High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/36734/2023disposed of

Yogesh v. State Of Haryana And Another

2024-01-23Mr. Justice Pankaj Jain6 pages

"#$ %$&'(') !*$(+ $#'#')$, -$,(.( /#"#$ ",0")"")% )#+$, $(1)%$)#( 23 / 4

,$($)# ,+.6)$(+3"7+$,"8 %9&"#$

,#+$1$#'#')$, ,":$(+4.:", :;"9#"8

8",0")" ( ,.)':" *"(+$8 %9&"#$ , ,+'#'##"<8 %9&"#$

,,$(1)%$)# 4

8 = 3> 06"0 1,$($)#1$#'#')8#+$1$#'#')$,'(($$7')*?."(+')* %"#$% 8,$*'(#$,$%.)%$,/$&#')( 8 8

"#<'&$/#"#')'#0",)".< '(#,'&#"+$)%",*",+ = ))$@.,$>8 ")%"<<&)($?.$)#1,&$$%')*(",'(')*#+$,$ ,:)#+$ ;"('( &:1,:'($ ) 8#+$ <<6')*,%$,6"(1"(($% A+$1,$($)#1$#'#')+"(;$$):9$%')97')* B.,'(%'&#') #+'(.,#.)%$,/$&#') ,;0 #+$1$#'#')$,($$7')*?."(+')* %"#$% 8 ,$*'(#$,$% ,

$)&$( 1.)'(+";<$ .)%$, /$&#')( C

#+$)%'")$)"< %$8 "# <'&$ /#"#') '#0 ",)".<8 '(#,'&#

"+$)%",*",+ 3$",)$% &.)($< , #+$ 1$#'#')$, &)#$)%( #+"# #+$ :"##$, "<,$"%0 (#")%( &:1,:'($% 9'%$ &:1,:'($ %"#$% = ))$@.,$> $ .,#+$,(.;:'#(#+"##+$%'(1.#$'( ')#$,($;$#6$$) "#+$,")%#+$() #'&$ :#') , )#+$"(7')* #+$.,#8,".,"9")("<8 8 ",0")" "&&$1#( )#'&$ ) ;$+"< ,$(1)%$)# /#"#$ (

,.)':" *"(+$8 %9&"#$"11$",(")%"&&$1#()#'&$);$+"< ,$(1)%$)#")%"%:'#(#+$ "&# #+$,$;$')*"&:1,:'($ ;$#6$$)#+$1",#'$( )9'$6 #+$";9$8#+$1",#'$(8'$#+$1$#'#')$,"( 6$<<"(,$(1)%$)#",$%',$&#$%#"11$",;$ ,$<$",)$% .#0 "*'(#,"#$C<<"?" "*'(#,"#$C#,'"< .,# ) ) #+$', %')*(8#+$<$",)$% .#0"*'(#,"#$C<<"?""*'(#,"#$C#,'"<.,# (+"<<,$&,%#+$',(#"#$:$)#(")% .,)'(+'#(,$1,###+'(.,#;0#+$ )$@#%"#$ +$",')*)#+$ <<6')*"(1$&#( .:;$, 1$,()(",,"0$%"("&&.($%')#+$ E+$#+$,")0"&&.($%'(1,&<"':$%

$)%$,F E+$#+$, #+$ &:1,:'($ '( *$).')$8 9<.)#",0 ")% 6'#+.#")0&$,&'),.)%.$') <.$)&$F

E+$#+$,#+$"&&.($%1$,()(",$')9<9$%')")0#+$, &"($,)#F G +$#,'"<.,#'("<(%',$&#$%#,$&,%#+$(#"#$:$)# #+$ )9$(#'*"#')*

'&$, "( # +6 :")0 9'&#':(C&:1<"')")#(",$#+$,$')#+$

&10 #+$,$1,#;$"<(($)###+$$*'(#,", .%'&'"< #+'(.,# $$%<$((#("0#+"#')&"($ ,")0,$"()#+$(#"#$:$)#( ",$ )# ,$&,%$% ) #+$ "

,$("'% %"#$8 #+$ <$",)$% <<"?"

"*'(#,"#$C#,'"<.,#(+"<<;$"#<';$,#0#&"<<#+$1",#'$()")0 #+$,%"#$;.#)#<"#$,#+")"6$$7#+$,$"

#$,H .,(.")###+$"

,$("'%,%$,8,$1,#%"#$%G ,:

+'$ .%'&'"<"*'(#,"#$8",)".<+"(;$$),$&$'9$%86+'&+'(#"7$)) ,$&,% (1$,#+$,$1,#8#+$,'"<.,#+"(,$&,%$%"( <<6( A#'(+.:;<0(.;:'##$%#+"#1.,(.")##')(#,.&#')( )2;<$'*+.,#"('((.$%9'%$,%$,%"#$% 1"(($%'),':')"<'(&$<<")$.(

