← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19172/2020dismissed

Arti Sharma And ANR v. Central Administrative Tribunal And ORS

2020-11-27Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih,Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma7 pages



         

  

   



   



   " #



 

  # "   $

% 

  $

  

 & '                  

  (  "

)"'

  

 

'

   ( *+, ! -  

 .#  $





     

        $ 

 

 

 /  1"

 23  '  4 

 

  

   # "

 $

% 

  $

,

4

 $'' 05 3

4

'

   "   

 

  # " 

67



-$8" $

 ,

 

0  1"

 2

293  ,

4 

  

'    





    

'

     $

 $  $ $  ''  

' ! :

"

     %  4 

 



  " ''   ,"

4 

 )   &

    :  "

   :

  "    

 $

' 9  /;0  1"

 23 $"'

 "' " $6' ! :

" *  

 

 '



   ''   ,  7;   $   

 

" ''  

  

,



8"

   ,

$  94  ;:

 ''



 

 '



 

 $

 

   "

   

 

 /;

 1"

 2/3  $



   

 -   

"''

$    

4 )    0 

 

 "  

  2

 '   $

 

  6274   6294   "+'

:

,  

"''

$       94  

  '' '"

"  

"  ''      

 '    !   :

" #

4' 



8"



  ,

 

" "  

  

    ! " #  "   $ %

$

!

  &    !  "  !

       !

  '" (   ) &    "   !

&

" *

 ! "

 "   

 !  &

$ 

& $ " $ , 

-

!

- 

.    + $/



0      , ,   !

!

 1 ,)

 

  3  

  

            /   + #/ " &  

! & &

& 

&&



 "!

 &  " "   " !

! & 

- 4         !

   &  "    "   &     "    !     ' &      '5

 ! $$

0

 &

" 

  

     6   6      .$ !  / "&  

 " $$ " & !     

+ '

  



  " $$" & ! &5

  *$

 4      $$" &  "  

$

 "  !

 &    

  ! "   & ' " &! &   !  " 

 6 7    &

   

$$ / '(  "' 

$ 

  $

#$ 

( 8

 !



 

*

  $   "

& "  " $$

   ' "

 9  $    " & '" 5 (

  

*



  /   &   '  (   '        6   "   

6  

/ "&  

 " !     

'

  

 $$    

  &

   &&   '

# 

   $$ '

&$ 

-  &

  ' 

'          !&    

  :  /

!-  !

  ' & 

 $'   $$  $ ' !

$$" &  -  &

 ' ! $ $



 '

$ ' !

  "

!!"

 ! !$$

$

   &     !

" 

&

(   / '( $  "



$    "

  " !

$$

 " 

$  $



 -  

!

!



  ' & #  $$

     6

 '

8!

 $ ' !

  " $$" & 

 

 



 "

' " '

$ '     !

    "    "              !  

-  "

 !

' &

  -    !

$$

$

 $$

 6 5 

  ! $$

  9  / "&  

   $$" & !     

'

  

   " &

    !  5    

 

   !!

       6

  6      .$ !     / " &  

;   

6 

& 

  $

! $$

$$" & 





&

   

 !

(!!

       $

  

&   "   !

 

 

  !

$$

< 



$  / '(  &  "  " 

4



  '

    &!

  "

 " !

$$

  7'

  &  & 



     '"

 " 



   "  &$"  6

$      /   &   '  (   / "  %

/ " 3 (!  !

& "&

  

!

  $ 

 "

' " '

 + , 

-

!

- 

.   

+ $/  

0        ,  ,  

 

       !

   &  "    "   & !  

   " !

$$



!

 $$

 6 

' 

         "  '

 '    

    ( 

!





$ ' !

 !

 ! $  $$

!

 &  "

  95

!

$$

! & 

&

     '    "  !             "  !    

 $$

 : (



    

!

  $

!

    5

          9    / "&  

 !     

'

  

 ! &35 

3  !   $  !

    $$" & ! &5

  $

  

& "   





$    "

  !

           9    / "&  



"

' ' 

 6    

$$  " ' 

 

 "

' " '

 ! (

 $ $

  !         '  

     

'# '     

    !&   

  :  /

-  &

$

 ,"

' $$

$   $$" & $    -! 



6     .$ !  / "&  





!$$  "

 & $$" &

0 

 

   6 !  8      "      &&   '

# 

$$ '



&$ 

 -  

  $

&$ 



$        

            &&     '

#    ,  $  

!!

$  !

 / '(   !

  

6

&$ 

 

 9   " $

  ''  

   $

 && !  !

!    -  "

 ' "

  6 $  / '( 

/ "%

/ " 



     $ $ $$$

!

  =  " &   $  $

&   &      

     !" #$%&'

$($(     

   

'

-$<

  = 

& '

  =