← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5314/2011allowed

Ajit Singh v. Nirmal Singh & Others

2016-08-23Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj6 pages



     

   



!" # $      

!"#" !$ %& !" 

" %# &'()%*+, )+*% )%-*.,

' (!")!&!*%+&, -&!

 & -&!!

"&.%/ (! # *%+&, -&!!

2 +/01 0-/2 3 ""

32, $1

"

4 &-

"& -&!  " "#-- % 32 $ & ..56/557   $&&!

 ,,%  ) +

 3 ! !

"!&  1681.9.7 :

- !!

%&";

<=*),(%! ,41# 3 ! "!&& 16>11?0/.*3 %!+ 32, $1

" "#  &- ,,% * , $ % & ) @#$!* ,&1  ! ) $  " +

* !

+ % "

!&#" #! "  $ )" 4  & &+ !$ ( &

 %&"

* ,&!0/*%!*)  )"&

%%!&%)""

! %"!4

 )"%",! &.856/557 - !* %#% !-&

&)1# !

-&!3&# !

$&"

 % "

. ,&"!

 )"8>2 !"&- %)")&!4"%!+ !)(A"

,!, *

$!%)" $& 2"

!2&->555A1# &,,% 

,&# %&)&!4-&!& 2 !%!

%#

&2 % / 

%,&$

"&&-/0*776A1&, $* ),)",&$ # %"-&

&)"'1  

 := &"

B&* %"#-- ! 0555 := 

%  /555 := !"

&!&

" .555 :+= 

" &- #!,"

 &- $ %, " % + "&

" ?776 :+= &$

"&-&!>D%"3 2 .5555   44 0 

*  ) % ""#!,  & E%* "#!

&-- % +

* -

% ,!&""1&3 ,&" ) 

  %!+ &--

)"&& %+ %%!+ *""#,*"#!

,&3 3#!% %& 2$&#&-,&$

"& 8 +  !%

%,&#"

-&! ! "%

!#"

%

!1 3&&4%!

,&!%&- ) !""",  >

 -&! 

 " !# %  , %%$ %&"

-&!-&#!%2" )"%!+ !32 !&- ""& #  & -!,#!

"*   ,&# % &  % " &3 -&!  ,&"% !3

!&% "   !

% ,&- % & 3 % +   - !*   )" &  

&"&&%!+    +

 % !

% )&#&3 -&!&  2 ! "

%"3 2"$% $#-&%!+  +

 " &

% 2 ,&$

"& -&! &"" &- ,&$ * -##!

 $

" % ,&$

% 32   &)!%"  %



"#-- !*#!&#"% %!"

&!&

"" "&& !"%  6 %,&#"

-&!!

2" !# %    "

% ,&$

"& "

 & ,&!%),,

"-&!&  "-#! !!# %%!+ !&-   &-- % +

 )" & &""

"" %!+     $  &- ,,%  " -, )" % 32 ,

  $% &-   &#! ) ,

  ,"

 3 !  & 9> &- /557* &  & &!

 )"

 %") """" %&-

&- ,!$ ,"

* )"&%!+ &-!

&.1!$ " " !$   )" & &""

"" 2 %!+     $  &- ,,% * " "#,* "#!

! " 

% & !

,&+ ! $&# &- ,&$

%&, $-!&$&) !&-&--

 ?

!" 2*  4  "#3$""&" &-

 -&! !

&01,!&""1&3 ,&!*"

4!&!

,&+ !$&#&-,&$

"&-!&$ &) !&-

 % ! ,&.87:/=:=&- (&&!

" , :

! !

- !!

% & " ;  ,<=* % -  )" +

 & "#!, 2&+&%" 3 2& 2$&#&-,&$

"&32

!&+"#!

%"3!

, % !$"%,&%&"&-"#!, & ,2 #"& "-," + 2& "#!

! ","

%-!$ %""# &0*),!

%""-&

&)"'1  

!"





#$ 

%"& '$%"

$"

 ( '

"'& %( (



"$

$(("

 )  

 #

 ( * +,- 9 ) !%%!+ !&-

) !&,

% .

!$

  "#!

!"#$$& %   -

&- ,!$  ,"

 ) & % &



4  & &""

""& %!+  &- !

 & .1!$  * %!+ !&-

F# "&*),!"