#'#<$%"(!*$(+-(/#"#$ ",0")"D")#+$,&:1<"')")# +7",/')*+/C/+/+$#"B/')*+8"&&.($%)":$<0!*$(+ /C +7", ")% -',$)%$, 4.:", / "11$",$% ;$ ,$ #+'( .,#;$')*,'"<.,#)%"#$% 8(#"#$:$)# &:1<"')")# +7", /')*+ ")% -',$)%$, 4.:", / 6$,$ ,$&,%$%) (#"#$:$)# "&&.($%!*$(+4.:", /C+7",6"(,$&,%$%:1<"')")#+7",/')*+9'%$+'( ($1","#$,$&,%$%(#"#$:$)#(#"#$%#+"#') ;$",')*

%"#$% 6'#+#+$')#$,9$)#') <&"<1$,()( #+$ (&'$#0:"##$,+"(;$$)&:1,:'($%;$#6$$)#+$&:1<"')")# ")% "&&.($% ")% #+$ ("'% &:1,:'($ +"( ;$$) "

$&#$% 6'#+.#")0&$,&')8 ,&$,.)%.$') <.$)&$")%(":$'( *$).')$ .,#+$,8+$(#"#$%#+"#+$+"();B$&#')')?."(+')* #+$ 1,$($)# /$1","#$ (#"#$:$)# "&&.($% "( ";9$ :$)#')$%+"(;$$),$&,%$%6+$,$') +$+"(%$1($%#+"# :"##$,+"(;$$)&:1,:'($%;$#6$$)#+$&:1<"')")#")% "&&.($% ') ;$",')* %"#$% 6'#+ ')#$,9$)#') <&"<,$('%$)#( #+$(&'$#0+$"&&.($%+"( ;$$)'%$)#'

'$%;0+'(&.)($<6+$,$"(&:1<"')")#+"(;$$) %.<0 '%$)#'

'$% ;0 #+$ )9$(#'*"#')*

'&$, # '( +.:;<0 (.;:'##$%#+"#) (#"#$:$)# )9$(#'*"#')*

'&$,( )":$<0 /-'B$)%$,4.:",

C36"(,$&,%$%6+ %$1($%#+"#')#+'( #+$,$'()<0)$ "&&.($%)":$<0 !*$(+4.:",/C+7",/')*+8,C9'<<"*$4B')%" &&.($% '()#%$&<",$%"(1,&<"':$%

$)%$,+$,$'() "*"')(# #+$"&&.($%"(1$,,$&,% <&"<1<'&$+$,$'()<0)$ 9'&#':C&:1<"')")#)":$<0+7",/')*+/C/+$#"B/')*+

)<0 )$ 1$,() +"( ;$$) ",,"0$% "( "&&.($% )":$<0 "&&.($% !*$(+ 4.:", 6+ "11$",$% ")% (.

$,$% +'( (#"#$:$)#')#+$&.,#) (1$,#+$(#"#$:$)# )9$(#'*"#')*

'&$,8"&&.($%+"( )#;$$)%$&<",$%"(1,&<"':$%

$)%$, )9'$6 (#"#$:$)#( &:1<"')")#8"(6$<<"("&&.($%8 ":("#'( '$%#+"##+$&:1,:'($;$#6$$)#+$&:1<"')")#")% "&&.($%'(*$).')$89<.)#",0")%6'#+.#")0&$,&'),")0 .)%.$') <.$)&$

(1$,#+$(#"#$:$)# )9$(#'*"#')*

'&$,8"&&.($%'()# ')9<9$%')")0#+$, $@&$1##+$1,$($)#)$ G+$,$'()$&:1<"')")#')#+$1,$($)# )":$<0+7", /')*+6+(.

$,$%+'((#"#$:$)#')#+$&.,#) +$,'*')"<(#"#$:$)# &:1<"')")#8(#"#$:$)# "&&.($%8 (#"#$:$)# )9$(#'*"#')*

'&$,",$;$')*($)#+$,$6'#+ , 7')%1$,.("< #+$)2;<$'*+.,#"(%$(',$%H 3$",)$%&.)($< ,,$(1)%$)#("%:'#(#+$ "&# 1",#'$( +"9')*&:1,:'($%")%(#"#$(#+"#+$+"();B$&#')')&"($#+$ ")% "<<1,&$$%')*((.;($?.$)##+$,$#"*"')(##+$1$#'#')$,",$?."(+$% /':'<",<08<$",)$%/#"#$&.)($<+"((#"#$%);B$&#')')&"($ #+$ '(?."(+$%;"($%.1)#+$&:1,:'($= ))$@.,$> +"9$+$",%<$",)$%.)($< ,#+$1",#'$(")%+"9$&",$ .<<0 *)$#+,.*+#+$,$&,%( #+$&"($ +'(.,#")% 1$@.,#+"(,$1$"#$%<0%$"<#6'#+#+$'((.$ $@$,&'($ B.,'(%'&#') .)%$, /$&#') #+$ %$ # ?."(+ 1,&$$%')*,$&*)'I')*&:1,:'($;$#6$$)1",#'$(')))&:1.)%";<$

$)&$(')#+$&"($( '")/')*+9(/#"#$ .)B"; ")%")#+$,8 =>/ 8 /#"#$ "%+0","%$(+9(3"@:'","0")")%

#+$,(=>G/ 84.<6')%$,/')*+D#+$,(9(/#"#$ .)B";D ")#+$,8 = >=,':')"<>G ")% ":1"<")%")#+$,9( /#"#$ "%+0","%$(+8= >=,':')"<> =,':')"< 11$"< %$&'%$%)#+ /$1#$:;$,8>+$1,1('#') <"6#+"#$:$,*$( ,:#+$"

,$("'%%$&'(')(,$)%$,$%;0 1$@.,#")% #+'(.,#'( ="> 6$,.C( ,9$(#$%6'#+#+'(.,#'(:.&+6'($, ")%'(.)"

