High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4202/2014disposed of

Kuldip Prakash Vindlas v. Union Of India & ORS

2022-08-01Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri7 pages

! "#$ %&%'( )

*%+! , -./.'0 1 #!+.'

122 # "# "3 #! . .#! "(0 -'

',"#!

#('

4 4 4 $ 56 2 26 56 2 1*2 2 4 4 4 2

.7 '0 %#7) !8".( ) 3"- (0

0.-.( 0%'0.#) 2- .# + "%#'

+) 3"- - ',"#!

#( "'

.8 #!-. . #) !8".( ) .#!

2%# + %,(.) !8".( ) 3"- - ',"#!

#( "

26 )

6 0.++ #& # (0 ,- #( :- ( , ( ( "# ;< (0 -

) ' (" (0 ! > ## 9 ,.''

! ;< (0

#(-.+ != # '(-.( 8 - ;%#.+) 0.#! &.-0 #0) 0.#! &.-0) :0 ;< "- & #.+ .,,+ .( "# :.' ! '= ''

! ;< 0"+! #& (0.( (0 . +:.<' :.'

! (" - .="%#( /

, #& # 8 : (0 +.: +. ! !":# ;< (0

"#5;+ , ? "%-( #

- ;%#.+ .= (" (0

"#+%' "# (0.( .,,+ .#( :.' ,. ! .# .="%#( "3 ' )@>)9AB # ?

'' "3

= #( .#! (0 3"- ) (0

- :.'

! (" -

.="%#( ' # - ,.<= #( :.' #.!8 -( #(+< =.!

+ .# 3"-

- ;%#.+ 0.! .+'" ;

# ,+.

! (" . %++ #0 7%!&= #( "3 (0 ' "%-( # !" # $%&%%%) ;%( /

, #& # 8 :

; #! #& ,-

#( "3 (0 "#5;+ , ? "%-() (0 3 :.' !

+ #

0 + ''% #& #"( "3 ="( "#) (0 -< :.' '(.< "# .#! . !

(. + ! "-!

- :.' ,.''

! ;< (0 ""-! #.( #0 "3 (0 '

"%-( "# @ 9) (0.( . ,-", - .+%+.( "# "3 (0 = # =%= - 8 '

! ;.'

#' "# "3 (0 - ;

=.!

.#! .# .33 !.8 ( ;

3 + ! ! '+"' #& (0

?.( = # =%= ;.' , #' "# :0 0 0 ! (" -

# "=,+ .# "3 (0 ) .# .33 !.8 ( "3 ,( 2.0!

8.) 2 # "- 8 ' "#.+ #.#

.#.& -) "-(0 -# . +:.<) =;.+.

.#((

# 3 + , -%'.+ "3 (0 '. ! .33 !.8 ( :"%+! &" "# (" '0":

(0.( ( 0.' ;

# .!= (( .="%#( ,.<.;+ .' (0 8 '

! ;.'

#' "# 3 ?

! .( 9D "3 (0 8 '

! ;.' ,.< #+%! #& ,.< ;.#! .#! &-.!

,.< :"%+! "= (" '

@9B , - ="#(0 .#! .' , - (0 .+%+.( "# '

E>)>C@B 0.' ;

# .+%+.( ! :0 0 :"%+! ;

"%('(.#! #& .="%#( ( 0.'

.+'" ;

# .8 -- ! (0.( = #( # ,.< '.+ "3 '

9E :.'

:-"#&+< !"# .#! ( '0"%+! 0.8

# # (0 ,.< '.+ "3 '

9C .#!

!% (" (0 = -& - "3 (:" ,.< '.+ ') ;< ,+. #& - + .# "# + (( C C) :0 +%;; #& :.' !"# ) ( ' # '%0 -%='(.# ')

> +! "%( (0.( (0 +. = "3 , #' "# .( '

@9B ' #"( 7%'( 3 ! .#! 0 :.'

! (" , #' "# "#+< .( '

A@9B :0 0 ' # (0 ,.< '.+ "3 '

9 C

8.#( ,"-( "#' "3 (0 .33 !.8 ( - .! .' %#!

