← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21390/2018allowed

Amit Garg v. Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited And ORS

2023-03-14Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj6 pages



 

    

          



 !" #$%$!&'()) 



  





  *+ 

 *    ,   

' - *

) ,+ ,)

 )             

       .... + ,)

 / ) * 

     !    "# $  #  %     &'&&()&* +,  -./  0       (&)'()&. +,  -&(/  !1   1 2  3#  0  !1     #1       0 #            #       1     &(4   1  ())' 5 1   6                  -3# !# 7 # 1)8 9 3:;&<%)4)< # 5   1 ())4  # ,84 9   ()&) ! #  1   !1# !0   10 1  = #      1 



 0!

 1 ()&'0      !          1    (()(()&'   0 !1 :

  #  0   !  !

!               #   1   0  !1   :

 

#     $  #     0 0 #1(4)(()&' = (.)(()&' 

!  = 

!-



      !   ##   6    #1        #1   8*)*<.%-01        4&)>   ,1 0   # #     1        !1  0#    1!1  1  ##            !   ?"+ !1  / 3# 77  2  3#     #       !1 !     ?"   0!0  0   &()8()&8 +,  -'/   0 

  

 - !

 ?  #   ! 0   &()8()&8 !1 # 79 &*8.4-()&8    #  "@  7900!1 #:

#  :

#  )>)'()&4   0      ?"  @    ?38><()&4 # :

#0!1 5 



 0    !        #  #  4&)>"

    3''*)8)'()&'   #  # 1  -   0  $             #   0    !    "   !    0  1     #  7    37 -A%? 38><%&4% B #%7 %7-&  &&&)()&*       1 0  #     #  #1  8*)*<.%-C     4&)>   0    !  7      0     &(4   1  ())'    3>&8*&'&&()&*   #   !        &'&&()&*0!   1   &(*

 1  ())' #       !   0   (*)'()&.D      #  !   0  ! 0 !1  -   9  !!1   #   !@##D0      0  !1   6=  0   10!#  0   #  0# 5E70   0"  FGD!#0 

 #10    #   !#!





 #        0 # !#11 ?               1       @      ,       !1     12 3# 1!  1!   1     "#    1 0  ;     11       0(4)(()&'7=34>-')H      1  ! !1   1      0  0#  #   (()(()&' 0  ;  !

        &( ;    !1  0  1    1  &(4+8/  1())'0    !     #0      #1 "  ! "!&( 10       #1!;    $ 0(4)(()&'   0  #  #1   !      &(  ?          #  !

" ;  $ ! !  !7$ 1 #   #



 # &(   

 #10   !"10   

 #1 !   !         1 0  !1  #  

   



   ! 



 !       ! " !     #$%&'&%   (    )%*)&$$ +    ! 



 

 

 "

    ,   -   ! .)& 

( /0 (     ,      )%*)&$$ !  +  " (  )& /0   !     (  ! 



 

 -  $)  1 !     ! ("  (   

 "  2

  '&*)&&31 2     !  4    !      ! "    $)' 5 $)3 ! 6" 7 )&&. +   /  -  $3 8&& /0  (  : !     7 (  2 (  "  ((   ,     )') )&$. 2 9

  '8*.&  )'))&$. 7 (    2"



 "

 ((   2    , 24  !"

   

 ,4  4"  4 !   ))&))&$. +    (    ! ))))&$.  );)$&$.  (   2"     < 

 



 !"!

!

))&))&$.

'88;

$38& ).&))&$.

$'&.= $.)& )8&))&$.

$838= $8&8 )=&))&$.

;%;3 $8.8 )'&))&$.

'8$$ $.&& )3&))&$.

%$)% $&%'

);&))&$.

''3$ $&$8 (  2 

  21  

 ! >    ,   2      ! )) ) )&$. 

#

)=))&$.  ("   >   , 42 " 

   /(4  2,   21  



2  



  42 "  



4 !! 

          ( 

  !    ((   " 



 ?   1 #4  >   4   2 4 44  ,  !   2  4  (  ! ))))&$.  )=).&$.@  D    !    -"#0       

      !#      7    #    D0    #    @    1

   0     #1 0       (&)'()&.!1  1       1              0 0 "#     1   # #  1  #        !   1(.)>()('0      1       0 0 0 #1         + ,)



 ()))         $ 

  0 (-4*  < A * 0 (   < A *