← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4089/2014dismissed

Vishwajit Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2015-03-13Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan8 pages

       

          

          

          

   

 

 

 

 





  !"# 



  !"# 



  !"# 



  !"#

 



$!"#

 



$!"#

 



$!"#

 



$!"# %&'()*%+%,-'

.+%+%,./ ./&0& '.+)+.)/1),)),2+'./&

.&3,2.,+&  $ 4

 $   

  

  $ 4

 $   

  

  $ 4

 $   

  

  $ 4

 $   

  

 /.&.,+ /.&.,+ /.&.,+ /.&.,+ $/ '%/)-60,20"278)+./+'.3.+%+%,./ $/

)9()"22%+%,)9278)+..,./)9")/1),) $/  $.'+),%"278)+./+'.::%&&%, ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;< ;<;<;< 

  

" 

  

" 

  

" 

  

" '.3.+%+%,./ )&&)%9&+'.)8+%,+'./.&3,2.,+= )/1),) 0>9%8./7%8.::%&&%,?'./.%,)+./+>./..//.2+ )&5+'.::%&&%,5@%,+/.)+%,-'%:)&%,.9%-%>9./+'.3&+ &&%&+),+ /.&&/?99.-.)2/.@ 4%,+'.&0>*.8+%,.

/+& 

/%.  )8+&  +')+  :)1  >.  ,+%8.2  )/.  +')+  +'. ::%&&%,  %&&0.2  )27./+%&.:.,+  2)+.2     %,7%+%,- )339%8)+%,&//.8/0%+:.,++!A+.:3/)/13&+&&&%&+),+ /.&&/&?99.-.)2/.@ 4%,7)/%0&&0>*.8+&%,+'.%-'./

208)+%, .3)/+:.,+"+)+.)/1),)   '/..3&+&(./.%, /.9)+%,++'.&0>*.8+%,./+&

 !

9)0&.#+'.)27./+%&.:.,+9)%22(,+'..&&.,+%)9 B0)9%%8)+%,&),2+'./.9.7),+3)/++'./.()&)&0,2./  C# &&.,+%)9D0)9%%8)+%,& 4 # &&.,+%)9D0)9%%8)+%,& 4 # &&.,+%)9D0)9%%8)+%,& 4 # &&.,+%)9D0)9%%8)+%,& 4 ?@  &&%&+),+  /.&&/&  ?)99  &0>*.8+&  .E8.3+ ?@  &&%&+),+  /.&&/&  ?)99  &0>*.8+&  .E8.3+ ?@  &&%&+),+  /.&&/&  ?)99  &0>*.8+&  .E8.3+ ?@  &&%&+),+  /.&&/&  ?)99  &0>*.8+&  .E8.3+ :30+./ 8%.,8."

%,.

/+&"

$)&& :30+./ 8%.,8."

%,.

/+&"

$)&& :30+./ 8%.,8."

%,.

/+&"

$)&& :30+./ 8%.,8."

%,.

/+&"

$)&& ::0,%8)+%,F$0&%8?,&+/0:.,+)9F8)9@ ::0,%8)+%,F$0&%8?,&+/0:.,+)9F8)9@ ::0,%8)+%,F$0&%8?,&+/0:.,+)9F8)9@ ::0,%8)+%,F$0&%8?,&+/0:.,+)9F8)9@ ?)@ ?)@ ?)@ ?)@ 2)8)2.:%8/.8/2(%+')+9.)&+##G +'.:)/H&/),.B0%7)9.,+-/)2. %,+'.I 3%,+&8)9.(%+'9.++./-/)2.& "" "" " ),2   )+  +'.  $)&+./5&  .-/..  9.7.9  %,  +'.  /.9.7),+ &0>*.8+/:),,2%),,%7./&%+1/),.B0%7)9.,+ 2.-/../:)/.%-,,%7./&%+1 ?>@ ?>@ ?>@ ?>@ 6,(9.2-.    %,2%J),&H/%+  03+  $)+/%8 &+),2)/2 ?8@ ?8@ ?8@ ?8@

)+%,)9  9%-%>%9%+1  .&+  ?

@J+)+.  .7.9

9%-%>%9%+1.&+? @&')99/.:)%,+'.:%,%:0:

.9%-%>%9%+1  8,2%+%,&  /  /.8/0%+:.,+&  ),2 )33%,+:.,+&)&&&%&+),+ /.&&/&%,99.-.& /7%2.2  0/+'./  +')+ 

  &')99  ,+  >.

