Charan Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

 





      
    

 !"#"$%& '() ( * + $ "$,*  "

"$+ -+#.#

.$/ 01 *+#  #2$ $ # &%  34& 



 5

 
   !

" #$%&   !'

()

"   *+(,  !

"- 
 5

) .  "      //   /      

"," &

!0(

) 

! , ( )",

."""/( )
     1 2 223      

!    $("/  4/  5/ 6! $
 
!

#(. ( ( #(
!

6 7& *"$!,, 8 (" 


 (!!

5 (),"  /( 9 1 2 223 

!  $

 ) /  ",    * (
& ",/"$ 1 2   /( 9) : : 221  22:5

 

(! 88

 8  
      !!(       "  (    ( ")",//!

, " //  /"!&!" !(  " )  

#!( ""/)

"! , ")!,,)84;!(  4/ 6)8  :

3)(  5 8 !!( 8

" )!, )/(")8( ")/
   

   )8"</
( &/", ,()",< 

"" !! "  !    )  !  )8    ,"(/    

1



  #!( "/(", " &/ )8        !  "# $% 
  & &%
' $( )* *(  =!>  "";?6?   ,!"",),"  * (
&.( "  ", ,,/ " 8(!

80(  () )8 

"

!/",")8!!(, "*(

= > 3 @ ") 

(")8!!(, @

,", !

  -   !   !(   "$   ("  "";  ?6?

        *(   =>  !  "      "!( !(, !" * (
&      /          (8  !  ("   $("/4/0(  A

!(),



,!,, "", !$("/ 4/

 !() (,) ", ! ,  @ ! * (
& 
!

. !  $("/  4/  

 )        !    ",

!"" 

/.$("/4/ 

 ,        !        )  !,,   ",      "    * ( 
&  5    (),     $("/  4/    0(    ,      () ! ,  A

!, ,&/",  2 -

- 3

-.""

! " ! 

!   !,,,  ", $6 $/ $,$" +( 


 &5 ((),"*(

= > "", !

),"( 8)8 !

! 

) (!"",, / 3 ." "   "

  )&"(/),/(

8 ! &/"

"( /(   ", ""

!  ,!)8 $("/4/ $
 
!

#( !/   !  //  ",  .  !    !

  , 

 

 ,"

8 /)  "."(),8 ""

!   !

  ()0( ,!,, ", /" 8 !&!

/",/ "  " 1 5  !( "   "(! ! : *(  +   ! "#$%
&&%
' $( )*"!) "!( ",""," * (
&.  ""(!)  ,

#-

  -$%


. /! 0 #

 ..  #

.. *   #  /.!  2!      %  ( 

       &%      .  2  2   .    

      .     

  !3 2 *(  = >!

 8"! "",$ ! 

),"( 8)8 !

! 

) (! "", /7(,  "";*(  =>" 

"!( !(, !" * (
&!(( $("/4/

0(   A

!(),

 ,!,, ", $ !.  A

!( 

8  "

8 ,!,,/ /(  (!

-  .!,,,()! , 

8?!((", !"(  8    ) 8   " ,/    (8  5  ,    *(  

  $("/4/

4;!( 4/  (      6  7&  *"    $       , !! &*"< &   ) .""

!! 

/
  !,"



"! ", * (
&)

! $("/4/ /  !! 8((  ,  " " $!""

!  "! 

! $("/4/  ,!

/(,))8 !(  "",  !  , 

! $("/4/ /""

!! !&/"," &

" , 

!(  
(!     "    ,          (  )8   $("/4/ /""

! ","

&./! $("/ 4/(  ),! " ;!

(,4   ,),)8" ,"" ", 8

-5)  ) "(  &"0( (!  / ,4   8 

3 !!(  -

 "/ ! (/  ,,!

/5 ! " ,  8 80(/ ",8

 "/ !/",/ "  "

"!(

 )  !/!

)&""((!)8   $("/  4/    !        !(  )8  8  

"

!(),!,"() !"( ("!6

5    

    ""         !

/     ",!

,//8!), 

/ ,.<?)  ";
(&&.%/ 24& + . )5* #&6$  ")  ;,,8    !,  !

,!).  ) ( , 2 .  . .1//

7  % 8! )5

2!.

  .%.       %    .     

9..:..:

  & .!8!% .9.% 
%2

- !!%.2.

 !%..


/;  2

                 2  .  

  
; /. -

*%/

1 
    !

!  "/.../ ; . 
 ; ;'.2 /.-

* /.

;

.2 

./.2./!

. 


  '/. .2 . '+ 7 .(  %. . 8!

/    !/


.

./ .!

! !% /. 9!/!. !

7

/

  +

. ./3  .  ",/(  8 ! & '() (  6
 5

$# +"