B.S.N.L. v. Ashok Gupta
!" #$ %&#%#'(
& )**'++ ! , -' ,., ,/ !( )',*0!('! 1
!" #$ %&#%#'(
& )**'++ ! , -' ,., ,/ !#'/ ! )',*0!('! 333
!" #$ %&#%#'(
& )**'++ ! , -' ,., ', 45.* )',*0!('! 661
!" #$ %&#%#'(
& )**'++ ! , -' ,., '7 4. )',*0!('!
!" #$ %&#%#'(
& )**'++ ! , -' ,., ,085.* )',*0!('!
3
!(''* !$ )**'++ ! , -' ,.,
!" #$ %&#%#'(
& )',*0!('! 9:
&5;
! "#$ %% &&
'( (
)'#*+% #$ %% && '( (
+ #,"+
'( (
-%
'(
(
'
.''/
&& "
%% & .
' 0# "#
1 +% /
' % & '.'& 2+ ' &3' '#&# '&& "
%% & 4" $" '/. 5'.'
45 " "
%% & '/ 0 0<
#!, ! **' + 0 1 0<
0333 0<
0661 0<
0
0<
2 /' $$+
''/ 0 " "
6+ 0 &3 $&''/
7 # '+ .+ 3' " '
$&'.
+ /' "
0 '/+ '/.+ %" 0'&& "
/ + " "
$&'. %% && ' 0
07 &'.' ' 8 03 0<
2 "
+' 45
7 9(3 ' .'
07 6'#'& :+/ :+' ;'#' ' , & %% & 07 45 "
.
3 &&3 "
+' 3 $
% 7 <"
(
% /" "'
/+& $%% &
1'/
&
)+/.
6+ &3
' )+/.
% 6'#'&:+/ :+' ;'#' ', &
3"'& .' '/ " %" $ $ ' "
% #' "
. '
"
'
&'0'&' 7 %7 7 .+ && / &7 + '//' "
.<"
7& 1%
&'.' 70) $ ' " "
+'
45 3 "% &7 0
07 '.
5 &3
6+
$ ''/ " "
.+ $&'.
' && "
+' &/ 3' " '
3 + /' "
(
%% && '
"3
%&' '
(453 ' &
.
"
+' 07' 3
0
07&'.' '0 '/ 0 7 "
. "
$$ +& $+ $ ' %% & '
%% && 6+
'
.
''/ & &3
6+ 0
#'/ " "
+' .+ 3 + /' "
0+ +%"&'/ "
'
%& " $&'. %&' '
3 0
07&'.' ' "
%% & -$ % ' $ 45 =
% / 3
' .'
>
&'/ // '
"
%&' '
(45 " %
"
0# $% '
$ %% &
" 0
%
07
% / 8"# "
& $+ & % '
%
+ "
%%
01
7 +' .+ 3 $&' 45 "
/ + " +' 3 3' "'%
'
7
. "
$$ +& $+ $ '3"'$"" 0
$1
. "
+' .+ 0 $.
+ ' '
+' 0
5
$+ & %% && " /+ " ' ' .
" "
%
' &'.' ' '&'/ "
+' /' "
45$..
$ 3
3"
"
$.%73 '$ % +$" "
+' 3"'$" "#
3' "'&'.' '?
/+ "
"
3 $ &'$ ' 0
# ' '
4 $"
"' ?'/"6+ "' %' 0+ "
.
" '$
?@0& +%
.
6+
'
.'/ "
#'
3 ?@0& '/& 4 $" "' 6+ ' $
!
!" " "
&'.' '
. "
'$ % ' 45
. "
7$+ $ '$$ +
+' .+ & $+ &
/+ " ' "
$
#$ %
%
!!
" & &' & (( ' 3 0
07 '/& 4 $" "' 6+ " "
+' 45 0 7 "
%
'
7
. "
$+ $ '3 0
07&'.' '%% &/' "
0# )+/.
