High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/26828/2016dismissed

Parvinder Singh v. Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd & ANR

2017-11-21Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath6 pages

#$% %&'(')*

#$% %&'(')*+%,-%. +%,-%. +%,-%. +%,-%. /

#.+')1%.')23 %$'$')%. 4( 3#.#$%$.5%6,.7.#$')8$1#)1$3%.( %(7)1%)$(

!* !* !* !*98!::! 98!::! 98!::! 98!::!

.%(%)$* !.!!6);#5/1+&#$%/

.$3%7%$'$')%. !.#,#)3#.,#/1+&#$%/

.$3%.%(7)1%)$(

::!/8"

::!/8" 3% 7%$'$')%. 3#( &3#55%)2%1 $3% .1%. 1#$%1

-= >3'&33%3#(-%%)3%51')%5'2'-5% .$3%.%265#.81'($.'-6$.(3'7 )(3.$/$3%$3.%%'5&,7#)'%(/)#,%5=/)1'#)'5.7.#$') 8','$%1?

.(3.$@$3%89A/')16($#)%$.5%6,.7.#$')8','$%1? (3.$@$3%89A#)13#.#$%$.5%6,.7.#$')8','$%1? .(3.$@$3% 89A/;')$5='((6%1#)#1+%.$'(%,%)$)

$')+'$%#775'&#$')(

.$3%76.7(% #55$,%)$ 81'($.'-6$.(3'7#$ 01'

%.%)$75#&%(') 6);#-')>3'&33,%12#.3/ '($.'&$#)2.6.>#(.%(%.+%1 .&#$%2.= 3% 7%$'$')%./ >3 -%5)2( $ $3% &#$%2.=/ #775'%1 . $3% (#'1 1'($.'-6$.(3'7 #)1 #5( (6-,'$$%1 # .%2'($%.%1 5%#(% 1%%1 1#$%1

') .1%.$ '55$3%%5'2'-'5'$=&.'$%.'# 3#+')25#)1 .21>))5%#(% .# <=%#.(%.&3#)&%/$3%(#'1#1+%.$'(%,%)$>#((3%5+%1#)1#2#')/ )

B/#55$3%'5&,7#)'%(76-5'(3%1# .%(3#1+%.$'(%,%)$

(#,%76.7(%#)1$3'($',%#775'&#$')(>%.%')+'$%1 1'

%.%)$('$%(') >3'&3 8 1'($.'-6$.(3'7 . &3%165% #($% &#$%2.= . 3,%12#.3/

'($.'&$#)2.6.>#((3>)#$. D/$-%#55$$%1-=$3%8/ ,#.E%$ 75#)

D 3% 7%$'$')%. #775'%1 ') +'%> $3% (#'1 #1+%.$'(%,%)$ #5)2 >'$3 $3% .%2'($%.%1 5%#(% 1%%1 1#$%1

)

B/ $3% 7%$'$')%. .%&%'+%1 # 5%$$%. ., $3% 8 ')$',#$')2 3', #-6$$3%$>1% '&'%)&'%(')3'(#775'&#$')/)#,%5=/'"&,75%$%1#775'&#$') #( 7%. 7.%(&.'-%1 .,#$ #)1 " &..%&$%1 #77%)1'F ., ,$3%. $3% #775'&#)$@),#..'%19()$-%,%)$')%1 8$-%,%)$')%1')75#&% 83%7%$'$')%.>#(/$3%.%# $%./')+'$%1$-%7.%(%)$#$$3%$',% 1.#> 5$(/(&3%165%1$-%3%51) 0

/')>3'&33%>#((6&&%(( 65 >%+%./')$3%5%$$%.1#$%1 C

/3%>#(') .,%1$3#$'

')$3%'%51 4%.'

'&#$').%1%)$'#5(?

