$#! $ ( '2!0+,!$"!!"$+

-$ 0' +, 7& 7&,(!( 0!+1$$ $ 0((& "

1$$ !0$,(,%1% (', $#! & 1 !((%'(,(1$$""(( &1!(!$ ", +,('& 0!+$'0, , $#! ( 0,%$ &$!

4$+ $'0,"!!" -$ 0&( !(

$""(($" !#!

7(&$1

7 ,$ 0((& " $!" " %&$ ' $1,.$3!+ &$ $,% $#! 4$ &( !( $ "-"(

$'0 !0$+ 0!+$+,(% $' $0 ""(&$+ 12! '!((%$ +!"% % 0!+&1$( !( $""(( $0 0! -$ 0 $+ $$! - '

!"$""((- $, ((,%$ ""((#! &1$$1 0!+$$ 1$$1 $ $ +,%$#! @ !( $ "-"(

$1' !,+ $$""(($$ (""(! 7 $ # #'( ! &$ $""((- $'0 ," 0 ,%$ (#! &!(,0,% $""((#! $ 6 % %&$$ (!"2!0+ *$ $#! + ' ),0$&

@5 6&1$ $,$($'1$ 1",%$ (#! &$ ""((#! !((( ""(! 7 $##& ' 0 $""(" 0 0 &$#! $ ""((#! $!(" $""(+ C 1 ! $ $(&$1' &$$""((#! $!($'$ ( $+ $ ' %$!($' !

%0 !; 0 0 " 09 $'0, "9.0$'-" < &%( !( $""((- 5$ (!"12!0+& *$ $#! $$ $!" +#! C) +$% D((0) $5&4$( 3 ($ !0$ "$4 #$'20$$ &

@:&1$(,%$#! $$(1 ""((#! & & ++((0(%,%$(0""(0= =& $""(! !(: $#!(($',

(&$ ,%+"(%0$$""(1+"C1 ! $ $( $" 7 $##& 1$$/"( !(:&$ +% ""(0 ( '(,(00 '" %& %$!$" %$!(

(""(! !(: 0$ B1' &$2!0+ ! $ 0$($ !$""(! 7 $#&1!((%, + $$! $ $'0," 0 1!(,0 A&( !( $""(($ ! $ (!" 2!0+ $!" +#! &*$!3!+ 5' ! $3!+ $ &

##'(

&1$ 1$(,%$ @ $"

((1 - ;

""(0/-" + $#!(, ($ ((100 ! -

4$+ ( , !0$ $/-" " 0$!,%$"(

1!(( $ '! & 4$!!($'," /-" $ 0< " !( (!$ ,'1!($1$$ $ $+ $! "(

&$ -2!0+, &1$ $," 0 ,%$= (#! =&$( 0$

(""(! 7 $#0$$!!( $'!((%," $ 0&$ !( $'," 0 C$" $#! &$1!(' %,'!(%+"(% $& &$""((#! 0$! 1$$ $ " 00$ 1 (%",%$ ( #! & @ !( $ "-"(

&$$ $& $" ""(&$!,+$$ !+ $" &$ " ,%$#! 1!(""(%%& '1 $ $,$$#! ,(1$'" ((%$($$ ""((- !" '$$%"" ' 1 !$ B&$!,+$$! - ' $""((- !($',$',0,%$ ""((#! &$ ! : C ,!(&( !( $""((!,+$$ !( !++,%$""((- &"! !$ ! $ !& 1 +(% 1 (% ,% $ $

"-"(

$ & ,(',( ! $ & !((%'$ " $ $'0,+1 (% $& !(%",%,$$#! ,(1 6 B'0 $ &$!0$ ! & *$ $#! &+ =!" $$($ 2!0+, (0""(! 7 ##, $ ""(( #! & $ #! 1!( 0 $ ! " 0 $'0 , . 0 $2!0+, ,%$ ( #! E%&'1 $ $$2!0+ $!" +#! *$! 3!+ 5= !" & $ , $( $ $ " 0 ,%$ (#! !((,.0 !

$((0""(! 7 ##&,'!(%&$#! ,!,%$ $2!0+ C$" &$$!0$$" + %0 !

""(., $ ""((#! ,%$2!0+, $ , !(% ,% $ #! & $

$ $% 1 1 0(% " 0 $%1 ' ' $! ,%$ (#! &$1' &$ &$ $ $ $ $ (#! " 00$2!0+ , & $ , (. (( 8!(%& 0$,0'$ 7 C$ !& "" " + $+ ,.$ ""((#! &1$$1!( 0$ ! 1$$ $ $ (#! 0 " 0 ,.0$""((- &1 (%"

4$ &$""((1$((' $""(&$

$&+ &$%$($ !" " %&$'0"! $'(/!$ '!

1$1$,$ 0(($'0, " !, $#! &%!$""(+', $#! 1!(, ,%&$#! ,(1$'0$($ "- "(

(." $!" " %,%$(0$$ ""((- $(1$' 4$( ""((#! 1!(( %$ ""( (, '$0 +&,%$ " %& ! 6!(

##&,$" .0(( '', $#! &$!0$ 0 $ "-"(

& (%""(! ##$, (&#! %& $ ,' 4$ $#! 1!(" $ + $""(, F! $ & $ " ( !( $ "-"(

, $#! ,0$"$( %, .' ,%$"(

/!" 0& $ !,

!((% ,%$ ""((#! & + $ ",% $ /!0 #! & $ "-"(

$(( , "& /"!! (1 C'1 1$$#! $$($ ,'&$+"!0 2!0+ $ ""((#! $""( " ,% +0$+ ,.$ ""((#! &1$$

, ' >$,$ 0(( '! $ ""((- &$, ! $ ( !(

-' * +.

".9$ >$$ ".09 A9 >$$ " ,( A9