-$ F9 0.( ;

( =.< ;

) # "=,+ .# -'

!.( ! @ C 9) (0"-"%&0 '(%!< "3 (0 .'

"3 (0

- :.' "#!%( ! .#! .+%+.( "# .' , ? '( #& ,.< '.+ .3( - 9(0 ,.< "== '' "# # (0 ,.< '.+ "3 '

99E :.' !"# .#! ("(.+ .="%#( ,.<.;+ .( (0

8 '

! ;.' , #' "# "3 ,- A , #' "# -' 3 ?

! .( 9D "3 - 8 '

! ;.' ,.< :0 0 #+%!

' ,.< .#! # (0

,.< .#!

"-- ',"#! #& (" = # =%= "3 ,- - 8 '

! ,.< '.+ ,+%' &-.!

,.< :0 0 : ++ "= (" '

@9B , =

# !"# .#! .' , - .+%+.( "# '

E>>C@B 0.'

# .+%+.( .+%+.( "# '0

( '

#+"'

! .'

## B

0.( # '(-< "3 . +:.<' B . +:.< ".-! "# (0

-' '( #( !

=.#!' "3 (0

''% ! . + (( - "

+< !

CBC !.( ! C C & 8 #& # (" (0

>CB>@BC !.( >-!

(";

-) C ,.< '.+ ' "3 '

A .#! '

AAA :

+%;;

! .#! &-.#( ! "-- ',"#! #& ,.< '.+ "3 9C :

A ( ' - 8.#( ("

= #( "# 0 (0.( # ;"(0 (0 .'

# .3( .;"8

'. ! ="! 3 .( "#)

) 3-"= ,.< '.+ "3 99E ("

9C (0 #' "# "3 (0 - - =. # ! (0

.( '

A@9B , = .' (0 < 3.++ : (0 # (0 "3 A(0 ,.< "== '' "#)

E>>C # 8 : "3 A(0 ,.< "== '' "# :

A #!

-%='(.# ') 8 '

! :.' ''% ! ,+. #& (0 - # (0

E>>C : (0 -.!

.< "3 '

0":

-) --"# "%'+< (0 ,.< '.+ :.' = #( "# ! .'

99E :0 .' ( 0.' (" ;

8 '

! (" 9C !% (" = -& - "3 (:" ,.< '.+ -% ,0"("",< "3 (0

(( ! C C .+"#& : (0 (' .## ' '0": #& +%;; #& "3 (0 (:" ,.< '.+ ' .#! ,+. #& (0

# (0 '.+ "3 9C .- #& .## ?

! .+"#& : (0 .' ## B B

0.( .;"8 '. ! -%='(.# ' + .-+< '0":' (0.( - :.' 0 ='

+3 :

++ .:.- 3.( (0.( 0 & (( #& , #' "# .' , - '.+ "3 '

9C) 0":

-) (""/ %#!% .!8.#(.& #.!8 -( #( = '(./ ;< :0 0 0

# '0":# (" ;

# (0 ,.< '.+ "3 '

99E 0%') 0 ' +. = (0.( 0 ! (" (0

#' "# G '

@9B .##"( ;

,( ! .' ( ' ;.'

.#! ' ;.'

! "# = '- ,- #(.( "# "3 3.(' (./ #& .!8.#(.& "3 #.!8 -( #( = '(./ ' :0 0 0.' - ,( # !%

(" 3H% #( 0.#& # (0 &"8 -#= #( #'(-%( "#' B ,"+ ' .#! .+'" !% (" 8.- "%' + ( &.( "#' # .+="'( .++ ,.-(' "3 #! . ;%( :0 # # "=,+ .# : (0 (0 -' "3 (0 ' "#5;+ "%-( . (0"-"%&0 '-%( #< "3 (0 !"%= #('

:.' =.!

