Avtar Singh & ORS v. Punjabi University & ANR
!"
!# !
$!!
! !#!
%&&
# '
#((
) *+ &+ , + - ./0 1 2( 3
++ (( 45
7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
+ <, - ./0
= 2( 3
++ (( 45 5 7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
+ ,&< - ./0 5(
> 5
++ (( 45
7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
,+ * - ./0 #( 2
++ (( 45 5 7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
+ ? - ./0
= 2( 3
++ (( 45 5 7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
?+ << , - ./0 5 2( 3
++ (( 45 5 7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
*+ , , - ./0 !8 2( 3
++ (( 45 5 7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
&+ < , - ./0 5( > 5
++ (( 45
7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
<+ ,*? , - ./0 (
>5
++ (( 45 5 7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
+ ?< , - ./0 /
1 > 5
++ (( 45 5 7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
+ ? , - ./0 1 2( 3
++ (( 45 5 7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
+ *? , - ./0
++ (( 45 5 7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
+ *?* , - ./0
@(
2( 3
++ (( 45 5 7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
,+ *?&& , - ./0 (
2( 3
++ (( 45 5 7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
, + ?<? , - ./0
((=
(
++ (( 45 5 7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
?+ &,* , - ./0 #+ #1(=
!33 @ ;
++ (( 45 5 7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
*+ *,* , - ./0 >5;8 > 5 ++ (( 45 5 7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
&+ <* , - ./0 !=7( 2( 3
5 ++ (( 45 5 7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
<+ & , - ./0 5 /5 3(;
++ (( 45 5 7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
+ &*& , - ./0 2(;
#8(
++ (( 45 5 7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
+ *< , - ./0 8 @ ;
++ (( 45 5 7(
(8(9:
( ;
++
1
!/) A"B / +
2 !
2/ ! 2 2
!!"
!#
!$ #!
!#
%% !# &
!%& !# "
%# # !# &
'$'
!#!& ( ) *
'# !# + ,-
&!"
!# & .- (
$ %# !#!&
/-
( )
%" '
!#!& 1 ( ,)
'%!"
!#!& 2 ( )
$"## !#!&
'&'# !#!& 1
?
1 ( )
'$33 !#!&
3'3 !#!& (1
&3%!
!# (
( )
4 &' $ $%$ '$ !
3& '
!#!& / !
2/ ! 2 2 + -
!B0 8 11
- 2 1 !
9 :- 9 !
+ 2- )
:- # #$ !# ;- 92 - 1 1 9 9= ) 9
2
2
) + 2- 9= - 9 > 9 9= 9= 1 > 9 -) 1 2
2- =
9
)
- 9
* 9= -
9 & >
-2 - - 1 1 )- ?-
9= ) - ) )- =
9
-)1 @A2 (-1
- +
'
5 8+
36( 2( 3:
?-,0 2 ?,:
1-1 ) 9 "
. - 2
2
-21 9 -
- 1 1 . - - -21 )- . - 2
- )-
- :- :- ) 1
-
) 2 =
9 - ) :- :-
:- :- 1
:- $ . -
2
& - -21
9= 9
9= ) ;
=
=
9 1 ) ) -
'
. -
2
-21 2 )
) - ) 1A - = ) - = 1 + - ) -) 2 % 9 1 9
9= 1B 9= ) 2 1 1 + -) 1 1 9 @A2 (-1
- +
> ) 4 "'
"3 -
! ! "
#
" $# "
" "
% & '
("
)*" + " "
,-." " " %" /
" "
0
"
& " "
"
" "
/ ! " "
1 , " ( "
)* " &""
" " !
2
3 /
' "
" " ! ! !# ' # ,
9 2 9 -
1 1
)- 2 9= ;
@9 2 -2 9 1 1-1 :- :-
:-
- 9
:- =
9 - D
+ - 1 -
- = ) - 1
9D
?-
9= 9 9= ) 1 1 2
=
9 9 A 1
)A 1 1 )
1 ) !
( ) /- ?- 9 -) 1
1-) 1 9 2
-
1 9=
) 9= - 1 1
- 1 > 9 9= 9 -
-2 9 2 1 2
#
:- 1 9 2 :- ) - -21 ) ) - = 2 1-1 ) 9 ) -
-)1 @A2 (-1
-
36( 2( 3A - 2 )
- - 9
36( 2( 3A -51
& . - -21
)
9 ) 9= - +
-
)- 9 - 1
= 9
1
"
+
) ) 1 - ; 2- ) 1
9 -1 9 9 9=
-
9 9= 9 B 9 9=
;
$ ) - -21
9
- 1 0) 2
1 112 11 9 2 ) 1=
'
> :- -
E 9 1
) - 9 - 1 )-
9 9
?-
:- - 2 ) :-
)9 9 )-1 9 11 9 1 - 9
-1 - 9 1 + 11 9 1
- 1 )- )- - 11 9 2 2 ) % 2- 2 1 !#
!
*+ &+ ,
-!
2/ ! 2 20 , #
= )B
F 4
2
F 4