/.B0%/.2  /  &08'  $)&+./5&  /-/)::.&  %, 2%&8%39%,.&/('%8'+'./.%&,

K ?@ ?@ ?@ ?@     

  %,  :30+./     

  %,  :30+./     

  %,  :30+./     

  %,  :30+./ 8%.,8.

8%.,8.

8%.,8.

8%.,8.

?)@ ?)@ ?)@ ?)@ 2)8)2.:%8/.8/2(%+')+9.)&+##G +'.:)/H&/),.B0%7)9.,+-/)2. %,+'.I 3%,+&8)9.(%+'9.++./-/)2.& "" "" " ),2   )+  +'.  $)&+./5&  .-/..  9.7.9  %,  :30+./ 8%.,8.  /:  ),  ,2%),  ,%7./&%+1  /  ), .B0%7)9.,+2.-/../:)/.%-,,%7./&%+1 ?>@ ?>@ ?>@ ?>@ 6,(9.2-.    %,2%J),&H/%+  03+  $)+/%8 &+),2)/2 ?8@ ?8@ ?8@ ?8@

.&%2.&  09%99%,-  +'.  )>7.  B0)9%%8)+%, 8),2%2)+.&  &'092  ')7.  89.)/.2  +'.  )+%,)9

9%-%>%9%+1.&+?

@/9.8+0/./&8,208+.2>1 +'.  ,%7./&%+1  /),+&  ::%&&%,"  0,8%9  

!

8%.,+%%8),2,20&+/%)9.&.)/8'/&%:%9)/+.&+ )88/.2%+.2>1+'.,%7./&%+1/),+&::%&&%, ?@ ?@ ?@ ?@    

%,%,./+&    

%,%,./+&    

%,%,./+&    

%,%,./+& ?)@ ?)@ ?)@ ?)@ 2)8)2.:%8/.8/2(%+')+9.)&+##G +'.:)/H&/),.B0%7)9.,+-/)2. %,+'.I 3%,+&8)9.(%+'9.++./-/)2.& "" "" " ),2 )++'.$)&+./5& .-/..9.7.9%,%,./+&/:

),,2%),,%7./&%+1/),.B0%7)9.,+2.-/../: )/.%-,,%7./&%+1 ?>@ ?>@ ?>@ ?>@ 6,(9.2-.    %,2%J),&H/%+  03+  $)+/%8 &+),2)/2

+.

+.

+.

+. 4 /+'.3&+.8+0/./%,+'.)809+1 %,.  /+&"  %7.  .)/5&  %39:)  /:  +'.

/.8-,%L.2,%7./&%+1/,&+%+0+.(%99>.+/.)+.2 )&.B0%7)9.,+++'.:)&+./5&2.-/..

,&08') 8)&.  /  +'.  30/3&.    2.+./:%,%,-  -2 )8)2.:%8/.8/2+'.3.//:),8.%,$)+/%8),2 .B0%7)9.,+  .E):%,)+%,  ),2  +'.  1.)/91 .E):%,)+%,&  +)H.,  20/%,-  +'.  %39:)  80/&.

(%99>.8,&%2./.2 ?@ ?@ ?@ ?@   

 

$   

 

$   

 

$   

 

$  $$ 

 $$ 

 $$ 

 $$ 

?)@ ?)@ ?)@ ?)@ 2)8)2.:%8/.8/2(%+')+9.)&+##G +'.  :)/H&  /  ),  .B0%7)9.,+  -/)2.  )+  $)&+./5&

.-/..9.7.9/),.B0%7)9.,+B0)9%%8)+%,/: ),  ,2%),  /  /.%-,  ,%7./&%+1J/.8-,%L.2 ,&+%+0+%, %, ::0,%8)+%,J $)&& ::0,%8)+%,J*0/,)9%&:

.&%/)>9.

.&%/)>9.

.&%/)>9.

.&%/)>9.

?%@ ?%@ ?%@ ?%@ '

.-/..  %,  ::0,%8)+%,J  $)&& ::0,%8)+%,J  0/,)9%&:  /:  ),  ,2%), ,%7./&%+1/),.B0%7)9.,+2.-/../:)/.%-, ,%7./&%+1 ?%%@ ?%%@ ?%%@ ?%%@ (  1.)/&  099  +%:.  +.)8'%,-J/.&.)/8' .E3./%.,8.%,),1)/.)$)&&::0,%8)+%, ?

