High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1253/2009dismissed

Gurcharan Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2018-05-10Mr. Justice Amit Rawal6 pages

!"##$%&%'(!)*+ ,-$.!-!'%'/.

00#11!'"

2#-&,& "!"# ,'3!4 !'".#- #&0'5#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%

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

* %-.%'5 !'5 <!& 0-7"#5!&-"#-!"#-!0#-%5".-##7'".&4)".#".#'?#$,"%8# '/%'##-*'&"-,$"%'%8%&%'

*!4.!8%5#-5#-5!"#5@ +A %'".#0!)&$!1# &@;A!'5-#7!%'#50&"#5".#-#,0",/,&"* +>*%#*-!0#-%57-#".!''#)#!-<#A +A<.#'.#<!&

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

11<%'/%&&,#&(; C

>!'5@@*11<%'/!55%"%'!1%&&,#&<#-# !1&-!7#5(;

.#01!%'"%*%'&,00-".%&$!&#*#?!7%'#5 =; !'3%"

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

. /.. & & ..

-0-

.,1 )21"$'"#'5 ".!"!7!1/!7!"%'"<$!5-#&$,15'"4#5'##?$#0"4)!7#'57#'"

2 -,1#&!'5".#8#-'7#'".!&'0<#-"7#-/#"<$!5-#&$%8%1!'5 #1#$"-%$&"-#!7&7#-#1)4)#?#$,"%8#-5#-#?#$,"%8#%'&"-,$"%'E-5#- $!'8#--%5#7!'5!"#&"!","-)-,1#& " <!& '#?" $'"#'5#5 ".!" ".# ".#!00#11!'";01!%'"%<!& <-'/1)-#8#-"#5*5,#"<.%$..#&,#-#5!1&&&!1!-)!'5*".#-#-#* ".#$!,&#!$"%'<!&-#$,--%'/!'5".#&,%"<!&'"4!--#54)1%7%"!"%' .#-5#--#8#-&%'%&%11#/!1*',11!'58%5!'5".#01!%'"%%&#'"%"1#5" 0-7"%'!&-"!-!"#-7".#5!"#.%&-#8#-&%''"%$#.!& 4##'%&&,#5"".#01!%'"%4#-#.%&-#8#-&%'!'5".%&!$".!&4##' !57%""#5 4) ".#

<#- <.%1# !00#!-%'/ !& =; # ,-".#- &,47%""#5".!"".#"-!'&#-".#01!%'"%,"&%5#".#$!5-#$,15'".!8# 4##'5'#<%".,".%&$'&#'"'&,00-".%&$'"#'"%'*-#1%#5,0'".# -!"%5#$%5#'5%$,11#5,"%' $3 3

/.. 00 "4

03., 0 5- .' 6 0.2!'5*".,&*,-/#5".%& ,-"-&#""%'/;!&%5#".#%'5%'/&,'5#-$.!11#'/#4)!11<%'/".# #/,1!- #$'500#!1

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

&'" 4##'-5#-#5"4#-#8#-"#54,"<!&/%8#'0-8%&%'!10-7"%'-! &0#$%%$0#-%58#'".#!00#11!'";01!%'"%<!&-#8#-"#54!

".#&,%"!-#7#'"%'#5<!&%1#5'

@*%#*!"#-1!0&#7-#".!'

7 &#8#')#!-&#?01!'!"%'.!&$7#-".%''"!00-!$.%'/".#,-" <%".%'-#!&'!41#"%7#

-".#-#!&'&&"!"#5!48#*!7".#8%#<".!"".#-#%&' %11#/!1%")-0#-8#-&%")%'".#%70,/'#53,5/7#'"&!'55#$-##&".#,-"& 4#1<*<.%$.!-#4!&#5'!00-#$%!"%'-!1!'55$,7#'"!-)#8%5#'$# /-,'5-%'"#-#-#'$#%&7!5#,"*7,$.1#&&!')&,4&"!'"%!1B,#&"%' 1!<!-%&#& #&,1"!'"1)*".#!00#!1%&5%&7%&&#5

4,8 *)+%

6.3 '(9:& +303.;- <.

=.<

+303 0>!

=.<