Basdev Bansal v. Punjab And Haryana High Court And ANR
! "
#"$ $%& '"(')*$" +*",- "
"./!0(!1+ "*-" 02*"31+ "*"-
( /( * -1 * -" 4 /"
""" 5$*) * " " 678
+9 :
+9: *9*( ($! !& -"/**%$"+"$.$3";"")*$!&
"36*3&"1
(*" " 6*3&"1
1"!
--) $- -( * & - / 6
< /* 9 "3*3-! 5$! ()" 3*$ "
,$! < *')*$"=&!*3+--3 2" ,$!1 8 "$ $ &( * $%& 0 "3 !"
>*-"!3"""
-( !!/ "*-" 6
<<
>* &" * " * * -" / -- !"4 " *&!*3 *$" '/-"3 2-!2""( <*(1
'3
"-" 6*3&"1
)**34/* * "/!!"(**%$"+"$.$3";/**--!
(! *3&"1
"*-$"- ? >" !3)4/ *1*--! "&
-" (-$- "&"))*-(-"/**%$"/** "-"/!!/ &(*" " 6
'!3
$!!!"( "*--" -"(/**%$"/** & * & 3" -( $ )" -" ( - $- ' "-"/ ! &(*3-$) " " *@&"$"(1
+9: >*-"("/ ! &(*:-4)" "
" * "(- " * * !3 / " $ " * ,$!7"$/!!-!( "3 &(*$"$*!4 3"+"$!1*--)$-/3 !(!& *-" 6
<<
/" " *""" /$! &-(&!*3 "* -" *!$) 3* *&" ** " "+9:
: "-4)>*$" $ * " )$ *"$!"! /"" ! * 3-$) " "+9: >*')*$"&)-$/ " !*""-!(&(*9 *") < A $") &( "0(!1 * !" $! " * -"**3-$) " "
"(- :
-4) - (("* *" " *3*&- /*$
" )--"$( *") 6 >*"- * ! $" <* (1
)*A-")"-* *"-!(3"1 *
3!"3" --)$- -( "" "
2)*12$-" 0" :A /;,)"" * * %$" "#" " 2**1 2$-" 0" A / -$( ,)""/
* " 2$-" /*"&(* -( " "2)*/-- $-/
1&$!( !& *$!& /)" *3!( "3
"0(!-$**1*"/ !(
("--"*)*--"-"$*"(/*"*-" 1*-"--"* *$*"/**)" /* "&!3 7("--"93!(/*!*-"
!3 "$ " "(*"("* & ! >* -"**3!"* " "2)*>
" (*!3*-""*&** +"$.$3"; &!) * 3 " * - /** *( * & -"3 "*3 */"$"2"" !"-"3 * - 2-! 2"" >* -( ! " * -
2"" 2-!2"" !>*-" / "/)3"-(**%$"+"$.$3";& "-"3 2-!2""( *
"*3 -"3*-
2-!2""9" -)*"-( 9 "3 3!$ ,$!
*"$!>*$)**3!(*-(
*-"/**-( %$"3-!(*&*3 9 -( %$"3-!(1*"&* *3!$ -*%$"3-!( "))*& +-( *-(& /**-( *-"*-(& /
<
6
<2*& -( 9-"3$!!( )" *%$"3-!($*& **3!( *-( *-" %$"3-!(/ 6
< $ 9 -( %$"3-!( "!("$!
--! *-" ,$!
:+ *$%& !2" , (,$!1
8 "*"B
8,$!C * * " " 2)* / " * 3" &(*'D&!;$ )1'?" *- /-! &" !!/ :
B>*3"*"-" "3 ! !!) 3!(-( 9/***"- $ * * /*! " 3-!( -"3 * *)*" -1 * %$"1 /*! $)* " "1&3!)&! *)" + $!!()1& "*
$"*"-"3 "/***"* !" (&-"3 2*" " "! $* !41 /
* * 3" ! -!(: &-! & "*
*/$)) *"( " "*3"*"!" (
&(33 / 'D&!;$ ) !() / *)$ ! --):$-*-( A* )*"$)** *33 /**"-" $ )< *
) *"! *-$
*3(1*-" 3!(* &$ $ /") $! ')*$"&!*3>*)" +* %$"3-!(1 "/***&3!
$ " -" *31 /
" >*!)&!("!3 *%$"
3-!( 5$ '/ "1 * ) ")" * * "*%$"3-!( * & -"3 *"-" /!!*%$"&*"/"4)*3 " *"3-!())!"-( **%$"1/**"$!($ *" &$")1 3( & " B3!$ $C "*!3 -$"- --)$- "D-"/**%$"?* -( & -- $- /
&$ !( !&>*$!& &)" "3
!(C
>* 3" -" *&--! * *-" (*3*& """ * -" !3 A --" * $! & / "" "3
$ !( (" 34) * !3 *1 " 0(!1 (1 * )$*) $" "3*-"/*" !( & &$"&! (*& 8 >* $%& 0 "3 "$
3( & *( ! /* "3 !
3!( --)$--( ") "33-!( &( "/)!-(*%$" $-" -" ,$!
:+ *
8,$!>*"! 9
*"$-")"-*" !!/ :
B+ "" $! " *3"* 0 "" $%&-! *
$"3!-" *-" ,$!
