Balbir Singh v. Gulzari Lal And ORS.

  

        

!"#$#%&'&()
 
*  !+,&-&(./ 00#++!("  1#-'2'

2+3!-&4!+!($"/#-'

 #'0($#("'

)  54   6 4  -#'#(")7 -6/+&8$9%!"#8-"/#!00#++!(" --&"!:!&(&8$9%!"#8--#'0($#("
 -1&-;8$9%!"#8-8 -%/&("8$9%!"#8--#'0($#("' "*
 </#"/#-"/# #0-"#-'+%!+(#='0!0#-:!>,#!++=#$"'## "/#?2$.:#("@

 ,#-##--#$""/# #0-"#--("  </#"/#-"/#?2$.:#("'/2+$,#-#0-"#$&("/#$&.#'"@ 77 77 4 8

4 /&'-#.2+!-'#%($!00#!+/!',##(&+#$!.!&('""/# ?2$.:#("!($$#%-##$!"#$* A80!''#$,>"/#+#!-(#$ &9&+ 2$.# #(&-&9&'&( 8:,!+!89&$#=/&%/"/#'2&""/#0+!&("&

-#'0($#("
/#-#&( -'0#%&&%0#--:!(%#"/#!.-##:#(" '!+#$!"#$

B8#C#%2"#$,>!$/2 !: $#%#!'#$ &( -#'0#%"!(!-#!:#!'2-&(.
*5C
D&(%+2$&(.!'/08'&"2!"#$ =&"/&("/#!,!$&9&++!.#!($+&8#/'&+!($&'"-&%":,!+!=!'

$#%-##$!($ "/#'!+#$##$$!"#$ 

B8#C#%2"#$,>'!&$ !$/2 !:&(!92--#'0($#("B8(!:#+>8!+,&-&(./

0-#'#("!00#++!(" 8=!''#"!'&$#/#?2$.:#("!($$#%-##=!' 20/#+$  ,>  "/#  +#!-(#$  $$&"&(!+  &'"-&%"  2$.#8  :,!+!8  (


 ##($!("B !00#++!(",#&(.("'!"&'&#$=&"/"/# %(%2--#("&($&(.'"= 2-"',#+=/!'&+#$"/&'-#.2+!-'#%($ !00#!+,#-#"/&' 2-" /#  ,-&#  !%"'  &(9+9#$  &(  "/#  0-#'#("  %!'#  !-#  "/!" !%%-$&(."0+!&("& -#'0($#("
/#-#&( 8/#&'!"#(!("&("/# '/0'&"2!"#$!"9&++!.#!($+&("/#-#(" ' * 70#-:("/ &(&"&!++>8=/&%/=!'+!"#-(&(%-#!'#$" '* 70#-:("/ (

%",#-8
B8!$/2 !:80-#$#%#''-7&(7&("#-#'"$##($!("'


"* -#'0($#("' "*/#-#&( #C0-#''#$/&'$#'&-#" '#++  "/#  '2&"  0-0#-">  "  "/#  0+!&("& -#'0($#("   
7"#(!(" .-##:#(""'#++=!'#C#%2"#$&(!92-0+!&("& -#'0($#("
,>!$/2 !:/#""!+!:2("'!+#%('&$#-!"&(=!' ' 8 7/#0+!&("& -#'0($#("
0!&$ ' 8 7"!$/2

!:!($"/#-#:!&(&(.!:2("=!'!.-##$",#0!&$(-,#-# 
A=#9#-8!$/2 !:89&$#'!+#$##$$!"#$ 

B8 '+$"/#'!&$+!($"!+,&-&(./$##($!("B !00#++!("- ' E8 7##($!("'
"*8=/!-#"/#'2%%#''-'7&(7&("#-#'" !$/2 !:8=/#C0&-#$&("/#:#!(=/&+#8$#(&#$"/##C#%2"&( "/#!.-##:#(""=!''"!"#$"/!"$##($!("B !00#++!("&'!