"-&!,&"% !&*" "&)  !-%,3 ,&!% %%!+ !&-

)"& &""

""+ %%!+ & % &-,,% &  !&#%  &  % & 4    "$  & &""

""& + " --, !&-,!$ ,"

)"& C$ %&  %"4 %%!+ !& !&%#, "%!+ 3# )"& &""

""  "$  3"

&-2 %!+ &-!

&.)"&+ %*&"#,-%,3 ,&!% %#"& "#$ &&! ""#$ & ,&.08:,=&- ,!

G#!

"&) !&- %

 )

 + $& !

!% ,,% * "#

2 !

G#!

%&,#$ ", #%%!+ &-%!+ !&-+

& "#!, 2   " ,"

*   "#!

! " & 4  2

  )!  " "#!

%"&,&$

 %) !&+"&"&- ,&.08:= &- , 3"

&-2

*)

&3

!& ! &%",#""  -- ,&-&1,&$

, &- !&+"&"&- ,&.08:,=&- , 7  + ) &- %",#""& 3&+ * "#3$""&" &-

-&! !

 & 01,!&""1&3 ,&! " -&#% % +&% &- 2 $ ! % " %",!% % .5  C$ H1/ ! & % * """

!&- ""&!* !&

%,*)&)" $ $3 !&-$ 3&!%""# %"3 2, !-, &, $"" % )"$ %!

"!,&&- 4

$&+ ", $)"&

%,"

&--!,#!

!

%" 2", %"3 2)"""

%">D:

= %"3 2 !-,  :C 1/= )" "& " % 32 $ " $ $3  $



3&!% ..  $- ! ,,% !

%%$ %&"

-&! -&#!%2" )"&

%%!&%)""

! %"

 "#

2 -!,#!

#!24 "6&./)

4"&

 $*)&)"%!+ !* ,&# % & %!+    +

 

" -&! 

!&% &- !

 $&" %#  & -!,#!

" "#-- % 32 $  ,&$  &- , $    $  &- ,,% ,3 + !2)

4 ">555A1

!$&% &""&-,&$ %#! 

!&%   !

% #% ! !

* " ""

% " .>*555A1  $ " % " $  3

" &   #  &- ?776A1 :C 18 & C 1.8=    " "&

% ,&$

"& &- 0555A1 -&!  % ,! "$&#&-,&$

"&)!% %&)!%"!"

&!&" "&

%-!&$.555A1&0555A1", $!

G#!

%!"

&!&)

& &&"

-&! -&

&)#  &$

"&)!% % 32  &)!%" "

A#!&#" %  " % -!&$ /555A1 & >555A1 % &)!%" % &)!%"  % "#-- ! -!&$ 0555A1 & >555A1  >D %"3 2"#-- %32, $"G# "-,*),)"%# &$ "!,&&-4

$&+ *""#,*,&$

"&&"",&!

32   ,

" -&! &    " &   %"3 2 "#-- % 32 , $  2 $ ! " -- , % " -##!

!, ,2&!"!

"# % &""&-,&$ &$ ./  + ) &- $2 3&+  %",#""&* ,&$

"& & ), $" 

%"!

%"-&

&)"'1  

 := &$

"& -&! >D

 %"3 2 """

%32 .5555



:= (

" :" %2)!% %32 !3# = ?776 := &"

B&* %"#-- ! >555 :+= 

A#!&#"%  >555 :+= E&""&- !%#!!

I>555A1

!$&-&!!

$&" .>555 :+= C

"&- % 0555 :+= !"

&!&,! " 0555   $44 0 /1 1

4  .0 "  "

G#

 &- $2 %",#""& 3&+ *   "

 " !% "$ ",,

%)!%&- "$&%- %%

%&, $" %-!&$/0*776A1&87*555A1  % $&# &- ,&$

"& )

 ,!!2  " I ?>D

#$-!&$ % &-- &- , $

&"

,#

B&

 & 01"#!,  &$ 2 3  "#!

 &-- %

)

%

&" ,&$

"&$&#34,,&#&-, &! 2 "$ &$!&#% $%%!-" .8 !&""1&3 ,&"-

%32!

2 %"$""

% /5/" 3   +*% )%-*., 4   * -) 

$/& $   

! $1%