.(3.$@$3%49A$3%') .,#$')2'+%)-=3',') 3'( #775'&#$') '( 6)1 $ -% #5(%G')&..%&$G,'(.%7.%(%)$%1/ #

%&$')2 3'( %5'2'-'5'$=/$3%)$3%#,6)$ </

G1%7('$%1-=3',-% .%&)16&$')2 $3%4>651-% .

%'$%1#)13'(&#)1'1#$6.%&651-%&#)&%55%1 3% 4 >#( &)16&$%1 #)1 #$ $3#$ $',% '$ >#( 6)1 $3#$ $3% .%2'($%.%1 5%#(% 1%%1 (6-,'$$%1 -= $3% 7%$'$')%. 1#$%1

>#( )$ ,%%$')2$3%&.%1%)$'#5 <=%#.(#('$3#(-%%) 6)1(3.$-=#7%.'1 =%#.#)1

,)$3(3%7%$'$')%.>.$%#5%$$%.$3#$#$$3%$',% 43% >#( )$ 3#+')2 #)= #5$%.)#$% ('$% . $3% 21>) 8" . (6- 5&#$') 3>%+%./ 3% &651 7.+'1% $3% 5#)1 #( 3% >#( 655= &#7#-5% 76.&3#(% . %F%&6$% # 5%#(% 1%%1 #$ (3.$ )$'&% )

/ $3% 7%$'$')%. >#( ') .,%1 $3#$ $3% 5%#(% 1%%1 (6-,'$$%1 -= 3', #'5( $ ,%%$ $3% ,')',6, &.'$%.'# <=%#.( #1+%.$'(%,%)$'%

B#)1$3#$3% 3#1-%%)2'+%)77.$6)'$=$(6-,'$1%$#'5( #11'$')#5G#5$%.)#$%5#)1-6$3%

B &651)$7.+'1%$3%(#,%-=&) '.,')2+'1%3'(5%$$%.1#$%1 C

3% (#'1.1%.1#$%1

3#(-%%)',762)%1 ') $3%7.%(%)$ >.'$ 7%$'$')/ ')$%.#5'#/)$3%2.6)1$3#$$3%7%$'$')%.>#()%+%.2'+%)#)=77.$6)'$=$ (6-,'$$3%1%$#'5( $3%#5$%.)#$%5#)1$3%.>'(%3%3#1#5.%#1=,%)$')%1') 3'(5%$$%.1#$%1 C

))%F6.% "$3#$3%'( 655=&#7#-5%$76.&3#(% .%F%&6$%#5%#(%1%%1 <=%#.(($#.$')2 #1+%.$'(%,%)$'%

B3%>35%&#(% $3%7%$'$')%.3')2%(67)$3'(#.26,%)$$3#$ 3%3#()$-%%)2'+%)16%77.$6)'$=-=$3%.%(7)1%)$()$3'(.%2#.1/3% 3#(.% %..%1$$3%7.+'(')( $3%.&36.%.26'1%5')%( $3%%265#.8

'($.'-6$.( !#.&3

<')>3'&3'$'(7.+'1%1$3#$H')&#(%'

$3%

%.%1 5#)1 . 21>)G21>) #)1

%.%1 5#)1 . (3>.,G(3>., -= $3% (%5%&$%1&#)1'1#$%>3'&3'((3>)')$3%#775'&#$')'()$ 6)1,%%$')2$3% %5'2'-'5'$= &)1'$')(G.%I6'.%,%)$( #( ($'765#$%1 ') $3% #1+%.$'(%,%)$G-.&36.%G#775'&#$') #$ $3% $',% '%51 4%.'