.(&3)3./&)88/.2%+.2(%+' " )+%,)9 .(&

 -.,8%.&"  )2%  /  .9.7%&%,"  %9:  $.2%)" /.30+.2  )27./+%&%,-  )-.,8%.&"  30>9%8  /.9)+%, %8./&    +'.  7./,:.,+&"  30>9%8  &.8+/ 0,2./+)H%,-&  ),2  .&+)>9%&'.2  %,20&+/%)9  ),2 8::./8%)9'0&.&@ ?>@ ?>@ ?>@ ?>@6,(9.2-.%,2%J),&H/%+03+$)+/%8 &+),2)/2 ?@ ?@ ?@ ?@   

 %, $0&%8   

 %, $0&%8   

 %, $0&%8   

 %, $0&%8 ?,&+/0:.,+)9F8)9@ ?,&+/0:.,+)9F8)9@ ?,&+/0:.,+)9F8)9@ ?,&+/0:.,+)9F8)9@ ?)@ ?)@ ?)@ ?)@ 2)8)2.:%8/.8/2(%+')+9.)&+##G +'.:)/H&/),.B0%7)9.,+-/)2. %,+'.I 3%,+&8)9.(%+'9.++./-/)2.& "" "" " ),2   )+  +'.  $)&+./5&  .-/..  9.7.9  %,  +'.  /.9.7),+ &0>*.8+/:),,2%),,%7./&%+1/),.B0%7)9.,+ 2.-/..  /:  ),  ,2%),  ,%7./&%+1J/.%-, ,%7./&%+1 ?>@ ?>@ ?>@ ?>@ 6,(9.2-.    %,2%J),&H/%+  03+  $)+/%8 &+),2)/2 ?8@ ?8@ ?8@ ?8@

.&%2.&  09%99%,-  +'.  )>7.  B0)9%%8)+%, 8),2%2)+.&  &'092  ')7.  89.)/.2  +'.  )+%,)9

9%-%>%9%+1.&+?

@/9.8+0/./&8,208+.2>1 +'.  ,%7./&%+1  /),+&  ::%&&%,"  0,8%9   8%.,+%%8),2,20&+/%)9.&.)/8'/&%:%9)/+.&+ )88/.2%+.2>1+'.,%7./&%+1/),+&::%&&%,

+.

+.

+.

+. )@ )@ )@ )@

  &')99  /.:)%,  +'.  :%,%:0:

.9%-%>%9%+18,2%+%,/)33%,+:.,+)&&&%&+),+ /.&&/%,99.-.& /7%2.2  0/+'./  +')+ 

  &')99  ,+  >.

/.B0%/.2  /  &08'  $)&+./5&  /-/)::.&  %, 2%&8%39%,.&/('%8'+'./.%&,

>@ >@ >@ >@ .9)E)+%,#G%&-/),+.2 /:##G+ #G    :)/H&  )+ $)&+./5&  2.-/..  9.7.9  /   8),2%2)+.&)/1),) 8@ 8@ 8@ 8@ .9)E)+%,#G%&-/),+.2 /:##G+ #G:)/H&++'. '

.-/..'92./&('

# ')7.  3)&&.2  +'.%/  $)&+./5&  2.-/..  %,  /.9.7),+ &0>*.8+3/%/++'.3+  2@ 2@ 2@ 2@ .9)E)+%,#G%&-/),+.2 /:##G+ #G:)/H&)+$)&+./5&2.-/..9.7.9%,/.9.7),+ &0>*.8+  +  +'.  '1&%8)991  ),2  7%&0)991 ),2%8)33.23./&,& .@ .@ .@ .@ .9)E)+%,#G%&-/),+.2 /:##G+ #G:)/H&)+$)&+./5&2.-/..9.7.9%,/.9.7),+ &0>*.8+++'.8),2%2)+.&('3)&&+'.%/$)+/%8 .E):%,)+%,/:/0/)9&8'9&)/1),)  / +'%&  30/3&.  &8'9  ('%8'  )99  0,2./  +'. *0/%&2%8+%,%99)-. ),8')1)+&)/1),)&')99 >.89)&&%%.2)&/0/)9&8'9&

+. 

