High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/26856/2016disposed of

Sohan Singh And ANR. v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2017-01-10Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

!"##$%&%'(!')!*+ , - ./!'.%'0/ !'"/#* #"%"%'#*& 1#*&)& ."!"# )'2!3 "/#*& #&4'5#'"&

!"#$ %&'()$ )(

#*%&+,$

*#&#'"( * '6!*.%'0/,57$!"#, *"/#4#"%"%'#*& 88888

)(

#*% & -9!'5 - $):#'"&''#;)*#& <

!'5 < !*#"!6#''*#$*5 ;#:4"%'%&!=&0*!'"#5*:%=%'0"/#$#*"%%#5$4%#& "/#!''#;)*#& 44=%$!"%'&&"!'55%&4&#5

#"%"%'#*& !*# !00*%#7#5 "/# %:4)0'#5 *5#* 5!"#5 >

4!&&#53+"/#==#$"*,?!4)*"/!=! <- !==@%'0"/# #7%$"%'4#"%"%'%=#53+*#&4'5#'"A)'5#*.#$"%'&A!'5"/#

)'2!3 #=%0%)& *#:%&#&!'5B!'5 7%$"%'!'5 #'" #$7#*+ $",

99- *&/*"C 99-$"D !'5)4/#=53+"/#::%&&%'#*,!=!'5/!* %7%&%',!=!'5/!*7%5#*5#*5!"#5 - <9 * '6!* .%'0/, =#!*'#5 $)'&#= * "/# 4#"%"%'#*& /!&

&)3:%""#5"/!"3"/"/#!)"/*%"%#&/!7#'""!6#'%'"$'&%5#*!"%'"/# $:4*:%&#5##55!"#5/#4#"%"%'#*&/!7#4)*$/!&#5"/#=!'5 :#!&)*%'06!'!=& :!*=!&*:.!5/).%'0/!'5!*'!%=.%'0/7%5#&!=# 5##5&5!"#5>A ,)==+5#"!%=#5%'4!*!>"/#4#"%"%',5)=+#'"#*#5 %'"/#2!:!3!'5%*"/#+#!* 99<99,->,&%")!"#5!" /!0@!*!

.%*6%, #/&%= /!0@!*! /#+ /!7# $'&"*)$"#5 "/# &/4& ' "/# !*#:#'"%'#5=!'5!'50%7#'"/#&!:#'*#'"/#!*#:#'"%'#5=!'5 @!&&%")!"#5!3)""%'0"/#:!%':#"!==#5*!56'@'!&C.)6/$/!%'!0!*

!5D$:4*%&#5%'?/!&*!>A9,@/%$/%&#7%5#'"*:"/#2!:!3!'5% ''#;)*# < /# !'!0%'0 ::%""## "/# )*)5@!*! ./*% .)6/!%'!'! .!/%3<*#&4'5#'" A %& %' 4&&#&&%' =!'5 %' ?/!&*! & 9 " -,?/#@!" - !'5 -!"&:#5%&"!'$#*:"/# =!'5%'5%&4)"#,@/%$/%&#7%5#'"*:"/#2!:!3!'5%*"/#+#!*><A

<> $:4=!%'"@!&:!5#""/#."!"%')&# %$#*, =%$# ."!"%',.!5!* /!0@!*!!0!%'&""/#4#"%"%'#*&@%"/*#0!*5""/#=!'5%' 5%&4)"#!'55)#""/#%'"#*7#'"%'"/#*#&4#$"!3=#4#*&'&,!$:4*:%&# @!& ##$"#5 ' !$", "/# !'!0%'0 ::%""## "/# )*)5@!*! %& %'"#*#&"%'0%')&)*4%'0"/#=!'5)'5#*"/#4&&#&&%'"/#4#"%"%'#*&!'5 /!5!==#0#5=+0""/#5#:!*$!"%'5'#' ,$4+@/%$/%& ''#;)*# AE !'5 ' "/# 3!&%& "/# &!:#, %=#5 "/# *#4*" /# 5#:!*$!"%' %& '" %' !$$*5!'$# @%"/ "/# %0/ )*" )=#& !'5

#0)=!"%'&,:)$/=#&&%'"/#!3&#'$#"/#4#"%"%'#*& /#4#"%"%'#*& !44#!*#5%'"/#!*#:#'"%'#54#"%"%'%=#5)'5#*.#$"%'&A!'5

99-$"!'5*!%&#5!=="/#32#$"%'&@%"/*#0!*5""/#:!%'"!%'!3%=%"+ "/"/#!)"/*%"%#&/!7#'"!44*#$%!"#5"/#$:4*:%&#!&"/#5%&4)"# *#0!*5%'0"/#=!'5/!5!=*#!5+3##'&#""=#5 /#!)"/*%"%#&/!7#)*"/#*

*#=%#5)4'"/#&#$'55#:!*$!"%'*#4*"5!"#5 A

,@/%$/%&'"!& 4#*"/#=!@#%"/#*!'+4)$$!4%'"'*!'+3)*2%@!&4=!$#5"%'5)""/# 6/!&*!'):3#*%'5%&4)"#!'56/!&*!>A9 7#'"/#!*#!6/!&*! >A9@!&'":#!&)*#5"%'5)""/##;!$"=!'56/!&*!&>A9,

9>!'5 A/#5#:!*$!"%'*#4*"%&@*'0!'5'"$**#$")%=5%'0 )*)5@!*!$:4*%&#5%'?/!&*! 9>%&!*!@!+*:"/#:!%'

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

*#&4'5#'"A@!'"#5""!6#4&&#&&%'?/!&*!>A9,*@/%$/, !$$*5%'0""/#4#"%"%'#*&,*#&4'5#'"A/!5'"%"=# '"/#$'"*!*+, *#&4'5#'"A/!&4=!$#5'*#$*5; ,2!:!3!'5%*"/#+#!*>< A, 5#:!*$!"%' *#4*" ; >, &)3&#F)#'" 5#:!*$!"%' $'5)$"#5 '

,6&/.%2*!; A"&)44*""/#$!&#!5%"3##'&!'5%'$!&# "/#*#/!53##':%&!44*#$%!"%',"/%&)*"@)=5/!7#5#%'%"#=+$:#" "/#*#&$)#"/#4#"%"%'#*&3+!44=+%'0"/#5$"*%'#!6%'"2)5%$%!=*#7%#@ /#4#"%"%'#*&/!7#:%&#*!3=+!%=#5"#&"!3=%&/"/!")'5#*"/#0!*3

?/!&*! 9>,*#&4'5#'"A%&&##6%'0#7%$"%'"/#4#"%"%'#*&*: ?/!&*!>A9 !"!==%"%&&,"/#4#"%"%'#*&$!'!=@!+&*!%&#"/# 32#$"%'!""/#*#=#7!'""%:#@%"/*#0!*5""/#%5#'"%"+"/#4*4#*"+!'5 '"%'"/#:!''#*!'5:5#!&%'5%$!"#5!37#

*"/#*#0%'0*#!&'&,"/#*#%&'%==#0!=%"+!'54#*7#*&%"+ %'"/#%:4)0'#5*5#*&/#&!:#!*#/#*#3+)4/#=5 0*)'5* %'"#*#*#'$#%&:!5#)" *%"4#"%"%'&"!'5&5%&:%&&#5 %/ 0/1*2 )(

# /3 %&+,$ 5 5 46 /7 89 /4

;

5 5

;