Gagan v. State Of Punjab

IN TH HE HIGH COURT FOR THE E STATES OF PUNJAB AND HANDIGARH HARYANA AT CH


' () .

  /01-1  2!'3! )* '

!!!11 , +,-- -       !!!-4/ 
 
 % 

 ! "#$%
  % $
Mr. 

'
) 

# 
+
,-
$'

!

!.

/$  $& "!

0

#

$

$"

#

 


   





1

2

#
$"

 


 

  










 
  


34,



 





!

 "#
$


% &














  

 


!) )

 '$"

"


 
'
'

## 

$"

# 

 
#


 



(# 

$ 
"
)
(

#


$ "


(("





(
56(  *

 8




) 


##

#
 

#
# 




 4

*(

'
 
#
 
'

#
"
 
'
(-

(




$
2722
+
 "



(-

$ 
 
($
8 2 !: 111

( (
(
(
'-


0


'
##


$ 

#


)
'
## 
'

-

 
(

<.
=
,->



#
# 
4

*(
 #



$
 (
$/ $
$




 
'



# 


 
#

'



 
0
#
'
##
 


 


&2





'

#

 

) 

9



 

$-

#"
$
'
)
(

-;$
'
'

'

#(
'## 


' 

#"
$
0 
'
(#

2
(
 
'
6 

(
#(
' 
'
'
(

$
% 2
(
 

(
'
#


# 
#
$6
(#

 
$ 

#

(
 $
'

'

< *> #(


'
##
#"

"





'
 
)

 4
#

,
'
 


#

 
$
)








 

34,
) 
#
'
 
0

(#
# 
'


(
56(

2

:')

#
'
)
 (




(
5 56(
'


(#


2

0





'
)
 (

 56(
'$"

(#
'







(#
'
'


 

$
)
(

 

!
,/ #


-
' 
) $"


## 
?6
 A
'

$"

"

:9

 
#





@
$


 

-
 
(#
(


 $


$

"

)
(
(

( 
56(
)



'
"

-

# ##"
(#


"
 


( (#
'

)
(
!
, ,/'#

9
 



 

##

# 


#"
?6
 &A

 
#"
(


## 
$"
$(


## 
'

( ($



(# #

$
'

$ 


#) 



:')



'
 


# 

'


## 
()
$"

# 


 
(#

 6(
) 
(#


1

2 ?6 
 7A





# 




(# 


 
$


"

'
 

(

"


 
#)

'

0


#
# )




-
 
(#
 
"
0

## 
'
()
$"

# 


 #


#

$
2
" 

#


(#
'


3 

*

2
:'

')


(

:9
'
(( 
$"






'

'



!
3

* 


" 
2 7;2

(#
' 


$"

:9

$"

"


 56(



(# #
'

)
$"
( (
56( *


-


 6(
(

#
 


+


#


 
##
'
)



')

$
)

 
'"

)




7
(

(
56( 

#


-
"
)
 #

(#"
'

( (

!($
2
B
 
$
$ (




#




#
# 
)

$
'
 

(#


$
 
$


0 0
"

(




#

 
#


  

     

      

 !   " !

! #$ % & '"   (( 

      



4

  

) )! " !*) %+ +"

, 



-, , .

 )!  " !/ )%1  1  



5

) ) )!  "

" ! /0%12  

 

-, .3737 $ $0/7

$%4  4 4 $

*% ,(

( 
 ..



-, , .

/ !  " !# $6 "

,  4   



 -, .

 ! " !*/ ,#"

$

$"

 # 
'

) $







(

#"





 

("
 
"


(#
 
#
$"



 

$(


(#
#
' 


(
56( 


:')

#
'
) )

"


( (#


 





' 

$"

(
56(  '$"
 
(#
#
'

 



(#
'
( 

5 0

 
'


 


#




2

$"


# 



(# 

$ 
"
)
(

#


$ "


(("





(
56(  *
4





# 
#

$

$
(  4
)



 

#

$
 

)
 




 "


#



# #
'
##
$"

#
# "


'
'
 (



$
 
($
8 2 !: 111

9
#



$
(
 
$





#
 


(
'

 

$-
 
#"
$
'
) 
(

-;$
'
'
 
#(
'##


' 

#"
$
0  '
(# 

2
(

'
6 6

(
#(
'
'
'

'
(

$
% 2
(
 

(
'
#


# 
#
$6
(#


$
 
#

(
$ $
'
 
'

< *>
0 

(#
#
'
 

(
5 56(

2
:') )

#
'
)
( (



 
(
56(
'
 

(#


2 0 






 #

$
(

'
" 


'
)
(
(
56( 
'$"

(#
'
 


 



(#
 

$"

#
 

$
) 

-
'
) )
0

2

2@


## 
'
()
$"

# 
$




- -

 
( (#


)
$ 




' 
'
'


$"



$"
# 

(#

0
 




$

 



'

( (#

$
 

(
6(
 



(


$ 


 
(
$"

#D

4

'

## 

'

"

 














 ;  (#


$
 


!



( 


4
("

')
$
#( (

6("
6# 
( 




$ 

$"


 
## 




(
$
( 
'

#


"

"


# 



#C

## 

 ; (#
 
$
 

:')

 
$

"
(# 
( 
"
(

 ;  (#

"
#$
 

!

,



 
$
#
#
  8

?#A
 (
)'

$
6# 
$"


 1   1   8

?# A 



# 



#
La axmi Nagappa Koli's case (supra), wherein, w while relying upon Thana Sing gh's case (supra a), Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that the Special Judge, onl ly in extreme an nd exceptional circumstance, ca an direct for examination of sec cond sample and d the first report of the FSL can nnot be ignored.
("

 


#) 


!


 
(#

(
" 
$"
56(
')


$ $

'
#
 
)
$


##
 
 ; (#
( (

## 

()
/

 "

#
0
 

2 '
  

$


!


$

( 



)
#

 
4

$


(
 

/(



$
#(
 "

6("
6# 
( 





$ $

$"


  
## 



(
$
 
'

#

&
"
 

#

 
#



 
##

$
  % 4

#



 
(#
'
'
(

$ $-
"
 

)
$
' 



(
56( 


" 

2
:')

 
'
)
(

 

56(



 
(#



7

 

#

( 

2
"

2
(


"


#
- -#

# 



(
$"

 (
56(

$
2
"

"


 
2

"
()

# ##
-
#(
 


 



(#
 
"
4




 

# 



#


(# 


6(
'
(# 


'
 (
0
#
"

"


$

$
3
 #


$ 
#

2
"


(


) 

#

 

(



( 
56(
"


'

'

)
- 
"






"

"
2
4
'

- 
##
 

#

#
 

(#

'
 

"
 
-
$"




 '

##
()
$"

"

# 
'



(#
 

$

$


$ $


( #
:')

#


'


'

 
/(



$
#(
 "

6("
6# 

6 ( 

'

 



$
 
## 



(
$

'

#

&
"
 

#


#



 
##

$
  0


'
#

(# 




"

 
)



6( "
6#
(
' 


#( (

#


 
(#

"
5) 

6# 
')

$
)
$ $"

#


'"
 
#

 

(

(
5 56(



"

()
# ##

-
#( 




"


@



#

$
2
"

"




'
 

6# 
(

$
(






 
(#
4 
)'




 


#


(#


$

$



"


#
# 

'


(# 


 $"

 17.09.2024   (MANISHA BATRA) JUDGE


 Whet ther speaking/reasoned Yes/No Whet ther reportable Yes/No