+. 

+. 

+. EEEEEE )@ EEEE >@EEEE .9)E)+%, 4 .9)E)+%, 4 .9)E)+%, 4 .9)E)+%, 4EEEE %@ EEEE %%@ EEEE %%%@ EEEE

+.4

+.4

+.4

+.4 EEEE

+.4

+.4

+.4

+.4 EEEE

+.4

+.4

+.4

+.4 EEEE  +  %&  ,+  2%&30+.2  +')+  +'.  3.+%+%,./  B0)9%%.2  '%&

)8'.9/  .-/..  %,  +'.  1.)/    &.80/%,-  AG  :)/H&  ),2 +'./.)+./2%2'%&$)&+./&%,%,./+&?+(1.)/&80/&.@%,+'. 1.)/!&.80/%,-IIG:)/H&/:+'.99.-.%,./+&" .8+/"'),2%-)/'

# '.3.+%+%,./')7%,-:)2.),)++.:3++&0>:%+), ,9%,.  )339%8)+%,  /  +'.  3&+    &&%&+),+  /.&&/  ?99.-. )2/.@ 4%,%,./+&%,/.&3,&.++'.27./+%&.:.,+2)+.2  "+'.&):.')&,+>..,)88.3+.2/+'./.)&,+')+ '.')&,+B0)9%%.2+'. )+%,)9 9%-%>%9%+1.&+?

@J+)+..7.9

9%-%>%9%+1.&+? @ '. 8)&. &.+  03  ,  >.')9   +'.  3.+%+%,./  %&  +')+ 0,2./  9)0&.  #  ?@    +'.  27./+%&.:.,+  -7./,%,-  .&&.,+%)9 B0)9%%8)+%,&"+'./.B0%/.:.,+')7%,-3)&&.2

()& )339%8)>9.++'.3&+&&&%&+),+ /.&&/&%,&0>*.8+&+'./ +'),  :30+./  8%.,8."  $)&&  ::0,%8)+%,"  $0&%8 ?,&+/0:.,+)9  ),2  8)9@  )&  )9&  %,.  /+&   +  ')&  >.., 7.'.:.,+918,+.,2.2+')+),.E8.3+%,')2>..,8)+.-/%8)991 8)/7.2  0+  %,&)/  )&  B0)9%1%,- 

  %,  8./+)%,  &0>*.8+& %,8902%,-+')+%,./+&  ,0/+'./),8.&08'&0>:%&&%,"

9)0&.#?@+'.27./+%&.:.,+('%8'9)%22(,B0)9%%8)+%,& /+'.3&+&&&%&+),+ /.&&/%,%,./+&')&)9&>.., )27./+.2  +"  ('./.%,  +'./.  ()&  ,  /.B0%/.:.,+    3)&&%,-

,),0+4&'.99")/-0:.,+/)%&.2%&+')++'.8),2%2)+0/. +'.3.+%+%,.//+'.3&+&&%&+),+ /.&&/%,%,./+& ')2+>./.-09)+.2&+/%8+91)&3./+./:&),28,2%+%,&+'. 27./+%&.:.,+  ),2  )&  &08'"  +'.  )8+%,    +'.  /.&3,2.,+4 ::%&&%,%,,+)88.3+%,-'%&)339%8)+%,,)880,+,+ 3)&&%,- 

  8),,+  &0&+)%,  )&  +'.  &):.  ()&  ,+  +'. :),2)+.),2/.B0%/.:.,+%,+'.27./+%&.:.,+2)+.2  %,/.&3,&.+('%8''.')2)339%.2/+'.3&+%,B0.&+%, I )7%,-'.)/29.)/,.280,&.9/+'.3)/+%.&)+9.,-+'" +'%&0/+%&+'.8,&%2./.27%.(+')++'./.%&,:./%+%,+'. &0>:%&&%,&  /)%&.2  ,  >.')9    +'.  3.+%+%,./  ),2  +'.  (/%+ 3.+%+%,2.&./7.&2%&:%&&)9  './.(092>.,2%&30+.(%+'+'.3/3&%+%,+')+ +'.8),2%2)+0/.+'.3.+%+%,./)&/.-)/2&+'.3&+&&%&+),+

I /.&&/%,+'.&0>*.8+%,./+&(092')7.+>.8,&%2./.2 &+/%8+91  )&  3./  +./:&  ),2  8,2%+%,&  8,+)%,.2  %,  +'. 27./+%&.:.,+  2)+.2      ')+  ')7%,-  >..,  &)%2"  +'.