'&#$') .%1%)$'#5( 4"/ $3%) $3% (%5%&$%1 &#)1'1#$% &#)

%. #) #5$%.)#$% 5#)1 >3'&3 '( >)%1 -= $3% #775'&#)$ G ,%,-%. $3% @#,'5= )'$9G7#.%)$( 2.#)17#.%)$(-$3,#$%.)#5#)17#$%.)#5" $3%#775'&#)$#()$3%5#($1#$%

. (6-,'((') #775'&#$') #( (7%&'

'%1 %'$3%. ') $3% #1+%.$'(%,%)$ . &..'2%)16, '

#)= ) &#(% #$ $3% $',% 4/ $3% &#)1'1#$% %F7.%((%1 ')#-'5'$=$,#E%#+#'5#-5%#)#55>%#$3%. ,$.#-5%#77.#&3.#167$$3% 21>)#(7%.#-+%&.'$%.'#/(6&3#5$%.)#$%5#)1>'55-%&)('1%.%1(6-;%&$$ '$((6'$#-'5'$= .7.+'1')2821>)#)1(3>., #&'5'$=#(,%)$')%1 3%.%')#-+%J 8%#.)%1&6)(%5 .$3%83#((6-,'$$%1$3#$,%.%5=-%&#6(% $3%7%$'$')%.>#((6&&%(( 65')$3%1.#> 5$(1%()$2'+%3',#)#-(56$% .'23$$(%%E$3%#55$,%)$-%&#6(%$3%') .,#$')(6775'%1-=3',#$$3%$',%

D '5')23'(#775'&#$')3#($-%#((%((%1#$$3%$',% 4$'( 6.$3%. (6-,'$$%1 $3#$ (')&% $3%.% >#( # .%(3 #1+%.$'(%,%)$ 1#$%1

B/ $3%.% .%/$3%7%$'$')%.>#(.%I6'.%1$7.+'1%$3%.%2'($%.%15%#(%1%%1 .# <=%#.(($#.$')2 .,

B#)1')$3'(.%2#.1/3%3#(.% %..%1 $ 5#6(% +''''"-" $3% .&36.% >3'&3 7.+'1%( $3#$ H.%2'($%.%1 5%#(% 1%%13#+')2,')',6, <=%#.( +#5'15%#(%7%.'1&,,%)&')2)#)=1#=

#1+%.$'(%,%)$67$$3%5#($1#$% (6-,'((') #775'&#$') #((7%&'

'%1%'$3%.')$3%#1+%.$'(%,%)$.&..'2%)16,' #)="J%3#(#5( .% %..%1$5#6(% < $3%.&36.%1%#5')2>'$3$3%@7.&%16.% ..%&%'7$ #775'&#$')9')>3'&3'$'(7.+'1%1$3#$$3%1% '&'%)&'%(>3'&3&#))$-% .%&$'

'%1 ')&561%( 5#6(% " >3'&3 7.+'1%( $3#$ H1%( )$ 3#+% 5#)1 21>)G(3>., #( 7%. $3% %5'2'-'5'$= &.'$%.'#J % 3#( #5( .% %..%1 $ 5#6(%

$3% .&36.% >3'&3 1%#5( >'$3 $3% @'%51 4%.' '&#$') .%1%)$'#5(4"/>3'&3.%#1(#(6)1%.*

8 4 8 4" # 4%.'

'&#$') $3%') .,#$')2'+%)')$3% #775'&#$') -= $3% #775'&#)$ >'$3 $3% .'2')#5 1&6,%)$( #)1 >'$3 $3% '((6')2 #6$3.'$'%( >3%.%+%. .%I6'.%1 '( &#55%1 '%51 4%.'

'&#$') .%1%)$'#5(4" - '%51+%.'

'&#$')>'55-%&#..'%16$ (%5%&$%1&#)1'1#$%#(7%.5#'11>)7.&%16.% ') $3%4/$3%') .,#$')2'+%)')$3%#775'&#$') -= $3% #775'&#)$ '( 6)1 $ -% &..%&$ 8%$$%. )$%)$ 8" >'55 -% '((6%1 >'$3 $3% #77.+#5 &,7%$%)$#6$3.'$= & ') $3% 4 '$ '( 6)1 $3#$ ') .,#$') 2'+%) ') $3% #775'&#$') '( #$ +#.'#)&% >'$3 $3% .'2')#51&6,%)$(#)1$3#$') .,#$')#