' '&&% '/0
?@0& +%
.
6+ A >''/ "
' '& 6'#'& :+/ " "
+' .+ 3 + '/ /' "
(
" 0 $.
'& %% &3 /' "' ''/3 "
&72+ '3"'$" '
$ '
'' "
%% & ' 3"
' "
$ $'
$+. $ ' $+ 0# +' ' 0
07&'.' ' 8 $ )+/.
"' 6+ &
'
.
?@0& +%
.
6+ ' ' 3 %
% ' ' &3 " &'.' ' ' +'
7 07453' "'7 ' '$ % ''
3' "'&'.' '$ ' 4 $" "' 6+ '$
( (
$'
-.' "
& /&% % ' '' '.'& $ $'
$+. $ 0
&&3 !
&' '
(%% && 45 $.%7 $.
'
-'
$ 3
+$$ ('('
B' 8' 5'.' ' %
' '&'/ +' 07 B' 8' ' 7 <"
+'
3+&"#
3' "'&'.' ' '
07 B' 8' ?3
.'
&7 &'.' ' %
' '&'/ +' 0745' "
7 <"
+' 3 07 45 3' "' &'.' ' %
' "
.' $.'/' -'
$ 6 2+ &7 "
+' ' 3' "'&'.' '8 "' #'
38. +%%
07
+
%
)+/.
"' 6+ .
&7)* &'
+
' % ' ' ,! '- !!. $'
/
% ' '
'- !!
( $'
A 1
% ' ' ( 0'- !!.( $'
6+ &
(
"3
)+/.
"' 6+ ' "
$
#$%
%
!!
"& &'& ((?3
"' )+/.
" & 0
$ '
' "
$ )* +"& ' "
$ '- 1 "6 2+ &7' ' "
& " +' 07 "
%&' '
(%% && ' 3' "'&'.' '
&*+% 5 6'#'&
3"
'?@0& +%
.
6+ +
' "
#'
3 1 ' "
'%% & 2+ ' &'.' '
8 #'
3 "
0# % % ' ' &3 "
''/ 6+ &3 " "
+' ' 0
07&'.' '
%
& /&&7 + '0& <"
+' %&' '
' "
%% & $% ' 0#
&& 0
+$"
"
& 0 3' "'&'.' ' && "
+'
7 0745
3' "' &'.' '
2+ & .7 0# ' $+ ' 0 0<
#!, ! **' + 0 1 0<
0333 0<
06610<
0
0<
2
&&3 "
)+/.
$
0 " "
6+ &3
' ?3
"
%% &0 '/
' ' .'
0 '/3' "+ .
' 0 0<
#!, ! **' +
+' %&' '
(%% && ' $
3' " $ +/"+
7 9(
+%
3 7 "
"+
"+
&7&/3' "% &'
+ +
'
C
D%
+. 0 1 0<
+' %&' '
(%% && ' $
3' " $ +/"+
7 A9( +%
&$ ' 7 "
"+ '/" "+
' 7' &7&/3' "% &'
+ +
'
C D%
+.
03330<
+' %&' '
(%% && ' $
3' " $ +/"+
7 9( +%
7 "+ "+
7' &7&/3' "% &'
+ +
'
C D%
+. 06610<
2
+' %&' '
(%% && ' $
3' " $ +/"+
7 A9( +%
3 7 + "+ '/" "+
' 7' &7&/3' "% &'
+ +
'
C
D%
+. 0
0<
2
+' %&' '
(%% && ' $
3' " $ +/"+
7 9( +%
&$ '# "+ "+
"'
7 3&7&/3' "% &'
+ +
'
C
D%
+.
A '
'&& "
0# $ " 0
&&3 C D "
.
& "
7 $" / %70& $$+
#'$ % #' 453"'$"3 $..
$'&0+ ' $ ' !. =
RAJ KUMAR 2015.02.13 19:01 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Chandigarh