$&#$%;0/$&#') #+$%$ =;> 6$9$,86'%$,#+$16$,*,$"#$,#+$&".#') =&> +$.)%$,<')')*1,')&'1<$6+'<$$@$,&'(')*(.&+16$,'( #+"# '# &") ;$ ')97$% # ?."(+ #+$ 1,&$$%')*( ,$&*)'I')* &:1,:'($ ;$#6$$) #+$ 1",#'$( ') #+$ :"##$,( 6+'&+ ",$ 9$,6+$<:')*<0 ")% 1,$%:')")#<0 &'9'< &+","&#$, <'7$ &::$,&'"<#,")("&#')(,",'(')*.# :"#,':)'"<,$<"#')(+'1 , ":'<0%'(1.#$( =%> +$("'%16$,'()##;$$@$,&'($%')#+$ 1,($&.#')(')9<9')*+$').(")%($,'.(

$)&$( :$)#"< %$1,"9'#0 ,

$)&$( <'7$ :.,%$,8 ,"1$8 %"&'#0 $#& "( (.&+

$)&$(",$)#1,'9"#$'))"#.,$")%+"9$"($,'.(':1"&#) (&'$#0 =$> /$&#') ,&"(#(%.#0.1)#+$'*+.,## "%9")&$')#$,$(# B.(#'&$"(6$<<#'('),$&*)'#') #+'(%.#0 &"(#$%.1)#+$'*+.,#8#+"# 1$@.,#+$<%#+"##+$'*+ .,#6.<%)#,$ .($#?."(+ .)%$,/$&#') :$,$<0 ;$&".($ ')%(:$)#')#+$,$ '*+.,#&")"(($(()"#.,$ ')B.,'$( (.(#"')$%8 6+$#+$, (.&+ ')B.,'$( ') <'&#$% ) 9'#"<C%$<'&"#$1",#( #+$;%0C)"#.,$ 6$"1)(.($%$#& = > /.&+ $@$,&'($ "# #+$ +")%( '*+ .,# 6.<% ;$ 1$,:'((';<$)<0"

#$,#+$$9'%$)&$'(&<<$&#$%"

#$,')9$(#'*"#') ")%&+",*$(+$$#'( '<$%C&+",*$( ,":$%%.,')*#+$#,'"< /.&+ $@$,&'($ &"))# ;$ &",,'$% .# 6+'<$ #+$ :"##$, '( (#'<< .)%$, ')9$(#'*"#') =*> E+'<$?."(+')* ')))&:1.)%";<$

$)&$($9$) 6+'&+",$ 1,'9"#$'))"#.,$8'*+.,#'(,$?.',$%#&)('%$, ")#$&$%$)#( #+$"&&.($%8&)%.&# #+$"&&.($%")%6+$#+$,+$

6"(";(&)%')*,6+$#+$,+$+"(:")"*$%#+$&:1<"')")## $)#$,')#"&:1,:'($ +.(87$$1')*')9'$6#+$"

,$("'% "&#(")%&',&.:(#")&$(8 #+'(.,#'( #+$&)('%$,$%1')')#+"#'#'(" '#&"($#$@$,&'($ B.,'(%'&#')9$(#$%.C( ,#?."(+#+$ "( ='> +$1,$($)#:"##$,%$()# "<<6'#+')#+$$@&$1#')("( &",9$%.#') 3"@:'","0")2( &"($=(.1,">'$+$').(

$)&$ =''> +$

$)&$("<<$*$%",$ 1,'9"#$)"#.,$ ='''> +$1",#'$(+"9$&:1,:'($% ='9>

(1$,#+$,$1,#,$&$'9$%#+$&:1,:'($'(("'%#;$ 9<.)#",0')'#()"#.,$ =9> :1<"')")#C9'&#': '( ,$1,#$% # +"9$ $)#$,$% ')# &:1,:'($)+'(6)9<'#') )($?.$)#<08#+$1$#'#')'("<<6$% %"#$% ,$*'(#$,$%.)%$,/$&#')( 8 8

"# <'&$/#"#')'#0",)".<8 '(#,'&#"+$)%",*",+= ))$@.,$>")%"<< 1,&$$%')*(",'(')*#+$,$ ,:8",$8+$,$;08?."(+$%?."#+$1$#'#')$,

= 4

> 1,0

E+$#+$,(1$"7')*C,$"()$% !$(C E+$#+$,,$1,#";<$ !$(C