%&$($3%

< %5'2'-'5'$= $3%&#)1'1#$%/$3%)#5%$$%.>651-% (%)$-=%2'($%.%1($ G7%%1($7')$')2 6$ $3% 1'(&.%7#)&= #)1'1#$6.% (%5%&$%1 &#)1'1#$%')(6&3#&#(%>'55-%&#)&%55%1#)1

K #775'&#-5% (%&6.'$= 1%7('$ .%,'$$%1 -= $3% (%5%&$%1&#)1'1#$%-% .%4>'55-% .

%'$%1'

#5(%G')&..%&$G,'(.%7.%(%)$%1') .,#$')3#(-%%) 2'+%)')$3%#775'&#$')J 8%#.)%1&6)(%5 .$3%.%(7)1%)$(3#( 6.$3%.(6-,'$$%1$3#$$3% 7%$'$')%.>#(2'+%)$3%

%.$7.+'1%$3%#5$%.)#$%('$%-6$'$(3651-%#() $3%1#$% #775'&#$')#)1')$3'(.%2#.13%3#(#5(.%5'%167)$3%7.+'(') $3%.&36.%>3'&33#(-%%).%5'%167)-=$3%7%$'$')%.#)1'(,%)$')%1 3%.%')#-+%$'(#5((6-,'$$%1$3#$$3%7%$'$')%.3#($7.+'1%#5$%.)#$% 5#)1)$3%5#($1#$% (6-,'((') #775'&#$')#)1)$# $%.$3%(6-,'((') #775'&#$') 3#+%3%#.15%#.)%1&6)(%5 .$3%7#.$'%(#)1# $%.%F#,')')2 $3%.%&.1/#, $3%&)('1%.%17')')$3#$$3%.%'(),%.'$')$3%7.%(%)$ 7%$'$') -%&#6(% $3% 7%$'$')%. 3#1 #1,'$$%15= (6-,'$$%1 $3% .%2'($%.%1 5%#(% 1%%1 76.(6#)$ $ $3% #1+%.$'(%,%)$ 1#$%1

B >3'&3 >#( (3.$ -= # =%#.

,)$3#)1>#()$,%%$')2$3%&.'$%.'# <=%#.($'( #5( )$ 1'(76$%1 $3#$ $3'( %... '( )$ .%&$' '#-5%/ 3>%+%./ ') $%.,( $3% 7.+'(')( $3%.&36.%')&561')25#6(% +''''""/.% %..%1$#-+%/$3% 7%$'$')%.'(#55>%1$2'+%#5$%.)#$%5#)1>3'&3'(>)%1-=3',.$3% #,'5= 6)'$G7#.%)$( 2.#)17#.%)$(-$3,#$%.)#5#)17#$%.)#5")$3%5#($1#$% (6-,'((') $3% #775'&#$') #( (7%&'

'%1 %'$3%. ') $3% #1+%.$'(%,%)$ . &..'2%)16,'

#)=3%7%$'$')%.1'1)$ '55%+%)$3%(#'1&.'$%.'##)13#(

%.%1 $ 2'+% $3% #5$%.)#$% 5#)1 )> #$ $3% ($#2% >3%) $3% 4 3#( -%%)

&)16&$%1 #2#')($ 3', #)1 '$ 3#( -%%) 6)1 $3#$ $3% .%2'($%.%1 5%#(% 1%%1 (6-,'$$%1-=3','()$+#5'1 36( ') +'%> $3%.% / 1 )$ ')1 #)= ,%.'$ ') $3% 7.%(%)$ 7%$'$')#)1$3%(#,%'(3%.%-=1'(,'((%1$3623>'$36$#)=.1%.#($&($( ::!"

::!"

::!" 4! 4! 4! 4! /

0 /

0 3%$3%.(7%#E')2G.%#()%1

%(G 3%$3%..%7.$#-5%

%(G