( :.' 3"%#! (0.( , - ' #"( ! ("

.#< , #' "# ="- (0.# '

A@9B .' 0 ' .(%.++< # (0

,.< '.+ "3 9C 3"- ) # +""/ #& 3-"= (.;+ & 8 # .( ,.& A "3 (0 ,., -;""/ ##

9 (0 #' "# "3 (0 - : ++ - =. # .( '

A@9B , = .#! (0 ' #" '", "3 .#< - 8 ' "# I ( ' #"( ! ',%( - - ( - ! "# > @ ECA) .' -.8 ++ #& / ( #', ("- .#! .( (0 ' '(.& ) 0 ' '(.( ! (" ;

#7"< #& - , "+! .& "3 E < .-'

"%#'

+ 3"- (0 -) .( (0 "%('

() 0.' '%;= ((

9 (0.( 0 !"

' #"( ,- '' 0 ' .'

&.-! #& (0 3 ?.( "# .', ( .#! ' "#+< "#( '( #& - &.-! #& (0 ' :0 0 ' "8 ! %#!

,- # ,+ +. ! !":# ;< (0 '%;'

H% #( 7%!&= #( ;< (0 "#5;+ , ? "%-( # '( ) !*+ ,, )-

%% 0 :.' !

! "# C .#! (0 # (0 - ;%#.+ ! !

#"( 0.8 # 3 ( "3 (0 ' # ( :.' ,-"#"%# ! . < .- +.( ( '

.+'" '%;= (( 7%!&= #( - ! %,"# "3 (0 "#5;+ , ? "%-( #

'%,-. :.' .+'" '%;7 ( =.(( - "3 "#' !

-.( "# # (0 '%;'

H% #( "-!

( ' #"( ! ',%( ,- # ,+

# +. ! !":# (0.( - -< 3-"= , -'"#' :0" 0.8 ( - ! ' #"( -= '' ;+ .#! ( :"%+! ;

# H% ("%' "- 0.-'0 "- .-; (-.-< (" '%0 .#

?( #() .' :"%+! 3.- "%(:

&0 (0

H% (.;+ ;.+.#

-' - &0( (" - ( ' . =.(( - "3 - "-! (0.( "# .# .-+ - ".' "# .+'") (0

- 0.! .,,-".0 ! (0 - ;%#.+ :0 # (0 -< :.' ;

( ! "3 '

@)B , - ="#(0 8 !

! C

, -%'.+ "3 (0 .;"8 '. ! .33 !.8 ( "3 (0 "33 .+ .+'"

:"%+! &" "# (" '0": (0.( (0 +%;; #& :.' !"# "# C C .#!

3"- ) .,,.- #(+< 3"- . , - "! "3 < .-' 3-"= C (" ) (0

:.' !-.: #& (0 '. ! .="%#( :0 0 :.' "# ."%#( "3 .# --"- :0 0 0.' ;

# .!= (( ! ;< (0 ',"#!

#(' . +:.<'

# '%0 -%='(.# ') (0 ,- # ,+ ' +. ! !":# # !* + '%,-. :"%+!

! - (+< "= #(" ,+.< :0 0 - .!' .' %#!

!"#

$ $ % !

& $ & ' " !"#

!"#

!" #

(

!" $

(

( ) *

@ "-! #&+<) /

, #& # 8 : (0 .;"8 ) :

"#' !

! ", # "# (0.( (0 ! > ## 9 ,.''

;< (0 #(-.+ != # '(-.( 8 - ;%#.+) 0.#! &.-0 #0) 0.#! &.-0) H% - ' (" ;

="! 3 ! (" (0

?( #( (0.( (0 -< "3 (0

'' .="%#( :0 0 0.' ;

# ,. ! (" (0 ( -

' #"( , -= '' ;+ .( (0 ' '(.& ) /

, #& # 8 : (0 - ' "8 ! %#!

- +.%'

) .#!

8 ( '

3%-(0 - +.- 3 3 ?.( "#) 3 !"# ) 0.' #"( ;

# 0.++ #& ! ;< (0

:- ( , :- ( , ( ( "# ' (0%' ! ',"'

! "3 ;< ="! 3< #& (0 - ;%#.+ ."-! #&+<

26 %&%'( )

1*2 2 -.7 .-"-.

0 - ', ./ #& B - .'"#

' B "

0 - - ,"-(.;+

' B "