V.K. Asthana v. Raghbir

 
    
 

    

!"#$%&% ''())%&# *(+","

%-$./+ ("'&0(&#

 1
  %-$./+ ''())%&# *(+","

!"#$%&% ("'&0(&# 



 !"#$  % #&$ +("(&# + /2+%3,&/%40*5%#( +#$(%''())%&# /&


%&0+("'&0(&#/&
6 +7%)/240*5%#( +#$(+("'&0(&# /&
6

%&0%''())%&#/&
6  % #&$

'

( ) 69:;%&0 66 /&
6

+  #$(  +(%"&"  +(5+0(04  #$(  %'')/5%#/&"  %+(  %))<(0

( /5/(&5=/&#$(5,+# ((/"3%0(-0 ()%= 0%="/& /)/&-#$( %''(%)/"5&0&(0 6 ;66 /&
6
+#$(+(%"&"+(5+0(04#$(%'')/5%#/&/"%))<(0 ()%=

 0%="/& /)/&-#$(%''(%)/"5&0&(0

%&0
 $("(#<%''(%)" /)(0%-%/&"##$(%<%+00%#(0  

'%""(0.=#+55/0(&#)%/3"+/.,&%)47&/'%#4%+(.(/&-0(5/0(0.= #$/"533&>,0-3(&#%&0#$('%+#/(""$%)).(+( (++(0#%"5)%/3%&#%&0 <&(++("'(5#/*()= %"( #$(5)%/3%&#<%"#$%#$(<%"<+2/&-%"%7<(('(+& ,)"$%& $%.%4%04,+#$%)7&/'%#&3&#$)="%)%+= 
:4 ?6 &  14$(<%""#%&0/&-&#$(2%5$%'+#/&&#$(3%/&%0 ,#"/0($/"')%5( <+2% #(+0/"5$%+-/&-$/"0,#=##%2("3(#+%&"'+## -#$/"*/))%-(%#%+,&0;@<$(&%5%+.(%+/&- A6:619

<$/5$  <%"  53/&-  +3  ()$/  "/0(  %&0  <%"  .(/&-  0+/*(&  +%"$)=  %&0 &(-)/-(&#)=$/#$/3%"%+(",)# <$/5$$(",

(+(0/&>,+/("<$/5$,)#/3%#()= (&0(0</#$%3',#%#/& #$(3/00)( /&-(+ #$(+/-$#$%&0 $(5%"( #$(<&(+4&#$(#$(+$%&04<%"#$%#/& %5#$($%0 ")0#$(*($/5)(#&($$#,/"#+=/&#$(=(%+ .,#.(5%,"(#$("%/0 $$#,/"#+=$%00/(0"$+#)=#$(+(% #(+4#$(+(-/"#+%#/&5,)0&#.( #+%&"

(++(0(0(&/(0 +<%&# 2&<)(0-(#$%##$(%55/0(&#$%0#%2(& ')%5(%&0 ,+#$(+')(%0(0#$%#/&%&=5%"($(<%"&#)/%.)(#'%=%&= 53'(&"%#/& $(+/.,&%)$()0#$%#$($%0&#.((&%.)(#'+*(#$("%)( %&0"/&5($(5&#/&,(0#.(#$(+(-/"#(+(0<&(+4&(-%#(0#$(5)%/3#$%#$( <%"&#)/%.)(#'%=%&=53'(&"%#/& "+(-%+0"#$(%55/0(&#4#$(+/.,&%).()/(*(0#$(#("#/3&=

#$(5)%/3%&#<$(+(/&$($%0"#%#(0#$%#% #(+#$(%55/0(&#4#$(&,3.(+

*($/5)(<%"-/*(&#$/3.=%3#+5=5)/"#<$$%0#%2(&$/3##$( $"'/#%)$(+/.,&%)%55('#(0#$(/&53(%"5)%/3(0.=#$(5)%/3%&#%&0 +0(+(053'(&"%#/&  

4?6/(
4?6%"'(+#$(3(0/5%)./))"4
:4?6 +'%/&%&0",

(+/&-%&0 
;4

?6 +)"" /&53( +#<

:

3&#$"%&0 
4 ?6 +)"" ,#,+(/&53(&%55,&# '(+3%&(&# 0/"%./)/#=

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

%+-,(0#$%##$(53'(&"%#/&/"/&%0(C,%#(4"/&5(&#$/&-$%".((&'%/0 + %##(&0%&#%&0"'(5/%)0/(#&3=5&"/0(+(0'/&/&4#$(+(/"&+(C,/+(3(&#  %'%/0%##(&0%&# +%&%3',#%#(03/00)( /&-(++(*(+4#$(+(/"&

,&5#/&%)0/"%./)/#=<$/5$#$(5)%/3%&#$%"",

(+(0%&0&#$/""5+(4$( 5,)0$%*(.((&%<%+0(0
4?6 +#$( D'(+3%&(&#0/"%./)/#=<$(+(%"

$($%".((&%<%+0(0

4?6&#$((&#/+(5&"'(5#," %5#4%3&# '(+",%0(0#$%##$(53'(&"%#/&5%&.((&$%&5(0

#$#$(%''(%)"%+(0/"3/""(0 '$#5'= #$(+0(+.(')%5(0&#$( /)( 5&&(5#(0 %''(%)&,3.(+(0%.*(   ; ( % #&$) **

!+ &, , - . /01-   2 % 1

&, , - - .

-34

% 1