:+ *$%& !2" , ( ,$!1
81*-( "3-!()
9 ! !!/"**%$"3-!(1 *-( $*"3-!(*!!&-- $-*! ! *-( *%$"3-!( $&%* !!/) :
>*%$" ") "33-!( *$! &!)*3 " *- /***(* &-"3 *$! !& ! *3 " &>* -":" " !7-( & )" -( *!/" *)*"-1 /***("! "/-(1*$! & ! >*") "33-!(*3
* -"3 * *)*" ! ! * & "/)-(5$!"3"**-( %$" "! /!! & ) $ " * "$ *"3-!(9" - ) * -( 97-"3 -- "- "" -("$$" "3
"** - *%$" '/ "1 * - " 9 -( 9" &(*" %$"3-!( $ "
"!$ "$!
*$%& !2" , (,$!1
8 *3 *-"3 *%$"3-!( *-( $*%$" 9 ! !*)*"
**-( *"1*"3-!( 3(1 )$*3)*-( " 9 $&%"$! ! %$31 ** 9" *-$ "*3 !$ "$!
*&9" &(* %$"3-!(
>*3!(*$! & "!("$!
--! *-" "$!
:+ $%& !2" , (,$!1
8 '/ "1 *!/"-1*%$"
"
/ "/)3"-(*-":" 7" -(!**"&( "$ ( "3)" *3" $( ! -(*"*&(/( "3!-( 91 * & -:$- ) $ " * "$*!!& 3&! >* 9 "3 " ) "3 3-!(*!!& 3&!*3 * *%$"1"-/*31**) *-(-- $- >* & --) $- -( & !!/ *"3-!( "* 31 * 3!( * ) " /* " "*-( *3%$"1"- /*31*-( *"/-- $- * "3C
>*)$ ! "3 &(*33 /'D&! ;$ )" *3$ 3) *&"1
>*-" -" * "" !!/ :
B A "3 ,$! * ')* $" =&!*3 +--3
2" ,$!1 8 1*! -(-(&! *3-!( *')*$"*!!&-"
*@"2* $!*,$! A* -(!1*-(*!!& 9 "3 ,$! < +4-) /*,$! << ,$!< < *$%& !2" ,$!$*&(-(-" 3-!(-"3 *)*"-!/"! -( -( 9 &( )") !
"3 $ -"3 $* 3!""E >*3-!( "/!!&-! * 3 B-( !C ""- $"
-"3" " "E >* -( " "5$" & -- $-1 *-( &*" %$"
9 -"-( 9"$! "$1 /*%$" "/*)*"-($
*!)* " "-( 9"3*"
"!$ )-"!-(C
>*')*$""!!" $%&0 "33 *"$)*!" 2-3&"1
8"- )" -" (-$->*"-
$"*""!(*%$ )3+9,: -
<
2$"%2)* "2;$ )1 '*"-$" *" <
>*"$9 !" * 3-!( /$! & !)&! -" ( "3 !( * * ) *3*-(9-&(/( $!"3 9 -("$! " -(! "3 33>*$"
*! ** /$! */*-"1/*&*3 * &-(&((*"3 1$**/**-- *-"1/**-(/-- $-/**%$" / "/)*)*"-($")-"31**!! & ! &+!/!!"0(!)" **-"(" *-" "+*!" * -" "!5$* * !3 * !)* *
%$ )3 *?" *--!)*
?+8
2$"% 2)* "2;$ )1'*"-$" *"
' )) $-*-"("") +,$!1"0(!"*!3 "--) $- -(& """ -" (-$->*3!( -($ !)* " "-( 9"
3*""!$ )-"!-(/*!4-) / ,$! * ')* $" =&!*3 +--3 2" ,$!1 8 < +4-) /*,$!<< ,$!< < $%& !2" ,$!>*"4)-*-" *3" "" 1*-"" "/) !" -( * * 33 %$" *$)* * / -"3 *- 2-!2""(& "+"$.$3"
;/-"3 *->*3!(*&" &(*"- 1&$* -$ -" *& ! !& *$!"""
" !"( >* %$" /*! " ) * 3 - " * "! -" * %( *)*"& **-"1 *" "1 "!! -$"-1*-" ! $!$-)" *-( "3* * !/9 *%$"
= * 'D&! + 3" ;$ ) *
* " "2)*1/** 3!" * * -"1 * 3-*!!(
&" $- " ) *
* 33 /'D&!;$ )1" "" & 1** *33*"! *-$ "
A "*"**3-$) " " 678
+9 :
+9 : " $$&!*( !/ " & *9 :)" $!-$"(& "3* $ *"*"$!"*"$ -" * -" * ")* >* " " 2)* )$*&!&(" )" !( !*-" ) " (" " /** " * & / " " !!(&(*"- " "1*-"D!3
"*& +/ <6
*&"!5$* !! * /$! &3 ! + / 6
3-! $"(" " "3* --)$- /*+"$.$3";12-!2""(, "D?
< @"/* * & & "1* - !!/ *3-$) " " 678
+9:
*9""$!& --)$- "3 6
*! ""$ "&""( *" " 5$* 5$*" 1*" "
+9: !)*"5$ *-" """" -" (-$- "*-" 6
<<
! >* -" *! ! """
-" (-$- "*-" !3 "3 $ "
"3+"$!1*3$ $&!$! &$" *-"/*"&!3 (*" 3*>*" "/!!1*/ "1--!(!3 "+ & /**&3 $3-! $"("" / 6
*!3 "3
*&) $- &(*-": -"(" ""* """*&3 *- A )"$ /" )"*"""
!
" #