27./+%&.:.,+),2"3)/+%809)/91"9)0&.#9)1%,-2(,.&&.,+%)9 B0)9%%8)+%,&/+'.3&+(092')7.+>./.)2)&)('9. 9)0&.#?@+?@&+),2B0)9%%.2>1 +.4?)@('%8'9)1&2(,%, 0,):>%-00&  +./:  +')+ 

  &')99  /.:)%,  +'.  :%,%:0:

.9%-%>%9%+1  8,2%+%,  /  )33%,+:.,+  )&  &&%&+),+  /.&&/  %, 99.-.&   +.4?)@2.&,+8)/7.0+),12%&+%,8+%,):,-&+ &&%&+),+  /.&&/&  )&  /.-)/2&  +'.  /.B0%/.:.,+    3)&&%,-

9.)/91"&08'/.B0%/.:.,+3)&&%,-

(092 )3391)8/&&+'.>)/2),2+)998),2%2)+.&)3391%,-/+'.3&+ &&%&+),+ /.&&/%//.&3.8+%7.+'.&0>*.8+ '.3/7%&+

+.4?)@  0/+'./  89)/%%.&  +')+ 

  (092  ,+  >.  +'.

/.B0%/.:.,+,91/&08'$)&+./5& /-/)::.&%,2%&8%39%,.&/ ('%8'+'./.%&,

+%&+'.8)+.-/%8),239.)2.28)&.

,  >.')9  +'.  /.&3,2.,+4::%&&%,  %,  %+&  /.391  +')+ 

  %& )7)%9)>9.  %,  +'.  &0>*.8+    %,.  /+&  ),2  )&  :),1  )&   8),2%2)+.&('')289.)/.2

%,+'.&0>*.8+%,./+&')2 )339%.2/+'.3&+&&%&+),+ /.&&/?%,./+&@%,/.&3,&. ++'.27./+%&.:.,+2)+.2  08'&+),2')&,+:.+ (%+'),1/.>0++)9)++'.'),2&+'.3.+%+%,./  '.89)%:+'.3.+%+%,./)&/.-)/2&.9%-%>%9%+1/+'. 3&+&&%&+),+ /.&&/?%,./+&@3/8..2&,))99)8%0& 3/.:%&./.)2%,-89)0&.#?@),2?@+'.27./+%&.:.,+%, %&9)+%,),2++'./.>1/.,2./ +.4?)@0,2./9)0&.#+>.

/.20,2),+   08' )/.)2%,-  ),2 8,&+/08+%, +'. /.9.7),+

 89)0&.+'.27./+%&.:.,+(092,+>.3./:%&&%>9.  ')+)3)/+"%+%&,+.7.,+'.8)&.+'.3.+%+%,./+')+ ),1+'./8),2%2)+.('')2,+B0)9%%.2

')&>.., 8,&%2./.2)&.9%-%>9./)33%,+:.,+++'.3&+&&%&+),+ /.&&/%,+'.&0>*.8+%,./+& &&08'".7.,+'.39.) 2%&8/%:%,)+%,%&,+)7)%9)>9.++'.3.+%+%,./  /+'./.)&,&/.8/2.2)>7."+'%&0/+%,2&+')+ +'.)8+%,+'./.&3,2.,+4::%&&%,%,')7%,-+/.)+.2+'. 3.+%+%,./+>.%,.9%-%>9./+'.3&+&&%&+),+ /.&&/%, %,./+&%&&+/%8+91%,+./:&+'..9%-%>%9%+18,2%+%,&8,+)%,.2 %,+'.27./+%&.:.,+2)+.2  

:./%+ /%+3.+%+%,%&2%&:%&&.2 ? 

  

@ ? 

  

@ ? 

  

@ ? 

  

@ $!"# $!"# $!"# $!"#      

 

 

 

$ $ $ $

+.

+.

+.

+.

'.+'.//..//.2++'..3/+./M?

.&J @ '.+'.//..//.2++'..3/+./M?

.&J @ '.+'.//..//.2++'..3/+./M?

.&J @ '.+'.//..//.2++'..3/+./M?

.&J @