77 ,(!&$#02-%/!'#--%('&$#-!"&( -:"/#0+#!$&(.'8++=&(.&''2#'=#-#-!:#$)7 F
 </#"/#-  "/#  0+!&("&  &'  #("&"+#$  "  $#%-##  - 0''#''&(  ,>  =!>    '0#%&&%  0#--:!(%#    "/# !.-##:#("  "  '#++  $!"#$  

B  =&"/  -#.!-$  " 0-0#-">&($&'02"#("/#.-2($'"!;#(&("/#0+!&("@



 </#"/#-  "/#  0+!&("&  =!'  -#!$>  !($  =&++&(.  " 0#--:/&'0!-""/#!.-##:#("@   </#"/#-  "/#  0+!&("&  &'  #("&"+#$  "  $#%-##  - 0#-:!(#("  &(?2(%"&(  !.!&('"  "/#  $##($!("'  (  "/# .-2($'"!;#(&("/#0+!&("@  E </#"/#-"/#0+!&("&/!'(%!2'#!%"&(!.!&('" "/#$##($!("'@  * </#"/#-$##($!("B&'!,(!&$#02-%/!'#- "/#0-0#-">&($&'02"#!($-9!+2!,+#%('&$#-!"&( '8&"'##%"@  B </#"/#-  "/#  '2&"  &'  !+'#  !($  -&9+2'  !($ $##($!("'!-##("&"+#$"'0#%&!+%'"'@  A

#+&#D "#--#%-$&(."/##9&$#(%#,"/"/#0!-"&#'8"/#'2&" =!'$#%-##$8!''"!"#$!,9#/#!00#!+!.!&('""/#?2$.:#("!($ $#%-##  =!'  $&':&''#$  ,>  "/#  +#!-(#$ $$&"&(!+  &'"-&%"  2$.#8 :!,!+!8( 
  /!9#/#!-$+#!-(#$%2('#+-"/#0!-"&#'!($/!9# !+'%!-#2++>.(#"/-2./"/#!00#!+&+#!'=#++!'"/#+=#- 2-"

&+# 0#-2'!+"/#+=#- 2-"&+#'/='"/!""/#%0> "/#!.-##:#("=!'0-$2%#$!($0-9#$,#-#"/#+=#- 2-",> =!>+#!$&(.'#%($!->#9&$#(%#=&"/"/#0#-:&''&("/# 2-" /#%0>"/#!.-##:#("&'C
/#'!:#=!'0-9#$,>

7E7 #C!:&(&(."/# 0+!&("& -#'0($#(" 
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
=!'!

"#(!("&("/#'!&$ '/0 /#!""#'"&(.=&"(#''6!0-&(./ <E /!'0-9#$"/# #C#%2"&("/#!.-##:#("/#!.-##:#(",#!-'"/#'&.(!"2-#' !$/2 !: /#'&:0+#$#(&!+"/#$##($!("'=&++("0-9# !(>"/&(./#'!+#$##$&(!92-$##($!("B !00#++!

'2,'#G2#("&("&:#/#-#-#8"/#'!:#/!'",#&.(-#$!$/2

!:#C0&-#$(



A&#,#-#"/#$!"##C#%2"&("/# '!+#$##$ 4#!-(#$%2('#+-"/#!00#++!("/!'!-.2#$"/!""/# 0-#'#("'2&"&',!--#$2($#- -$#-  2+#  $# &9&+

7*7 -%#$2-#8
 &('/-"5  5  /#0+!&("&/!$&+#$"/#'2&"-0#-:!(#("&(?2(%"&(- '"!>&(./&'$&'70''#''&(8=/&%/=!'#C"#($#$"/&:89&$#-$#- $!"#$  *

A   =#9#-8  "/&'  '2&"  =!'  &+#$  (   
A /#-#-#8&"!:2("'"'0+&""&(.20"/#%+!&: !:"/#9&#="/!""/#0-#9&2''2&"=!'-'&:0+# &(?2(%"&(!'"/#$!"#'!+#/!$("!--&9#$=#9#-8"/#%!2'# !%"&(  /!$  !-&'#(  "  "/#  0+!&("&  =/#(  "/#  '!+#  $##$  $!"#$



B8&(!92-$##($!("B=!'#C#%2"#$!($=/#(&" %!:#"0+!&("&5'("&%#/#-#-#8/#%2+$!+=!>'=&"/$-!="/# '2&"  -  0#-:!(#("  &(?2(%"&(  !($  &+#  !  %:0-#/#('&9#  '2&"  - 0''#''&(!($'##;0#-:!(#("&(?2(%"&(,>=!>%('#G2#("&!+ -#+&#0#-2'!+"/#%!'#&+#'/='"/!"&"&'!G2#'"&(!%" "/!"(G2#'"&(+!=:2%/+#''"/#'2,'"!("&!+G2#'"&(+!=&' &(9+9#$&("/#0-#'#("%!'#/#-#!-#%(%2--#("&($&(.'"/# "= 2-"',#+=!($"/#-#&'(&++#.!+&">!($&(&-:&">&("/#'!:# /#0-#'#("!00#!+&'!%%-$&(.+>$&':&''#$

4    
 
* '?;'